Church schools worried new equality bill will impact their ‘autonomy and distinctive Catholic ethos’

The Church Schools Association has called on government to postpone the approval of the equality bill, warning the proposed law could undermine the constitutional rights of church schools to preserve their Catholic identity.

In a statement issued as parliament debates legislation establishing a new Human Rights and Equality Commission, the association said the bill was being rushed through parliament ahead of the summer recess without sufficient time for scrutiny or public consultation.

While reaffirming its commitment to promoting dignity, inclusion and equal treatment, the association said the proposed legislation raises "important questions" about its implications for the autonomy of Church schools and their ability to uphold their distinctive Catholic ethos.

The association argued that legislation of such constitutional and societal significance should not be approved without adequate time for detailed study and meaningful consultation. It also said the current draft appears to have overlooked key issues raised during previous consultation processes.

Church schools have a legitimate expectation that any new legal framework will respect the rights guaranteed under the Constitution, existing laws and international human rights instruments, including the freedom of religious communities to establish and administer schools in accordance with their religious identity and values, the association said.

It called on the government and parliament to allow more time for stakeholders to examine the bill, propose amendments where necessary and ensure the final law strikes what it described as an appropriate balance between strengthening equality protections and safeguarding the autonomy and Catholic identity of Church schools.

The association also said it remains willing to engage constructively with the government, MPs and other stakeholders to ensure the legislation reflects both Malta's commitment to equality and the role played by faith-based educational institutions.

The statement was signed by Church Schools Association co-ordinator Stephen Cachia.

The proposed bill, tabled by government, will give a stronger voice to society’s most vulnerable people.

The National Commission for Human Rights and Equality will replace the existing National Commission for the Promotion of Equality and investigate both human rights violations and discrimination.

Its protections would apply to individuals and legal entities, including companies and organisations. It would cover discrimination in areas such as employment, education, access to goods and services, and advertising, on grounds including sex, age, religion, disability, race, sexual orientation, gender identity, and health status.

Equality minister Rosianne Cutajar said the law would also place a formal obligation on the state to promote equality and continuously combat discrimination. Within one year, the government would be required to draw up a national plan promoting equality across all areas of the state.