Pope Leo XIV had tried during his first year as pontiff to insist
that his essential role was that of a pastor accompanying his flock.
President Donald Trump’s continuing criticisms – and Leo’s increasingly
bold retorts – complicated the effort and overshadowed Friday’s
anniversary of Leo’s election.
Leo spent the eve of the 1-year mark meeting with U.S. Secretary of
State Marco Rubio, who had come to the Vatican on a fence-mending visit.
Trump’s repeated broadsides against history’s first U.S. pope created
an unprecedented back-and-forth on the Iran war that strained U.S.-Holy
See relations.
By the end of the visit, both the Vatican and the State Department
stressed their strong bilateral ties. But the episode nevertheless
pushed Leo out of his comfort zone and onto the global stage to make
zingers like the one this week, after Trump’s latest misrepresentation
of his views. “If someone wants to criticize me for announcing the
Gospel, let him do it with the truth,” Leo said.
It’s all a bit out of character for Leo who — the world has come to
learn in this first year — is at heart a mild-mannered, 70-year-old
Midwestern missionary priest, and a reserved one at that. He likes to
play the solitary game of tennis, cites the fifth-century philosopher
St. Augustine from memory and insists he is merely quoting the Bible
when he calls for peace, as he did again Friday in marking his
anniversary.
“May the God of peace pour out an overflowing abundance of mercy,
touching hearts, soothing grudges and fratricidal hatred, and
enlightening those who bear special responsibilities of governance,” Leo
said during an anniversary homily in the ancient city of Pompeii.
The Trump-Leo feud aside, the former Robert Prevost after his first
year seems driven not by the dramatic gesture or headline-grabbing
tensions that often fueled his predecessor, Pope Francis. Rather, Leo
seems inspired by the calm, persistent zeal to preach the Gospel and —
thanks to his Augustinian spirituality — emphasize community and
harmony.
A year of learning and unifying
Leo began his improbable papacy promising to work for unity in a
polarized world and church, and at the one-year mark, he seems to be
delivering.
After Francis’ revolutionary and sometimes divisive 12-year papacy,
Leo has brought a calming balm to the Vatican and church at large. He
seems intent on healing divisions, even as new threats of schism emerge.
That has certainly been the case as he navigates some of the
thorniest challenges facing the Catholic Church: tensions between
traditionalists and progressives, financial problems facing the Holy
See and the geopolitical crises at the heart of the Trump vs. Leo
dissonance.
“I think the challenge that the Holy Father has is to strengthen the
unity of the church,” said Cardinal Wilton Gregory, a Chicago native
like Leo and the retired archbishop of Washington. While there have
always been divisions, Gregory said social media had amplified them, and
that Leo seems intent on tamping them down.
“Social communication makes it possible for people to take sides, and
sometimes taking sides adds to the divisiveness that we have to deal
with and that the Holy Father, as the Bishop of Rome, has to respond
to,” Gregory said in an interview.
“He has to call us to our better angels,” he added.
That seemed to be Leo’s modus operandi when, days into his recent
Africa trip, he temporarily quelled the Trump broadsides by essentially
declaring he was above the president’s social media rants. While
insisting he would continue preaching the Gospel message of peace, Leo
said it “is not in my interest at all,” to debate Trump.
“I primarily come to Africa as a pastor, as the head of the Catholic
Church to be with, to celebrate with, to encourage and accompany all the
Catholics throughout Africa,” he said.
He repeated that message at the trip’s conclusion, saying the
political role that comes with being pope, a head of state and global
moral authority, was simply not his priority.
An English-speaking American pope
For many, the shock of an American pope, who defied the taboo
precluding a Rome-based moral counterweight to the White House, still
hasn’t worn off.
“It’s been the first year of an American pope who has been critical
of what America is doing for the most part,” said Anthea Butler, senior
fellow at the Koch Institute, Oxford University.
She stressed that Leo is doing so “not coming full-on like Francis
would,” but approaching issues from the side. He’s not naming names,
he’s merely preaching the Gospel.
That approach has certainly helped some U.S. Catholic institutions,
after the American church developed an almost comically bad relationship
with Francis. His criticism of American-style capitalism was amplified
by U.S.-based conservative Catholic media during his papacy.
For many Vatican watchers, the Argentine pope simply didn’t “get” the
U.S., and vice versa. Some U.S. Catholics eventually soured on donating
to the Holy See under Francis, following years of unrelenting stories
of mismanagement, corruption and scandal.
But with a Chicago math major now pope, “he can’t be dismissed as
being ignorant of the realities in the United States,” said Kerry Alys
Robinson, chief executive of Catholic Charities USA, a national network
of Catholic agencies.
Robinson said she had never seen U.S. Catholic bishops so united as
now, particularly in speaking about the dignity of migrants and poor
people. She credits that to many factors, including the Trump
administration’s immigration crackdown and funding cuts that have
created a common purpose. But she doesn’t discount the unifying message
from Leo, in English.
“It’s very different when you are hearing the message without it being mediated through translation,” she said.
Repairing US relationships
Ward Fitzgerald, president of The Papal Foundation, which funds the
pope’s charity projects in the developing world, said an
English-speaking pope has been a boon especially in the U.S. and Europe,
where there is anecdotal evidence of a “Leo effect” spurring new
converts.
“I think there’s lots of reasons for it, but I certainly think that
having a pope who speaks English helps young people understand the
messages of the Holy Father,” Fitzgerald said in an interview. That also
translates to donors to the church, especially from the United States.
“When you tell a donor, ‘I really appreciate what you do’ in English —
and they’re English — I think it resonates,” Fitzgerald said. “And so
they give a little more.”
The Papal Foundation recently announced 25 new families had
joined its ranks since Leo’s election, a not-insignificant number given
membership requires a minimum $1.25 million pledge.
Fitzgerald and members of the foundation met with Leo last week and
gathered in St. Peter’s Basilica for a Mass celebrated by Cardinal
Timothy Dolan, the towering figure of the U.S. Catholic hierarchy and a
kingmaker in the 2025 conclave that elected Leo.
Dolan is also chummy with Trump, and is a member of his Religious Liberty Commission.
In his homily, Dolan extolled the attributes of St. Joseph, the
father of Christ and a figure so beloved in the church he is the patron
saint of more causes than any other saint. Dolan also revealed his
feelings about Leo, whom he had watched in the Sistine Chapel become the
267th pope a year ago Friday.
St. Joseph was a man of silence, Dolan said, calm and secure in his place.
“A man who exuded a sense of depth and substance. A man who is shy,
all right, a man who is focused on his mission,” he added. “A man,
always attentive to God’s plan.”
Dolan then asked the Americans seated in the pews if they could think of anyone else who fit St. Joseph’s description.
“I can,” Dolan said. “Pope Leo reminds me of Joseph.”