Saturday, November 14, 2026

PCI fails to justify sharing data on former church elder

The Presbyterian Church in Ireland (PCI) has failed to justify sharing sensitive personal data about a former church elder according to the Data Protection Commission (DPC).

The DPC upheld two complaints brought by Steven Smyrl, who was dismissed as an elder in the Church in 2019 following his same-sex marriage.

The DPC concluded that Dublin and Munster Presbytery failed to demonstrate that it had a lawful reason to use or share Mr Smyrl's personal information on two separate occasions.

The information included details about Mr Smyrl's sexual orientation and private life, which had originally been supplied in confidence during an internal Church disciplinary process.

In a letter of outcome, the DPC said it was engaging with the PCI about its data protection practices.

The complaints arose following two separate incidents that involved confidential documents being submitted to a commission established by Dublin and Munster Presbytery in 2019.

The six-member Presbytery Commission was set up to examine Mr Smyrl's position following his same-sex marriage.

During the proceedings, two documents of support were submitted - one by Mr Smyrl, the other by the minister & secretary to the church council of Christ Church Sandymount.

Mr Smyrl understood that the documents would remain confidential and would be seen only by the members of the judicial commission.

However, he later discovered that information contained in them had been used in other Church proceedings, which is why he complained to the DPC.

The first complaint related to December 2019, when four ministers in the Dublin and Munster Presbytery sought to establish a separate investigation into the minister and the church council of Christ Church Sandymount, because of their support for Mr Smyrl.

When ministers' request was refused, they appealed to the Presbyterian Church's Judicial Commission - its senior internal judicial body.

During that appeals process, one of the four ministers quoted directly from the confidential letter of support which included sensitive personal information about Mr Smyrl relating to his sexual orientation.

Mr Smyrl complained to the DPC that the information was used without his permission, and it agreed that the Presbytery had failed to demonstrate a lawful reason for this.

The second complaint related to a ruling by a Church inquiry in September 2021, which described Mr Smyrl and his spouse, Roy Stanley, as "sexually immoral people".

The couple considered the description defamatory and sought its withdrawal.

A draft letter prepared by the Church's solicitors was presented to a Presbytery meeting in February 2022, with the intention of retracting the description.

However, the letter was made available to approximately 30 ministers and elders attending the Presbytery meeting and was also sent to the minister and church council of Christ Church Sandymount the following day.

Mr Smyrl complained that the letter included highly sensitive personal information.

The DPC found that the Presbytery had failed to demonstrate why the additional private information was necessary, to retract the disputed description.

The DPC letter of outcome concluded that the Presbytery had failed to demonstrate a lawful reason for using the information in the two incidents.

It also noted that individuals who believe they have suffered harm because an organisation mishandled their personal information may be entitled to seek compensation through the courts.

Mr Smyrl has said that he intends to seek legal advice about possible compensation for the harm he believes he has suffered.

The DPC acknowledged that considerable time had passed since Mr Smyrl first submitted his complaint and expressed regret for the time taken in the case.

It added that it was engaging with the Presbytery about its data protection practices, with a view to addressing the shortcomings identified.

Mr Smyrl said that finally, he felt vindicated.

In a statement, he welcomed the outcome and thanked the DPC for upholding both complaints.

He said he had provided highly personal information in confidence and was deeply disturbed to discover that it had subsequently been shared with others.

"I find it deeply disturbing that PCI appears to have little regard for the privacy and dignity of individuals. I had supplied highly personal and deeply sensitive information in confidence and was utterly taken aback to discover that it was subsequently shared with others without consent," he said.

He said they had caused considerable embarrassment and humiliation, and he criticised what he described as the Church's apparent belief that its theological position gave it permission to demean people whose lives did not conform to its doctrines.

"A church should be expected to show compassion and respect for others," he said.

"Instead, my experience has been of an institution that seems to think it can do as it pleases, regardless of the consequences or hurt it causes."

Steven Smyrl said no organisation should consider itself above the law, and no individual's privacy or dignity should be treated as expendable.

The Presbyterian Church in Ireland and the Data Protection Commission have been contacted for comment.

Relic of saint who inspired Santa ‘burned and crushed’ in French church theft

Part of the bones of Saint Nicolas, the fourth-century bishop who inspired Father Christmas, has allegedly been destroyed in a church theft in France.

On 2 November priests at the Basilica of Saint-Nicolas-de-Port in Lorraine reported that a reliquary containing bone fragments of the saint had been stolen. 

Police have since arrested a suspect, who reportedly admitted acting spontaneously out of a “desire to destroy” the relic. 

 It was a secondary fragment rather than the basilica's famous finger bone relic. Saint Nicolas de Port is one of France's few sanctuaries to hold a relic of the saint.

An official public statement issued by the parish on 6 November 2026 stated the unnamed perpetrator admitted breaking the display case then burned and crushed the relic. His motivation was that he believed devotion to the bones was idol worship.

The parish said the attack was “a profound attack on our history, our faith."

Nicolas, who lived between 270 and 343 AD, was bishop of Myra in modern Turkey. He is best known for giving his inheritance to the poor, and for the story of how he gave three girls bags of gold to save them from prostitution.

The destroyed fragment had been placed beneath a statue of the saint in the patronal chapel in the early 2000s. The Association Connaissance et Renaissance de la Basilique, which works to preserve the building, said on 7 November that the basilica’s main relic is unharmed and remains in the treasury.

The town itself has a long history. Pilgrims have travelled there for almost 1,000 years. Italian sailors took Nicolas’ skeleton from Myra to Bari in 1087. In 1098, a knight, Aubert de Varangéville carried a bone fragment to Lorraine, traditionally identified as a finger from the saint’s right hand, the dextre bénissante, or “blessing right hand”.

This particular incident follows a string of thefts, vandalism and arson attacks on Christian heritage sites across France. It comes weeks before the saint’s feast, with the basilica’s torchlight procession planned for 5 December, the eve of the Feast of Saint Nicolas on 6 December.

North-west MPs sign letter to Archbishop of Liverpool over plans to fold Catholic schools into academies

Multiple members of Parliament from north-west England have signed a letter to Most Rev Archbishop John Sherrington, Archbishop of Liverpool, opposing a plan to fold more than 200 Catholic schools into academy trusts. 

Eight MPs, including Christian MP for Lancaster and Wyre Cat Smith, have signed the open letter to Archbishop John, questioning the plans and asking whether pupils will benefit. 

Paula Barker, Liverpool Wavertree MP, posted on Facebook that she and Maria Eagle, MP for Liverpool Garston, have reportedly had a meeting with the Archdiocese voicing concerns. 

Barker, Eagle and Smith have been joined by seven other MPs in signing the letter: Kim Johnson, MP for Liverpool Riverside; South Ribble MP Paul Foster; Maya Ellis of Ribble Valley; Blackpool North and Fleetwood MP Lorraine Beavers and Warrington North MP Charlotte Nichols.

Barker posted on the social media site on Tuesday 10 November, writing: "I am pleased that other NW colleagues have joined in opposing the plans. Thanks to all the parents who have shared their objections with me & I look forward to continuing to work together on this issue."

She raised the issue of how finances would be managed under academy trust governance and whether pupils, particularly pupils with special educational needs, would benefit. 

Academies have greater freedoms over their curriculum, term times and admission policy, and are not run by the local authorities, often the county council.

Archbishop John has called Catholic schools a vital part of the Church's educational mission and declared the proposal as a measure that he thinks protects Catholic education 'for future generations'. 

Sherrington said: "I believe we are better together, working together to serve the mission, having greater support for staff and keeping control of our educational system for the future generations of Catholic children and others. Together, we are a constellation of stars offering hope in our Archdiocese."

The Diocese of Lancaster has said the plans guarantee 'high-quality Catholic education'. 

There have already been strikes in Lancashire and Merseyside over the plan, and the trade union, the National Education Union, says that members at St Austin's Catholic Primary School in Liverpool have unanimously voted for strike action. Preston, Fleetwood and Liverpool schools have also taken industrial action. 

More strikes will take place from late November to early December if an agreement isn't made.

Big Church Festival rules out UK event in 2027 amid financial uncertainty

Big Church Festival has announced it will not hold a UK event in 2027, as organisers work to secure the future of the Christian music festival.

In a statement, organisers said they were “sad to announce that there will not be a UK festival in 2027”, but were working towards a return in August 2028.

The announcement comes after the charity behind the UK festival faced significant financial difficulties following the cancellation of this year's event.

The 2026 festival was brought to an early end on 28 August after a large sign fell at the site, killing 41-year-old Eastbourne pastor Robert Guanco and injuring six others. Investigations into the circumstances of the accident are ongoing.

In October, organisers told ticket holders that refunds could not be guaranteed, explaining that the festival costs millions of pounds to stage and that substantial costs had already been committed or incurred before the cancellation.

In an email to ticket holders, the charity said it was “not in a financial position to provide payments to ticket holders who might be entitled to receive some refund”.

Ticket holders were given the option of requesting a refund or donating the value of their tickets to help support the charity.

In its latest statement, organisers thanked those who had chosen to donate, saying their generosity was helping “give the Festival a chance at a future”.

The statement said:“With all that Big Church Festival is currently working through, we’re sad to announce that there will not be a UK festival in 2027. But please know we’re working as hard as we can to find a way back for August 2028, so pencil the bank holiday weekend into your diaries, and please continue to pray for a way forward. We are longing to be back together again!”

Despite the pause in the UK, organisers confirmed that Big Church Festival Europe will go ahead from 20 to 22 August 2027.

The European event was announced earlier this year and will be run by a separate charity, independent of the UK organisation.

Explaining the distinction, the statement said:“If you’re wondering how that’s possible, it’s because Big Church Festival Europe is owned and run by a different European charity and is independent of Big Church Festival here in the UK. It shares our name and the same vision: to gather the Church and create a space for people to meet Jesus.”

The UK organisers said they were “excited that the team in Europe will be carrying the Big Church vision in 2027” and encouraged supporters to follow the European festival on social media at @bigchurcheurope.

They also urged supporters to continue praying for the UK festival's return.

Catholic schools must stop having to justify their existence, says CEIST chief

The head of the Catholic secondary schools trust CEIST has said she hopes that within the next 15 years Catholic schools will no longer have to defend their place in the Irish education system.

Maeve Mahon, CEO of CEIST (Catholic Education An Irish Schools’ Trust), said the argument that there is no room for religious schools in a State system should be “done and dusted” by 2035–2040.

Speaking on The Irish Catholic’s Education Nation podcast, Ms Mahon was asked what she hoped Catholic education would look like in 2035 or 2040, and what she hoped would have been left behind.

“What I hope we’ll have lost, perhaps, is this need for us to constantly have to, if you like, say, ‘This is why we’re here, and we deserve a place in the system’ – that we’re not apologising for ourselves for much longer,” she said.

“I think we have stopped that in the main, but I think there is still a narrative out there that the State needs a secular State system, and that there’s no place for religious denominational schools in that system. I hope that conversation will be done and dusted by then… and it will have been settled.”

‘No such thing as value-free’

Ms Mahon rejected the idea that any school could be neutral on values. “In a truly secular society there is a space for everybody, and there is no such thing as a value-free society,” she said. “Every kind of institution you have – a school, a State school – still has values. It must have, or else what is it about?”

“This narrative that we’re hearing a lot of, that we need a value-free [system], that we don’t need a place that has Christian values – there’s no such thing as a value-free environment. There are values no matter what.”

She said she hoped the debate currently underway at the Education Convention and elsewhere, which “seems to be a lot about whether we should have any kind of school except a State school”, would have disappeared, and that there would instead be recognition of “a space for all kinds of different educational systems”.

“We all have a space. We all can claim a space,” she said.

‘In for the long haul’

Ms Mahon said her chief hope was that CEIST schools would not lose “who we are, and why we are”, and would remain places where students “are seen, and they know that they’re seen, they’re valued, and they’re loved”.

“I hope our CEIST schools will still be able to see that at the heart of their schools is the person of Jesus Christ and the values that he espoused, and that that’s what we’ll be working from – that that’s the why we do what we do, because we believe in the story. That would be my hope.”

She acknowledged that falling pupil numbers would mean fewer schools. “We probably will have less schools because, as we know, the demographics are going down anyway. So schools are going to have to rationalise, and we are going to have to rationalise our schools,” she said.

“But I think we will still do what we’ve set out to do, which is to continue to provide Catholic education for those who want it. As long as that need is there, CEIST will be there to answer it.

She concluded: “I firmly believe we’ll all still be here. I think CEIST schools are in for the long haul.”

Pope cites Benedict XVI in Chiclayo: "Without truth, love falls into mere sentimentalism"

Pope Leo XIV opened his homily with a greeting filled with affection for the faithful of his former diocese. 

“What joy it is to return to Chiclayo! It is a blessing for me to be with you once again,” said the Pontiff, who expressly thanked the people of Chiclayo for their prayers “especially for my health in these moments of trial that, with God’s help, I am overcoming.” 

The allusion comes just weeks after his hospitalization at the Gemelli Polyclinic in Rome for a pulmonary condition.

The Pope asked those present to continue praying for him so that the Lord might grant him “the grace to continue confirming my brothers and sisters in the faith,” a formula that directly recalls the mission entrusted to Peter.

Evangelization, a duty for every baptized person

The core of the homily was the evangelizing mission, which Leo XIV described as “an urgent and inescapable duty for every baptized person,” whether ordained ministers or lay faithful. To support this, he drew on Paul VI’s exhortation Evangelii nuntiandi, according to which evangelization constitutes the essential mission of the Church, its deepest vocation and its reason for being, and on the dogmatic constitution Lumen gentium, which presents the Church “as a universal sacrament of salvation.”

In response to the question of how to proclaim Christ today, the Pope answered that the key is “the witness of an authentically Christian and coherent life,” with Jesus Christ at the center of both the proclamation and of existence. That coherence, he clarified, is not merely the fruit of the will, but “a grace we must implore from the Lord.”

Leo XIV placed the encounter with Christ at the Last Supper and pointed to the Eucharist and the Word as “the two tables from which we live and are nourished.” From this he drew one of the most significant phrases of the day: “To evangelize is not to impose doctrines or to rely on efficient structures, but to bear witness to that real encounter with Jesus Christ.” Citing Francis’s Evangelii gaudium, he insisted that the mission does not rest on persuasive speeches or on proselytism, and he encouraged the recovery of “shared prayer” in homes, which he referred to as “little domestic Churches.”

“Without truth, love falls into mere sentimentalism”

Drawing on the second letter of Saint John, proclaimed in the day’s liturgy, the Pontiff stressed that the proclamation of the faith is linked to charity and to helping those most in need. He also referred to the encyclical Magnifica humanitas to highlight the connection between the Gospel proclamation and the transformation of “the structures of human coexistence.”

The Pope then balanced that social emphasis with an explicit reference to truth. Truth, he affirmed, “does not consist in a theory, an abstract idea or a utopia, but in a person, Jesus Christ,” who invites us to conform our lives to his “in faithful obedience to his commandments.” He recalled a teaching of Benedict XVI in Caritas in veritate: “Without truth, love falls into mere sentimentalism, and truth without love becomes rigid and cold.”

Leo XIV also acknowledged the seriousness of the crisis in the transmission of the faith. “In some regions of the world, this transmission has been almost completely interrupted,” he warned, pointing to religious indifference, materialism and selfishness as challenges. In the face of these, he urged the faithful to bring the Gospel into the family, the workplace and the public sphere, “resisting the temptation to relegate faith to the individual sphere.”

In the final stretch, the Pontiff recalled that “mission is not improvised” and extended an invitation to the entire Peruvian Church: “The world awaits us and the mission is only beginning.” He concluded by entrusting the evangelizing task to the intercession of Our Lady of Evangelization.

German ambassador to Vatican says Pope Leo XIV wants to visit Germany

According to Germany’s ambassador to the Vatican, Pope Leo XIV intends to visit the central European country.

Bruno Kahl, 63, said to Colonge-based Catholic website, domradio.de, that it was too early to start planning the trip but Leo’s intentions were clear.

“On behalf of the Federal Government, I renewed the invitation previously extended by the Federal President and confirmed by the Federal Foreign Minister. The answer is already clear: he intends to come to Germany,” he said.

“However, the exact sequence of his upcoming trips is not yet fully defined. He himself says he advised his predecessor to visit Germany and will, of course, heed that advice. It is still too early for concrete planning, though,” he added.

Crux Now‘s request for comment from the Vatican press office was without immediate reply.

Kahl also said his impressions of the pope were very positive.

“I was very impressed,” Kahl said. “The Pope is approachable, open, straightforward, speaks in an uncomplicated, direct way, and makes you feel personally taken seriously,” he said.

“He is very quick-witted, humorous, and therefore an exceptionally pleasant conversationalist,” he also said.

Kahl had previously been critical of the Vatican’s stance on the war between Russia and Ukraine, particularly during Pope Francis’ pontificate, but he was more approving of Leo’s view on the conflict.

“First, I need to correct that somewhat,” he said when asked about his previous comments.

“Especially regarding the criticism of equidistance, there has been progress between the pontificate of Francis and that of Leo XIV. Pope Leo clearly identified who the aggressor and who the victim is. I have little criticism to offer there,” he said.

Kahl also said that he himself is a Catholic.

“I am a very happy and very committed Catholic Christian. I try—as everyone tries—to live my convictions in everyday life. There are many opportunities to do this in professional contexts, whether it’s managing employees or representing the Church’s principles,” he revealed.

A complex relationship

The prospect of a papal trip to Germany is an intriguing one given the complex relationship between the Vatican and the German church in recent years.

Following a landmark study into sexual abuse in the Church in Germany in 2018, the German Church launched the “Synodal Path” in 2019, a series of meetings and consultations.

Among other things, this process has led to calls for ordination of women as priests and deacons, more lay involvement in the Church, and blessings of couples in same-sex relationships.

The Vatican has issued a number of warnings that the “Synodal Path” does not have the authority to change Church teaching.

“In order to protect the freedom of the People of God and the exercise of episcopal ministry, it seems necessary to specify that the ‘Synodal Way’ in Germany has no power to oblige the bishops and the faithful to adopt new ways of governing and new approaches to doctrine and morals,” the Vatican said in a 2022 statement.

“It would not be lawful,” the Vatican continued, “to initiate in dioceses, before an agreement reached at the level of the universal Church, new official structures or doctrines, which would represent a wound to ecclesial communion and a threat to the unity of the Church.”

In 2023, Francis criticized the process as “elitist” and “ideological” during an interview with Associated Press.

In 2024, a video circulated online of Francis jokingly asking German bishop Jörg Michael Peters, Auxiliary Bishop of Trier, “Are you Catholic?”

In April of this year, German journalists asked Leo about comments made by Cardinal Reinhard Marx, in which the archbishop of Munich and Freising had said priests should bless couples in same-sex unions or in marriages not recognized as valid by the Catholic Church.

In his response, Leo said the Holy See “has made it clear that we do not agree with the formalized blessing of couples, in this case, homosexual couples, as you asked, or couples in irregular situations, beyond what was specifically, if you will, allowed for by Pope Francis in saying all people receive blessings.”

There have also been public clashes as recently as this November.

Following Leo’s comments on the way back from his trip to France that abuse is “first and foremost a human problem”, Bishop Georg Bätzing of Limburg published a statement on his diocesan website criticizing him last week.

“Should the Church downplay or deny the systemic causes of sexualized violence, that would be a serious setback,” Bätzing said. “It would further hurt victims and jeopardize the credibility of the investigation.”

Pope Leo XIV meets survivors of clerical abuse in Peru

Pope Leo XIV has met six survivors of clerical and institutional abuse in Peru, listening to their accounts of suffering and reflecting with them on the need for truth, healing and the creation of safe environments within the Church.

The meeting took place shortly after 4.30pm local time on 12 November at the Apostolic Nunciature in Lima and lasted just over an hour, according to a statement from the Holy See Press Office.

The six participants had suffered abuse at the hands of members of the clergy and ecclesiastical institutions in Peru. The Vatican statement noted that some of the survivors had previously belonged to groups linked to the Sodalitium of Christian Life, the Peruvian ecclesiastical movement.

Following a brief greeting in the chapel of the Nunciature, His Holiness met each survivor individually, listening to their personal accounts of suffering and pain.

The discussions also considered how to bring about a change in mindset within the Church through listening to victims, seeking the truth, supporting processes of healing and committing to the establishment of safe environments.

At the conclusion of the meeting, His Holiness thanked the survivors for their testimonies and expressed his closeness to them and to all victims of abuse whom he had been unable to meet during his visit. Before departing, the Pope imparted his blessing on those present.

The encounter came on the same day as His Holiness addressed more than 60,000 young people and university students gathered at Lima’s Estadio Nacional for a prayer vigil, the final event of his first full day in Peru.

During the gathering, Pope Leo urged young people not to allow past mistakes, personal suffering or uncertainty about the future to prevent them from following Christ.

“Perhaps some of you may think that you have made too many mistakes or that it is already too late to begin again. I would like to say to you: Look to Jesus. He knows your story and continues to invite you to walk with Him,” His Holiness said.

The Pope encouraged those present not to believe that they needed to have their entire futures settled before responding to God’s invitation. “You do not need to have your entire future figured out before responding to Him. Take the step you can take today. Trust in His love and allow Him to accompany you. Often, the Lord shows us the way as we walk along it,” the Pope said.

Reflecting on the questions and uncertainties facing young people, His Holiness emphasised that Christ was concerned with every aspect of their lives. “Jesus is interested in all of this because He is interested in you,” His Holiness said.

The Pope encouraged them to speak honestly to Christ, even when they struggled to find the words for prayer, reminding them that the Lord knew their tears and the questions to which they had not yet found answers.

He also stressed that suffering did not have the final word and urged young people to seek the support of those who loved them, acknowledging that some sorrows required both time and the assistance of others. His Holiness warned against allowing the expectations of others to determine the course of their lives, reminding the gathering that every individual had a unique contribution to make.

“God created you capable of doing a good that no one else can accomplish in exactly the same way,” the Pope said.

Addressing the fear that following God’s will might require abandoning personal ambitions, the Pope warned against the temptation to believe that sin was necessary to experience life fully, referring to the account of the Fall in Genesis 3:5.

Burnham's bill to reform church appointments takes step closer to becoming law

A bill which would allow Andy Burnham, as Prime Minister, to advise on bishop and archbishop appointments has taken another step closer to becoming law. 

As a professing Catholic, Burnham is barred from advising the King on appointments in the Church of England under the Roman Catholic Relief Act 1829. 

The Jews Relief Act 1858 puts the same restriction on those of the Jewish faith.

The Prime Minister called this an “antiquated and archaic anomaly” in September, being “unacceptable for there to be a legislative bar against people of any faith performing all the functions of my office.”

Approval from the Prime Minister is now symbolic in the modern day, as the Church puts forward its candidate, but the practice dates back to the Reformation when the monarch became head of the Church and took responsibility for appointments. 

The Church Appointments (Repeal of Discriminatory Provision) Bill passed second reading in the House of Lords on Tuesday with support from across the chamber, including on the Bishops’ Benches. 

Speaking in favour, the Bishop of Manchester, Rt Rev David Walker, said: “This is a modest but important Bill that brings our constitution to closer alignment with the values of modern Britain. The restriction preventing those who profess the Catholic or Jewish faiths from advising the crown on church appointments has its origins in a very different period."

"I and other Christians believe that God created humans equally and in his own image, each of us with inherent value and purpose."

He added: "The strength of our UK democracy is derived from the unique diversity of its participants.”

He went on to say he believed it was important for the Prime Minister, and their appointments secretary, to be included in the process, reflecting interests “on behalf of the nation” so new appointments “can serve wider society at both diocesan and national level, while also serving the structures of the Church.”

Bishop David concluded: “The repeal of this discriminatory provision will strengthen not only the important relationship between Church and state but the constitution itself, by better reflecting the principles of religious freedom and equal citizenship.”

Not all parliamentarians have been supportive of the change. Sir Edward Leigh MP, who is Catholic, told the House of Commons he was “not sure that many of us Jews and Catholics have really felt discriminated against since 1829”. He added that the government should focus on “more important things”.

The bill will go through its final stages in the House of Lords on 23 November. If passed, it will go to the King, the Supreme Governor of the Church, for Royal Assent to become law.

Former Methodist leader tells sexual assault trial he is ‘tactile’ but not sexually motivated

A Methodist minister has denied any sexual motive to his 'tactile' behaviour as he gives evidence at trial where he is accused of sexual assault.

Rev Steven Wild, formerly the most senior Methodist in Cornwall, told Truro Crown Court on Thursday that he is “tactile” and “touchy” but has never been sexually attracted to women in his congregation.

The 72-year-old from St Ives denies ten counts of sexual assault and one of indecent assault against several adult women who were members of the Methodist Church.

The alleged offences span 2004 to 2019 and took place in the Isles of Scilly, Cornwall, Devon, Southport, Bristol and Derbyshire.

The prosecution alleges he hugged women for far longer than necessary, touched their thighs, legs or knees, and repeatedly kissed their cheeks. Some complainants said they felt unable to speak out because of his seniority and were told it was just “Steve being Steve”. One woman said he pressed his groin against her leg.

When asked about this, Wild replied: “I pushed my groin into nobody but my lovely wife.”

However, Wild did describe hugging and touching as common in church life, which he says was an expression of “the oneness of the body of Christ”. He originally told the police that he couldn't remember if he had put his hand on a woman's thigh, but any contact like that would have been accidental.

In reference to complaints that people felt they couldn't question his behaviour because of his seniority, he denied suggesting to women that complaining about him would be "doing the Devil’s work".   

Wild told his barrister: "I don't talk about Satan...Only in Bible studies. I would never refer to Satan in that way. I would never do that."

The court heard that the Methodist Church carried out seven safeguarding audits in Cornwall between 2018 and 2021 and that he was suspended in 2021.

Austrian bishops adopt first rules for AI in the Church

The Austrian Bishops’ Conference has adopted its first rules on the use of artificial intelligence in the Church, declaring that AI may never take the place of human relationships, pastoral conversations, or the rites of the Church.

“The use of AI in the celebration of the sacraments, preaching, liturgy, or pastoral care may only be supportive,” a core provision of the new framework states. “Replacing human relationships, pastoral conversations, community, or rituals with AI is inadmissible and is expressly rejected.”

The bishops published the provision in their press statement on Thursday, explaining: “Particularly in preaching, liturgy, and pastoral care, the irreplaceability of personal encounter and human relationship must be preserved.”

The full document section is titled “Framework Regulation on the Use of AI Systems in the Catholic Church in Austria and Its Institutions.” It takes effect once it is published in the next official gazette of the bishops’ conference. The bishops met in Salzburg from Monday to Thursday.

“Artificial intelligence is reaching ever more areas of life. The opportunities it brings are matched by high risks,” the statement said. “AI also opens up new possibilities for the work and mission of the Church. Its use brings new ethical, legal, and social challenges and calls for responsible handling.”

“The rules are grounded in the Christian image of man, the inviolable dignity of every person, and respect for their freedom,” the bishops said. “AI should serve the human person and strengthen him in his responsibility, not replace him. Its use therefore requires critical review, human oversight, and orientation toward truth, justice, and the common good.”

The framework also sets organizational requirements. “Among other things, the rules provide that every diocese must appoint a person responsible for AI,” the bishops’ conference said. “For cooperation across Austria, a new working group is being set up that includes all diocesan AI officers.” Experts in data protection, information technology, and theological ethics will also take part, as will the Austrian Conference of Religious Orders.

In November 2025 the bishops’ conference set up a working group on the use of artificial intelligence in the Church. Led by Bishop Hermann Glettler of Innsbruck, it was tasked with examining legal and ethical questions as well as practical applications for the Church.

At their summer plenary in Mariazell in June, the bishops explicitly endorsed Pope Leo XIVʼs social encyclical Magnifica Humanitas.

“Pope Leo calls on us, even in the face of the promises of AI, to preserve the greatness of the human person, indeed the ‘beauty of being human,’ as a corrective and a standard,” they wrote at the time.

They quoted the encyclical: “It is not enough for artificial intelligence to make us more efficient or connected; it must also serve to build a universal human family, with shared rights and duties, where digital proximity becomes a real opportunity for encounter and mutual care.”

In the era of artificial intelligence, the encyclical says, “ours is the pressing duty to remain profoundly human.” The bishops added in June: “Precisely because it is the rich and powerful who develop AI systems and use them to their advantage, we need the perspective of the poor, the weak, and the disadvantaged that the pope has called for.”

“The future will not be decided by the performance of our systems but by whether we take responsibility — for the human person and for a culture of encounter, love, and peace,” they wrote.

Pope Leo XIV meets abuse victims in Peru, says Church must make 'amends'

Pope Leo XIV met six victims of clerical abuse in Peru on Thursday, including some linked to the once-powerful and now-disbanded Catholic society, Sodalitium Christianae Vitae.

The US-born pope is on a nostalgic return to the nation he calls his "homeland", and knows the abuse scandal well from the nearly two decades he worked in Peru as a missionary and bishop.

Leo spent over an hour with the victims, meeting "each person individually, listening to their stories of suffering and their pain," and "thanked them for their invaluable testimony," the Vatican said.

Together, "they reflected on how to foster a shift in mindset – by listening to victims, seeking the truth, pursuing paths towards healing, and committing to the creation of safe environments," it said.

Sodalitium Christianae Vitae (SCV), a lay society founded in the 1970s that was widespread in Latin America, was shut down in 2025 by Leo's predecessor Francis after years of allegations of sexual, physical and psychological abuse, as well as corruption.

Before he was elected Pope Leo XIV, Robert Francis Prevost was the bishop designated to hear from SCV victims, who said he was supportive of their claims.

'Pain'

In an address to bishops earlier Thursday, Leo described the "pain" caused by Catholic clerical abuse and said the Church must make "amends" to victims and foster "a culture of prevention and protection."

Clerical abuse, a global scourge, was "a reality that has caused us so much pain," the 71-year-old said.

In April 2026, the Vatican announced plans to set up a "listening channel" in Lima for victims, and use assets seized from the lay movement to compensate them.

Renzo Orbegozo, a 50-year-old victim, told AFP they were seeking "comprehensive reparation."

"Many require psychological and medical support, as well as social reintegration – all of which, ultimately, translates into financial assistance," he said.

On the eve of the pope's South America tour, the US-based non-profit Bishop Accountability presented a list in Lima of 77 members of the Peruvian clergy it said had been publicly accused of abusing minors.

Anne Barrett Doyle, co-director of the group, called on Leo to implement "zero tolerance" of abusers.

'Knows Peruvians' needs'

The head of the 1.4 billion Catholics has not shied away from tackling sensitive political and social topics during his three-nation Latin American tour.

Pilgrim Pedro Campos said Leo was "a member of our country who ... knows the needs of all Peruvians."

At a speech later to some 40,000 people on the challenges facing Peruvians, the pontiff slammed "machismo" attitudes and said violence against women was "a reality that wounds all of humanity."

There was no excuse for "an unequal sharing of domestic responsibilities or the subordination of one spouse to the other," he said.

Chicago-born Leo was given a raucous reception by crowds lining the streets, chanting his name.

Thousands of people – including children dressed as the pope or as bishops – lined up for a glimpse of the pope as he drove by in the popemobile.

At a prayer vigil attended by some 60,000 young people in Lima's national stadium, the pope made his way around on foot to greet people, as thousands held up their phones as torches.

'Steep ascents'

The intense trip to Uruguay, Argentina and Peru comes just weeks after the pope had surgery for lung cancer, but he shows no sign of flagging.

In his speech, Leo made fond references to Peru's landscape and culture, telling the Catholic clergy to think of their mission as a difficult but rewarding walk, like the path that leads to Machu Picchu.

He compared the Catholic mission to the "steep ascents" of the Inca Trail in Peru.

The trail, an ancient network of routes that traverses much of the Andes, "is not to be walked alone," he cautioned.

During his tenure in Peru, Prevost worked in poor and remote northern areas, and remained close to local communities during periods of hardship, visiting them sometimes on horseback.

"Walking together fosters communion," he said.
Six days in Peru will see Leo travel from the deep Amazon to the high Andes. He will visit Cuzco, at more than 3,400 metres (11,000 feet) elevation, which will test his recovery from lung surgery.

He will also make an emotional return to Chiclayo, the northern city where he was bishop for a decade.

Burglar sentenced for stealing around €1,000 from Dublin city centre church

A Dublin parish team has told a court that it diverted limited resources that would've been used to support their community to cover repairs after a burglary of their church.

James Byrne (45) took around €1,000 from a safe at Our Lady of Lourdes Church, Sean McDermott Street on August 4, 2025.

He also damaged locks and internal doors, with repairs costing €1,800, Dublin Circuit Criminal Court heard on Thursday.

The court heard that a priest arriving to say Mass the following morning found a private locked area at the back of the sacristy ransacked, and the safe open. An office area had also been disturbed, with locks broken.

Gardai found a ring near the safe, which they collected as an exhibit. DNA obtained from the ring matched Byrne.

He was also identified from CCTV.

Byrne, with an address at Parnell Square, Dublin 1, made admissions when he was later interviewed by gardai, identifying himself on CCTV.

He denied the ring was his and said he didn't wear one. When it was put to him that he'd stolen €1,000 from the church's safe, he said it wasn't that much and apologised.

Byrne told gardai that he was addicted to cocaine and cannabis at the time and carried out the burglary to fund his habit and as he'd been threatened.

In a victim impact statement read to the court, members of the Our Lady of Lourdes parish team said that this incident had shattered the sense of safety and the sanctity of the church.

They said that the limited resources that could have supported the community had to be diverted to repair the damage caused.

The parish team outlined feelings of anxiety and fear, that some now look over their shoulders and find themselves locking doors. They said there is now a "constant distracting worry about our personal safety" and that Byrne's actions had "deeply disrupted" their lives and strained limited resources.

Byrne has 60 previous convictions, including 30 for burglary and four for criminal damage. He is currently serving a three-year and nine-month sentence, with the final nine months suspended, for other burglaries committed around the same time as this incident.

The investigating garda agreed with defence counsel that Byrne admitted to the offence and that no one was confronted or attacked during the burglary.

Counsel suggested to the garda that this incident should have been dealt with alongside the other offences committed by Byrne around the same time, for which he was sentenced earlier this year. The garda noted that it took time to obtain DNA analysis from the ring as part of the investigation.

A letter of apology and letters from Tiglin and Merchants Quay were handed to the court.

Defence counsel said that Byrne's addiction "has ruined his life" and left him living in hostels for 20 years.

Byrne is making efforts to address his addiction and has enhanced status since going into custody.

Judge Orla Crowe accepted the defence's submission that if this incident had been captured at the same time as Byrne's other recent offending, all would have been sentenced together.

However, she noted that there was no fault on any party and that it was "proper policing" for the gardai to wait for DNA analysis before charging an accused person.

Imposing sentence, Judge Crowe noted that a church is a particular type of premises and a "place of sanctuary" where people go "to look for comfort".

She said the victim impact statement was "particularly evocative" noting that some of the people who work there say they look over their shoulders when they go in and are afraid of what they might find.

She said they were "very upset" by what had happened.

The judge said that Byrne's drug problem is "front and centre" and at the root of his offending.

Having considered the mitigation, the judge said she would impose a sentence to run alongside the sentence Byrne is currently serving.

She imposed a two-year sentence backdated to July when Byrne entered his guilty plea.

Ramón Castro, president of the Mexican episcopate, accompanies Leo XIV in Peru to "gather learnings" ahead of a possible visit to Mexico

Mons. Ramón Castro Castro, Bishop of Cuernavaca and president of the Mexican Episcopal Conference (CEM), will accompany Leo XIV during his apostolic visit to Peru, which takes place from November 11 to 16. 

The news was announced on November 11, at the beginning of the CXXI Plenary Assembly of the Mexican bishops, through the Catholic News Network, the media outlet of the Episcopal Commission for the Pastoral of Communication of the CEM. 

Castro travels at the invitation of the Peruvian Episcopal Conference to represent the bishops of Mexico in the activities of the Pontiff, and described the invitation as “a gift of providence” that will allow him to strengthen the bonds of fraternity with the Peruvian Church.

Learning from the Peruvian organization

Peru is the third and final stage of a trip that the Pope began on November 6 and which will conclude on the 17th, after passing through Uruguay and Argentina. 

Beyond the gesture of communion between episcopates, Castro presented a practical reason: to establish collaborative ties with the bishops of Peru and learn about their experience in the preparation and organization of the papal visit. 

The objective, according to the CEM, is to “gather learnings” useful for the Church in Mexico in the event of a possible arrival of the Pope to the country, whose visit has been desired on various occasions, so that the Mexican episcopate thus joins the episcopal conferences that have asked the Pontiff to visit their territory.

A message from the trip

Castro addressed the faithful through social media with a phrase that summarizes the meaning of his presence: “Know that I carry each one of you in my heart.” 

Ramón Castro was elected president of the CEM during the plenary assembly of November 2024, as InfoVaticana reported at the time.

Octavi Vilà before Barcelona: an ERE in Poblet, a monk under investigation and the 2017 statements

On December 19, in the Sagrada Familia, Barcelona will have as archbishop a man who was ordained a priest eleven and a half years earlier. 

The sequence of Octavi Vilà Mayo fits in a single line: presbyter on May 1, 2015, abbot of Poblet seven months later, bishop of Girona in February 2024, and archbishop-elect since November 11. 

What public sources record about that trajectory goes beyond the profile of a monk with a late vocation. There is an abbacy marked by a collective dismissal, a community that his successor last year put at 17 monks, and the arrest of a religious for touching a girl, a case for which no sentence is known. 

There are two statements signed in September and October 2017, at the height of the independence process. And there are two and a half years in Girona that leave the diocese with six archpriestships where there had been thirteen.

Tarragona, December 11, 1961, and the classrooms of La Salle are the starting point. The University of Barcelona awarded him a degree in Geography and History in 1984 and a diploma in Library Science and Documentation in 1987, to which he added two postgraduate degrees, in new information technologies and in cultural management. His working life took place in the newspaper archive of Tarragona, from 1983 to 2005. 

In those years he accumulated positions in the lay environment of Poblet and Santes Creus: the secretariat and vice-presidency of the Bibliographic Archive of Santes Creus since 1998, the secretariat of the Brotherhood of Poblet since 2000, with Ramon Mullerat as president, and that of the Poblet Board of Trustees since 2003, as well as a seat on the board of the Montserrat Tarradellas i Macià archive, which the monastery holds. 

When in July 2005 he knocked on the abbey’s door, at the age of 43, he had already spent five years sitting on its lay governing bodies. Diari de Tarragona recalled in October, when reporting on a lecture he gave at the Centre de Lectura in Reus, a little-known family connection: Vilà is the great-grandson of Maria del Carme, sister of Joan Baptista Grau, the bishop of Astorga who commissioned Gaudí to design the episcopal palace.

In Poblet the path was swift. Temporary vows came in January 2007 and solemn profession on August 15, 2010. The Faculty of Theology of Catalonia had him as a student between 2007 and 2015 and granted him a licentiate in Systematic Theology. The biography of the Episcopal Conference lists him as superior in May 2014. On May 1, 2015 he received priestly ordination and on December 3 the community elected him abbot; the abbatial blessing took place on February 27, 2016. From that ceremony remains one of his phrases: “I am abbot for you, I am a monk with you.” 

On December 2, 2021 came the community’s confirmation, extending his crozier until the canonical age. As abbot he presided over the Cistercian Congregation of the Crown of Aragon, sat on the General Chapter and the Synod of the Order, and headed the board of the Tarradellas archive.

His abbacy coincided with the central years of the independence process. Crónica Global places the abbot at the inauguration of Carles Puigdemont as president of the Generalitat and reproduces the dialogue of that day: “Poblet is my house,” the president told him upon learning which monastery he came from, and the abbot left the door open. The invitation had its effect: the president returned on a private visit, prayed and ate with the community, and stayed almost the entire day. 

At the end of March 2017 the visitor was the Hispanist John H. Elliott. A chronicle by Cayetana Álvarez de Toledo in El Mundo, then cited by the blog Germinans Germinabit, records that the abbot asked him about the parallel between 1640 and the situation at that moment and about the heirs of the Count-Duke of Olivares. Crónica Global reads in that second question an allusion to the government of Mariano Rajoy.

On September 21, 2017, ten days before the illegal referendum, his signature and that of the abbot of Montserrat, Josep Maria Soler, closed a joint statement. Two ideas structured the text: a call for prudence and responsibility on the part of the Catalan and Spanish governments, with dialogue as the way out, and the obligation to serve the common good by listening to the voice of the majority. 

On October 3, two days after the vote, a second statement appeared with eight signatures: those of Soler and Vilà, those of five abbesses and prioresses, and that of the prior of Solius. Four assertions summarize it: a Catalan political and social movement that has been “immensely and overwhelmingly peaceful” from the beginning, the condemnation of violence in all its forms, the rejection of unnecessary force, whether from a group or from public authority, and the demand for negotiated solutions.

Then came the visits to the imprisoned independence leaders. Ara, Catalunya Religió and Hispanidad take them for granted, although none of the three specifies dates, prisons or names. Nació Digital attributes to him, without dating it, a statement of sorrow for “the exiles and the imprisoned.” Ara summarizes his position in those years as support for the so-called right to decide and for a dialogue that would not override the will of the Catalans. The nationalist label does not fit him, in the view of Hispanidad. Puigdemont publicly celebrated his appointment to Girona in 2024. Crónica Global also attributes to him dealings with Oriol Junqueras.

On July 20, 2020 the visitors were the King and Queen, with the abbot and the prior, Rafel Barruè, waiting for them at the monastery door. The entourage included Minister Salvador Illa and the Government Delegate, Teresa Cunillera, and no representative of the Catalan Executive. The protest, called by Òmnium, the ANC and the CDR, gathered about five hundred people and ended with some police charges and one detainee. From February 2025, already in Girona, comes his assessment in Ara: a lower political tension than in 2017 and a Church that then wanted to build bridges and found it hard to find common ground.

That same year 2017 left another encounter in Poblet. From June 9 to 11, as this medium reported on November 12, the Catalan bodies of the Supreme Council of the 33rd Degree met in the monastery, with the then Síndic de Greuges as speaker. Neither of the two sources documenting that meeting mentions the abbot or specifies in which premises it was held. The news archive of the Supreme Council itself now allows an additional detail to be added: of the Catalan meetings it records between 2017 and 2025, the one in Poblet is the only one held in a monastery. For the others it gives the city or the county and, in a single case, the venue: a hotel in Granollers.

Poblet also preserves the memory of the Duke of Wharton, founder in Madrid of the first Spanish lodge, buried in 1731 in the church atrium. In 1952 the slab lost its place in the temple, and outside the wall the Spanish Wikipedia places it. The local historian Josep Maria Vallès i Martí maintains something else. In an article published in February 2023 in the journal Cultura i Paisatge he dates to December 13, 2017, following dampness in the chapel of Saint Benedict, the return of the slab and the remains to their original location, and places them since then in the chapel of the Holy Sepulchre, in the galilee, which is the church atrium. Vilà had then been abbot for two years. The information rests on that single source and arrives without documentary support.

Behind the external guesthouse, opened in 2010, was the Fundació Populus Alba, the private entity that runs the monastery’s economy. Its presidency fell in 2021 to the abbot himself. The closure came on May 21, 2021. Nine days later Diari de Tarragona reported that the foundation had notified the workers, after thirteen months of a temporary lay-off scheme, of a collective dismissal affecting 15 of the 22 employees of the complex. The staff recalled that the 7.6 million euros for the building had come from public funds. Losses in accommodation was the foundation’s argument; “bad management,” the reproach of those dismissed. The building’s second life began on July 1, 2022 and bears the signature of Petits Hotels, the company that operates it. 

The reopening chronicle published by Catalunya Religió attributed to Vilà a conviction: without clients of all kinds the accounts would not balance. Business tourism, congresses and weddings: that was the market it was aiming for. The horizon of financial recovery that his successor, Rafel Barruè, gave in April 2025 to the Agència Catalana de Notícies is 2032, after years of losses.

From that same conversation comes the state of the community. There were 17 monks, four of them in the infirmary. Barruè counts himself as the 33rd monk on the day he entered; roughly half have been lost along the way. The last two solemn professions date from January 2020. The novitiate of the pandemic, seven aspirants, ended without a single perseverance. Between that January and Vilà’s departure to Girona, four years passed without the abbey adding a single solemnly professed monk. In 2024, after the election of the new abbot, Diari de Tarragona put the community at around twenty.

In the summer of 2021 the abbey faced the arrest of one of its monks. The arrest, carried out by the Mossos d’Esquadra on August 25, fell on a 68-year-old religious to whom touching a five-year-old girl was attributed. The reported facts took place ten days earlier, on August 15, in the monastery square, in daylight, after Mass and with the parents present. The complaint was signed by a German tourist and included a photograph. The following day two different messages left the monastery. 

The first, official, bore the abbot’s signature: the community’s consternation, solidarity with the girl and her family, and three precautionary measures for the monk—outside all pastoral activity, without leaving the enclosure and without capitular rights—plus a canonical investigation. The second was reported by TV3 from an unidentified monastery spokesperson: a “witch hunt” and an abuse that, at that hour and in that place, did not seem credible. The same expression is put by VilaWeb in the mouth of Tòfol Trepat, whom it presents as president of the Poblet board of trustees and for whom those were not sexual touches but a possible misunderstanding by the tourist.

The monk’s judicial statement, that same August 26, contained the admission of a single touch, according to monastery sources cited by the Agència Catalana de Notícies. The release on charges decided by the duty court of Valls was accompanied by periodic appearances, withdrawal of the passport, prohibition to leave Spain and an order not to approach the girl or communicate with her. The investigation corresponded to the Court of First Instance and Instruction number 3 of Valls. 

The homily at the conventual Mass on Sunday the 29th was the abbot’s personal response: a community ashamed and repentant, turned into “a stumbling block for believers and non-believers,” and the idea that a brother’s fault is the sin of all. What came afterward is known through his successor. Barruè’s account to the same agency, in April 2025, has four parts. The first, an out-of-court agreement with the family, still unsigned, with financial compensation and a 200-meter distance, which would not be final until there was a trial date. The second, a complaint: justice is moving “excessively slowly.” The third, the monk’s absence from the church liturgy, which the family frequented. The fourth, a protocol for the protection of minors drawn up with the Fundació Vicki Bernadet, in application but still without the monks’ signature. Since then no resolution, judicial or canonical, has been recorded.

The next destination was Girona, by appointment of Francis on February 29, 2024. The see had been vacant since the death of Francesc Pardo on March 31, 2022, and Ara highlighted the historical leap: 593 years without a monk in it. The episcopal ordination took place on April 21 in the cathedral. From the interview he gave those days to La Vanguardia two ideas remained: abuses, handled “incorrectly” for many years, and parishes, which he did not intend to close although he did plan to group their faithful in the larger ones for Sunday Mass. 

Catalunya Cristiana, which interviewed him as bishop-elect, then put the diocese at around 380 parishes spread across thirteen archpriestships, 110 incardinated priests and two seminarians. From that conversation comes an idea he attributed to the conciliar constitution Lumen gentium: “the Church goes from the bottom up,” and its starting point is the people, not the episcopate.

The balance of his first two years appeared in Diari de Girona. Agència Flama summarized that May 2026 interview with an admission by the bishop, that the organization of the territory called for a review, and with the figures that explain it: 381 parishes, four seminarians and a clergy with an average age of over 73. The headline was his: “Now Catholics are so by conviction, not by inertia.” The review came on July 28 with three decrees. The main one reduced the thirteen archpriestships to six and gave them names of Marian shrines; another opened a consultation to designate the new archpriests, already appointed this autumn. 

In matters of abuse his management leaves three facts: a diocesan commission based outside the bishopric, the closure of two cases that remained open with the accused already deceased, and a face-to-face request for forgiveness from the person who had suffered the abuse. The data come from his February 2025 interview with Ara, the same one in which abuse of power and of conscience merited a phrase with a recipient: “the Opus Dei must work on this aspect, evidently.”

In that same interview immigration appears as easy material for populism, and the Church as a place where integration also occurs through language. The papal blessing of the tower of Jesus of the Sagrada Familia, in June 2026, gave him occasion to apply it: he had to speak in Catalan, he came to say, while from the archdiocese of Barcelona came a categorical denial of any agreement in that sense. Catalan did end up entering the ceremony, as this medium then reported. Arenys de Munt and Sant Iscle de Vallalta lost in February, by decision signed by the bishop, the rector they had received five months earlier, who provisionally retained Arenys de Mar. The official explanation was the care of some relatives; the municipal radio station’s included possible disagreements in the parish. 

An opinion piece published in this medium in September stated that the community requesting the traditional Mass in the diocese remains without a church. Hispanidad summarizes his Girona period in three words: “he went unnoticed.” The most resounding praise comes from the mayor of Girona, Lluc Salellas, of the CUP, who sees almost no one better for Barcelona.

The succession to Omella was prepared for months. Catalunya Religió dates the formal start of the process to June, around the papal visit, and attributes the final consultations to Nuncio Piero Pioppo. The same medium said the cardinal was satisfied and brought up his friendship with Josep Alegre, the abbot who preceded Vilà. 

Religión Confidencial maintains that his candidacy had behind it high officials of the Generalitat, that the Catalan Government moved intensely in Rome and Madrid, and that the archbishop of Tarragona, Joan Planellas, was one of the main backers of a Catalan-born archbishop. Hispanidad states, on the contrary, that Omella would have preferred Florencio Roselló, archbishop of Pamplona. 

Crónica Global reports the satisfaction of sources in the Govern and the reservations of anonymous ecclesiastical sources about the intellectual and theological formation of the chosen candidate. Against those reservations stand the licentiate in Systematic Theology in his official biography and the public judgment of Omella, who has described him as a man “intellectually prepared.”

He learned of the appointment on October 27, from the nuncio, and gave his consent. Girona occupied the first place in what he conveyed: that the diocese should not again go long without a bishop. From his appearance on the day of the announcement also remains this phrase: “They have come as they have come; I have never sought these responsibilities.” 

The following day he was in Girona, concelebrating with Planellas. Several questions remain without public answer: where Wharton’s slab is today and who decided to move it, how the monk’s case has ended, by what criterion the guesthouse admitted meetings such as the one in June 2017, and what accounts were left by the foundation the abbot presided over.