Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Over 300 Christian Brothers served with newspaper summons

The names of over 300 former Christian Brothers have been published in a national newspaper, following an order from the High Court almost two weeks ago.

It is the second time in recent months that former members of the congregation have been served with a summons by way of a national newspaper advertisement.

The 314 former members have been named publicly as part of a claim for damages for childhood sexual abuse, although it is not being alleged that the men whose names have been published had anything to do with the crimes.

In July this year, Ms Justice Mary Rose Gearty separately issued a similar order regarding 341 former members of the Christian Brothers.

The move came following the congregation's decision not to provide a nominee for the purposes of litigation in a case in which a man is seeking damages for the sexual and physical abuse he suffered at the hands of Liam Coughlan, a former Christian Brother, at CBS primary school on Stephen Street in Kilkenny in the 1970s.

Liam Coughlan of Pine Grove, Tramore, Co Waterford was jailed in 2023 for sexually assaulting numerous boys at the school during the 1970s, including the man at the centre of the case. He died in prison last month.

As an unincorporated body, the Christian Brothers cannot be sued if it does not provide a 'nominee'.

In circumstances where no member of an unincorporated body puts themself forward to represent a body as a whole in litigation, all of the relevant members may be pursued.

Philip Treacy of Coleman Legal has said the names of 435 former members of the Christian Brothers will be published in a similar, but separate 3rd such legal action.

Last year, the Congregation in the Republic of Ireland had net assets of €51.7 million.

The Register of Charities also shows that it had an income of €18.7m in 2025, while expenditure stood at €11m.

Former De La Salle brother (87) jailed for ‘fiendish’ historic abuse of boys

An 87-year-old former De La Salle brother and Dublin school principal who sexually abused five teenage boys in his care in a “fiendish” way in the 1970s has been jailed for four years.

Cormac Hilliard, known to his pupils as Brother Benignus, was described by his victims in court as an “evil monster” and a “paedophile” who was physically violent as well as sexually abusive.

Hilliard, of Stradbally Cottages, Castleconnell, Co Limerick, pleaded guilty at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court to five sample counts of indecent assault against each of his five victims at the school and other locations in Dublin on dates between 1970 and 1977.

The boys were aged between 12 and 14 at the time of the abuse and were pupils in the school. Hilliard was in his thirties at the time. Two of the complainants wished to waive their anonymity, the court heard.

The abuse took the form of inappropriate touching of the boys and forced masturbation of Hilliard in some cases. He abused them in the school corridors, in his office and – in the case of one boy – in his car.

He exposed himself to one boy while shouting at him for hiding in the school toilets. He slapped one of his victims in the face before abusing him and used a leather strap to punish another boy.

The complainants described mitching off school for lengthy periods and becoming disruptive in class in the wake of the abuse.

Some of the boys were told to leave the school when they fought back; others changed schools or ended their education prematurely in an effort to escape Hilliard. Many of them left school without formal exams.

Each of the five complainants, who are now in their 60s, described how the abuse affected their education, their mental health, their relationships and the course of their lives.

One complainant, John O’Connell, who wished to waive his anonymity, came forward over 15 years ago but no prosecution was taken at the time. The same thing happened when a second complainant came forward in 2022, but the case was taken up again by Detective Garda Anita Brannigan when a further three complainants made disclosures.

Det Gda Brannigan told Tessa White BL, prosecuting, that when Hilliard was questioned by gardaĆ­ in 2010, 2022 and most recently in 2023, he categorically denied the allegations. He entered the guilty pleas ahead of his trial which was due to take place last May. He has no previous convictions.

Sentencing Hilliard, Judge Martin Nolan said Hilliard “had a basic duty to educate and protect these boys”. “He failed singularly in that duty,” he said. “He behaved in a fiendish way. He believed he was untouchable and unstoppable. He believed he was immune from all reprimand.”

He said the victims in the case “had their prospects dimmed” as a result of Hilliard’s abuse and were left in a “hopeless situation”.

He set a headline sentence of eight years, which he reduced to four years taking a number of mitigating factors into account including Hilliard’s guilty plea and his advanced age.

“I have to take his age into account to some degree, but he deserves to go to prison,” the judge said.

In his victim impact statement read out by Det Gda Brannigan, Mr O’Connell described how he felt numb after he was first abused and developed acute anxiety which has stayed with him all his life. He said his education suffered badly, his self-confidence never recovered and he used alcohol to relieve his anxiety.

The second complainant, who was not in court for the sentence hearing due to ill health, said he did not want to refer to Hilliard by name. “He was the reason I left school at a young age,” he said. “I really wanted to do my exams but I couldn’t continue…I left school out of fear of this person.”

He said the abuse “messed up” his life and his relationships and he was thankful that justice would finally be done.

The third complainant said it was the brave actions of the Blackrock College abuse survivors that caused his own memories to come back to the surface. “That’s why I’m standing here today,” he said. “I hope after today I can put this behind me.”

The fourth complainant said he was excited to start secondary school but it wasn’t long before he was exposed to traumatic abuse. He said Hilliard was physically violent as well as sexually abusive and he has “never recovered from it to this day”.

He described lying on railway tracks sobbing after one “horrific episode” and how he spent weeks mitching off school before being forced back when his parents were informed. He said he was then asked to leave the school as he was being “disruptive”.

“I was so angry that I was being punished when the evil monster who perpetrated sexual abuse on me had caused me to be disruptive.”

The fifth complainant, Michael Scanlon, who also wished to waive his anonymity, read out his own victim impact statement. He said it was a “living nightmare” going to school because of Hilliard.

Mr Scanlon was expelled from the school after an altercation with Hilliard, which resulted in another teacher hitting him to the face with a belt buckle. He said he never told his mother why and eventually cut his education short.

He said he went to night school but never had the same opportunities as his siblings who got their state exams. “This was a result of being the victim of a paedophile.” He thanked the gardaĆ­ in the case for their “compassion, professionalism and care”.

Defence counsel Carl Hanahoe SC said Hilliard joined the De La Salle brothers from the age of 15 or 16 and lived an isolated existence in his later school years and in UCD, where his robes marked him out and he lived in a seminary.

He took a sabbatical in the late 1970s and did a psychology course upon his return to Ireland before leaving the religious order in 1990. He continued to teach, got married and had a child. He retired in the late 1990s and spent about 20 years volunteering for a suicide prevention hotline, the court heard.

Mr Hanahoe asked the court to take Hilliard’s age into account, noting time in custody will be very difficult for him in his late 80s and with age-associated health problems.

City Quay Church celebrates final Mass ahead of refurbishment closure

Parishioners of the Church of the Immaculate Heart of Mary, City Quay, said a temporary goodbye to their beloved church on Sunday, November 8 at the final Mass before the quayside church closed for 10-12 months for refurbishment.

Parish administrator V. Rev. Alan Hilliard celebrated the final Mass on Sunday, praising the community for their help in advocating for the church’s refurbishment, and encouraging a continued sense of togetherness for the year ahead.

Mass will continue at the community centre owned by the parish, a few doors down from City Quay Church, and events during the Advent season will continue online, said Fr Hilliard. “It won’t be an easy year, it will be frustrating at times, but sometimes that will bring us back to the light of God even more.”

The renovations will aim to “brighten up the space” and make it “more prayerful”, said Fr Hilliard, after Mass. He noted that City Quay, the only church on the quays to be open all day, not just for Mass, is consistently busy with visitors and parishioners coming in for prayer.

Parishioner Bernadette Scully, who crosses the river from the Northside to attend Mass, said that City Quay is her favourite church, with a “nice community”. 

Asked about maintaining community during the year ahead, without the physical gathering place of the church, she said, “the people will make it work.” 

Similarly, parishioner Bianca, who has attended City Quay for a year after moving from Brazil three years ago, said she loves the environment of the parish community, and will continue to attend Mass at the community centre during the year.

Home Office accused of anti-Christian bias over leaked extremism report

A leaked Home Office internal report has been accused of linking what it calls “Christian extremism” to concerns about immigration, multiculturalism and changing social values.

Journalist Stephen Edginton has reported that the internal paper was prepared by the Home Office’s Research, Information and Communication Unit for the government’s counter-terrorism taskforce Prevent.

He alleges that the report describes Christian extremism as a radical interpretation of Christianity where traditional values and the Christian faith are thought to be under threat from immigration and multiculturalism.

Liberal views on sexuality and gender, white supremacy, anti-Muslim and anti-Jewish prejudice are said to have been associated with the ideology.

The threat of violence is reportedly rated as low and no terrorist attacks have been assessed as primarily linked to Christian extremism.

Jeremiah Ignnubole, UK legal counsel for Christian advocacy group Alliance Defending Freedom acknowledged that calling for violence was unacceptable - but claimed that the report conflated religious beliefs as extreme.

He told Steven Edginton's Substack: "Recognising and wanting to preserve Britain’s Christian cultural heritage and traditions is not extreme.

“It suggests an institutional anti-Christian bias has taken hold in the Home Office, and Secretary of State Shabana Mahmood now has serious questions to answer.”

A key distinction the report allegedly states is that Christian nationalism is not immediately viewed as Christian extremism. Challenging liberal democracy and justifying violence were seen as key factors distinguishing the two ideologies.

Figures such as British priest and Christian right commentator Calvin Robinson and former British National Party (BNP) leader Nick Griffin are said to be named as individuals aligned to the Christian extremism.

Recommendations to tackle what the Home Office call Christian extremism reportedly look for the Government to work with churches and religious organisations to grow stronger “theological resilience” against interpretations of the faith which justify violence or hatred.

A Home Office spokesperson told Premier Christian News in a statement: “We do not comment on leaks and cannot comment on RICU’s capabilities or areas of operational focus.”

The Home Office said that the Government has committed to publishing the State of Extremism report, which will set out extremism in the UK, and that the RICU has helped the UK tackle terrorist propaganda.

Diocese of London appoints first Director of Safeguarding

The Diocese of London has appointed its first Director of Safeguarding, following recommendations from an independent audit earlier this year.

Dr Leethen Bartholomew, who has 27 years’ experience in safeguarding, social work and public sector leadership, will take up the role on 23 November 2026.

He joins the diocese from the Greater London Authority, where he was Head of Children and Young Londoners and Designated Safeguarding Lead. 

His previous roles include Head of the National FGM Centre at Barnardo’s and senior positions within the City and Hackney Safeguarding Children Partnership. 

He has also led safeguarding audits of Church of England dioceses through the Social Care Institute for Excellence (SCIE).

His appointment is part of a wider action plan developed in response to recommendations from the INEQE Safeguarding Group’s independent audit which was published in May 2026. It found that while safeguarding was increasingly embedded across the diocese with a growing awareness and confidence in raising concerns, some victims and survivors didn’t feel their experiences were sufficiently person-centred or trauma-informed.

Over the last year, the Diocese of London's safeguarding record has come under significant scrutiny following a number of high-profile cases, including concerns raised by a former member of its safeguarding team. 

The diocese’s plan sets out measures to strengthen safeguarding leadership, governance and accountability, improve support for parishes, increase capacity for casework and ensure the voices of victims and survivors help shape practice.

Acting Bishop of London, Dr Emma Ineson, said: “Safeguarding is fundamental to the life and mission of the Church. We want our churches and communities to be places where people are safe, valued and heard.

“We welcomed the independent scrutiny provided through the INEQE audit and committed ourselves to learning from its findings. I am delighted that Leethen is joining us to build on the work already underway. He brings considerable expertise and experience and will play a pivotal role in helping us deliver our safeguarding commitments.”

Dr Bartholomew said: “As a practising Christian, I am particularly pleased to be joining the Diocese of London at a time when it is demonstrating such a strong commitment to safeguarding improvement."

“The diocese's response to the INEQE audit recognises the importance of listening, accountability and learning, with a clear focus on the experiences of victims and survivors. I look forward to working with colleagues to strengthen safeguarding culture, support parishes and help ensure our church communities are places where people can thrive and feel safe.”

Sarah McKimm, Independent Chair of the London Diocesan Safeguarding Advisory Panel, welcomed the appointment and action plan: “This action plan demonstrates a commitment to listening, learning and continuous improvement. It puts the voices and experiences of victims and survivors at the heart of safeguarding practice and sets out an ambitious vision for supporting parishes to stay safe.

“The plan, together with Leethen’s appointment, provides a strong foundation for the next phase of this work.”

'I will continue to stand for the Gospel': Police drop case against Watford pastor arrested for criticising Islam

A pastor who was arrested by police for allegedly criticising Islam in viral footage has been vindicated after his case has been closed with no further action - and he says he will continue preaching the Gospel.

Pastor Steve Maile had been preaching in Watford town centre talking about his thoughts on violence in Islam and asking whether Islam was a religion of peace. 

The pastor of Oasis City Church, is said to have been singing hymns and Christian songs and preaching for about ten minutes. 

He was also reported to have told spectators that he had compassion for Muslims and wanted them to become Christians. 

The married father of four and grandfather, aged 67, was then arrested on suspicion of assault and racially or religiously aggravated disorderly behaviour. 

Mr Maile said that the event has taken a “terrible toll on his family”. Maile said: “I am relieved that the police have finally confirmed what I knew from the beginning: I had committed no crime.

“I was peacefully preaching the Gospel, singing and speaking about my Christian beliefs. Criticising Islam is not a criminal offence. This ordeal has taken a terrible toll on me and my family.

“Being suddenly surrounded by police officers, handcuffed in front of my family and taken away as if I were a dangerous criminal was humiliating and deeply distressing.”

During footage of the arrest, one of three Hertfordshire Police officers can be heard saying: “In the name of Jesus, get in the car.”

The grandfather said that he was handcuffed tightly into a “double lock” for 90 minutes and telling officers he was in pain. He required splints for his injured hands after his arrest. 

He was also accused of assaulting a child, which he denied immediately, and a woman filming the arrest says that he’s a grandfather and a pastor.

He was held for 12 hours, initially taken to Watford police station and then transferred to Hatfield police station. 

Maile alleges that he was unable to go to the toilet for a prolonged amount of time and his family were unaware where he had been taken. 

An accusation of assaulting a teenager was dropped, as a Section 5 public order allegation which he believes is linked to Biblical-based statements criticising Islam and homosexuality. 

Maile added: “I will continue to preach the gospel publicly, including in Watford, and I will continue to tell people about the love and saving power of Jesus Christ.

“I forgive those involved, but forgiveness does not mean there should be no accountability. I will continue to stand for truth, freedom and the gospel.”

Maile was represented by Christian Legal Centre - their chief executive Andrea Williams called the outcome of the investigation “sadly predictable”. 

She said: “In a free society, religions and ideologies must be open to scrutiny, debate and disagreement. The police are not there to shield Islam, Christianity or any other belief system from criticism.”

A spokesperson for Hertfordshire Constabulary wrote to the pastor: “Based on the evidence currently available a decision has been made to refuse charge you [sic] in respect of the above offence(s) because the evidence did not meet evidential stage of the full code test set out in the Code for Crown Prosecutions.”

Fr. Altman blasts ‘total apostasy’ at the Vatican under Pope Leo

Father James Altman, during last week’s 2026 Rome Life Forum, discussed Pope Leo XIV’s denigration of the Blessed Virgin Mary’s titles of “Co-Redemptrix” and “Mediatrix of all Graces,” as well as her messages to pray for the conversion of sinners by welcoming them to the Vatican with open arms.

During his talk, Altman highlighted how Pope Leo’s Vatican has welcomed a pilgrimage of LGBT-identifying Catholics into St. Peter’s Basilica while banning the traditionalist pilgrims attending the 2026 Summorum Pontificum pilgrimage from entering the basilica last month. 

The “cancelled priest” stressed that, rather than repeating Our Lady’s commands to “do whatever” Our Lord tells us to do and repent of our sins, he has denigrated her titles of “Co-Redemptrix” and “Mediatrix of all Graces.”

“What has gone wrong … total apostasy…. As you surely all know, the Summorum Pontificum pilgrimage was stopped outside the Vatican; they got as far as the obelisk … and from that point forward they were stopped from entering into God’s church, our church, that is our Vatican, that is our basilica. It doesn’t belong to Pope Leo, and it doesn’t belong to anybody but God and us,” Altman said.

“They were stopped from going in, but if you remember, it was about a year ago or so, in walks the ‘LGBTQ,’ dressed in filthy garbage, they had the ‘F-bomb’ on the back of their shirts, and yet they stop Catholics from going in,” he added. “God damns every single person that was involved in stopping their entry into St. Peter’s. Leo, the buck stops with you. Leo, who spends more time kissing up to the personification of pansy, James Martin.”

Altman continued:

Leo, who, rather than proclaiming ‘Viva Christo Rey,’ rather than urging every sinner to repent and make straight the way of the Lord. Leo, rather than repeating our Blessed Mother’s last recorded words in the Gospel, ‘Do whatever Jesus, my son, tells you to do,’ he denigrates her titles.

Catholic Council on reform stop: Can't accept decision

The Catholic Council in the Diocese of Speyer has asked the Apostolic Nuncio in Germany, Archbishop Hubertus van Megen, in a letter to rethink the stop sign for the parish reform process of the diocese. 

"We cannot accept this decision either in terms of content or in style as it was made without any synodal involvement and consultation with the representatives of all those involved in this process, which has been going on for more than two years," the letter, which was dated Saturday, reads. 

The Vatican ban is "suitable in the entire diocese, among priests, employees, lay representatives and many faithful to trigger great disappointments with considerable long-term effect with negative consequences for the church in the diocese. But the cause of Jesus needs enthusiastic, not increasingly frustrated."

The ordered interruption did not take into account the decisions taken by the now emeritus bishop Karl-Heinz Wiesemann in his term of office after broad consultation. 

"In all our actions, we have moved in the diocese on the foundation that (sic!) our former bishop has explicitly authorized," the Catholic Council stressed. The decision of the nuncio to completely stop the reform process "is thus nothing more than the annulment of the explicitly taken decision of our former bishop. This is completely incomprehensible to us.”

Suspension causes greater damage

Of course, the rights of a new bishop would be respected. The further work on the process therefore did not involve any binding decisions. "We are convinced that the suspension of further work does much greater damage to the diocese than moderate informal further work without implementation steps," the Catholics' Council said. "After all, in the way in which this decision came about, we see a clear contradiction to the path taken towards an increasingly synodal church."

The path to a more synodal church would have made it necessary to enter into a dialogue with "the main stakeholders in this process (priests, lay people, employees, representatives of the committees, etc.) before deciding to get to know our goals and the planned further work steps," the Catholic Council demanded. "Instead, you are submitting a one-sided decision to the diocese, which calls into question everything that synodality stands for in our understanding," the letter said. "I am convinced that this approach does not correspond to the image of a synodal church, as it is drawn by the final document of the World Bishops' Synod 2023/24, to whose implementation all dioceses are called worldwide."

Passion and commitment suffer

Initial reactions after the decision of the nuncio became known already showed "that the motivation and commitment of the many people who have participated in the process in recent years with a lot of passion and the will to shape a sustainable church will suffer greatly from this decision," according to the Catholic Council. 

Further impacts would not be apparent until the coming weeks and months. 

But the decision also has consequences for the new bishop: "We would have liked to have handed over to the new bishop well-prepared and with great unanimity concept drafts for the reform process, on the basis of which he could have made his decisions in full freedom." 

Now, however, there is a risk that the new bishop will first have to regain lost trust.

The diocese of Speyer had informed on Wednesday that the nunciature had ordered, with reference to church law provisions, to suspend the ongoing parish structure process during the sedisvacance. 

"We will respect and implement the decision. However, I am disappointed with the content of the letter," Diocesan Administrator Markus Magin explained, according to the press release.

Archbishop of Detroit prohibits a lawyer from advising the faithful who want to save their parishes with canon law

The Archbishop of Detroit, Edward Weisenburger, has issued a written prohibition barring attorney Kevin Kijewski from offering “canonical advice or guidance” to any Catholic in the archdiocese, according to Kijewski himself in a column published on November 9 in Catholic World Report. 

Kijewski, a resident of Birmingham (Michigan) and spokesperson for the Parish Preservation Alliance, an association founded by parishioners, explains that the directive, dated October 22, reached him by FedEx at his home on Monday the 26th, one day before a meeting with the faithful from across the archdiocese.

According to his account, the document also prevents him from raising funds for any canonical cause and from collaborating with canonists not approved by the archbishop. 

The directive explicitly mentions the meeting, citing its date and location, and asserts that Kijewski lacks even “the most general level of experience” in canon law. 

That same evening, he adds, the vicar wrote to him that if he attended, he would be doing so “knowingly” in violation of the order.

Six hundred parishioners from more than 120 parishes

The gathering took place on October 27 in a rented hall in the Detroit suburbs. More than 600 parishioners from over 120 parishes attended to hear a canonist explain the rights the Church recognizes for the faithful in the face of restructuring plans, according to the same text. 

The Parish Preservation Alliance had called the event.

The following day, October 28, Weisenburger issued a statement warning the faithful against “outside organizations and individuals” who solicit donations in exchange for promises that they can halt or control the restructuring through canon law. 

In the text, he maintains that “no organization or individual can guarantee a specific outcome or predetermine future decisions” and recommends consulting only canonists approved by the bishops of Michigan. He also states that “no final decision has been made” regarding pastoral assignments, closures, or mergers.

The plan that threatens Sunday Mass in up to 90 parishes

The origin of the conflict is the restructuring process announced by Weisenburger in November 2025 for all parishes in the archdiocese. 

Preliminary models contemplate that up to 90 of the 209 parishes could cease celebrating Sunday Mass, a scenario that the faithful equate to a covert closure. 

According to Kijewski, the archdiocese estimates it will have around 130 active priests in 2034, compared to the current 224. InfoVaticana has already reported on these projections.

The archbishop has indicated that the final plan and the assignments of the priests will be announced in April 2027, and that its implementation will require a transition period. 

Meanwhile, the faithful who wish to use the channels provided by the Code of Canon Law find themselves, according to Kijewski, with the diocesan pastor closing the door to the advisors they themselves have chosen. 

In his column, he recalls that in 2024 the bishop of Buffalo prohibited the faithful from using parish properties to organize appeals and later revoked that measure.

Bertomeu admits he proposed criteria and names for the Pope's meeting with victims in Lima

The pontifical commissioner for the Sodalicio case, Jordi Bertomeu, has acknowledged that he participated in the preparation of the meeting between Leo XIV and abuse victims at the Apostolic Nunciature in Lima, although he attributes the final decision to others. 

In an interview published this Saturday by Alfa y Omega, the official of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith explains that “I was asked to make suggestions about the criteria that should be followed”, that he proposed some names, and that the final decision belonged to “other Vatican instances,” without specifying which ones.

The interview is published two days after the Pope received six victims, some linked to groups related to the Sodalitium of Christian Life, in a meeting from which JosĆ© Enrique Escardó, the first public whistleblower of the organization, was excluded. 

He described it as a deception and had already blamed the nuncio and the Peruvian Episcopal Conference for his exclusion. Bertomeu does not mention Escardó. When asked about the complaints of victims who were not invited, he responds: “Yes. Unfortunately, it happens frequently.” 

And he adds that the meeting “must be an open door, not a new frontier”.

The commissioner describes the Lima meeting as “a moment of great consolation for the survivors and, also, of hope,” but warns of the risk that it may remain just a gesture: “Listening that is not translated into concrete decisions runs the risk of becoming a new disappointment”. 

What the victims demand, he says, is “truth, justice, recognition of the harm, and reparation,” and reparation must also include financial compensation. According to his data, there are more than 250 victims of the Sodalitium.

Regarding the liquidation of assets, Bertomeu maintains that the goal is for those responsible for the abuses to make available to the liquidating commissioner the assets necessary to compensate the victims. 

He acknowledges that it is not easy to convince them, says he cannot detail the steps to obtain those resources, and points out that alleged financial irregularities and a business network linked to the group are still under investigation, which may require the support of civil authorities. It will be necessary to determine, he adds, whether the assets offered for liquidation truly correspond to the group’s former patrimony. 

“What cannot be tolerated is that the victims are deceived once again by those who should take responsibility for the harm caused”, he states. 

A week ago, in an internal letter to the victims, the commissioner had already postponed the reparation indefinitely until the Holy See’s bodies have “sufficient certainty” about the canonical legality of the economic activities of the suppressed group.

In the same interview, Bertomeu describes the founder, Luis Fernando Figari, as “a young Peruvian of classist and far-right orientation,” heavily influenced by the Spanish Falange, and recounts, according to testimonies received by the special mission, surgical interventions on young people, including ovary removals, treatments with psychotropic drugs, pressure to marry after leaving the group, and job offers in linked companies as a form of dependency. He says he has known Leo XIV since he was bishop of Chiclayo.

The commissioner’s words coincide with a new request from the victims. This Saturday in Chiclayo, less than five hundred meters from the cathedral and about two hours after the Pope crowned the Immaculate Virgin, a group of Sodalitium victims, peasants from Catacaos, and members of the organization Ending Clergy Abuse called in a press conference for a meeting with Leo XIV before he leaves Peru, according to the agency Efe, reported by Religión Digital. 

The peasants from Catacaos, in Piura, claim they were stripped of their lands by companies linked to the Sodalitium and that its suppression did not end them. 

“Reparation is not an act, it is a process”, said Matthias Katsch, a victim of abuse at a religious school in Berlin. The complainants demand the dismantling of the group’s economic structure and want to deliver a letter to the Pope before he boards the plane.

There is no record of a response from the Holy See to that request. 

Francis suppressed the Sodalitium in 2025; a year and a half later, financial reparation to the victims remains pending, and the person coordinating the process admits that the final word on the meeting was not his and that it is not easy to gather the assets with which it must be paid.

Bertomeu proposed criteria and names for the Lima meeting, but says the decision was made by others.

Austrian priest claims that 1.4 million Catholics are in lodges and not excommunicated

The Austrian priest Michael Heinrich Weninger, a former diplomat and author of a doctoral thesis in favor of reconciliation between the Church and Freemasonry, has once again called on Rome to change its stance. 

In a conference in Lübeck, reported by katholisch.de based on information from the portal Aussicht.online, Weninger estimated that around 1.4 million Catholics worldwide belong to a “genuine” lodge and maintained that, in his view, they are not excommunicated.

According to the German Catholic portal, the priest argued that there is no fundamental contradiction between the Catholic faith and membership in regular Freemasonry, whose lodges require belief in God and prohibit political activity within their ranks. 

In his opinion, the Vatican still does not sufficiently distinguish between those lodges, which are religious in orientation, and openly anticlerical organizations. “Any madman can call himself a Mason”, he said. And he added: “A Mason is at heart a good person who works on himself to become even better”, to which, in his view, a Catholic priest has in principle nothing to object.

Weninger also reviewed the history of modern Freemasonry, which he places at the feast of St. John in 1717, when what he called the mother lodge of all the genuine lodges in the world was founded in London, and stated that theologians participated in drafting its constitution. 

Relations with the Church, according to his account, deteriorated in the nineteenth century, with the Enlightenment, the French Revolution, and Italian unification. He also maintained that many clerics, including bishops and cardinals, historically belonged to lodges.

His thesis clashes with the position of the Holy See, reaffirmed three years ago. In November 2023, the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, in a response signed by Cardinal Victor Manuel FernĆ”ndez and approved by Francis, replied to the Filipino bishop of Dumaguete, Julito Cortes, that the active membership of a faithful in Freemasonry is prohibited due to the incompatibility between Catholic doctrine and Freemasonry, and that those who join it formally and consciously are subject to the provisions of the 1983 declaration. 

That text, signed by Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger as prefect of the then Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith and approved by Saint John Paul II, established that the faithful who join Masonic associations are in a state of grave sin.

Weninger’s argument plays on a legal nuance. The 1917 Code of Canon Law expressly condemned Freemasonry and punished its members with excommunication, while the 1983 Code removed that explicit mention. 

Ratzinger’s declaration was published precisely to clarify that the change in the Code did not alter the Church’s negative judgment, and the 2023 response confirmed it without distinguishing between regular and irregular lodges.

Weninger, widowed since 2011, was ordained a priest by Cardinal Christoph Schƶnborn, now Archbishop Emeritus of Vienna. His thesis on reconciliation between the Church and regular Freemasonry was published in 2019 by the Pontifical Gregorian University. 

It is not the first time he has presented it publicly: in June 2025 he defended the compatibility between the two, dressed in a cassock, from the podium of the Grande Loge Nationale FranƧaise in Paris.

The issue has echoes in Spain, where it has become known that, while Octavi VilĆ  was abbot of Poblet and now Archbishop of Barcelona, the Supreme Council of the 33rd Degree gathered its Freemasons in the monastery for three days in June 2017.

Weninger says that 1.4 million Catholics are in lodges and not excommunicated; Rome recalls that their membership is grave sin.

Minister asked to intervene in Tuam Mother and Baby Home oversight board dispute

An internal dispute within the State oversight board for the Tuam Mother and Baby Home excavation has led committee members to call directly on the children's minister to intervene.

Annette McKay, a family representative on the Tuam Advisory Board, and whose sister Mary Margaret O’Connor is believed to be buried at the site along with nearly 800 other children, initially handed in a resignation notice to Norma Foley on October 7.

It is understood she raised questions about the board's current leadership, citing a difficult working relationship with the chairperson, Dr Brian Farrell, the practical independence of the board, and the weight given to family views.

While the direct dispute lies between Ms McKay and the chair, two other key board members have stepped forward to back her.

Ms McKay, who is calling for an independent review of the board’s leadership, has raised several concerns, including how Galway County Council attended nine of the 15 meetings since the establishment of the board in 2024, but was not included in the minutes of the meetings.

She has also raised concerns families were not receiving sufficient support as the exhumation of the children who died at the Tuam home continues. So far, 109 babies' remains have been recovered.

"The silencing of people’s voices has been a theme in the story of Tuam from the beginning, and it is not healthy that anyone on the board should feel that this is continuing," she said.

"I resigned because I had serious concerns about how the advisory board is led and run, and whether family representatives are genuinely being heard."

She has since withdrawn her resignation notice "as a temporary measure so that Tuam families would continue to have representation while the minister considers my concerns".

The Tuam Babies Family Group has also waded into the row, and has written directly to the minister in support of Ms McKay, warning families cannot once again be sidelined.

The standoff escalated when it emerged the chairperson, former Dublin City Coroner Brian Farrell, engaged in separate correspondence with Ms Foley to seek a meeting "on behalf of the board", a move the Department of Children confirmed to the Irish Examiner.

A spokesperson said the minister "will be replying positively to that request shortly".

Ms McKay expressed "deep concern" over being left in the dark about the chair's correspondence to the minister, noting she was not consulted or told about the letter.

"He cannot speak for me or present my views as part of a collective board position," she said.

The Department of Children confirmed Ms McKay had officially rescinded her resignation and Ms Foley “will reflect carefully on the issues raised by Ms McKay in her letter”.

Ms McKay said she was staying solely as a tactical measure to maintain a family voice while her demand for an independent review was addressed. 

"I am not walking away from Tuam. I am refusing to pretend that a seat at the table is the same as having a voice at it," she said.

A series of questions were put to Dr Brian Farrell via email on two occasions; he did not respond.

Industrial school survivor claims State failed her sisters over criminal record clarification

An industrial school survivor has accused the Government of failing her two late sisters by not assuring her that they do not have criminal records, which was the common perception during the historical process of placing children in such institutions.

Miriam Moriarty Owens said her sisters Joan and Aine "were never criminals" and that it was an appalling injustice that she has not received official confirmation that they are not.

The Kerry woman said she had been given clarity about her own criminal record, but she was still waiting for the same recognition for her sisters, who were sent to industrial school as children.

It was a popular misconception that children sent to industrial schools were sent there because of criminality, which led to further stigmatisation.

This year, all those who endured time in the industrial schools were promised by the State that they were not seen as criminals, as part of an official Government apology to survivors of institutional abuse.

Ms Moriarty Owens, who became a prominent figure outside Leinster House last year when she joined three other survivors on hunger strike over access to enhanced medical cards, received a letter earlier this year from justice minister Jim O’Callaghan.

The letter said that the State did not regard her as having committed a criminal offence and that "no criminal conviction was recorded against her in relation to her detention in Pembroke House between June 16, 1959, and July 27, 1970".

However, Ms Moriarty Owens questioned the value of the assurance when her sisters had not been afforded the same treatment.

She said the perception of criminal records had damaged survivors’ lives, preventing some from travelling abroad or securing good jobs.

Ms Moriarty Owens has been protesting outside the DƔil every Tuesday.

Mr O'Callaghan said in a statement: "The State did not, and does not, regard individuals as having committed a criminal offence, and no criminal record is recorded against them, by virtue of their detention in any industrial school. 

"No person and, in particular, no agency of the State should regard these individuals as having committed a criminal offence or having a criminal record. 

"The Department of Education and Youth (DEY)  have responsibility for the historic industrial and reformatory schools and holds the relevant records, although they acknowledge that these records are incomplete.

"Officials in my Department have been in contact with the Department of Education and Youth (DEY) on this matter and will continue to assist DEY with the provision of certificates confirming that no criminal record is recorded against individuals by virtue of their detention in an industrial school, where requested to do so."

British tourist smashes Jesus statue outside Vilnius church

Shocking CCTV footage has captured the moment a foreign tourist laughed with a Jesus statue before it smashed to pieces.

In the clip, a man wearing a blue beanie and a black jacket is seen sitting on a street bench in Lithuania’s capital Vilnius as his friend stumbles into frame hauling the statue.

The seated man pulls out his phone to seemingly record the stunt.

His friend – dressed in a long grey coat and a checkered scarf – struggles to walk straight while manhandling the statue.

Seconds later, after lifting the statue into the air the figure’s arms suddenly snap off, sending the rest of the golden sculpture crashing to the ground where it shatters.

Left standing stunned, with severed golden arms in each hand, the man quickly bolts from the scene, with his friend walking off in the same direction moments later.

While the man carrying the statue appeared to be intoxicated, authorities have not confirmed whether alcohol was a factor.

The duo are believed to be from the UK as their British accents can be heard in the CCTV footage, though police are yet to officially verify their nationalities.

The incident is said to have unfolded outside the Shrine of Divine Mercy – a historic 15th-century church in Vilnius’s Old Town.

The footage was shared online by the church’s priest, Father Elijas Anatolijus Markauskas.

According to Fr. Markauskas, the sculpture had been taken from a wooden cross inside an inner courtyard just steps away from the street where the pair were filmed.

The priest called on the public to circulate the video in a bid to help track down the culprits.

The Sun reported local police confirmed a pre-trial investigation has been launched under Article 284 of the criminal code of the Republic of Lithuania, which relates to public order offences.

“On November 11, at about 9pm in Vilnius, Dominikonų St., from the inner courtyard of the church, an unidentified person broke a golden sculpture of Jesus hanging on a wooden cross,” police said.

The Shrine of Divine Mercy is a major religious landmark in Vilnius and is famously home to the original 1934 painting of the Divine Mercy.

Authorities are continuing to appeal for anyone with information about the suspects’ identities to come forward.

Church clock chimes again after outcry over single noise complaint

A church clock is chiming once more after thousands of people signed a petition against its silencing due to a single noise complaint.

The clock at St Margaret's in Wolstanton, Staffordshire, had chimed since 1889 without issue, apart from during the two world wars and periods of maintenance, the church said.

In a post on social media, the church said the chimes were silenced from 18:00 GMT on Thursday after an officer from Newcastle-under-Lyme Borough Council instructed it to do so while a complaint was investigated.

In a statement the authority has confirmed that the chimes have been restored earlier on Monday but it was still looking at a longer term solution.

While the quarter-hourly chimes were silenced, the bells still rang for church services over the weekend.

Jessica Nixon, from Newcastle-under-Lyme, launched a petition which had attracted 2,630 signatures by Monday morning.

"They have been going for 137 years and I just thought, why has one person been able to make a complaint and very quickly they have been stopped?" she said.

"The community of Wolstanton should have been made aware."

Nixon said she initially started the petition out of frustration and had not expected it to attract so much support.

Although not a regular churchgoer, she attended a service after learning about the issue.

"A lot of the people there I was speaking to were there because of the situation with the chimes," she said.

"If you can get people there for that reason then it's worked."

She added: "Why should one person make that decision? If you don't like the sound of them, don't live by them."

Pat Taylor, whose husband is buried in the church graveyard, said she was saddened when the chimes were stopped.

"When I go to the graveyard and the chimes go, I think that's my husband talking to me and letting me know I've been," she said.

She said she was shocked the chimes had been silenced following a single complaint.

"They shouldn't have stopped it for a single complaint. They have been going for years," she added.

The council leader said officers had followed the correct procedures when responding to the complaint.

However, he said he was exploring possible solutions which could allow the chimes to return.

"I don't want to promise the mechanical solution can work yet because we haven't even found out what technology is needed, how easy it is to install, and what the cost of that comes to," he said.

"But if I can do it, and if I can afford it, 100% we'll do that."

A spokesman for the council confirmed the chimes had been restored.

He said that because a statutory noise complaint was made there was a duty to investigate but no formal notice was issued.

"We recognise that the clock chimes are an intrinsic part of the life of the church and the village, and we have arranged for them to continue as usual."

They went on to say that they would continue to work with residents and the church on a longer term solution if legally required.

Trans law should be scrapped, say church leaders

More than 1,300 church leaders have demanded that Labour scrap its controversial trans law, which they say would “criminalise” Christian preaching.

A total of 1,314 ministers and pastoral workers put their names to a letter to Bridget Phillipson, the equalities minister, saying the draft Conversion Practices Bill would target “normal, responsible Christian parenting”.

Signatories included Anglican vicars and Catholic priests, as well as clergy from other denominations. They said the “grossly offensive” law would create a “speech crime” targeted at those who taught “mainstream Christian doctrine”.

The letter added: “We will not cease to fulfil our duty to God to teach his ways faithfully, even if an unjust law should make us criminals for doing so.”

Under the draft bill, which is being scrutinised by MPs and peers, people would face five years in jail for putting pressure on someone to change their sexuality or gender identity.

Although the legislation is meant to target abusive behaviour, opponents say it is poorly drafted and could mean parents being criminalised for having honest and loving conversations with their children about whether they really want to change gender.

The letter was organised by the Greater Love Declaration, a conservative Christian group that represents clergymen and other church staff from every major denomination, including the Church of England, Roman Catholics, Presbyterians, Baptists, Pentecostals and independent churches.

The group opposes same-sex marriage and blessings, and says Christians should “pursue chaste singleness outside of marriage”. It says its members are unanimously opposed to the abuse the ban is meant to outlaw, which it says is illegal under existing law.

As well as the ministers and pastoral workers, 1,539 other churchgoers and supporters have supported the letter.

The letter tells Ms Phillipson: “Responsible Christian parents and pastors will be criminalised by the draft bill, in direct violation of human rights law on family life, freedom of speech, and freedom of religion.

“We urgently request that you abandon this bill, and that you meet with us to gain a better understanding of historic Christian teaching, to avoid a disastrous legislative misstep.”

Calls for bill to be abandoned

Last week, the Anglican Church told The Telegraph the draft bill risked criminalising prayer.

A spokesman said the legislation must not “unintentionally criminalise” providing prayer and pastoral support, and that it must allow for discussion and disagreement.

The Catholic Church in England and Wales has also voiced concerns about the bill and called for it to be abandoned.

The letter signed by the church leaders said the legislation would “catch genuine, faithful, historic Christian ministry and Christian parenting in its scope”. It added: “We are dismayed and baffled by the draft bill on so-called ‘conversion practices’ currently undergoing pre-legislative scrutiny.

“None of our churches would ever condone abusive practices of the kind which advocates for this bill have implied take place in Christian churches, and which are thankfully already illegal. Nevertheless, as drafted this bill would criminalise normal, healthy Christian ministry, along with normal, responsible Christian parenting.”

Christian teachings ‘needed more than ever’

The signatories said Christianity had always taught that marriage was for a man and a woman, and had always been against sex before marriage.

The letter said: “Christianity has also understood, along with almost all people throughout history, that sex cannot be changed.

“These Christian teachings are very good and are more needed than ever in our day of vast family breakdown and ever-growing mental health problems among the young...

“For two millennia Christians have found these things to be gloriously true. Yet for Christian ministers to teach them to their congregations, and for Christian parents to teach them to their children, would inevitably be interpreted by some as attempts to ‘change’ their ‘orientation’ or ‘identity’.

“The bill creates a speech crime, and those who teach mainstream, historic Christian doctrine would inevitably be judged guilty of it. Needless to say, we will not cease to fulfil our duty to God to teach his ways faithfully, even if an unjust law should make us criminals for doing so.”

The letter said “conversion” was a core Christian concept “which describes turning, in obedience to Jesus Christ and by the power of the Holy Spirit, from self, sin and pride to humble trust in God”.

‘Grossly offensive to Christians’

It went on: “By appropriating this Christian language as a label for an ill-defined and wide-ranging criminal offence, the draft bill is not only grossly offensive to Christians but will inevitably catch genuine, faithful, historic Christian ministry and Christian parenting in its scope. Indeed, it seems designed to do so.

“The bill appears to be motivated by assumptions about Christian ministry which are unrecognisable to us. We are unaware that any attempt has been made in drafting this bill to speak to leaders of normal, orthodox Christian churches.”

One signatory, the Rev Dr Matthew Roberts, minister of Trinity Church York, writing for The Telegraph, below, said: “We say that we are ‘baffled and dismayed’ by it, for good reason. The bill is a Trojan horse.”

Another signatory, the Rev Tim Vasby-Burnie, Anglican vicar of St George’s Church in Shrewsbury, said: “Jesus’s teaching brings life and direction in this confused world, but it also challenges our inner desires and the assumptions of our society.

“The proposed bill would leave ministers and pastoral workers, who seek to pass on Jesus’ teaching, in danger of legal trouble or even cause their actions to be criminalised. I signed the letter to protect free speech and religious freedom.”

Julie Maxwell, deputy director of the Christian charity Lovewise and a member of the Church of England’s General Synod, said: “I signed this letter as someone who is involved in the pastoral support of young people and also of parents.

“I signed because of the danger the proposed bill poses to those who seek to teach and guide children and young adults in historic Christian biblical teaching on marriage, relationships, sexual intimacy and gender.

“The proposed bill claims to protect children but in fact turns the law on those who have primary responsibility for protecting children – those who care for and guide children as they navigate their development through puberty and adolescence.”

Graham Nicholls, a signatory and pastor of the independent evangelical Christ Church Haywards Heath, said the bill was harmful.

He said: “It will criminalise the everyday conversations parents and church workers have with children and adults where they explain the Bible’s teaching on sexuality and gender and encourage people to follow it.

“It would suppress freedom of speech and freedom of religion. It’s not plugging a gap in the law; it’s enforcing a particular ideology ... It’s the beginning of policing any moral conversation. Hundreds of thousands of Christians will likely fall foul of this law.”

A Government spokesman said freedom of belief, whether faith-based or wider, would be respected by the ban. He said: “Simple prayer, expressing religious freedom or holding different beliefs are not abusive conversion practices and therefore not in scope of our draft bill.

“We have consulted with a range of religious leaders who have shared support of our draft bill. We have brought forward a draft bill for pre-legislative scrutiny in order to get this right and end almost a decade of delay for LGBT+ people who should never have to suffer abuse in an effort to change who they are.”

Homily of Archbishop Dermot Farrell - 14 November 2026

We gather to celebrate someone who was a shepherd, a pastor of the Lord’s flock in the true sense of the word. He left us the witness of his life. His prayer life demanded a life that was marked by simplicity and self-discipline. I have no doubt that if St Laurence O’Toole were alive today, he would encourage us to find ways to reach the hearts of the today’s peoples of Dublin, and beyond with the gift of the gospel.

St Laurence O’Toole laboured to restore peace between enemies; he was not only a man of prayer, but his faith was seen in action in the way in which he cared for the poor and homeless people.  Many of the issues he confronted are still with us today.  These challenges are what Pope Leo XIV continues to put before every member of the Church today.  He has repeatedly warned against a faith that is busy with activities but blind to real suffering.   The Church must “leave behind all passivity and indifference” and cannot remain “unengaged spectators” while people are crushed by injustice, discrimination, and violence. (General Audience, September 2, 2026)

Pope Leo urges priests and communities to ask a simple but piercing question about everything they do: “Why?”— and to evaluate whether their initiatives truly lead people to Christ and serve the parishes’ actual wounds. (18th September 2026)

Of course, activity is not the same as encounter.  It is not enough to ask whether an initiative is “well organized” or “well attended”; the real question is whether it “truly leads to Christ” and “brings the Gospel into contact with the real lives of the people.”  A parish that multiplies meetings but does not become a pastorally converted Church to walk with Christ among those whom it cares for risks becoming what the Gospel warns against: busy, even impressive, yet spiritually hollow.

A faith that tends to its outward rituals but is blind to invisible suffering is nothing but a rehearsed theatre.  We must “unmask the contradictions” of a world where wealth and technology advance while hunger, poverty, and loneliness persist.

Who are the unseen sufferers in our communities?  The Holy Father’s own descriptions help us name them: those who feel “bewildered” and can no longer find where to meet the Lord; those who participate in many activities yet remain spiritually adrift; those who serve in silence and are never publicly acknowledged; those who are “crushed by injustice, discrimination, and violence” and for whom the Church must “lend our voice” and “be their friends.”

Pope Leo insists the option for the poor is “primarily a theological category,” not just a social or political stance. We are called, “to find Christ in them, to lend our voice to their political stance. We are called, “to find Christ in them, to lend our voice to their causes, but also to be their friends, to listen to them, to speak for them.”  Like St Laurence that moves us from vague sympathy to concrete friendship and responsibility.

What does this look like in practice, in light of St Laurence’s life and the Holy Father’s guidance?

  • Ask “Why?” about every ministry. Does this activity help people encounter Christ and address real needs, or is it habit and inertia?

  • Be a Church that listens—above all to the authentic voice of the Holy Spirit. Pause to recognize what has borne fruit, what has not, and why; involve the whole community, even those “from the outside.”

  • Prioritize encounter over efficiency, productivity and performance. Focus on “whom and how to encounter” before “what to do”; let people be known by name, not treated as numbers.

  • The conversion to which the Church is called needs to be grounded both in the call to deepen personal holiness and an institutional reform within the Church that facilitates the full participation of all the baptised in the life and mission of the Church—ecclesial discernment, decision-making, implementation and a culture of transparency, accountability and evaluation, practices that are intimately connected. Such responsibility flows from baptism itself. (see Final Document, The Synod of Bishops, 2024, 11)

  • “Work slowly but surely, without being obsessed with immediate results.”  This will help “us patiently to endure difficult and adverse situations or inevitable changes in our plans. It invites us to accept the tension between fullness and limitation, and to give a priority to time.” (See Pope Francis, The Joy of the Gospel,  223)

  • Stand with the invisible. “The Church, if she wants to be Christ’s Church, must be a Church of the Beatitudes, one that makes room for the little ones and walks poor with the poor, a place where the poor have a privileged place” Pope Leo, Message for World Day of the Poor 2026, no 21). Follow our Patron Saint’s example and take on the burdens of their brothers and sisters and bind up their wounds

  • Unmask contradictions. Refuse to accept a faith that coexists comfortably with indifference to poverty, violence, isolation, homelessness and injustice. As Pope Francis reminded us “none of us can be saved alone. (Message for World Day of Peace, 2023)

This is not about adding more programmes. It is about letting the Gospel reshape our attention and our priorities.  Every priest knows the challenges of aligning pastoral care and fidelity to Church teaching coherently and in fruitful tension.   The tensions placed before us about how doctrine and pastoral care should be related in practice can cause fear and feelings of pastoral impotence.  But, when we focus only on rule-keeping, offering a false hope of faith without ambiguity, people know where they stand in relation to a law, but lose sight of where they stand in relation to God. (see Timothy Cardinal Radcliffe, “Hoping Against Hope,” Synod Retreat Meditation, 1 October 2023).  Like our Patron Saint, however, we have the certainty that God has entered our world, fills us with courage, empowers us and sends us out on daily mission among his people.

The challenge of St Laurence O’Toole and Pope Leo is not to abandon ritual but to ensure that ritual leads to love.  We want communities where no one is “anonymous, invisible and misunderstood,” where people feel “welcomed, accompanied, valued and jointly responsible,” and where the Church truly shares the joys and the hopes, the griefs and the anxieties of our time, especially the poor and afflicted.

Inspired by the example of St Laurence and confident that the divine life which sustained him is also at work in our lives, we renew our commitment to the service of the people of this diocese, that they may recognise the hand of God at work in their lives, and the fullness of life God desires for all that he has created.  Another great saint, wrote the following line that, though not specific to the Irish situation and in need of a slight transposition, is apposite to St Laurence whose entire life was distinguished for gentleness and charity and the quest for peace. “If you would be the person you are meant to be, you could set fire to the whole of the Archdiocese of Dublin.” St Catherine of Siena, Letter to Stefano Marconi, T 368, Le Lettere, vol 5, TommasĆØo edition , Florence: Giunti, 1940, p 266).