The head of the Christian Brothers has said that, contrary to recent commentary, the congregation's focus remains resolutely on settling abuse claims in a timely manner without the stress and delays of litigation.
Brother David Gibson said that, in addition to contributions to redress and statutory funds, it had provided compensation of over €40m, including legal fees, to over 200 claimants and provided counselling for survivors.
His statement comes after 314 former members were served with a summons, by way of a national newspaper advertisement, for the second time in recent months.
It is not being alleged that the men whose names have been published had anything to do with the crimes, but is a result of the congregation's decision not to provide a nominee for the purposes of litigation in a case in which a man is seeking damages for sexual and physical abuse suffered at the hands of a former brother.
"Our typical approach is to acknowledge a claim with an offer of mediation, and we can confirm that, at present, a majority of notified claims are settled within 12 months without the stress of a court appearance," Brother David Gibson said, adding that 28 had been settled this year alone.
"Claimants are listened to in a non-adversarial setting and their claims are settled in a timely manner.
"The vast majority of claimants and their legal representatives are opting for non-adversarial resolution of claims."
Brother David Gibson said the experience is that protracted litigation has very little, if any, benefit to claimants.
He added that compensation in protracted litigation is not materially different to what would have been received via early settlement and legal fees in protracted litigation are typically four times the compensation received by claimants.
However, he said some are significantly higher.
In one recent case, the head of the congregation said, the claim for legal fees by a legal firm was almost 19 times the compensation paid to the claimant.
"Regrettably protracted litigation diverts and depletes resources available for future claims and serves only to enrich the legal firms focusing on protracted litigation."
He said the primary focus remained on ensuring just, timely and appropriate settlements for survivors without the stress of litigation.
He invited any past-pupil of Christian Brothers' schools, who may have experienced sexual abuse, to make contact with a view to timely resolution.
As an unincorporated body, the congregation cannot be sued if it does not provide a nominee.
In circumstances where no member of an unincorporated body puts themself forward to represent a body as a whole in litigation, all of the relevant members may be pursued.
In July, Ms Justice Mary Rose Gearty issued a similar order regarding 341 former members of the Christian Brothers.
The 314 former members were named publicly as part of a claim in which a man is seeking damages for abuse he suffered at the hands of Liam Coughlan, a former brother, at CBS Primary School on Stephen Street in Kilkenny in the 1970s.
Coughlan, of Pine Grove, Tramore in Co Waterford, was jailed in 2023 for sexually assaulting numerous boys at the school during the 1970s, including the man at the centre of the case.
He died in prison last month.
Christian Brothers position 'particularly unchristian' - solicitor
Solicitor Philip Treacy said the publication of the names was a "direct consequence" of the Christian Brothers not putting forward any member to act as a nominee or representatives in the proceedings.
"This in turn leaves victims in the particularly legally disadvantaged position of having to spend the time finding and pursuing all relevant members of the congregation at the time of the abuse perpetrated upon them, which runs into several hundred defendants having to be formally joined to each one of these cases," he told RTÉ's News at One.
Mr Treacy said the Christian Brothers should be challenged on why it is taking this position.
"The reality is there's nothing in law that prevents any one of its members from coming forward to act as nominee in our experience.
"They are the only religious order that chooses to do this. It is a matter of choice and it is something that could be very easily avoidable.
"The consequences are to further traumatise victims of childhood sexual abuse.
"These men, who are able to come forward after many years of carrying the abuse, suffering the trauma, finally reach a position where they can pursue what is their legal right to seek justice and then they are met with these obstacles."
Mr Treacy added that this was making things "extremely difficult" and "costly" for victims.
"It adds to trauma for people who, as I said, have carried trauma for their entire lives. It's totally needless and particularly unchristian in my view.
"For the sake of all the victims who are being retraumatised by this litigation strategy, I would urge and call upon those in a position of authority in the Christian Brothers to finally choose to do the correct Christian and moral thing."
Christian Brothers must 'face responsibilities' - Martin
Taoiseach Micheál Martin called on the Christian Brothers "to face up to its responsibilities and to deal properly with survivors".
Speaking on his way into a Cabinet meeting, Mr Martin said: "Too many of them [survivors] have to go into the courts for far too long.
"The order should accept responsibility for the abuse perpetrated by some of its members in the past and should compensate those survivors and those who are victims of such abuse."
Tánaiste Simon Harris said victims and survivors of child sex abuse by religious institutions have been treated "despicably".
"The reality is that those victims and survivors must wake again today to a situation where this issue is being publicly discussed, with a religious order refusing to put forward a nominated individual and hiding behind a bizarre legal structure."
He called this "insulting" and "painful".
The Tánaiste said it adds "further pain to victims and survivors who have suffered enough already".
"Religious institutions could end this today by enabling the courts to carry out their work by putting forward a nominated person," he said.
"The fact that they haven't done that is really just an insulting final act to survivors and victims, and they need to reflect on that very seriously."
Last year, the congregation in the Republic of Ireland had net assets of €51.7 million.
The Register of Charities also shows that it had an income of €18.7m in 2025, while expenditure stood at €11m.
Anyone affected by the issues raised in this report can contact:
Sage Advocacy
01-536 7330
Email : info@sageadvocacy.ie