Monday, November 16, 2026

As church numbers dwindle, Catholic dioceses are forced to merge and adapt

“God Almighty, does that mean we’ll have to go to Mass in Kerry or Limerick?” asked one of the Sunday morning faithful outside Cobh’s St Colman’s Cathedral.

At the start of the month, news emerged that the Diocese of Cloyne is likely to be amalgamated with a neighbouring diocese in the coming years.

The River Lee — more or less — divides the county of Cork into two Catholic dioceses: Cloyne in the north with a Catholic population of about 150,000, and Cork and Ross in the south with 224,000.

In early October, a consultation document was circulated privately by the seven bishops in Munster, presenting multiple merger options. 

Four related to Cloyne, variously proposing its merger with Cork and Ross, Waterford and Lismore, Kerry, or Limerick.

Any merger would likely take years to complete, with the dioceses initially continuing as separate administrations under the management of one bishop, before eventually becoming a single entity. 

Such an amalgamation is made more likely for Cloyne because its current bishop, William Crean, will in December reach the Church’s retirement age of 75.

It is thought that the most likely coming together would be between Cloyne and the neighbouring Cork and Ross, ultimately creating a new diocese with a Catholic population of 375,000.

With vocations to the priesthood plummeting in recent decades, parishes across the country have merged as “families” in recent years, with priests operating across multiple areas.

To address the concerns of the Cobh parishioner concerned about having to travel to the other end of a merged diocese for Mass, one priest said that the more immediate effects of any such merger would most likely be felt by clergy.

“Let’s say it’s going to be Cloyne and Cork and Ross,” he said. “At the moment, you could have a priest serving, say, in Mitchelstown, and Bishop Crean might move him to, let’s say, Youghal, about an hour’s drive.

“If we had one large diocese, that priest might be asked by the new bishop to move from Mitchelstown down to Crookhaven, which is a two-hour journey.

“Now, there is a certain logic to having all of Cork in one diocese, and there is a bit of history there too.” 

That might be an understatement. 

The original Diocese of Cork was established by the Synod of Ráth Breasail in 1111, but four decades later the Synod of Kells established the separate dioceses of Cloyne and Ross. 

In 1326, Pope John XXII, at the behest of King Edward II, issued a papal bull for the union of Cork and Cloyne, which was eventually enacted a century later in 1429.

For the first half of the 18th century, the Catholic bishop of Cork and Cloyne was the administrator of Ross, before Cork was broken off by Pope Benedict XIV, with Cloyne and Ross amalgamated. 

In 1850, Cloyne and Ross were separated, and Cork and Ross merged in 1958.

Now, that diocesan dance will begin again, and one priest quipped: “Amalgamation once again.”

The merging of parishes is part of the Catholic Church’s ongoing efforts to address the continuing collapse in numbers of priests in Ireland, and the ongoing decline in religious observation.

Half a century ago, 141 new priests were ordained in Ireland, and there were 5,618 priests in diocesan ministry. Some 25 years ago, 22 priests were ordained, with about 3,300 priests in ministry.

Last year saw six priests ordained in Ireland, with about 2,000 in ministry across the country.

In the 2022 census, 3.5m people, or 69%, identified as Catholic, signifying a 10% decline on 2016. In September, an Ipsos/B&A survey of people living in rural Ireland, undertaken for the Irish Examiner, found that 34% of people in rural communities go to Mass weekly.

Just 13% of people aged between 25 and 34 said they were weekly church-goers, but the figure was 26% for the youngest cohort surveyed, those aged 16 to 24. The highest weekly Mass attendance, at 65%, was in the 65-plus age group.

Four years ago, the bishop of Cork and Ross, Fintan Gavin, said the Catholic Church in Ireland “could not try to maintain a system that was there for a different time, when there was a lot more priests and a lot more people” attending Mass.

“We can’t keep going with all the churches that we have; how do you decide where Mass is on a Sunday, and if we believe that it’s gathering people together, how do you bring them together, rather than having a splinter group here and there and Father rushing in his car from one to the other?” 

Predicting that implementation of the family of parishes model would be where “rubber meets road”, Bishop Gavin said it would be in practical decisions that difficulties would become apparent.

“I think everyone understands it until there won’t be a Mass here, ‘We always had a baptism here and all our children were baptised here, in this particular church’. You could keep that system going for another few years, tipping around, but what is the Church for? It’s not about just keeping churches for the sake of it.” 

In February, the Augustinian friars announced that St Augustine’s Church in Cork city would close. For generations the church had been at the heart of the city’s spiritual life.

As a religious order, the Augustinians operated in the diocese with the consent of the bishop and had not come under the family of parishes regime. 

However, the order was as prone to dwindling numbers as any other part of the Catholic Church in Ireland.

When he announced that the Augustinians’ 750-year association with the city was soon to end, vicar provincial Fr Paddy O’Reilly said the order in Ireland had only 10 friars under 70, with more than half of its priests over 80.

Fifty years ago, he said, it would have had “at least 12 novices and three to four ordinations every year”.

“Today we would be lucky to have one novice and most years we have no ordinations. We are also getting older and less able.” 

In July, when the Augustinians held their final Mass in Cork city, St Augustine’s Church was full to not far from twice its 1,200-strong capacity.

The heat in the 84-year-old building was almost unbearable, and many of those in the congregation admitted they had not regularly attended Mass there but had wanted to be there one last time out of love for St Augustine’s.

In the sacristy after the ceremony, one celebrant joked wryly that he had never realised there were so many Catholics in Cork.

In February 2025, the then cardinal Robert Prevost — now Pope Leo XIV — met with the four Irish archbishops to discuss reconfiguring dioceses.

Last year saw the diocese of Achonry merged with Elphin under Bishop Kevin Doran. This year has seen Killala merge with Tuam under Archbishop Francis Duffy, and Ossory merge with Ferns under Bishop Ger Nash.

With church attendance and clerical vocations unlikely to improve, the policy of downsizing is certain to continue under the new papal nuncio Archbishop Jan Romeo Pawlowski, who was appointed last month. 

The 65-year-old Pole was formerly papal nuncio in Greece. He replaces Archbishop Luis Mariano Montemayor (70), who served in Ireland since 2023.

Pope Leo XIV flies Peruvian helicopter into Andes Mountains as he makes good on 4-year-old promise

Pope Leo XIV took to the skies in a Peruvian military helicopter to a town in the Andes Mountains after being forced to abandon his trip on the ground.

Photos of the experience show the leader of the Catholic Church boarding the Peruvian Air Force Mi-17 helicopter in Chiclayo — a town in northern Peru — on Saturday morning, before taking off and flying for 40 minutes east over the mountain range toward Santa Cruz de Succhabamba, located at more than 6,000 feet.

Letters from Leo, an online site dedicated to the pontiff, wrote that Leo was snapped standing close to the helicopter's window, watching the mountain range go by. Video from the Peruvian Air Force also shows the religious leader climbing up into the cockpit to ride, all the while wearing a headset and sitting between the two pilots.

During his time as Bishop of Chiclayo, the pope — then Robert Provost — would drive a Mahindra 4x4 pickup into the highlands where several of his parishes, including Cañaris, Incahuasi, Uyurpampa and Santa Cruz lay. The site reported that when the road gave out, the future pope would climb onto a horse and continue the journey.

Accroding to the report, tens of thousands of people were awaiting him at the town's esplanade at the end of his journey, all eager to be a part of his 11 a.m. Mass. The site claimed that many of the people who greeted Leo had come a day before his arrival and slept in the town, even after the half a million people greeted him back in Chiclayo.

Leo had last held a Mass in Santa Cruz on Sept. 28, 2022, in honor of the town's patron, the Señor del Costado, or "Lord of the Pierced Side," referring to the wound inflicted on the right side of Jesus Christ by a Roman soldier's lance. It was after that that Leo returned to Rome, but not before promising to return.

During his Mass, Leo told the congregation that it was "a very big dream the Lord has allowed me." Leo added, "The Lord knows the roads you travel, the fatigue, the worries, the challenges you face."

Welcome home

Leo's visit marks the third and final leg of the U.S.-born pontiff's apostolic journey to South America, running from Nov. 6 to 17. In his first words as the leader of 1.4 billion Catholics, Pope Leo gave a special shout-out in Spanish to his "beloved Diocese of Chiclayo" from the balcony of St. Peter's Basilica.

The return of Leo reaffirmed his affection for Chiclayo's churches, schools, and sanctuaries and is widely viewed as the emotional highlight of his South American trip. It was clear that, despite his long absence, he remains beloved for championing social justice issues and for his closeness to the people, especially the poor.

"We love him so much because he's worked here, he knows our sufferings, he knows it all," said 85-year-old Evelina Cruz when asked about her feelings regarding the pontiff.

Many of those who still reside there remember how the then-bishop led the life-saving purchase of oxygen production plants during the COVID-19 pandemic. Or how he'd drive his pickup truck to remote villages to hand out blankets and sing Christmas songs, and his love of regional dishes like duck with rice and goat stew.

"People aren't saying, 'The pope is Peruvian.' They're saying, 'The pope is Chiclayano!'" said the Rev. Jasson Sempertegui, who was his secretary when he led the diocese. "In Chiclayo we like to say: 'The pope is returning home.'"

Although born on Chicago's South Side, the pope moved to Peru in 1985. During his time in the city, Leo often repeated a joke: "Chicago, Chiclayo, what difference is there? Only one letter."

Castillo calls two young people killed in a protest against Merino "martyrs" before Leo XIV

Cardinal Carlos Castillo, Archbishop of Lima, used the prayer vigil of Leo XIV with young people at the National Stadium to bestow the title of martyrs on the two protesters who died in November 2020 during the demonstrations against the government of Manuel Merino. 

“And there are two martyrs of the young people, Bryan and Inti,” he said on Thursday, November 12, before the Pope and some 52,000 people, after recalling that in the mobilizations of recent years, “in some cases, several of them were shot.” 

Leo XIV then took the floor, limiting himself to thanking the cardinal’s intervention in a generic way and mentioning neither the deceased nor the term. The word martyr does not appear in the speech published by the Holy See.

Jordan Inti Sotelo Camargo, 24, and Jack Bryan Pintado Sánchez, 22, died on November 14, 2020, in downtown Lima during the second national march against Merino, struck by pellets. Merino resigned the following day and Francisco Sagasti assumed the presidency. 

Since then, the two names have become the symbol of those mobilizations and the cause of human rights organizations, which attribute the deaths to police repression. Six years later, no court has established who fired the shots.

The judicial process explains why the cardinal’s words are not innocuous. 

The then Prosecutor of the Nation, Zoraida Ávalos, filed a constitutional complaint against Merino, his President of the Council of Ministers, Ántero Flores-Aráoz, and his Minister of the Interior, Gastón Rodríguez, as alleged perpetrators by omission of the homicides. 

Congress archived the complaint in 2022: the Subcommittee on Constitutional Accusations approved in June the report of Congressman Alejandro Cavero, which held that there was no evidence that the Police had used lead pellets, and the Permanent Commission ratified the archive on July 1. 

The Prosecutor’s Office then turned against the police chain of command. Prosecutor Jhousy Aburto has requested up to 35 years in prison for several officers as indirect perpetrators, arguing that the deployed agents carried 12-gauge shotguns compatible with the pellets found in the bodies. 

No ballistic expertise, according to the documentation handled by the Lima newspaper Expreso, has linked a specific projectile to a weapon or a specific agent.

Expreso published on Saturday an extensive report accusing the cardinal of failing to tell the truth. The newspaper includes the testimony of jurist Mario Amoretti, former dean of the Lima Bar Association, according to whom the Police did not use lead ammunition, there are videos with homemade weapons in the hands of protesters, and the Prosecutor’s Office, which clung from the beginning to the thesis of police responsibility, “refused to investigate them.” 

The newspaper also mentions the discovery of 352 rubber pellet cartridges, which would reinforce the defense of the agents. The thesis of the infiltrators, however, has not been proven either. 

The December 2020 expert report on Sotelo’s body described a lead pellet from a shotgun cartridge with no signs of artisanal manufacture, a fact that does not prove police authorship but also does not support the homemade weapons hypothesis. The case remains open in all directions.

Expreso also provides documents on the two deceased. According to the reproduced sentence, Pintado was convicted in 2018, through early termination of the process, as the perpetrator of an aggravated theft against a 16-year-old adolescent from whom he had taken the mobile phone, with a suspended two-year prison sentence. 

In Sotelo’s case, the newspaper does not present a conviction, but a police report from August 2018 from the Caja de Agua police station in San Juan de Lurigancho, which describes him as having been intervened with drugs that, according to the document, he declared he sold retail to pay for his studies. 

When the report was released in 2020, the family maintained that it was an error that had been overcome. Merino told Bethel Noticias that the deceased were not martyrs of any repression and that their death was used politically, and has lamented that a space of faith is used to politicize the tragedy, although he says he wishes justice for the families.

None of this resolves the question raised by the cardinal, and it is worth stating it precisely. A criminal past does not prevent martyrdom: the Church venerates converted sinners and the Gospel promises paradise to the good thief on the very day of his death. 

What makes a martyr is the cause, not the suffering or the biography, according to the old Augustinian formula: martyrem non facit poena, sed causa. 

The Catechism defines martyrdom as “the supreme witness to the truth of the faith” (n. 2473), a testimony of Christ dead and risen sustained until death. Francis opened in 2017, with the motu proprio Maiorem hac dilectionem, a different path for those who offer their lives for others, but conditioned it to a free and voluntary offering, moved by charity, in the face of certain and short-term death, and to the exercise of Christian virtues. 

Dying from a gunshot in a demonstration against a government does not fall into either of the two categories, whoever fired it.

The setting aggravates the use of the term. Castillo did not speak at a rally but at a prayer event presided over by the Successor of Peter, before tens of thousands of young Catholics. 

In the mouth of a cardinal and in that place, the word martyr does not function as a civic metaphor. It functions as an ecclesial judgment. It is not the first time that the archbishop has introduced these names into the liturgy. 

In the Te Deum on July 28, he asked in the prayer of the faithful for Inti, for Bryan, and for Eduardo Ruiz, “Trvko,” the rapper killed in October 2025 by the shot of a police sub-officer dressed as a civilian, as then recognized by the Commander General of the Police, Óscar Arriola. Praying for the deceased is a work of mercy. 

Proclaiming them martyrs before the Pope is another matter.

Leo XIV spoke that night of the cross, the instrument of death that through Christ’s self-giving became “the place where his love was manifested.” 

It was the only death he spoke of.

Pope Leo XIV crowns the Immaculate Conception in the cathedral of Chiclayo and entrusts to her his "life and ministry as Successor of Peter"

Pope Leo XIV presided this Saturday, November 14, at the Cathedral of Santa María de Chiclayo, over the coronation rite of the image of the Immaculate Virgin, and took the opportunity to entrust his pontificate to her. 

The Pope celebrated the act in the church where he began his episcopal service as Bishop of Chiclayo in 2015, during his apostolic journey to Uruguay, Argentina, and Peru, which concludes on November 17. 

“To your immaculate heart I entrust today my life and my ministry as Successor of Peter,” he said in the homily, according to the text published by the Holy See.

The ceremony brought together the faithful inside the cathedral and hundreds more in the square surrounding it. 

At the beginning, the Pope gave thanks to God for returning to the church that witnessed the first steps of his episcopal ministry and explained that the crown he was about to place on the image symbolizes the tribute of gratitude and filial love offered by himself, the people of Chiclayo, and the entire Church. 

After the homily, he placed a golden crown on the Virgin, amid the applause of those present.

“With you I learned to be shepherd of Chiclayo”

The most personal moment came when Leo XIV addressed the image directly. “With you I learned to be shepherd of Chiclayo,” he stated, and recalled the years when the Virgin accompanied him through the towns and cities of the diocese and taught him to meet his people. 

He also recalled that devotion to the Immaculate is part of the Christian roots that shape the identity of the people of Chiclayo and strengthen their faith.

The homily also had a tone of hope amid the shadows of the present. The Pope acknowledged that darkness continues to lurk and that the uncertainty of increasingly widespread violence produces threat and unease. 

In response, he presented Christ as the answer, citing Isaiah: “a child is born to us, a son is given to us.” Only He, he said, “is the light that illuminates the most hidden corners of human existence” and the only one capable of rescuing from sin.

The Virgin as “cause of our joy”

Leo XIV invoked Mary as “cause of our joy,” because her “yes” to the angel allowed God to enter the history of men made man. He asked the faithful of Chiclayo to continue walking together, “as one family of God,” with love, forgiveness, and the pursuit of justice.

The Pontiff concluded with a prayer that begins with the words “Holy Mary, full of the presence of God.” 

In it, he asked the Virgin to continue accompanying her people and to obtain for the faithful the gift of listening attentively to the Holy Spirit, so that they may be builders of peace and reconciliation and servants of the Kingdom of God and of their brothers and sisters.

A day dedicated to his former diocese

The rite is part of a day the Pope dedicated to his former Peruvian see. That same day, InfoVaticana reported on his speech at the University of Chiclayo, where he warned against transhumanism, and the day before it covered his homily at the Mass celebrated in the city, in which he cited Benedict XVI.

Gluten-free hosts are still not valid for Mass: the 2003 norm that Rome ratified in 2017

Hosts made without any gluten are not valid matter for celebrating the Eucharist, whereas those containing the minimum amount necessary to make bread are valid. 

This is the norm established by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith in a circular letter dated July 24, 2003, signed by its prefect, Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, and which remains in force.

The text specifies that low-gluten bread is valid provided no foreign substances are added and no procedures are used that would alter the nature of the bread. 

It also permits must, that is, grape juice whose fermentation has been stopped without altering its nature, for example by freezing. It is up to the Ordinary to grant permission to use minimum-gluten bread or must, and this permission may be granted on a regular basis for as long as the situation that justifies it continues.

The 2017 ratification to bishops worldwide

The Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments ratified these criteria in a circular letter to bishops dated June 15, 2017, signed by Cardinal Robert Sarah, prefect, and Archbishop Arthur Roche, secretary. 

The document, which InfoVaticana reported on at the time, suggests that Ordinaries ensure the eucharistic matter through appropriate certificates and that they may issue specific guidelines within the framework of the episcopal conference.

The letter also reminds bishops that they must warn pastors of their responsibility to verify who supplies the bread and wine and whether the matter is suitable. It likewise asks that producers be reminded of their duty to respect the norms absolutely.

What celiac faithful can do

According to the 2003 letter, a celiac faithful who cannot receive bread, even minimum-gluten bread, may receive communion with wine alone. The norm therefore does not prohibit communion for celiacs but offers these alternatives within valid matter.

The same document addresses the case of priests. With the Ordinary’s permission, a presbyter who cannot take bread may receive communion with wine alone in a concelebration, and one who cannot take even a minimal amount of wine may do so with bread alone. 

However, one who cannot receive communion with bread may not celebrate the Eucharist individually or preside over a concelebration, and the letter urges “great caution” in admitting to the priesthood candidates who cannot take gluten or alcohol without serious harm to their health. 

When the president of a concelebration uses must or minimum-gluten bread, the concelebrants receive communion with ordinary bread and wine.

Ordo Iuris denounces that Nowacka's mandatory health education violates parents' rights in Poland

The Polish legal institute Ordo Iuris has denounced that the decision by the Minister of Education, Barbara Nowacka, to make health education compulsory violates Article 48 of the Polish Constitution, which guarantees parents the right to educate their children in accordance with their own convictions. 

“The lack of a real possibility to exempt the student from health education infringes Article 48,” states the director of the organization’s Education Center, Artur Górecki, in a comment published on the institute’s website.

Until now, Ordo Iuris recalls in its message on X, parents could withdraw their children from similar classes, something that with the new model would no longer be possible. 

The organization also launched a petition “against the sexualization of children” and claims that the reform ignores the voice of thousands of parents and teachers. 

Górecki describes the decision as “contrary to the will of a large part of society” and “dictated by ideological reasons,” and attributes to the minister pressure from international organizations.

A separate and voluntary sexual health module

The subject entered Polish schools in the 2025/2026 academic year, replacing the former family life preparation course. 

According to the Ministry’s approach, the compulsory part would cover general health, while sexual health content would be taught in a separate and optional module, which, according to Nowacka herself, would represent approximately one tenth of the total.

Górecki sees this separation as a “tactical maneuver.” 

In his view, the curriculum is ideological and the Ministry will eventually incorporate that content into the compulsory block. He adds that the attitude of “we know what we’re doing and we’ll do it our way” does not constitute an educational reform.

The bishops have already invoked the same articles

The constitutional argument is not new. In November 2024, the Polish Episcopal Conference informed the PAP agency that the Ministry’s project was contrary to the Constitution and cited its Articles 48 and 53: “Sexual education, in accordance with the Constitution, remains the competence of parents and not of the State,” the bishops stated.

The minister responded in the same conversation with PAP that the subject does not contradict the Magna Carta and that it is “extremely necessary for Polish youth.” 

Nowacka maintained that developing the curriculum is the responsibility of the Ministry and not of the Episcopate, and that with the argument of parental competence, the teaching of biology or physics could also be questioned.

The debate also comes at a time of attention to the role of parents in affective education. InfoVaticana reported that, according to Ordo Iuris, the Council of Europe recommends “comprehensive” sex education from an early age that would limit parents to being informed.

EU nuncio, Bernardito Auza: European rearmament must serve peace, without renouncing legitimate defense

Archbishop Bernardito Auza, apostolic nuncio to the European Union, warned in Brussels that the continent’s rearmament must serve peace, not war, while also upholding the right of nations to defend themselves. 

He made these remarks during the conference held on November 11 and 12 by the Centesimus Annus Pro Pontifice Foundation, in collaboration with the Commission of the Bishops’ Conferences of the European Union (COMECE), as reported by EWTN News, which covered the event.

A “deep and multidimensional crisis”

Auza described Europe’s situation as a “deep and multidimensional crisis” affecting security, economic competitiveness, and the continent’s foundational values. European rearmament is advancing in this context, driven by the war in Ukraine and doubts about the United States’ security guarantees to NATO allies.

In response to this dynamic, the nuncio recalled that the Church teaches “unarmed and disarming peace” and maintained that security “cannot be separated from the culture of peace and dialogue.” Defense policy, he said, cannot be built apart from reconciliation among peoples.

“The Church is not a naïve pacifist”

However, the archbishop made clear that this stance does not mean denying legitimate defense. “The Church is not a naïve pacifist,” he stated, adding that the doctrine of just war cannot be abandoned, because at its core it affirms the right to self-defense and the protection of fundamental values.

Auza also drew on the teaching of Leo XIV, recalling the Pope’s address in Metz on September 28, in which he praised Robert Schuman’s commitment to reconciliation and warned against the temptation to entrust peace to military force rather than dialogue. 

The Pontiff had already criticized European rearmament at La Sapienza University in Rome, as InfoVaticana reported.

The nuncio’s intervention coincides with Archbishop Richard Gallagher’s defense of the just-war doctrine, which the secretary for Relations with States described as a response to what he called “dangerous pacifism,” as this outlet reported. 

Both diplomats thus emphasize that the Holy See seeks to combine the ideal of peace with recognition of legitimate defense.

Other matters discussed at the meeting

During the conference, Auza also spoke about Haiti, where he served as nuncio, and stated that Haitians must lead the reconstruction of their country, although the international community has a moral obligation to help. 

The meeting also addressed migration, with reference to the mass arrival in Ceuta in July and the dangers of Mediterranean crossings, with interventions by MEP Lena Düpont and Corinna Ullrich of the European Commission.

For his part, the foundation’s president, Paolo Garonna, announced initiatives in Asia-Pacific, the Americas, and Africa, adapted to the realities of each region, along with an ethical framework uniting the public and private sectors.

Cobo asks 800 catechists from Madrid for "territorial, synodal and missionary conversion"

Cardinal José Cobo, Archbishop of Madrid, called this Saturday on the diocese’s catechists for a “territorial, synodal and missionary conversion” during the Sending Mass he presided over at the parish of San Juan de la Cruz, on the occasion of the Diocesan Catechists’ Meeting. 

According to information from the Archdiocese of Madrid, some 800 catechists took part, including several with hearing impairments who promote inclusive catechesis.

Three conversions and a definition of the catechist

In his homily, Cobo invited the catechists to return to Galilee, the place where every vocation begins, and told them that their task responds to a call to be with others and to build with others. 

“Being a catechist means being a door so that the Christian community can proclaim Jesus Christ,” he stated, according to the archdiocese. 

He added that their first call consists in discovering where Jesus Christ is among us and showing him to those who may not yet have found him, and described the Holy Spirit as the one who goes ahead, so that the catechist only has to reveal that presence.

The cardinal then broke down the three conversions. 

The territorial one leads to asking what the Lord asks of the diocese; the synodal one, to discovering baptism and understanding that in the Church no one walks alone; and the missionary one, to adapting to new needs, welcoming new questions and languages, and knowing how to listen. 

These are the three axes of the pastoral project “Let us raise our gaze together,” which gives the meeting its title and with which the archdiocese is guiding the process toward the Diocesan Assembly of 2027.

Sending, end-of-year review and questions to the archbishop

After the homily, the catechists made their profession of faith, received a candle and were sent forth with the archbishop’s blessing. 

The meeting also reviewed the activity of the past year: catechesis days by vicariates, participation in the Jubilee of Catechists in Rome, formation courses, a sign-language course and retreats for the spiritual care of the catechists.

The new diocesan Delegate for Catechesis, José María Pérez Navarro, opened the event by stating that “the Church exists to evangelize” and stressed that the whole Church must support catechesis, which is a shared mission. 

Among his priorities he cited the baptismal catechumenate for adults, follow-up after the sacraments, family catechesis and collaboration between parishes and schools. 

The work of Manuel María Bru, delegate from 2015 to 2025, was also acknowledged. For his part, Patxi Fano, author of the meeting poster, led a session on the role of the catechist focused on putting Jesus at the center.

In the question-and-answer session, the catechists raised how to keep children after the sacraments, how to involve parents and godparents, or how to face their own fears. 

Cobo replied that catechesis is a process and not a one-off event, that families must be accompanied from the faith they already have, and that the true guide is the Holy Spirit. 

He confessed that his greatest fear is to insist on his own plans instead of God’s and cited Jesus’ question to Peter by the Sea of Galilee: “Do you love me?”

Cobo’s pastoral line

The message adds to the line the cardinal has been setting in recent weeks, with the pastoral letter “We are lives on the way,” in which he requires the archbishop’s authorization and at least two years of trial for new ecclesial realities in Madrid, and with the pre-diocesan assemblies prior to the 2027 assembly, in which synodality occupies a central place.

Jennifer Hudson to headline Vatican Christmas concert for the poor

Grammy- and Academy Award-winning singer Jennifer Hudson will usher in the Christmas season at the Vatican with a concert for the poor.

The R&B artist will perform on Dec. 5 at the seventh edition of the Concert with the Poor in the Vatican’s Paul VI Hall. As in 2025, Pope Leo XIV will attend the concert, which will support approximately 3,000 people in need served by volunteer organizations around Rome.

Hudson will become the first American vocalist to perform at the Christmas concert, singing alongside the renowned priest and composer Monsignor Marco Frisina, Italian actress and singer Serena Autieri, and the choir of the Diocese of Rome. 

It will also mark Hudson’s second performance at the Vatican, following her 2025 appearance with others at “Grace for the World,” in tribute to Pope Francis, who died earlier that year.

The 2025 edition, which hosted a pope for the first time in its history, featured Canadian singer Michael Bublé, who described the experience as an encouragement to others to discuss their Christian faith openly.

“My hope is that there’s a young person who might listen to me today who might be afraid to share their faith or to be open about it, and they look at me and they say, ‘Wow, look at Bublé. He’s not afraid to share it,’ and maybe it will give them the strength to do the same,” Bublé told EWTN News.

Pope Leo XIV has attended at least eight musical events since his election in 2025; his most recent was the “Canticle of Peace” musical prayer service at Castel Gandolfo in July, performed by Andrea Bocelli.

Tickets for the Dec. 5 concert are free, with registration opening on Nov. 19 through the website.

Pittsburgh Diocese establishes ‘Cabrini Fund’ to help immigrant families facing hardship

The Diocese of Pittsburgh said this week that it is establishing an emergency initiative called the “Cabrini Fund” to help immigrant families address what Bishop Mark Eckman called their “hardest moments” including the loss of household providers.

The announcement, made on Nov. 13 — the memorial of St. Frances Xavier Cabrini — said the fund is meant to address what the diocese said is a “growing need” to help immigrants in crisis in western Pennsylvania.

It will offer “temporary emergency assistance” to immigrant families in the diocese who are facing “extraordinary hardship.” 

The diocese said that the fund is meant to function as a last resort after “other sources of assistance” have already been utilized.

It will offer immigrant families money for rent, utilities, medical care, food, clothing, diapers and other essentials.

The families served by the fund will also be connected with “trusted partners” to help address long-term needs, including “employment, schooling, health care, and qualified legal help.”

“The Church cannot solve every difficulty a family may face, but we can make sure that no family faces its hardest moments alone,” Eckman said in announcing the fund.

The diocese will begin distributing funding on Dec. 12, the Feast of Our Lady of Guadalupe. It will be administered by the diocesan Catholic Charities affiliate and funded by donations through either the charity or via individual parishes.

As with much of the rest of the country, Pennsylvania has seen an uptick in immigration enforcement over the last few years, with authorities there detaining and at times deporting immigrants in the country illegally.

The diocese said immigrant families in Pennsylvania are facing crises that include “the loss of a Household’s provider” as well as “fear and uncertainty for their children.”

The title of the fund refers to St. Frances Xavier Cabrini, the first American to be canonized and the founder of the Missionary Sisters of the Sacred Heart of Jesus.

In 1950, Pope Pius XII officially named her the patron saint of immigrants, recognizing her lifelong dedication to displaced and marginalized communities.

Youth group raises $15,000 for first marble statue of St. Carlo Acutis in Miami

When the youth group approached Father José Luis Menéndez with the request for a statue of teenaged St. Carlo Acutis to be installed on parish grounds, the pastor of Corpus Christi Parish realized this could be an opportunity to build up the self-esteem of young parishioners.

He gave them a challenge: fundraise the majority of the statue’s cost, and Corpus Christi would take care of the remainder. “They’re old enough to fight for what they believe,” said the priest. “It’s a way to train them to realize that they can accomplish whatever they want.”

Corpus Christi Parish is a largely immigrant parish in Allapattah, and many of the members of One Youth Group face family hardships, according to Dalia Saravia, one of the group coordinators. 

Integrating the kids into fundraising for a statue of the Church’s first canonized millennial, Father Menéndez hoped to instill in them a sense of empowerment.

Several months and $15,000 later, Saravia believes Father Menéndez’s plan was a success.

The first marble statue of St. Carlo Acutis in Miami was blessed and inaugurated on the evening of Oct. 12, more than half a year after the youth group’s first fundraising event. 

Outside the parish hall where the statue now stands, Father Menéndez, Father Adelson “Sonny” Moreira, and Deacon Antonio “Tony” Perez prayed over the artwork, sprinkling it with holy water as the excited crowd looked on.

That moment was the first time the children of One Youth Group saw the statue unveiled, said Saravia. And to think that a journey to Assisi, months of hard work, and an act of faith had brought them this gift.

How it all began

St. Carlo Acutis (1991-2006) from Italy became the first millennial to be declared a saint after his canonization last year on Sept. 7, 2025. He passed away at just 15 years old from leukemia. St. Carlo loved Jesus in the Eucharist and was a huge proponent of going to Adoration: he even created an online exhibition of Eucharistic miracles to inspire people to come to the Eucharist.

St. Carlo also played Pokémon and dressed up as Spiderman, showing a love for contemporary culture and making him easy to befriend for the eighth graders through high school seniors in One Youth Group.

Felix Rodriguez Escalante, one of the youth group coordinators, began sharing Carlo Acutis’ story with the group prior to the saint’s canonization. After all, St. Carlo is “the first millennial saint, he’s your age, he’s a programmer - if there’s anybody you guys are going to be able to connect with, it will be him,” said Saravia, echoing Rodriguez Escalante’s words to the youth group.

Rodriguez Escalante and Saravia planned to travel overseas for the Jubilee of Young People in Rome in July 2025, which would have been soon after St. Carlo’s expected canonization on April 27, 2025. However, when Pope Francis died on April 21, the canonization was postponed until September.

Even so, when Rodriguez Escalante and Saravia traveled to the Jubilee of Young People, they visited Assisi and actually saw Carlo Acutis, whose body is visible in his tomb. The experience of praying in front of the soon-to-be-saint made a big impression on the youth group coordinators, especially Rodriguez Escalante.

“Once we came back, Felix started telling Father that he thought it would be a great idea for the parish to have a statue of Carlo Acutis,” said Saravia.

Faith set in stone

Father Menéndez was on board with featuring a statue of St. Carlo: having this depiction of the saint at the parish would serve as an image of what young faith can accomplish.

“It’s a challenge: ‘If he did it, why not us?’” he said.

Through the Archdiocese of Miami’s annual Priest Convocation in September 2025, the pastor connected with Vaticano Creations, Inc., headed by Ruggiero Schiraldi. His father, Paolo Schiraldi, is the statue’s sculptor.

It was time for One Youth Group to get to work fundraising for the statue.

“At the beginning, it was very daunting,” Sarvia admitted.

The youth group’s initial fundraiser was launched in January. Throughout the coming months, the group’s fundraising endeavors included putting together a Valentine’s Day party and bingo events. By May, along with some help from generous donors, their fundraisers generated $15,000.

Crystal Nieves, a volunteer leader with One Youth Group and a freshman at Miami-Dade College, said although it was hard “because a lot of us are shy,” it ended up being “really exciting.”

The statue unveiled

After sunset on Oct. 12, the Corpus Christi community gathered around the parish hall, the statue of St. Carlo Acutis still concealed in a black veil for the big reveal. When Rodriguez Escalante and fellow youth group leader Cristopher Lopez lifted the covering, there was the white marble for all to see, depicting St. Carlo with a big smile on his face, wearing a backpack and carrying a cell phone!

“It’s a special day for a very important saint,” said sculptor Paolo Schiraldi, there to see his depiction of St. Carlo unveiled.

The statue was intentionally placed at ground level, rather than being elevated. “He is at the same level because he is the same human being that any one of us can be,” said Father Menéndez. 

After the clergy sprinkled the statue with holy water, parishioners crowded around to take photos with the statue.

Corpus Christi Parish is known for its patronage of the arts, as a home to historic colonial Spanish artwork and the venue for the Martha/Mary Concert Series. A marble statue of St. Carlo Acutis aligned perfectly with the parish’s goal to bring high-quality art to their underprivileged community.

As for One Youth Group, they already began a second project: fundraising to attend World Youth Day in Seoul, South Korea in the summer of 2027. At the statue blessing, they were even selling desserts and coffee as part of that goal.

For Nieves, the statue blessing reaffirmed the good that young people can do in their community: “We can become saints, too.”

Catholic priest charged over K1.5 million in suspected crime proceeds

A Catholic priest has been arrested and charged with four counts of possession and concealment of properties reasonably suspected to be proceeds of crime, valued at more than K1.5 million.

Father Titus Malama Sande, 45, of the 15 Miles, Chikumbi area in Chibombo District, is facing the charges, Anti-Corruption Commission Head of Corporate Communications Joseph Mwenya said.

Mwenya said the particulars of the offences in the first and second counts were that, on dates unknown but between Jan. 1, 2020 and Dec. 31, 2025, in Lusaka District, Sande, jointly and whilst acting together with other persons unknown, allegedly possessed and concealed bonds valued at K538,000 held at a named bank.

The bonds were reasonably suspected to be proceeds of crime, Mwenya said.

In the third and fourth counts, Sande allegedly concealed two motor vehicles, a Toyota Hilux and a Toyota Dyna light truck, with an estimated combined value of K1 million, Mwenya said.

The offences allegedly occurred between Jan. 1, 2020 and Dec. 31, 2025, in Lusaka District, where Sande, acting together with other persons unknown, allegedly registered the vehicles in his name, purporting that they belonged to him when, in fact, they had been acquired by Veronica Chisanga Kabwe.

“The said vehicles are reasonably suspected of being proceeds of crime. The suspect has since been released on bond and is expected to appear in court soon,” Mwenya said.

The development was linked to the apprehension of former Ministry of Community Development and Social Services Executive Officer Veronica Chisanga Kabwe and Zambia News and Information Services Senior News Editor Chimangeni Banda, who were arrested last month for possession and concealment of properties worth K5 million.

Mwenya said the commission urged members of the public to desist from engaging in corrupt practices, warning that corruption and the concealment of proceeds of crime would not be tolerated, regardless of an individual’s position or status in society.

“The ACC further reiterates its call for members of the public to report suspected cases of corruption to the Commission,” he said.

Belize Catholic Diocese Reviews Records of Priest Convicted of over 100 Sex Offences

The Roman Catholic Diocese of Belize City and Belmopan says it is reviewing records connected to the ministry of former missionary priest Father Edward Gallagher, following reports surrounding his conviction on sex offences in Northern Ireland. 

The review comes after questions were raised about his time serving in San Ignacio, Cayo, and reports that a Belizean teenager later travelled with him to Northern Ireland.   

The Roman Catholic Diocese of Belize City and Belmopan is examining records from Father Edward Gallagher’s time serving in Belize, following revelations of his guilty plea to more than one hundred sex offences in Northern Ireland. 

Gallagher served as a missionary priest in San Ignacio, Cayo, between approximately 1999 and 2004 after being sent to Belize by the Diocese of Derry. 

In a statement issued on November 12, the Belize diocese said it has not received any complaints or allegations of abuse against Gallagher during his years of ministry here. 

However, officials say they are reviewing available records as part of their responsibility to ensure transparency and accountability. 

The review follows reports that, after his missionary assignment in Belize ended, Gallagher returned to Northern Ireland accompanied by a Belizean teenage boy who reportedly lived with him for a period of time. 

The Diocese of Belize City and Belmopan said anyone with information or concerns is encouraged to come forward and that such matters will be handled with confidentiality, respect and pastoral care.  

Gallagher, who is 59 years old, pleaded guilty at Londonderry Crown Court in October to 109 sex offences committed between 2023 and 2025. 

The charges include attempting to communicate sexually with children and possessing indecent images of children. 

The offences occurred years after his service in Belize. Gallagher remains in custody awaiting sentencing, which is scheduled for December 9. 

Church authorities in Northern Ireland say Gallagher was removed from ministry following his arrest, and the Bishop of Derry has indicated that he is seeking his dismissal from the priesthood through the Vatican. 

The Belize diocese says its review remains ongoing.

Priest added to New Orleans clergy abuse list 6 years after investigation

Fifteen years after Mark Lambour first reported that a priest molested him as an altar boy — and six years after Lambour went on WWL Louisiana and the Archdiocese of New Orleans launched an investigation — the church has added Father Joseph deWater to its list of clergy credibly accused of child sexual abuse.

Lambour, however, didn't live to see it.

He died in September 2025 at 67, after years of pressing the church to acknowledge his allegations.

DeWater, who denied another accuser's allegations in an exclusive interview with WWL, died in 2023 at 88.

New Archbishop James Checchio added deWater and 26 other priests to the list Friday, bringing the total clergy on the list to 106. DeWater's entry on the updated list notes that nine proofs of claim were filed against him in the archdiocese's bankruptcy case, which concluded with a $305 million settlement early this year.

Checchio did not respond to specific questions about why deWater was added now, years after allegations against him became public and his predecessor launched a formal investigation.

For Lambour's younger brother, David, the announcement brought both relief and renewed frustration.

"I'm sad that it has taken six years almost since your original reporting," David Lambour said, referring to WWL's detailed report on deWater in January 2021.

"But it's a pattern of lies, obfuscation, deflection. And it's been the same way for however many years it has been since the first victim."

Years of unanswered calls

WWL first interviewed Mark Lambour in August 2018.

He demonstrated how calls to the archdiocese's clergy abuse hotline went straight to voicemail.

"This is why it's frustrating," he said. "This is why you can't get help."

Lambour said he first reported his abuse to the archdiocese in 2011. He accused deWater of molesting him in 1972, when he was an altar boy and deWater was pastor at St. Francis Cabrini Church.

In a December 2020 interview, Lambour described being in the church sacristy when the priest put his arms around him and kissed the back of his neck, then fondled him.

He recalled panicking, hoping someone in the church would hear him.

"I just kind of broke away crying, just said 'I'm going to tell my dad,'" Lambour said. He added that he never told his father, a burly widower, for fear he would have gone into a rage and killed deWater.

Two months after WWL first started looking into Lambour's allegations in 2018, then-Archbishop Gregory Aymond released a list of 57 clergy credibly accused of sexual abuse. DeWater was not on it.

The omission devastated Lambour. As Aymond added names over the following years, deWater remained absent.

In late 2020, a second accuser came forward, and Aymond launched a formal investigation.

Earlier this year, another man who said deWater abused him as a boy, Andre Fourroux, told WWL that the priest belonged on the list.

"He needs to be added!" Fourroux said in February.

Aymond retired earlier this year without adding deWater.

DeWater said Aymond believed him

In December 2020, WWL sent a crew to interview deWater at his home in the Netherlands.

DeWater welcomed the crew inside his apartment in Voorhout, southwest of Amsterdam, and said he had spoken with Aymond just two few days earlier. DeWater said Aymond informed him of the formal investigation in a letter and spoke with him about it on the phone.

DeWater still had his paperwork related to the allegations out on his living room table, and he described the archbishop as understanding.

Asked whether he felt Aymond believed him, deWater replied: "I have the feeling that he believes me. Yeah."

The second accuser alleged that deWater took him swimming naked. DeWater acknowledged going swimming with him but denied undressing in front of him or seeing the boy unclothed.

"The changing was done separately," deWater said.

Asked whether anything happened in the swimming pool, he responded: "No, no, absolutely nothing."

The nine bankruptcy proofs of claim now noted in deWater's entry are allegations submitted through the bankruptcy process, not criminal charges.

Unless forcible rape is alleged or a victim was taken across state lines, deadlines for filing criminal charges for sexual assaults that allegedly happened before the 1990s have almost all run out.

But that's not the case for civil lawsuits. The Louisiana Legislature enacted a "lookback window" for filing for damages from decades-old sexual assault claims, paving the way for the archdiocese to settle around 600 claims in its bankruptcy.

Checchio pledges to face the truth

In a recorded video announcing the list update Friday, Checchio called the release "a heavy day and a sad day" and connected the disclosures to the church's obligations under its bankruptcy settlement.

"The road forward has to be connected with the telling of the truth," he said, also emphasizing assistance for survivors.

"We have to be willing to face the truth, whatever it was," he said.

Checchio said no clergy with allegations found credible remain in ministry in the archdiocese. He also pledged to do everything possible to prevent further abuse.

When Checchio took over from the retiring Aymond in February, the new archbishop asked a church board that reviews allegations of abuse to take a fresh look at all claims made through the archdiocese's 2020 bankruptcy case, archdiocesan spokeswoman Sarah McDonald said.

That review led to the additions announced Friday, she said.

Those assurances did not answer why deWater's name remained off the list for years after Lambour and others came forward.

For David Lambour, the consequences of that wait are inseparable from his brother's struggles.

He remembers Mark as the older brother who looked after him when they were children. Later, their roles reversed as Mark struggled with the effects of childhood trauma.

David believes the abuse set his brother on a downward spiral involving drinking and other mental and physical health problems.

"I believe that the incident perpetrated by Joseph deWater killed my brother," he said. "Not immediately, but (it) set him on a path of a downward spiral that ended up costing him his life."

Now, David is relieved that the church has finally named the priest his brother accused, even as he says the ordeal cost him his own faith.

And he had a message for other survivors, hoping they'll be inspired by his brother's courage.

"You're not forgotten," he said, "and that there hopefully will be better days for you."

Mangaluru priest accused of abusing boys: What did the church know? (Contribution)

Father Cyprian Pinto was arrested on October 17, 2026, following a POCSO complaint accusing him of sexually assaulting minor boys at the St Vincent Ferrer church in Mangaluru.

It was an arrest that shocked Mangaluru's Catholic community and deeply divided it.

The allegations were specific. Five boys had accused the parish priest of sexual assault and abuse.

But before the arrest, a letter written by one of the young boys to the Bishop of the Mangalore Diocese had been leaked. 

In it, the 14-year-old described how Father Cyprian had allegedly sexually assaulted him on three occasions. The letter was doing the rounds on social media.

Father Cyprian is now out on bail. He will face trial, and it is for the court to determine whether he is guilty.

But there is another story here.

My colleague Anisha Sheth spoke to two men who alleged that they had been sexually assaulted by the same priest when they were children. These accounts go back nearly three decades.

Anisha also found that the Bishop knew about the allegations at St Vincent Church almost two months before an FIR was registered. And yet, the Bishop’s office did not immediately approach the police.

Many of you may have heard of Spotlight, the investigative series by The Boston Globe newspaper that exposed how sexual abuse of children by Catholic priests was not merely a series of individual crimes, but a systemic problem, compounded by the church's efforts to conceal it.

The Mangaluru case raises some uncomfortable questions about whether similar institutional failures are playing out here.

First, who is Father Cyprian Pinto?

Cyprian Pinto was ordained as a Catholic priest in 1988. In the nearly four decades since, he has served in eight churches under the Mangalore Diocese.

He was appointed parish priest of St Vincent Ferrer Church in Valencia, Mangaluru, in May 2026.

But the allegations against him are not limited to his time at Valencia.

Anisha spoke to men who recalled being sexually assaulted by him when they were boys at other churches where he had served.

One of them, whom we are calling Stany, says the alleged abuse began when he was in Class 9 and Cyprian arrived as the new parish priest. He says he eventually told two church elders about what had happened. Their response, according to him, was that he should not tell anyone because the priest might have done it by mistake.

The alleged abuse was not entirely unknown. 

In December 2004, the Kannada daily Karavali Ale had published a report about allegations of sexual misconduct by a priest in the area, though it did not name Cyprian Pinto. Anisha spoke to a person, who in fact tipped off the Karavali Ale journalist back then.

These are of course allegations from decades ago, and they have not been adjudicated. But they raise an important question: were there warning signs long before the current case?

Now, let's come to the five boys at Valencia.

According to multiple accounts we have, five boys and their parents met Bishop Peter Paul Saldanha of the Mangalore Diocese on August 17. 

Each of the children had reportedly written a letter to the Bishop describing the alleged abuse. One of these letters, written by a 14-year-old, was later leaked.

The boy described how Father Cyprian initially behaved in a friendly manner before allegedly sexually assaulting him on three occasions. He also said he had witnessed the priest molest another boy.

Think about that for a moment.

These were children who had gathered the courage to tell the head of their church what had allegedly happened to them.

What happened next?

The Bishop reportedly ordered an internal inquiry. The Judicial Vicar and a priest were appointed to conduct the probe. Father Cyprian was also summoned. The inquiry report was reportedly sent to the Vatican, though TNM could not independently confirm this.

The priest was moved away from his administrative responsibilities and placed on leave on August 26.

But there was one glaring omission.

The church did not immediately report the allegations to the police.

And this is not simply a question of whether the church followed its own internal procedures.

It is a question of whether it followed the law.

The Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, or POCSO, is very clear on this.

Section 19 says that anyone who knows or suspects that a child has been sexually abused must report it to the police. Section 21 provides for punishment for failing to report an offence. 

In other words, you cannot decide to first conduct your own internal inquiry, establish whether the allegation is true, and then decide whether to inform the police.

The police say that when one of the children eventually complained to the police, he said that the bishop asked him to go to the police. 

But even then the question remains, why not inform the police immediately? 

And there are now questions about what happened after the arrest as well.

Activists and community members have alleged that sections of the church and the priest's supporters have attempted to influence the families and turn public opinion against the children.

Of the five boys who wrote letters to the Bishop, eventually only one complained to the police 

A complaint has been made to the Mangaluru Police Commissioner alleging that the church's vice president, Ronald Rodrigues, intimidated the families, warning them about repeated police questioning, court proceedings and the possibility of their children's identities being exposed.

There have also been allegations that some priests have used the pulpit to indirectly defend Father Cyprian and without naming him.

At a Sunday mass at a church in Mangaluru, a priest reportedly said that Catholics themselves had crucified a priest and urged the congregation to pray for his acquittal.

A prayer flyer circulated on WhatsApp also urged people to pray for the priest and the Bishop. It spoke of protecting the church from misunderstanding, without acknowledging the children who had come forward.

Activist Stanly KV of Odanadi Seva Samsthe has written to the Karnataka High Court's Juvenile Justice Committee, alleging that families of the children are being intimidated.

His complaint also raised concerns that four other children who were prepared to come forward have been deterred from doing so. 

He also alleged that some children were questioned by the police without first being referred to the Child Welfare Committee for counselling.

As Mangaluru’s Catholic Community grapples with these allegations, let’s not forget that this is not the first time questions have been raised about the church's handling of sexual abuse allegations.

In 2021, Father Lawrence Johnson from Mumbai was convicted of sexually assaulting a minor boy. The case exposed serious lapses by church authorities, including Cardinal Oswald Gracias, who failed to report the complaint to the police under POCSO and instead initiated an internal inquiry. This despite the child bleeding from his injuries.  

Father Joseph Palanivel Jeyapaul was convicted of sexually abusing two minor girls while serving in Minnesota. Despite repeated warnings from the US diocese, the Ootacamund Diocese accommodated him in India. This was around 2016. A case that TNM followed diligently. 

The most horrifying example is from Kottiyoor in Kerala. In 2017, Father Robin Vadakkumchery was convicted of raping and impregnating a 17-year-old girl. But the cover up before that was elaborate, a church-run hospital and church officials helped him. To the extent that the child’s biological father was at one point made to say that he raped his own daughter. But DNA tests proved otherwise.

These are just a few examples. Of course, these cases are different, and their legal outcomes are different. But they point to a recurring question: when allegations of sexual abuse involve members of the clergy, does the institution act to protect the victim or to protect itself?

The Catholic Bishops Conference of India had formulated a Child Protection Policy in 2015 and revised it in 2023. The Kerala Catholic Bishops' Council also issued guidelines in 2019.

But policies mean very little if they are not implemented, and if there is no transparency about how complaints are handled.

And that brings us back to Mangaluru...

Father Cyprian Pinto has been granted bail. Bail is not an acquittal. The allegations against him must be investigated thoroughly and fairly, and the court will decide his guilt or innocence.

But the questions about the church do not disappear with the bail order.

The Catholic Church is an institution that commands enormous trust among its followers. That trust comes with responsibility.

The children who wrote those letters were not asking the church to protect its reputation. They were seeking an end to the sexual assault.

And that is perhaps the most disturbing part of this entire episode.