The Church of England has “undoubtedly lost a measure of credibility”
after its parliamentary body voted down legislation to allow women
bishops, the Archbishop of Canterbury has said.
In a strongly worded presidential address, Dr Rowan
Williams said the Church was going to be faced with “very uncomfortable
and very unpleasant accusation and recrimination” after last Tuesday’s vote
and that it had a “lot of explaining to do” to Anglicans and wider
society alike.
“Whatever the motivations of the voting yesterday, whatever the
theological principle upon which people acted, the fact remains that a
great deal of this discussion is not intelligible to our wider society,”
he said. “Worse than that, it seems as if we are wilfully blind to some of the
priorities of that wider society. We have some explaining to do. We have as a result of yesterday undoubtedly lost a measure of
credibility in our society and I mean that as objectively as I can
because it is perfectly true that the ultimate credibility of the Church
does not depend on the goodwill of the public … but the fact is as it
is.”
He warned that last Tuesday’s vote had done nothing to make polarisation in the Church less likely.
“The risk of creating further polarisation – of views and identity – is a very real one,” he said. “I hope we will try and hold back from simple recrimination in all of this.”
The Archbishop said Synod itself was now “under scrutiny” as to why the
legislation had fallen despite the majority of Synod members – and
Diocesan Synods - voting in favour.
The legislation required a two third majority in each of the three
houses and was passed by the bishops and clergy, but defeated by a
margin of six votes in the laity.
The Archbishop defended the “high level of consent” required to bring
in significant change to the Church, but said there would be questions
asked about a “holding hostage of Synod” by minority groups.
Senior Church figures are to meet in the coming weeks to discuss the
fallout from the vote and how to meet the “urgent demand for close,
properly mediated conversation”.
Bishops will be out and about in their dioceses to gauge reactions
and some have already suggested that the scheduled February meeting of
the General Synod be postponed until July because of the strength of
feeling over the issue.
“Bishops feel that a full Synod in February is a little close for
comfort given all the consequences we have to explore,” Dr Williams
said.
He appeared to be open to the suggestion of a delay, but added that
the process towards allowing women bishops should not lose momentum.
“It would be tempting to conclude that it is too difficult and that the
issue should be parked. I don’t believe that is possible because of the
sense of our credibility in wider society,” he said. “Every day in which we fail to resolve this is a day where our
credibility in the public eye is likely to be diminished and we have to
take that seriously.”
He added: “There is a matter of mission here and we can’t afford to
hang about. We can’t indefinitely go on living with the anomaly of
women being priests who cannot be considered bishops.”