Sunday, November 22, 2026

Leo XIV chooses as theologian a Thomist critical of Amoris laetitia

The speeches of Leo XIV will pass from now on, before arriving at his table, through the hands of a French Dominican who has been reading St. Thomas Aquinas for more than forty years and whose published work allows to know quite precisely how he thinks. 

Serge-Thomas Bonino, 65, named this Saturday theologian of the Pontifical Household, is the author of a 2016 article that examined reference by reference the use of Aquinate in Amoris laetitia and pointed out where the exhortation fell short. He is also the secretary general that Benedict XVI elected to the International Theological Commission, the president of the academy that Leo XIII founded to promote the doctrine of St. Thomas and an advocate of the Second Vatican Council who had the position of the Society of Saint Pius X untenable. 

His file does not fit on either side that disputes the reading of the pontificate. He is not a traditionalist, although last Pentecost he preached on the pilgrimage of Chartres before the faithful of the traditional Mass. Nor is it a man of the “paradigm shift” that Francis asked for theology in a 2023 motu proprio: six days after that document an interview was published in which he demanded that theology not abandon metaphysics.

The Holy See made the appointment public this Saturday, November 21. Vatican News and ACI Stampa present Bonino as president, since 2014, of the Pontifical Academy of St. Thomas Aquinas and as professor of Philosophy and Theology in Rome, where he teaches at the Pontifical University of Santo Tomás de Aquino, the Angelicum, and recall that between 2004 and 2020 he was a member and later general secretary of the International Theological Commission. He replaces the 75-year-old Polish Dominic Wojciech Giertych, who has held the position since 2005. 

The first chronicles do not explain the relay or say what fate awaits Giertych; the Italian note of the Vatican portal does not even mention it, and it is ACI Stampa that reminds us of who Bonino is going to. They account, however, for other decisions published the same day: a new undersecretary in the Dicastery for the Clergy, several consultants in that of the Eastern Churches and the personal title of archbishop for two secretaries of dicastery, the Irish Paul Tighe, of Culture and Education, and the Spanish Aurelio García Macías, appointed secretary of the Divine Worship on October 10.

The calendar invites you to seek meaning in the gesture, even if no source relates it to anything. León XIV returned on Tuesday from twelve days of travel through Uruguay, Argentina and Peru and has on the table, without known decision, the synthesis report of the meeting that commemorated in October the ten years of Amoris laetitia. A month ago he renewed the International Theological Commission with 24 names proposed by Cardinal Víctor Manuel Fernández, four of which have held thesis in tension with documents of the Doctrine of the Faith, according to the review published by this media. 

On Monday 23 begins the first plenary session of that renewed Commission, which preserves as secretary general Piero Coda, the theologian who relieved Bonino in 2021. The appointment of this Saturday does not touch that body or the dicastery on which it depends. It affects something smaller and closer: who reads the Pope before the Pope speaks.

The office is of the oldest of the papal court. Until 1968 he was called master of the Sacred Apostolic Palace, and the Dominican tradition makes him start in Saint Dominic himself, in 1218, when the founder would have begun to explain the letters of St. Paul to the clergy of the Curia. The Catholic Encyclopedia of 1911 counted 84 successors, all friars preachers, of whom 18 came to cardinals and 10 were Spanish, and quoted among them John of Torquemada, uncle of the inquisitor, and Silvestre Prierias, the first Roman theologian who responded to Luther. 

For centuries the teacher taught theology in palace and preached before the Pope, and from Leo X no book could be printed in Rome without his license and that of the cardinal vicar; he was also a born consultant of the Holy Office. Paul VI changed his name in 1968, with the motu proprio Pontificalis Domus, who reordered the Pontifical Household, and the office was reduced to the essentials.

The essential thing is to review. Giertych explained it in February to EWTN: the Pope’s speeches are written by different people according to the subject, and the theologian examines them before they arrive at the Pontiff to detect confusing, ambiguous or needy formulations of correction; he lives in the Vatican because some texts arrive at the last minute. He is one of the few people who reside permanently in the Apostolic Palace, and a visitor told in 2010 that in his rooms hang four large paintings with the miniature portraits of about a hundred predecessors, starting with Saint Dominic. 

ACI Stampa talks about a work of consultation and doctrinal review of the Pope’s speeches. The real scope has always depended on each pontiff. Cardinal Georges Cottier, who served John Paul II and, in his first months, Benedict XVI, told Benedict shortly before retiring to the agency of the American bishops that his main task was to examine the thousands of words that others prepare for the Pope to say or publish them and detect in them doubtful theology. The theologian of the Pontifical House governs nothing and does not sign anything. Review and propose, and the last word is from the Pope.

Bonino's three immediate ancestors cover seventy years. Mario Luigi Ciappi held the position from 1955 to 1989, with five popes, and Paul VI made him a cardinal in 1977. Cottier, Swiss, was named in 1990 according to his official biography, received the purple in 2003 and retired in 2005. Giertych's been almost twenty-one. There is a precedent that the biography of Bonino repeats halfway: Cottier was secretary of the International Theological Commission since 1989 when John Paul II made him a theologian for the Pontifical Household, and he retained the two positions until 2003. And another that may matter: Ciappi presided since 1979 the Pontifical Academy of St. Thomas, the same one that Bonino presides over today, without leaving the office. It has not been communicated whether Bonino will retain the presidency, or whether he will continue to teach.

Giertych was born in London on 27 September 1951, in a Polish exile family, younger brother of politician Maciej Giertych and uncle of Roman Giertych, and turned 75 two months ago, the age at which the resignation usually arises in the Curia. He studied history in Poznań, entered Polish Dominicans, was ordained in Krakow in 1981 and doctorated to the Angelicum, where he taught moral theology before entering the general council of the Order. Benedict XVI appointed him on December 1, 2005. Of his public interventions there are two that define the profile: in 2013 he explained to the agency of the American bishops why the Church cannot ordain women, and in 2018, in Sydney, he argued that the contraceptive mentality has distorted male sexuality and rejected that Amoris laetitia gives rise to reinterpret Humanae vitae. 

His last act known as the pope’s theologian was a paper, on October 7, at the Marian congress of the Augustinianum in which Cardinals Burke and Müller defended the title of Co-redeemer. His, according to the program, dealt with the primacy of virginal love in the maternal love of Mary, and the chronicles consulted do not attribute any reference to the title or the note of the Doctrine of the Faith that considers it inopportune. In February, EWTN presented it pending the move of Leo XIV to the Apostolic Palace, willing to receive him as a neighbor.

Bonino was born in November 1961 in L’Estaque, the fishing district and factories of northern Marseille that Cézanne and Braque painted. When Benedict XVI made him secretary general of the Theological Commission, a press semblance that reproduced the blog Le Salon Beige celebrated that the new secretary was an old “minot” of L’Estaque, the word Marseilles to say boy, and highlighted his joviality. 

He passed through the Saint-Exupéry and Thiers high schools of his city, the latter in the preparatory classes, and in June 1982 was admitted to the École normale supérieure in Paris, the house that has formed much of the French intellectual elite. In October of that same year he entered the Dominican novitiate in the province of Toulouse. There is no account of that decision or data about his family in the sources consulted.

Normalist and friar at the same time, he obtained in 1984 the maîtrise of Philosophy in Paris with a work on the spirit of worship in St. Thomas that Claude Bruaire directed, he served in the military teaching philosophy in the military lyceum of Aix-en-Provence, studied Theology in the convent of Toulouse and was ordained a priest in June 1988. Then came Fribourg. There he graduated with a memory of the prophecy in the disputed Questions of Veritate and was doctorated in February 1992 with a thesis on the science of God, the second question of the same work, under the direction of Jean-Pierre Torrell, author of the reference biography of St. Thomas. 

The thesis, translation and commentary, appeared in the publisher Cerf with a foreword by Ruedi Imbach and more than six hundred pages. In 1993 he added a doctorate in medieval philosophy from the University of Poitiers, with Pierre Magnard. From that school he has the method he has later defended: to read Thomas as a historian before using him as a theologian.

His career took place for almost a quarter of a century in Toulouse. Since 1990 he taught medieval philosophy at the Catholic Institute and Dogmatic Theology in the study of the Dominicans, directed for about two decades the Revue thomiste, which the Dominicans published since 1893, co-founded in 1995 the Institut Saint-Thomas d’Aquin and was between 2002 and 2011 regent of studies of his province, the friar responsible for the intellectual formation of the others. 

From those years are two collective volumes that he coordinated and that draw the map of his concerns: the minutes of the colloquium with which the magazine celebrated its centenary, dedicated to St. Thomas in the twentieth century, and the book on the controversy of the Surnaturel of Henri de Lubac, later translated into English. In December 1999 he entered the Pontifical Academy of St. Thomas, which John Paul II had just refounded. Between 2009 and 2012 he was also a national religious councillor of the Guides et Scouts d’Europe, and on October 20, 2012 he received, with three other Dominicans from his province, the title of teacher in Sacred Theology, the highest degree granted by the Order. The province of Toulouse is, among the Dominican French, which has maintained the Tomist tradition of the Revue thomiste, that of Marie-Michel Labourdette and Marie-Joseph Nicolas.

What he understands by being a Thomist left it in a short text from 2003, translated into English in 2010. To be a Thomist is not to have read Thomas, which anyone can do, but to take it as a teacher, and that choice is an act of prudence and confidence, not the conclusion of a syllogism: human intelligence learns from others and within a tradition. From there come two symmetrical rejections. 

It rejects the Thomism that preserves from the saint a vague spirit and disregards its doctrine, and rejects the one who treats the work as a timeless and immutable system, guaranteed by authority and alien to human fallibility. Between both he places the work of the historian, which allows to distinguish in Thomas the principles of the conclusions tied to his time, such as the physics of Aristotle, and the task of integrating truths born in other traditions whenever they marry with those principles. For this integration, which is not concordism or eclecticism, it is based on Labourdette. Catholics are reminded of one more argument: the repeated recommendation of the Church weighs on choosing teacher.

John Paul II appointed him a member of the International Theological Commission in 2004, when he presided over it, as the prefect of the Doctrine of the Faith, Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger. It was responsible for presiding over the subcommittee that drafted the document on the natural law, adopted unanimously in December 2008 and published in 2009. His presentation of that text explains the purpose. 

The natural law had been discredited after Humanae vitae, branded as a physicist and an enemy of personal autonomy, and it had to be rescued from both the caricatures of the manuals and a rationalist and secularized Isnaturalism. He argues there that human rights need an absolute foundation that legal positivism cannot give them, that civil law contrary to natural law does not bind in conscience, which justifies objection, and that democracy requires stable values and not the back and off of the majorities. He also warns against the theory of basic human goods of Germain Grisez and John Finnis, for the risk of denying nature all moral relevance. 

The last chapter of the document is titled Jesus Christ, fulfilling the natural law, and the presentation of Bonino summarizes it this way: the Church distinguishes the reason of faith without separating them, and the natural law receives its full meaning in Christ and is transfigured by the new law of charity.

The document had a replica in Spain since traditionalism. The Argentine Juan Fernando Segovia published in 2011 in the Madrid magazine Verbo a critical examination of more than thirty pages in which he pointed to Bonino as one of the main editors and reproached the document for mixing tomism with personalism, reducing the common good to the good of the person, bringing natural law closer to the language of human rights and leaving it, in short, separate from the divine law and the social reign of Christ. The controversy serves to place the character. Her tomism is not that of the traditionalist Hispanic school, and those who have read it from her have known it for fifteen years.

Benedict XVI appointed him secretary general of the Commission on December 17, 2011, replacing the also Dominican Charles Morerod, who had just been made bishop of Lausanne, Geneva and Freiburg, and incorporated him as a consultant to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. He continued to live in Toulouse until 2014. The first document he had to present was 2012’s Theology, the result of seven years of work, which he summarized as a reminder of the “genetic code of Catholic theology.” The starting diagnosis was twofold: inwards, disciplines increasingly far away from each other and a pluralism that threatened to make theologies immeasurable; outward, a theology that has lost the monopoly of the religious and is cornered in the university. 

As an example of what happens when the method fails, he cited the 1984 instruction on liberation theology, which denounced the uncritical use of concepts taken from Marxism. His reading underlines four things: that theology can only be scientific because it is a believer, that dissent in front of the Magisterium has no place in it even though theology is not a mere record of what it teaches, that legitimate pluralism cannot degenerate into theologies incommunicado with each other and that prayer is part of the office. “The spiritual implication of the theologian is not an option,” he wrote.

In 2014 the Commission published two more documents, and again he explained them. The first responded to the thesis that monotheism breeds violence, and Bonino titled his reading with a resounding formula, the heresy of violence in the name of God. He argued then, in an interview with the weekly newspaper of the diocese of Paris, that the root of intolerance is not to affirm a truth but in relativism, because where there is no truth or criteria to discuss it each one imposes his own. 

The second was about the sensus fidei, the instinct of faith of the baptized that Francis was going to make a foundation of synodality. His explanation sets a limit that should be remembered: the meaning of the faith is not the majority opinion of Catholics, it is manifested above all in those who live the faith thoroughly, with prayer, life of the Church and reading of Scripture, and it is up to the Pope and the bishops to determine what belongs to the apostolic faith. He added, on the other side, that there was no strict separation between the teaching Church and the discent Church and that that principle had not always been applied well. He attributed to Newman, in the nineteenth century, and Vatican II the merit of having restored value to the consultation of the faithful. One of his comments is titled a pleasant image to Francis, Il fiuto delle pecore, the smell of the sheep.

Francis confirmed it in the secretariat in September 2014, when the Commission was renewed, and on November 6 of that year he put him in charge of the Pontifical Academy of St. Thomas Aquinas, which Leo XIII had founded in 1879 in the heat of the encyclical Aeterni Patris. A Spanish priest, the priest of Barcelona, Lluís Clavell, of Opus Dei, professor of Metaphysics at the University of the Holy Cross, succeeded in the presidency. 

The Academy, based in the Casina Pio IV, gathers its members each year in plenary session and publishes the minutes with the title Doctor Communis. That same year he moved to Rome, to the Angelicum, as an ordinary professor of the Faculty of Philosophy and commissioned in the Faculty of Theology, and was dean of Philosophy for almost a decade; he was succeeded by the American Dominic Holtz. The courses he has announced for this academic year say quite a bit about his interests: the divine names according to St. Thomas, the question of the existence of God, providence and divine government, the history of medieval philosophy.

Under its secretariat, with Cardinals Müller and Ladaria successively in the presidency, the Commission published The Synodality in Life and Mission of the Church, in 2018, Religious Freedom for the Good of All, in 2019, and The Reciprocity between Faith and Sacraments in the Sacramental Economy, in 2020. 

The secretary general coordinates the work; the presentation of the last two occupied two Spaniards, Javier Prades and Gabino Uríbarri. Of the latter, Bonino also left an explanation of his own, published in L’Osservatore Romano in March 2020, about the marriage between baptized non-believers. The thesis that he exposes dismisses two extremes, the automatism that has by sacrament every marriage between baptized whatever their faith and the rigorism that would require the bride and groom an elite faith, and affirms that the total absence of personal faith renders doubtful the validity of the sacrament to the extent that it compromises the minimum intention of contracting a natural, indissoluble, faithful and open marriage to life. There is no, write, a measure of faith, and discernment corresponds to the pastor. The question fully touches on the practice of ecclesiastical courts.

The text that will be read with more attention today is 2016. Six months after the publication of Amoris laetitia, The Thomist magazine of the Dominican Americans published in its October issue a twenty-page article of its, translated from French, about the presence of St. Thomas in the exhortation. Its author, who signed as a professor at the Angelicum, was then secretary general of the International Theological Commission. It begins with a warning of method that is almost a self-portrait: the Thomist who reads a papal text is exposed to three temptations, judge him alone as a historian and reproach him for inaccuracies, to stand as judge of the Pope by measuring his conformity with the Aquinate, or to fall into what he calls ecclesiastical sociology, which consists of counting points and measuring by the quotations how much authority Thomas retains. 

To the latter he adds a political reverse: that of those who, without greater interest in Tomism, invoke its name to give a traditional appearance to the novelties and avoid the reproach of rupture. Made the caveat, count. It finds eighteen explicit references, eleven quotations and seven remissions, concentrated in twelve of the 325 paragraphs; thirteen are in the fourth chapter, on love, and five in the eighth, that of discernment of situations called irregular. Fifteen come from the Theological Sum and the rest of the Suma against Gentiles, from the commentary to Ethics to Nicomachus and from the issues of evil.

From the fourth chapter he values the recovery of the Thomist psychology of passions and love. The analysis stops in the eighth. Bonino distinguishes in paragraph 301 two cases. The first is that of those who do not understand the value of the norm by ignorance or by the pressure of a culture that distorts judgment: to take into account those mitigating in pastoral discernment is, he says, “entirely legitimate” in strict Tomism, because there are circumstances that diminish the voluntary character of the act and, with it, responsibility. 

The second is that of those who know the norm and are in a situation that would seem to leave it no way out than a lesser evil. There the Dominican brakes. That case does not limit the ability to decide, but the available options, and resembles what Thomas calls perplexity. And Thomas, remember with the comment to the Sentences, does not admit that anyone is really caught up in a dead-end dilemma: when it seems so it is because there is a sin before that can and should be given up. The reasoning of the exhortation, he adds with caution, seems to assume that the divorced and remarried cannot live the continence in a humanly balanced way even with grace.

The second objection concerns paragraph 304, which quotes the Suma, in question 94 of the Secundae Prima, to recall that the general rules fail more the more the more they descend to the particular. The quotation is correct, concede, but incomplete. The distinction, which is Thomas, between the positive precepts, which command to do something and do not obligate in all circumstances, and the negatives, which always and without exception forbid and bind, are missing. 

On that distinction, he recalls quoting his numbers 52 and 67, rests Veritatis splendor’s teaching on intrinsically evil acts. He further notes that the observation of note 348 on particular knowledge does not give advantage to the exception to the rule, and that it is curious that the exhortation does not refer to the epichey, the virtue that allows it to depart from the letter of a law; it specifies that the epiqueia always operates within a higher law and that the first principles of natural law do not admit dispensation. The article does not speak of communion, or of note 351, nor of the dubia that four cardinals had presented in September of that year and that were made public in November. 

He leaves aside the discussion about whether or not the exhortation is tomist and concludes that he rightly draws attention to the teachings of the saint who deserve more weight: his anthropological realism, his analysis of passions and love and his way of articulating the norm, the concrete and the subjective factors. Three years later, the French version appeared in the minutes that the Academy, already under his presidency, dedicated to St. Thomas, marriage and family.

There is a later scene that the appointment returns to the present. On September 22, 2022, Francis received the participants in the 11th International Tomist Congress, promoted by the Academy and held at the Angelicum. He delivered Bonino the prepared speech and spoke without papers. He said that with Thomism what happened to the school founders, that the teacher was used to say what one thinks; that the Thom had been a slave to casuistic thought, and that that interpretation dwarfs the master’s thought or makes it ridiculous. He cited as an example the Spanish Losada, who to explain the metaphysical continuum invented the Punta inflata.

To Thomas, he added, it must be contemplated before explaining it and, very cautiously, interpreting it. And he told an episode of the Synod on the Family: when there were unclear points about the doctrine and about certain interpretations of St. Thomas, Cardinal Schönborn, Dominican, gave his judgment a lesson in the theory of high height, because he explained to Thomas without using it. “Never use the teacher for the things I think of,” he summarized. The speech he did not read presented Thomas first and foremost as a tireless saint and seeker of the face of God, he asked for a living and not museum tomism, with a double movement of historical study of the work and dialogue with the current world, and highlighted his doctrine of creation with a quote from Chesterton. 

No source says the Pope thought of the 2016 article. The president of the Academy, who had just received the speech from the Pope, had written six years earlier about those who invoke the name of Thomas to give traditional appearance to novelties.

By then he was no longer secretary of the Theological Commission. On September 29, 2021, Francis appointed Piero Coda, a priest linked to the Focolare Movement and professor at the Sophia University Institute in Loppiano. Bonino had completed three five-year periods in the Commission, and the resume now closed that stage in 2020. It was not a dismissal: the statutes set five years and he had been in the body for seventeen years. 

But the relay changed the tone. Coda declared in July 2023 to L’Osservatore Romano that “there is no reform of the Church without reform of theology”, defended that theology departs from human experience rather than metaphysics, although he warned that it is necessary to recover the ontological foundation of the faith, proposed to rethink the original sin and the relationship between grace and freedom, and argued that theology is done synodally. 

On November 1 of that year Francis signed the motu proprio Ad theologiam promovendam, which calls for theology a turn of method, inductive and contextual, and warns that it is not enough to propose in abstract formulas and schemes of the past.

Six days later, on November 7, La Nuova Bussola Quotidiana published an interview with Bonino about his book on creation. He does not mention the motu proprio or Francis. It says something else. He warns against theologians who dispense with metaphysics and reduce the search for God to historical and cultural experience; argues that the idea of a perfect and almighty God, lord of the cosmos and history, is not a thesis of school, but biblical and Christian; rejects the theses that, in order to discharge God from the responsibility of evil, deny that it is the origin of everything, and affirms that the first article of the Creed is the most answered of the last decades. He said in passing that a document of the Theological Commission on God was left unpublished because its members failed to agree. 

And he applies the argument to ecology: it recognizes the merit of remembering that man and nature have the same origin in God, criticism when it functions as a substitution religion made of external behaviors and points out the incoherence of the green parties that defend abortion and contraception. With Benedict XVI remembers that human nature is also part of God’s design.

That book, Dieu, Alpha et Oméga, of 2022, is the second volume of a course of theology in the ancient way, the commentary followed by the Sum. The first, Dieu, “Celui qui est”, appeared in 2016 and is dedicated to the treatise of God one. The second devotes almost eight hundred pages to creation, providence, and evil. David Torrijos Castrillejo, professor at the San Dámaso Ecclesiastical University of Madrid, in the magazine De Medio Aevo, of the Complutense, reviewed it in 2024. 

The review places Bonino in the line of traditional Dominican Tomism, in continuity with Réginald Garrigou-Lagrange: he argues that creation and conservation are really identical and that God works in the operation of the creature without annulling its freedom, and resists accepting the “breakable motion” with which Jacques Maritain wanted to explain sin. It also contains a chapter on evolution, which explores the resources of Tomism to integrate biological theory. 

In the 2023 interview he explained why it seems urgent: many young people who study Darwin have a hard time reconciling evolution with the Christian vision, and that difficulty can become an obstacle to faith if they are not given intellectual instruments. The Spanish reviewer ends up wishing for a translation. This medium has not located any book of Bonino translated into Spanish.

Among his books there is one of less frequent subject, Les anges et les démons, fourteen theology lessons published in 2007 and translated into English by the editorial of the Catholic University of America; the commercial tokens of that edition present it as the most complete book on the subject since the Council. It systematically exposes the Christian doctrine of angels and demons according to the principles of St. Thomas, from the constitution of the angel to the sin of Satan, and part of a pastoral realization: the belief in intermediate spirits, so widespread in contemporary spirituality, needs to be evangelized. 

He has also published a history of medieval Latin philosophy, a study of Saint Thomas reader of the Song of Songs, a volume of Études thomasiennes, two books of spirituality entitled with words of the letter to the Galatians and, in 2024, a brief one about the will of God, how to discern it and how to conform to it. The American Catholic Philosophical Association granted him his Aquinas Medal in 2024, and France made him a knight of the National Order of Merit by decree of November 2023. Much of his recent activity has had an American public: the medal was presented at the association’s annual meeting in Chicago, in 2023 he spoke at the Dominicans’ house of studies in Washington and the University of Notre Dame has told it among his lecturers.

On the Second Vatican Council his position is that of continuity, and he held it before Benedict XVI gave him name in the speech to the Curia of 2005. In September 2003 the magazine La Nef published a debate with priest Claude Barthe. According to the version circulating of that text, Bonino defended the Council there and placed the problem in his interpretation; he asked to read it in the light of Tradition, as recommended by Cardinal Ratzinger, and to understand his novelties as a homogeneous development; he saw in the liturgical reform of Paul VI benefits, such as the greater place of the Word of God, and limits that the competent authority can correct, and greeted the interest of the new generations of clergy. 

In May 2009 he directed at the Catholic Institute of Toulouse a colloquium of the Revue thomiste entitled Vatican II, rupture or continuity, whose stated object was to study how the Thomist tradition can contribute to a reception of the Council as an act of living Tradition. Years later he summarized history in a chapter published by Oxford University Press: the Council left in a bad place a certain Tomism, whose categories it hardly uses, and yet Tomism has revived, by the institutions that teach it, by historical research, by the interest of theologians and by their usefulness in thinking the relationship between faith and reason.

The Society of St. Pius X knows this position well because it has fought it. The priest Jean-Michel Gleize, professor of the seminary of Écône, wrote in the Courrier de Rome that the colloquium of Toulouse was born vitiated by the notion of living Tradition, which judged evolutionist and relativist, and noted that, apparently, the organizers themselves had regretted the absence of the Fraternity. Two publications from that environment have also collected a Bonino trial appeared in the 2002 Revue thomiste, in a review of the biography of Monsignor Lefebvre written by Bernard Tissier de Mallerais. 

It is quoted by Gleize himself, in 2011, and Le Sel de la terre, the magazine of the Dominicans of Avrillé, who dedicated a reply to him: the position of Lefebvre and his own is “intenable”, untenable, because whoever judges the Magisterium in the name of Tradition ends up trusting himself with an individual conscience that is given for sure of the rupture, and because that rupture, if it were certain, would lead to the doubt The two appointments come from the stakeholder and the original has not been consulted. They have another weight today. Since the episcopal consecrations of Écône on July 1, the Fraternity is one of the open records of the pontificate, and the man who will review the texts of the Pope has written for twenty-four years, if the quotations are faithful, what he thinks of the underlying argument.

With the faithful of the traditional liturgy living in communion with Rome the treatment has been another, and the most recent figure is six months old. On May 24, Pentecost Sunday, Bonino preached the homily of the Central Mass of the pilgrimage from Paris to Chartres organized by the association Notre-Dame de Chrétienteté, the great annual appointment of Catholics linked to the traditional rite. It was in the meadow of Les Courlis, near Rambouillet, in the second of the three days of marching. Tanzanian priest Antonius Maria Mamsery, superior general of the Missionaries of the Holy Cross, celebrated, and CNews broadcast the Mass live for the third consecutive year. The 44th edition gathered about twenty thousand pilgrims, according to the organizers, and ended Monday in the cathedral with a pontifical Mass of Cardinal Raymond Burke. 

A year earlier, in that same place, Bishop Athanasius Schneider had celebrated and preached. The homily, which the association has published, does not mention the rite, the Council or the Pope. It is ordered in five acts, the creation, the annunciation, Pentecost, the Mass and the present of the pilgrims, and it follows in all the same Spirit: the one who looms over the chaos of the origin, the one who covers Mary, the one who forms the Church and the one who works in consecration. He's got preacher humor. He resorts to Chernobyl and Fukushima to ponder what a Mass radiates, prevents those who assist her from the danger they are in, which is to end up looking like Christ, and attributes to them a “vocation of arsonists,” because the fire of the Spirit must pass from them to their family and to the whole society. It was not his first deal with the association: the training video series of Notre-Dame de Chrétienté includes four interviews with him about the angels, undated, who present him as secretary general of the International Theological Commission, the position he left in 2021. This pilgrimage is not that of the Society of Saint Pius X, which that same weekend organizes his own in the opposite sense, from Chartres to Paris, and whose Pentecost Mass celebrated this year Bishop Bernard Fellay. 

The traditionalist blog Rorate Caeli recalled the homily within hours of the appointment and presented it as proof of the proximity of the new theologian to the pilgrims of Chartres. What is proven is shorter: Bonino accepted that pulpit and spoke from him of the Mass and the mission.

On Leo XIV this medium has only located a text, prior to the appointment in a year and a half. In June 2025, a month after the conclave, La Nef published an article about the name chosen by the new pope. It begins with a caution: Francis’ supporters look for signs of continuity in Leon’s first gestures, who lived badly that pontificate see a return to normalcy, and both read what they want. Then read the name. Leon probably refers to St. Leo the Great, defender of the Christology of Chalcedon, and the Christological tone of the Pope’s early speeches confirms that affinity. He refers mainly to Leo XIII, and Bonino asks that it not be cut. Leo XIII was not just the Pope of the social question. He was the architect of a project: accepted the end of the Christendom of the Old Regime, he sought a new way of presence of the Church in modern societies based on natural reason and natural law, and that is why he restored with Aeterni Patris the Christian philosophy according to St. Thomas twelve years before writing about the workers. The moral and social disorders that Rerum novarum denounces have intellectual roots. 19th-century Catholic thought, he recalls, had become eclectic, made of loans of Cartessianism, ontologism, traditionalism and spiritualism, and Aeterni Patris opposed a Christian philosophy rooted in Scripture, in the Fathers and in Thomas. “No choice between Rerum novarum and Aeterni Patris,” he writes.

Hence he draws a wish, which he formulates between interrogations: that the evangelization of intelligence is again a priority. It proposes concrete tasks: to evaluate contemporary cultures in the light of their philosophical principles, to form the clergy in a common philosophical and theological heritage and to overcome the drift of legitimate pluralism towards the fragmentation of theologies in an archipelago. It closes by wondering if all this will not be just a good wish. What Leo XIV has then said to theologians does not deny or consecrate it. In September 2025, before a symposium of the Pontifical Academy of Theology, he pointed out the motu proprio of Francis as a compass of that institution, he asked for a wisdom theology, in contact with the people, capable of responding to digital challenges, and evoked Rosmini, who saw in it a form of intellectual charity. 

On November 26, 2025, he received the International Theological Commission and asked him to join the study to prayer, in the manner of Augustine, Buenaventura, Thomas Aquinas, Teresa of Lisieux and Newman; let himself be enriched by the experience of the local Churches; dialogue with the other sciences, as Veritatis gaudium wants, and discern new things with creative fidelity. He also quoted Benedict XVI, in Caritas in veritate, to warn against the excessive sectorization of knowledge and against human sciences closed to metaphysics. At that point the warning coincides with that of Bonino in 2023.

The personal bond between the two, if any, is not the case. León XIV is a former student of the Angelicum, where he graduated and received a doctorate in Canon Law in the 1980s; Bonino arrived at the university in 2014. The rector, the American Dominican Thomas Joseph White, has been received by the Pope in a private audience, according to the university itself, which has celebrated the continuity of another of its professors, Simon Gaine, in the Theological Commission. At the general audience on January 28, the day of his liturgical memory, the Augustinian Pope recalled St. Thomas, in greetings to the pilgrims, as a wise commentator on Scripture.

There are silences that are also part of the portrait. This media has not located any public pronouncement of Bonino on Fiducia supplicans, on Traditionis custodes, on the female diaconate, on the Marian note of Doctrine of the Faith or on the death penalty. On the traditional Mass there is a gesture, the homily of Chartres, and no position; in liturgical matters only the judgment of 2003 on the benefits and limits of the reform of Paul VI has been found. His signature is not recorded in any of the manifestos and corrections that circulated during the pontificate of Francis, of which he was a collaborator until 2021 and under which he continued to preside over the Academy. His way of disagreeing, when he did, was that of the 2016 article: a specialized magazine, twenty pages, footnotes and no allusion to the controversy of the day. The absence of findings does not prove that he has not spoken. It indicates, at the very least, that he has not done so out loud.

With this data, what can be claimed of the appointment is limited. There is continuity on the outside: one Dominican succeeds another, as commanded by a custom of eight centuries, and one Thomist and professor of the Angelicum to another. It changes the generation, ten years younger, and changes the specialty: Giertych is moralistic and Bonino is a theologian of God, of creation and of providence, as well as a historian of medieval philosophy. Change the trail too. 

From the new theologian it is known what he thinks of the use of St. Thomas to support exceptions to the negative precepts, of the theology that is disregarded by metaphysics, of the fragmentation of schools and of the sense of faith understood as the opinion of majorities. What cannot be claimed is that Leo XIV chose it for that, or against anyone. The same Pope signed a month ago the list of the Theological Commission, and Francis, who relieved it in 2021, had confirmed it in 2014 and had entrusted him with the presidency of the Academy that year.

There are questions left without a public answer. Why now, and if Giertych submitted the resignation by turning 75. What will become of the Polish Dominican. If Bonino will retain the presidency of the Academy of St. Thomas and his classes. If the Pope knew him. At the close of this information this media had not located statements from Bonino, Angelicum or the province of Toulouse. 

The first tests of the office will come soon and will not be signed: the texts that Leo XIV pronounces in the coming weeks, including those of the five Roman parishes that he plans to visit between the end of November and December 20, the Christmas speech to the Curia, what the Pope decides to say, if he decides to say anything, about the report of Amoris laetitia that he expects at his table. 

In none of these texts will it be recorded which line the theologian crossed out or which one he proposed.