The apostolic nuncio said Speyer must suspend the reorganisation process until the appointment of a new bishop, as under canon law its administrator cannot make decisions that would bind the next ordinary.
Catholics in the Diocese of Speyer said they are “disappointed” by the suspension of its pastoral restructuring plan by the apostolic nuncio to Germany.
The programme, titled “You shall be a blessing”, began two years ago led by Bishop Karl-Heinz Wiesemann, intending to reduce the number of parishes in the diocese from 70 to just nine.
The new parishes, roughly mapped on existing deaneries, were to be led by leadership teams of a parish priest, a pastoral assistant and the head of the parish office. They would work together with a parish synodal council.
Fr Markus Magin was appointed diocesan administrator following Wiesemann’s unexpected retirement aged 66 on 19 August this year.
In a letter to the diocese, the nuncio Archbishop Hubertus van Megen said the diocese must suspend the reorganisation process during the vacancy.
Continuing with the project would “raise expectations, put changes in process and lay foundations for personal obligations” which would significantly limit the new bishop’s freedom to decide, he said.
Under canon law, an administrator has the same rights as a diocesan bishop but is not permitted to make decisions that would bind the next bishop or restrict him in exercising his office.
The diocese had decided to continue with the reform process and Magin had called a “more informal meeting” of the former diocesan assembly, which had also lost its mandate with the vacancy, on 31 October.
Isabelle Faul, chair of the assembly, said: “The seat on the bishop’s chair is empty, but our common conference table remains occupied.”
An incoming bishop would now face the additional burden of having to rebuild trust that had been lost by Rome’s intervention, sources in the diocese said.
Magin said the decision would be “respected and implemented” but said he was “disappointed”.
Concerned that this could throw back the reordering of parish structures by years, he said it was tragic that Rome was putting the brakes on the process towards a more synodal church begun two years ago.
The “complete halting” ordered by Rome did not adequately take into account the decisions that had already been made and indeed “disrupts the continuity of diocesan life”.
Bishop Wiesemann had said before his retirement that this specific synodal way should be taken forward. Magin clarified that “substantial and legally binding decisions” would “remain the prerogative of the new bishop”.
The lay Catholic Council in Speyer wrote a letter to the nuncio saying they cannot accept either the decision or the style in which it was made, without any synodal participation or consultation.
His decision is “nothing but the reversal of the explicit decision of our former bishop. This is incomprehensible to us,” they said.
