The Church of England’s slavery reparations plan has been described as promoting a form of “segregation” in Africa.
The compensation plan, titled “Project Spire” was devised to divert £100m to atone for the Church’s financial ties to the slave trade.
A string of recommendations submitted by the project’s oversight committee in 2024 suggested that goals of the funding ranged from investing money in black-owned businesses “ideally in perpetuity”, to giving black people access to “real estate” to address “historical wounds”.
But plans to offer reparations have been criticised by the clergy in Malawi, which suffered from the Arab-led slave trade and was liberated by the expansion of Christianity.
Speaking to the Telegraph in Lilongwe, the Rt Rev Fanuel Magangani, an Anglican bishop, warned: “We don’t have another word for this but segregation.”
He claimed that the Church has been swayed by the “politics of the day” into creating the conditions for “racial division”.
“If the Church’s promoting segregation, what is it trying to do? It is trying to bring division into the body of Christ.”
Until the British made Malawi a protectorate in 1891, it was ravaged by Arab-Swahili slave traders who transported Africans to the Muslim world.
Bishop Magangani said that, in Malawi, “we take the British not as the predators, but as the protectors”.
In place of a slavery reparations plan, Bishop Magangani, who leads the Northern Malawi diocese, has suggested a fund – open to applicants of all backgrounds – specifically to help the Church grow around the world.
In a set of “hopes” for the future, Project Spire documentation includes the aim to “address whiteness” and tackle “white privilege”.
The 2024 recommendations suggest that funding could reach up to £1bn, although the project is still under consultation.
The consultation for the reparations plan was conducted in Jamaica, Barbados, Ghana and England, and there are plans to promote access to funding in the Caribbean, UK and West Africa.
The Church began researching its ties to slavery in 2019, specifically financial endowments known as “Queen Anne’s Bounty”.
The monarch established this fund in 1704 to support clergymen in buying land from which they could generate income.
Concerns were raised that money from the fund, now worth around £9.2bn, was invested in annuities linked to the South Sea Company, which transported thousands of slaves from Africa to South America.
Some historians have questioned Church concerns, arguing that these annuities were government debt instruments, not direct investments in slave-trading activities.
The idea that Britain should offer collective atonement through reparations has also been repudiated by a former Archbishop of Canterbury, Justin Welby, who oversaw the launch of Project Spire amid a broader movement of historical reckoning following Black Lives Matter protests in 2020.
The Church of England has been approached for comment.
