1,204 complaints were made to the ASA about the advert that was run by The Christian Party in 2009, ranking it fourth in the Authority's history.
A rival campaign by the British Humanist Association generated only 391 complaints.
A British Safety Council advert for condoms, which used an image of Pope John Paul II, was fifth with 1,192.
A 2012 advert for pregnancy and abortion advisory clinic Marie Stopes International came sixth with 1, 088 complaints.