I am a clergyman in charge of a growing Anglo-Catholic parish church in Winchester. I love my job, I love my parish, I love the Church of England.
When Christ tells us that we are to love our neighbours as ourselves, this does not mean telling our neighbours everything they want to hear or doing everything they would like done.
So it is with the Church Commissioners of the Church of England.
Sometimes hard truths have to be faced, hard words have to be spoken and hard things have to be done. This is the unfortunate case with the Project Spire legal challenge.
The bare facts are these: the Church Commissioners are responsible for administering a fund of roughly £11.6 billion. They are planning to use £100 million of this money on an initiative called Project Spire.
Project Spire essentially constitutes that £100 million being used for slavery reparations.
The Commissioners are not fond of the word “reparations” so they use the words “healing, justice and repair”.
But the fact is that the justification that they are using for Project Spire concerns historical claims that the predecessor fund to the current fund, Queen Anne’s Bounty, was invested in shares in the South Sea Company which dealt in slaves and received money from individuals linked to the slave trade.
The claim is that, since some of the money is derived from slavery, it should be paid to communities affected by historic enslavement. The intention is to invest this money in businesses and social projects in black communities.
I would characterise my objections to Project Spire by saying that I believe it to be legally, historically and morally dubious.
Firstly, on the matter of legality. The Charity Commission states that the Church Commissioners’ charitable activities are as follows:
Promoting the mission and ministry of the Church of England especially by supporting poorer dioceses with ministry costs, providing funds to support mission activities, paying for bishops’ ministry and some cathedral costs, administering the legal framework for pastoral reorganisation and closed church buildings, paying clergy pensions for service prior to 1998 and running the clergy payroll.
Without getting into the legal weeds, the Church Commissioners are purporting to set up a new fund into which the £100 million will be placed because they know that Project Spire does not fit with their charitable purposes. They are using Section 106 of the Charities Act 2011 which they say justifies this move legally.
But Section 106 exists to give a charity legal authorisation to move funds if there is a moral obligation to do so. For example, if a will fails to reflect a deceased person’s intentions and money was paid to a charity as a result then Section 106 may apply. We believe that the proposed payment fails the applicable legal test in this instance because there is no moral obligation for the funds to be used in this way.
In addition, from a layman’s perspective on matters of law, the Church Commissioners are seeking special authorisation because the proposed transfer falls outside their ordinary spending powers. They are aware that this is the case.
Why do they not simply focus on what they are supposed to be using this money for?
Surely the Church of England’s use of charitable funds should be above reproach rather than of questionable legality.
Secondly, the historical argument lacks credibility. Again, I speak as a layman, but the historical justification for Project Spire makes the basic mistake of conflates the South Sea Company with South Sea Annuities, claiming that Queen Anne’s Bounty derived profit from shares in the former which was heavily linked to the slave trade.
But the fact is that Queen Anne’s Bounty was primarily invested in South Sea Annuities, which were in effect government bonds — the profits of which did not derive from the slave trade.
The Bounty acquired South Sea Company stock in 1720 and disposed of its trading shares by 1730. Those shares were sold, crucially, at a financial loss. The income from South Sea Annuities was interest on government debt and not profit from slave trading.
The Commissioners’ report also makes the claim that the fund derived partly from benefactions from people linked to slavery. But these claims are questionable also because a donor’s association with slavery does not by itself show that a particular donation came from slave-trading profits.
There are various other things that could be said about the historical argument, such as the fact that the British Empire played a leading role in the abolition of slavery and that it was in fact prominent members of the Church of England, such as William Wilberforce, who were critically influential.
And we should also note the ubiquity of slavery in pre-abolition times between people of all skin colours such that it is simply absurd to identify black people in modern western nations as uniquely disadvantaged by slavery.
The whole notion of reparations in general is incoherent in any case because, in order to be consistent, it would imply that we should go through the entire moral register of history attempting to repay everyone for every historic injustice that their ancestors faced and that may have resulted in their present-day disadvantages.
How comprehensive should we be? Should descendants of nineteenth century cotton mill workers in northern England be repaid for the less than salubrious working conditions suffered by their forebears, for example?
Should descendants of Anglo-Saxon villagers receive reparations from the scions of marauding Vikings? The whole concept descends into ludicrous farce when any kind of consistency is applied.
I am already straying into the territory of ethics. And it is here where I can speak perhaps with some existential authority. I live and breathe the atmosphere of a parish church that does not receive adequate funding to carry out fundamental parochial ministry. I am myself not paid by the Church of England for my role but only receive a house for the better performance of my duties.
Mine is one of thousands of churches the length and breadth of the country that does not receive even the baseline level of stipendiary ministry needed to facilitate thriving parishes.
Instead, what we see are ever increasingly large mergers of parishes to make benefices of multiple churches, often numbering in double figures, with a single stipendiary vicar to oversee them all, leading to decline, depression and burnout. We see churches shut and turned into flats.
We see historic vicarages sold for a quick injection of cash into diocesan bank accounts. We feel very little, if any, benefit from the Church Commissioners’ £11.6 billion fund.
That fund ought to preclude all of this by giving parishes a chance to flourish. Instead, clergy and hard-working laity labour seemingly against the system in order to keep their beloved parish churches alive.
When I was given the chance to challenge Project Spire in the courts, I hesitated. I did not want to bring obloquy upon myself or upon my parish church.
But I believe that the Church Commissioners ought to think again. They should abandon Project Spire and use this money for the purposes for which it was given in the first place: to assist parish churches in their vital ministry to the people of this nation.
