Tuesday, July 08, 2025

Redress as part of Commission of Investigation into allegations of historical sex abuse in schools could run to ‘tens of millions’

Education Minister Helen McEntee has set up a new Commission of Investigation, this time into sexual abuse in secondary schools, both lay and religious.

It follows a scoping inquiry which heard 2,395 allegations of historical sexual abuse in day and boarding schools run by religious orders, involving 884 alleged abusers in 308 schools across all areas of the country.

Ms McEntee pledged that it would not involve endless extensions and runaway costs – as reflected in recent Dáil remarks by the Taoiseach, who added that they don't often deliver closure for survivors either.

"I do believe we are learning," the Minister said, when asked about the Farrelly report into the Grace case, which is set to top a taxpayer cost of €20 million and which ran to eight years with repeated extensions – only to deliver an "unreadable" report of 2,000 pages, with no Executive Summary, as minister Norma Foley had requested.

Ms McEntee claimed that religious orders would contribute to the vital element of redress – despite the failure of religious orders to live up to their responsibilities for a quarter of a century now.

She offered no ceiling for compensation payments, or any minimums for church contributions, but said the Government would be looking to identify assets held by religious organisations.

The Minister was vague however about forcing redress, declining to refer to sequestration or seizure of assets, which the Attorney General has been asked to study by Ms Foley.

She said only that the Attorney General had been involved in drawing up the terms of reference and guidance, which sets a limit of five years for the project, with a requirement for an interim report after two years.

Mr Justice Michael McGrath will chair the commission.

Ms McEntee said she wanted to thank every single survivor for their bravery in coming forward, acknowledging the late Mark Ryan and his brother David, "who were absolutely instrumental".

The findings of the scoping inquiry were "nothing short of devastating," she said. "What is clear is that survivors want accountability.

"They deserve accountability, and that is why I am today announcing the establishment of a Commission for Investigation."

The inquiry will begin this work "in the coming months," she said, beginning with a survey of survivors that will be oriented towards their needs.

The chair will be assisted by two commissioners who will look at the handling of sex abuse claims in both religious and State schools, while engaging with survivors.

The latter taking of evidence will be "anonymised, non-adversarial and with no cross-examination," the Minister insisted, adding that it would involve a sampling approach.

The terms of reference were set out "to ensure that we do not go over time," she said, but the redress would be a "significant amount," she said.

Ms McEntee added: "We are talking in the tens of millions."