Thursday, July 04, 2024

Pope Francis' rottweiler: Cardinal Fernández charts new, uncertain course for Vatican's doctrinal office

When Pope Francis tapped Cardinal Víctor Manuel Fernández to head the Vatican's doctrinal office on July 1, 2023, he wasn't just naming his longtime Argentine theological adviser to one of the church's most powerful roles. 

He was also re-envisioning how that department would operate in the modern world and attempting to ensure that his reforms might outlast his own papacy.

Accompanying the announcement of Fernández's appointment in the Vatican's daily bulletin was a letter articulating that as prefect of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, he should actively promote the work of theology and new ways of evangelization rather than replicating past "immoral methods" that sought to control or punish theologians.

"The text of the letter that the pope wrote to the new prefect is in some ways an epoch-making event," Italian theologian Andrea Grillo told the National Catholic Reporter. "It marked the official beginning of a new understanding of the function of the dicastery, moving away from the inquisitorial and censorious styles of the past."

"This certainly influenced the way the new prefect interpreted his role," added Grillo, who teaches at Rome's Pontifical Athenaeum of St. Anselm. 

At the time of the appointment, the now deceased American theologian Richard Gaillardetz declared it to be the "most consequential curial appointment of this 10-year-old pontificate."

One very busy year later, Fernández (or "Tucho," as he is called) has not just become Francis' closest curial collaborator, he also has emerged as a gatekeeper to the 87-year-old pope — and both men seem to be operating at a pace that indicates that they are well aware that time is not on their side.

Fiducia shockwaves and synodality

Even before Fernández officially assumed his role on Sept. 14, 2023, he gave a flurry of interviews where he signaled an openness to studying gay blessings and expressing his firm opposition to abortion. (The cardinal declined NCR's interview request for this article.)

With regular social media posts and a frank conversational style during Vatican press conferences, he immediately brought a new degree of accessibility and candor to an office long known for its secrecy and limited access. 

Since arriving in Rome, he has operated at a feverish pace that has been met with equally fierce resistance. Past writings on sexuality and kissing have been called into question by his conservative detractors, and his mishandling of clergy abuse allegations during his time in Argentina have raised concerns about what this portends for the Vatican office responsible for investigating abuse complaints against minors. 

None of this has slowed him down.

"It's been a very active and complicated first year for him," Villanova University theologian Massimo Faggioli told NCR. "And the reception has been mixed."

Under his watch, the Vatican's doctrinal office has released no fewer than a dozen public documents over the last year, compared to the publication of only a handful of documents in past calendar years.   

The documents have included new rules on assessing alleged supernatural occurrences, a note clarifying that transgender individuals may serve as godparents and be baptized and a major new treatise on human dignity that condemned sex change operations, gender theory and surrogate motherhood. 

But no document has caused more debate than when in December 2023, the doctrinal office released a new declaration, Fiducia Supplicans, allowing priests to bless individuals in same-sex relationships. 

The decision sent shockwaves through parts of Eastern Europe and especially Africa, where the bishops issued a joint statement effectively rejecting the document. Later, the Coptic Orthodox Church cut off dialogue with Rome over the move, and in May, Fernández traveled to Cairo to meet with Pope Tawadros II in an effort to ease the tensions.

The release of Fiducia did not include a Vatican press conference to allow for further clarifications, which is standard practice for documents of such magnitude. Less than a month later, the cardinal issued a formal follow-up responding to the document's mixed reception. Adding to the confusion, the text caught most Vatican officials by surprise, including the pope's Council of Cardinal Advisers and members of the doctrinal office.

"If the document was not screened, it should not have been signed," said Grillo, who added that both in Fernández's documents and interviews the "relationship between [church] discipline and doctrine" has at times been vague.

Complicating things further is the fact that the release of Fiducia came in the midst of the pope's ongoing synod on synodality, where among the hot button issues that are still being discussed is the church's response to LGBTQ Catholics. One prominent cardinal charged that the timing of the document "discredited" the synod process itself. 

In March, the Vatican announced that the pope had established 10 working groups to study some of the synod's most controversial topics that will work beyond the synod's conclusion this October. Two of the groups — one on "theological and canonical questions about specific ministerial forms" and the other on "theological criteria and synodal methodologies as a basis for shared discernment of controversial doctrinal, pastoral and ethical issues" — have been entrusted to Fernández's purview.

According to Faggioli, the study groups are the pope's efforts to encourage the work of collaboration and synodality, while at the same time his own authority.

"He is letting the commissions do their work, but he is also exercising his primacy in synodality," said Faggioli. "He is effectively saying, 'This is a synod, but I am the pope and the guy that I trust is Cardinal Fernández.' "

New policy and personnel

When Francis became pope in 2013, he inherited German Cardinal Gerhard Müller as head of the Vatican's doctrinal office. The conservative theologian who Pope Benedict XVI appointed in 2012 quickly proved to be a bad fit for the new pope's more pastoral style of governance.

At the conclusion of Müller's five-year term, Francis replaced him with Spanish Jesuit Cardinal Luis Ladaria, a low-profile individual who largely kept out of the public eye until his retirement last summer. The arrival of Fernández immediately signaled a new chapter for the office, both in terms of policy and personnel.

In Faggioli's estimation, it would have been near impossible for Francis to shake things up too dramatically until after the death of Benedict XVI. As Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, he held the post for nearly a quarter century and earned a reputation as "God's Rottweiler" for his role as the enforcer of church law and the manner in which he sought to tamp down dissent among theologians.

Now, late into a very different papacy, Pope Francis' rottweiler has arrived on the scene with a very different mandate. 

"Fernández is the ​​first real successor to Joseph Ratzinger, and he's very different from him,"  Faggioli said of the Argentine cardinal's large public profile and the parallels between the trust Ratzinger and Pope John Paul II enjoyed and that bond between Francis and Fernández.

"He certainly has succeeded in becoming the cardinal to Pope Francis' right-hand," said Faggioli. 

Jesuit Fr. James Keenan, vice president of global engagement at Boston College, told NCR that Fernández has emerged as both "a public theologian and pastoral administrator."

Keenan recalled the publication of Francis' 2016 apostolic exhortation Amoris Laetitia, which among other things provided an opening to Communion for divorced and remarried couples. The document was, in part, ghostwritten by Fernández; later the pope would go on to promote the Argentine theologian's interpretation of the document as authoritative.

"It was clearly a way that the pope was showing us that the evident pastoral sensitivities of  Fernández were constitutive of his theological leadership," said Keenan. "No longer could church teachings simply be reiterated, they needed to be applied credibly such that they conveyed an understanding of the struggles of the people of God."

"Fernández does this repeatedly," he added. 

While the Vatican's doctrinal office — formerly known as "The Inquisition" — long held a reputation for enthusiastically suppressing heresies and restricting questionable theologians, Francis has used the Fernández appointment to chart a new direction for the church in the third millennium.

"I do not think that Fernández sacrifices or compromises the law of the church, but he's attentive to the hierarchy of truths and provides a pastoral hermeneutics through which he respects both the complexity of church teaching and the consciences of the faithful as they respond to the summons of Christ," said Keenan. "In this he is like the canonist theologian who knows the smell of his sheep."

Brazilian theologian Maria Clara Bingemer told NCR she believes this new direction will help "stimulate" theology so that it will be able to reflect on the theological revelations that "appear at the frontiers of life and thought."

"Theology supposes taking risks," she added, and "not being afraid of thinking."

And at 61, Fernández has shown he is energetic and willing to pioneer this new era at the Vatican in service of a reform-minded 87-year-old pope.

But, as Faggioli cautioned: "The pope's age makes his job riskier. It makes Fernández's survival after Francis a bit complicated."

Carlo Acutis and 14 Blesseds approved for canonization

Pope Francis presides at Monday's Ordinary Public Consistory of Cardinals

The College of Cardinals gathered with Pope Francis on Monday morning in the Vatican’s Apostolic Palace for an Ordinary Public Consistory.

The Pope led the Cardinals residing in Rome in praying Mid-Morning Prayer of the Liturgy of the Hours before they proceeded to review the causes of canonization of several Blesseds.

Cardinal Marcelo Semeraro, Prefect of the Dicastery for the Causes of the Saints, presented a brief report—known in Latin as the Peroratio—on the lives and miracles of the 15 people under consideration, after which the Consistory voted and approved their canonization.

Martyrs and religious examples of faith

The largest group of new Saints were martyred in Damascus, Syria, in 1860 and are known as the “Martyrs of Damascus.”

They include Fr. Manuel Ruiz López, OFM, his 7 companions, and the brothers Abdel Moati, Francis, and Raphael Massabki, three Maronite laymen.

All 11 were killed in hatred of the faith during the 1860 Syrian Civil War, which saw thousands of Christians killed in Ottoman Syria by Muslim militiamen.

According to the Peroratio, the Massabki brothers and the 8 Franciscans were murdered on the night of July 9, 1860, as they prayed inside the Franciscan church in Damascus.

Two Italians—Fr. Giuseppe Allamano and Sr. Elena Guerra—were also approved for canonization. Fr. Allamano founded the Consolata Missionaries in the early years of the 20th century. Sr. Guerra dedicated her life to the education of girls and founded the Oblates of the Holy Spirit in the late 19th century.

The Consistory approved the canonization of a Canadian-born religious, Sr. Marie-Léonie Paradis (born Virginie-Alodie Paradis), who founded the Little Sisters of the Holy Family in the early 20th century.

The names of these 14 new Saints will be inscribed in the List of Saints on Sunday, October 20, 2024.

First millennial saint

Pope Francis and the Consistory of Cardinals then voted to approve the canonization of the first Saint from Generation Y, those born between 1981 and 1996 commonly known as millennials.

Blessed Carlo Acutis will likely be proclaimed a Saint during the 2025 Jubilee, possibly along with other canonizations.

Born to Italian parents in London, England, in 1991, Blessed Carlo was a web designer who died from leukemia at the age of 15 in Monza, Italy.

He was known for his devotion to Eucharistic miracles and Marian apparitions, which he catalogued on a website he designed.

According to the Peroratio, Blessed Carlo was “welcoming and caring towards the poorest, and he helped the homeless, the needy, and immigrants with the money he saved from his weekly allowance.”

Monday, July 01, 2024

CWI : The Oratory Society (3)

In the last while, we have been carefully monitoring the development of the 'new' website of The Oratory Society, and the information contained within it is indeed questionable - to say the least.

Some questions for Eduardo and Creaner in relation to this site....

1. Why are you using the address of 6 Princes Gardens? This property is due to be reclaimed by the RC Diocese of Down and Connor by the end of August, but it seems that Eduardo is not willing to relinquish it.

2. Do you, Eduardo, think that the agreement between your allegedly celibate partner/husband, Patrick Buckley and the Diocese of Down and Connor extends to you also?

3. Do you, Paul Creaner, think likewise?

4. As we are all aware, Patrick Buckley is deceased (Deo Gratias) and yet much of the information on the website speaks of him in the present term...any particular reason why?

5. (quote) Both Bishop Pat and Fr Paul are registered officiates with The General  Registrar’s Office, N Ireland (GRO) and on the register of Register of Solemnisers for the Republic of Ireland (available to view on line). You can contact Pat and discuss your wedding arrangements with him. (unquote). This information needs to be changed, and quickly so. One would think that before publishing any website that the information on the site would be correct - why are such untruths still contained on this site?

6. As Patrick Buckley is certainly deceased, is it proper to still have pictures of him on the site? Do you not think that this is insulting to those who were so certainly wronged, maligned and slandered by him? 

7.  There is a 'blog' section on the website...are we to expect more of what went before?

Some simple questions Eduardo and Paul....maybe ye would like to address them in the public interest.

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

AODHÁN DE FAOITE

Eagarthóir / Editor

16-Year-Old Builds Rosary Business to Spread Devotion

16-Year-Old Builds Rosary Business to ...

There are many Catholic parishes, institutions, shrines and companies around the world that make rosaries.

But are any of them run by a 16-year-old?

Rings of the Lord — which crafts quality, handmade rosaries designed to last — was founded nearly four years ago by Will Henry, the oldest of Brad and Ashley Henry’s five children. 

Although a young, developing entrepreneur, Will is also an active member of his local parish, Immaculate Conception Church in Hendersonville, North Carolina, assisting as an altar server.

There, he met Steven Rademacher, a general manager of a high-end sporting goods store, who also oversaw the parish’s altar server program. The Henrys and Rademacher quickly developed a friendship when the former moved into the area from Florida nearly five years ago. A craftsman from an early age, Rademacher (now in his 30s) often constructed little items, including an “Irish Penal Rosary” — a 10-bead rosary used by Irish Catholics to covertly pray while persecuted by the English government in the 17th and 18th centuries. Brad noticed Rademacher’s rosary and asked for one, which the latter obliged.

One Sunday morning in 2021, when Rademacher delivered the rosary to the Henry house, Will saw it and immediately gravitated to the design and what it represented about Irish Catholics’ determination to keep the faith alive.

“I hand it to [Will] and he says, ‘Oh, this is so cool. You could have a business selling these,’” Rademacher told the Register. When Rademacher informed the then-12-year-old that he had no time to create a new business, he recounted, Will “paused, looked up at me and said, ‘Well, then I’ll do it.’”

For Will, the opportunity was too good to pass on. He already aspired to create his own business and had an affinity for developing websites. As he states on the Rings of the Lord page: “It was the enthusiasm I had about the rosary combined with my entrepreneurial spirit that led to starting a business, making these rosaries, and spreading the rosary’s devotion to the Blessed Mother.”

With assistance from Rademacher and his parents (both attorneys), he connected with wholesalers for supplies and filed the necessary paperwork to establish Rings of the Lord. To help build the rosaries, he enlisted his other siblings, particularly his younger brother Walker, 13, who has assisted him since its launch, creating well-made devotional aids: the rosaries consist of silver beads, plated metals and stainless steel to prevent them from breaking.

Quality Prayer Aids

“The rosary quality is important to me because I believe that we should make those things we reach to God for with great care,” the teenage businessman told the Register. “We don’t want to have to buy rosaries again and again. I think quality is so important because it shows respect to our Creator.”

Business, however, was slow going at first. For most teens, hitting such an obstacle would have deterred them from continuing the venture. But not Will. For him, Rings of the Lord was not simply a passing childlike fad — it has been an opportunity to bolster his business acumen and faith.

“The Rings of the Lord has stayed around because, for me, it’s not been as much about if it’s successful or not,” he told the Register. “I’m learning about business in a certain way and business just interests me so much.”

Still, Will wanted to spread awareness about the Irish Penal Rosary and devotion to the Blessed Mother. At first, he marketed them on Instagram, but then expanded his horizons by reaching out to the Abiding Together podcast, hosted by Sister Miriam Heidland, Michelle Benzinger and Heather Khym. The show gave Rings of the Lord a shout-out, which helped increase orders. Since then, the business has been featured on other outlets, including EWTN. Depending on the season, Will and Walker are building and shipping hundreds of Irish Penal and five-decade rosaries per week.

Mom Ashley couldn’t be prouder.

“He’s gotten a little taste of all of it,” Ashley told the Register. “This is his thing, and he keeps pushing it and driving it.”

She has had her own growth in developing a relationship with the Virgin Mary and the Rosary. Born into a Protestant household, Ashley converted to Catholicism when she married Brad. Admittedly, she “wasn’t drawn to Mary initially,” but has since consecrated herself to the Blessed Mother. To her, the Rosary is now a crucial aspect of their family life — even so far as hosting parishioners for a monthly prayer and potluck dinner.

“I’ve just continued praying the Rosary with our children,” she told the Register. “What I’m focusing on now is learning how our lives so much align with the mysteries of the Rosary. We have our sorrowful times, our joyful times, our glorious times — our lives go through the same kinds of cycles and mysteries just as Christ’s did.”

Rings of the Lord’s customers have also shared their increased devotion to the Rrosary — as well as the product’s quality. One review by “AnneMarie S.” says she feels “such a gravity when I pray with this finger rosary,” adding, “The presence of our Blessed Mother is right at hand when I use it to pray for the unborn in prayer groups.” Another customer named “Joseph L.” remarked on the rosary’s “durability,” saying in allows his children to become familiar with a rosary and explore” the prayer’s mysteries.

Saintly Inspiration

Selling rosaries, however, is only one aspect of Rings of the Lord’s mission. Convinced by his mom and inspired by soon-to-be canonized Carlo Acutis, who developed a website chronicling Eucharistic miracles, Will has begun compiling and marking on a map stories of saints — from St. Dominic, founder of the Rosary, to Pope Leo XIII — who have been intrinsic in spreading devotion to the Rosary. Still a work in progress, he hopes to add more biographies to the map, including St. John Paul II, whom he admires. As he told the Register, “If St. Pope John Paul II is praying the Rosary, that probably means I should be praying the Rosary as well, because he obviously knows something I don’t about our Lord and Savior.”

Much like the saints he admires, Ashley’s faith has served as a model for Will; likewise, his endeavor has strengthened her and her children’s devotion to the Rosary.

“Overall, this whole journey has been a blessing for our whole family, and Will is the driver behind it,” she told the Register. “He’s pulled his siblings in, and it’s part of our household discussions on what needs to happen this week. The business has been great in what Will has learned, but also our faith, our relationship with the Blessed Mother has grown through this, too.”

She added, “I just love seeing him grow spiritually and want to share the fruits and the power that can come from praying the Rosary, especially as a family.”

For Rademacher, Rings of the Lord has made the Rosary more “in front of my mind than it would have been otherwise” and built a friendship he never anticipated. He also admires Will’s willingness to “take calculated risks” over the past several years, with an attitude of not being “bound by common inhibitions or common fears.”

“I consider him a peer even though he is nearly half my age,” Rademacher told the Register. “It’s made a real friendship that, regardless of where he and I end up in the future, that friendship is always going to be there. And, quite frankly, I cannot wait to see what he does when he is out of college and out of the world. It’s going to be super interesting to watch.”

Will has remained humble throughout the journey, often crediting his parents, Rademacher and his brother Walker for their support, to whom he says Rings of the Lord would not have grown to what it is today. He also is grateful to the Blessed Mother, telling the Register that “a lot of this business is just the blessing of the Lord.”

In the end, no matter what his future holds, Will hopes to “remain close” to the Rosary, following Mary’s fiat (her “Yes” to bear Christ), as well as spreading the Gospel message to those in his generation.

“Today, what you see a lot in the world is that the emptiness of sin is just so draining of people’s joy and happiness because they’re “not living the joy that the Lord has given,” he told the Register. “It’s very important to stay close to Mary in today’s day and age. She’s the Mother of God.”

Metropolitan Daniil becomes Bulgaria's new Patriarch

Bulgaria's Orthodox Church has elected the current Metropolitan Daniil from the Danube city of Vidin as its new Patriarch. 

In a run-off vote on Sunday, 69 clergy and laity who had gathered in the capital Sofia for a national council voted in favour of the 52-year-old. 

According to local media reports, the opposing candidate, Metropolitan Grigory (53) from Vratsa, received 66 votes.

In the first round of voting, none of the nominated candidates received the necessary two-thirds majority. The two candidates with the most votes advanced to the second round. A simple majority was sufficient in this round. The election was necessary because Patriarch Neofit died on 13 March at the age of 78. He had led the church since 2013.

Daniil's election as head of the church for life is considered a surprise. Metropolitan Grigory, who was appointed provisional head by the Holy Synod in March, had been considered to have better chances. 

The new Patriarch Daniil was born on 2 March 1972. He began studying English in Sofia in 1996, but decided to study theology the following year and entered the monastery. He has been a bishop since 2008. From 2010, he gained a great deal of experience abroad as vicar to the Metropolitan of the United States of America, Canada and Australia, until he was elected Metropolitan of Vidin in north-west Bulgaria in 2018.

Ten days ago, the church's governing body, the Holy Synod, proposed three metropolitans as candidates for the patriarchal election, as stipulated in the church statute. The National Council includes all bishops as well as clergy and lay people delegated by the dioceses. Representatives of the monasteries, seminaries and theological faculties also took part in the patriarchal election.

The new patriarch will be enthroned on Sunday afternoon in the cathedral in Sofia. The honourable head of the Orthodox churches, the Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew I of Constantinople, and the Vatican's ecumenical representative, Cardinal Kurt Koch, will also take part in the ceremony.

As head of the Bulgarian Orthodox Church, Neofit had helped to heal the wounds caused by the split in the Church in the 1990s. At that time, there was a counter-patriarch. The large funeral ceremonies for Neofit showed his popularity among the population. Around two thirds of the 6.4 million Bulgarians profess Orthodox Christianity. Only just under 39,000 people voluntarily declared themselves to be Catholic in the 2021 census.

Worldwide donations for St Peter's penny increased

Worldwide donations for the Pope's charitable work have increased. 

Income from the so-called St Peter's penny totalled 52 million euros last year, according to a report published by the Vatican on Saturday. 

This was 8.5 million euros more than in 2022, bringing donations almost back to pre-coronavirus levels with income of 54 million euros.

Almost 70 per cent came from donations from dioceses and private individuals. 

At 13.6 million euros, the USA recorded the highest national donation volume, with Germany in fourth place with 1.3 million euros. 

Other donations came from foundations and religious congregations.

On the other hand, fund disbursements totalled 103 million euros, 7.5 million euros more than in 2022. 90 million euros flowed into activities of the Holy See to support "the apostolic mission of the Holy Father". 

The remaining 13 million euros went to 236 church and aid projects in 76 countries.

Presiding bishop-elect to forego installation at National Cathedral; scaled-back event to be held at church’s New York headquarters

Presiding Bishop-elect Sean Rowe and the installation planning and transition committees announced June 28 that Rowe’s installation service will take place Nov. 2 at The Episcopal Church’s headquarters in Manhattan, New York, instead of Washington National Cathedral, the seat of the presiding bishop, according to a press release by the church’s Office of Public Affairs.

Rowe will be installed during a service in The Episcopal Church Center’s Chapel of Christ the Lord. The service will be livestreamed with interpretation available in multiple languages.

“With gratitude to all involved, I have decided to begin this ministry in a new way,” Rowe said in the press release. “With a simple service at the church center that will include everyone via livestream, we can care for God’s creation by reducing our collective carbon footprint. I have great respect and admiration for the ministry of Washington National Cathedral. My seating will take place in the following months, and I am grateful to Dean [Randy] Hollerith and the cathedral staff as we plan for that event.”

The U.S. presidential election, scheduled for Nov. 5, was among many factors for the decision to change installation venues, according to the Office of Public Affairs.

The Most Rev. Henry St. George Tucker in 1938 was the first presiding bishop to be installed at Washington National Cathedral; all subsequent presiding bishops have been installed there. The cathedral officially became the seat of the presiding bishop in 1941 as a result of an action at the 1940 General Convention, held in Kansas City, Missouri, according to The Episcopal Church Archives.

The Diocese of Washington and the cathedral “wholeheartedly support” Rowe’s decision, Washington Bishop Mariann Edgar Budde said in the press release. 

“We look forward to the day of his seating at the cathedral, and we will celebrate that occasion with great joy,” she said.

Rowe now serves as bishop of the Diocese of Northwestern Pennsylvania and provisional bishop of the Diocese of Western New York. The House Bishops elected Rowe on June 26 on the first ballot to serve the church as its 28th presiding bishop, succeeding the Most Rev. Michael Curry.

Curry’s term ends on Oct. 31 and Rowe’s begins on Nov. 1. 

“God is calling The Episcopal Church into a new future, and this service will mark the beginning of that journey,” Rowe said in the press release.

Further details on the installation will be provided as they become available.

Church’s most classically Capuchin prelate reaches milestone at 80

American Catholicism marked a quiet milestone Saturday, as Cardinal Sean O’Malley of Boston turned 80 years old on the feast of Sts. Peter and Paul. 

It’s apt that his birthday coincides with the annual celebration of the great apostles of Rome, because it’s arguable that no other U.S. prelate has ever come quite as close to becoming the Bishop of Rome himself as the now-octogenarian Capuchin.

Having turned 80, O’Malley now is no longer eligible to participate in the conclave that will elect the next pope, and almost certainly off the board as a contender. Eleven years ago, however, there was a serious possibility that had the candidacy of the then-Cardinal of Buenos Aires, Jorge Mario Bergoglio, stalled, many electors might have turned to O’Malley.

According to some reconstructions, O’Malley had as many as ten votes on the first ballot in the 2013 conclave. While his name disappeared as it became two-horse race between Bergoglio and Cardinal Angelo Scola of Milan, several cardinals said after the fact that had neither of those two prevailed, O’Malley was a plausible “Plan B.”

O’Malley was certainly a crowd favorite. He was the landslide winner in an online poll sponsored by Corriere della Sera, Italy’s newspaper of record, in terms of who people wanted as the next pope – in part because of his profile as a reformer on the church’s sexual abuse scandals, but even more because with his bushy beard and brown Capuchin habit, he reminds Italians of Padre Pio, who remains one of the most ardent objects of popular devotion in the country.

To speculate about O’Malley as pope, however, is to play a game of “What might have been?” What we can say with certainty is that even without holding Catholicism’s top job, he has been among the most consequential American churchmen of the last quarter-century.

We got a reminder of the point on Friday, when O’Malley released a statement in his role as President of the Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors indirectly chiding the Vatican’s Dicastery for Communications and its chief, Italian layman Paolo Ruffini, for continuing to display artwork from accused sexual abuser Father Marko Rupnik on the dicastery’s web site.

“We must avoid sending a message that the Holy See is oblivious to the psychological distress that so many are suffering,” O’Malley wrote in his letter, which was addressed to the heads of the various Vatican departments.

The letter put an exclamation point on O’Malley’s reputation as the go-to figure in the Catholic hierarchy on the sexual abuse issue, and the primary advocate for victims and survivors at the seniormost level of the power structure.

Let’s be clear, by the way, that no one should be using the past tense quite yet with regard to O’Malley’s ecclesiastical career.

To begin with, he remains fully in charge in Boston despite having hit the usual retirement age for diocesan bishops five years ago. In some ways, O’Malley is becoming the new Cardinal Kazimierz Świątek, who remained in the saddle as the Archbishop of Minsk until the ripe old age of 91 because Pope John Paul II simply didn’t want to let him go.

For another, and despite suggestions to the contrary, it could well be that his role as president of the anti-abuse commission will not end automatically with his 80th birthday, but that he will stay on for a while longer at the request of Pope Francis.

Nonetheless, there is at least one aspect of the Sean O’Malley story which is absolutely set in cement, no matter what the future holds: To wit, that few churchmen have ever as fully incarnated the charism of their religious order the way O’Malley does the ethos of the Capuchins.

In many ways, O’Malley is to the Capuchins what the late Cardinal Carlo Maria Martini of Milan was to the Jesuits, i.e, the Prince of the Church who most perfectly reflected his order’s personality. Where Martini was a vintage Jesuit —  intellectual, aloof, visionary and forever a maverick — O’Malley has always been down-to-earth, accessible, utterly conventional in some ways, and always more comfortable with campesinos than fellow cardinals.

Since the Counter-Reformation, Capuchins have prided themselves on taking the toughest jobs the church has to offer without celebrity or complaint, and that’s O’Malley to a tee. After a stint as a bishop in the Virgin Islands — okay, admittedly, not quite hardship duty — he was assigned to three dioceses in a row suffering from the fallout of clerical abuse scandals, culminating in the ecclesiastical Chernobyl that was Boston in 2003.

The fact that O’Malley has insisted on continuing to sport his Capuchin habit whenever possible, despite his exalted status as a Prince of the Church, is a visual way of expressing a much deeper internal reality.

The core of Capuchin identity always has been closeness to the people they serve. The classic Capuchin exemplar is the character of Fra Cristoforo from Alessandro Manzoni’s novel I Promessi Sposi (“The Betrothed”), who defends the beleaguered couple of Renzo and Lucia from the malevolent Don Rodrigo, and who ends up dying in a poor Lazzoretto, meaning a quarantine zone for victims of an outbreak of the plague in Milan.

Manzoni famously defined the Capuchins as frati del popolo, “brothers of the people.” At one point in the story, Fra Cristoforo confronts Don Rodrigo over his efforts to thwart the marriage between Renzo and Lucia so he can have the girl for himself.

“I pity this house,” Fra Cristoforo says. “The curse of God is hanging over it. You will see if the justice of God can be overawed by a few bricks, or terrorized by a few hired thugs. You believe that God made a creature in his own image to give you the pleasure of tormenting her. You think that God will not defend her, and you despise his warning! You have judged yourself. The heart of Pharaoh was as hard as yours; but God knew the way to break it. Lucia is safe from you. I tell you so, poor friar as I am.”

Reading those words, one can easily hear O’Malley’s own deep baritone voice denouncing the mistreatment of the Hispanic and Haitian immigrants he served at the Centro Católico Hispano in Washington in the 1970s.

O’Malley was living in Washington in 1968 when race riots broke out following the assassination of Martin Luther King Jr., and was part of a group of friars who sheltered roughly 700 people, many elderly and Hispanic, in a local church for a week. Among other things, a baby was born in their impromptu community that week. He also took part in the “Poor People’s March” organized by Ralph Abernathy, sleeping in one of the tent cities and watching as off-duty police lobbed tear gas at the protestors.

One can also hear echoes of Fra Cristoforo in the way O’Malley has ministered to victims of clerical sexual abuse, both as a diocesan prelate and as head of the Vatican’s own anti-abuse panel.

“Poverty does not always lead to love,” O’Malley once said. “But love always leads to poverty, to the poor and God’s little ones.”

Granted, there’s legitimate criticism to be made of O’Malley’s record both as a diocesan bishop and a Vatican potentate. No one can spend as much time in power as he has over the last 30 years and not leave behind a mixed bag, containing both triumphs and occasionally egregious failures.

What no one can question, however, is that over a lifetime, Sean O’Malley has attempted to live his vocation as fully as possible, not simply as a priest or a bishop but also as a Capuchin Franciscan. Speaking as someone educated and formed by the Capuchins out on the high plains of western Kansas, I can testify from personal experience that’s no small thing.

Now, we await the rest of the story.

Christian community in Gaza now under ‘real’ risk of complete ‘disappearance’

Fr. Gabriel Romanelli — New York Encounter

THERE IS something of the Friar Tuck about Fr Gabriel Romanelli. He is a rotund and balding Argentinian who exudes infectious joy. He is blessed with an innocent sense of fun which comes, perhaps, from recognising the beauty of life and of creation in the midst of the suffering around him. He is a man who can easily make you wonder if he is perhaps one of the pure of heart whom Jesus said can “see God”.

Without doubt, he is also a man who can see suffering. As parish priest of the Church of the Holy Family, the one Catholic church in Gaza, he says he suffers deeply for Jewish Israelis massacred in the Hamas terrorist at tacks of 7 October and for the tens of thousands of Palestinians who have died in Israeli military operations since. He also suffers for his small flock, which before the war numbered 135 people out of an overall Gaza population of 2.3 million and which are now fewer because some have died and others have fled.

“We have lost 33 people and I knew every one,” he says mournfully in the same Buenos Aires dialect spoken by Pope Francis. “They were my family.”

Now, he is deeply fearful that the ancient Palestinian Christian community of Gaza might disappear altogether as the conflict continues without any end in sight. Together with the Greek Orthodox Church, there were 1,017 Christians in Gaza on the eve of the war.

When the Israel Defence Forces at tacked Hamas, many Christians took shelter in the Holy Family compound that, besides the church and presbytery, also houses a school and sports facilities, a convent of Missionaries of Charity sisters and an orphanage.

“The highest number [sheltering] was 700,” Fr Romanelli told jour nalists during a pastoral visit to London.

“Now we have about 500, mostly Greek Orthodox. We have lost by death 33 people, more than three per cent of our Christian community in Gaza.

“Twenty of them were killed, 17 inside the compound of the Greek Orthodox Church of St Por phyrius during bombing by the Israeli Defence Forces which made the wall collapse.

“Thirteen have died from lack of medicine and they include seven children and some old people. About 260 Christians have left the Gaza Strip by different ways but always via the south. We have lost 25 per cent of our Christian community.”

Three Catholics were killed by Israeli snipers, two of them in the church compound when they were on their way to a bathroom.

Fr Romanelli says that nowhere is safe in Gaza. He continues: “For 2,000 years the Christian community was there – in different ways, but always there. Now the risk of disappearance is real.

“The Patriarch and other religious leaders want us to stay because the Christians are a necessary element of Palestinian society.

“Even under risk it is a good thing for the majority of the population, and it’s also a worthy thing, a good thing, for Israeli society to be partners with Palestinian, Christian and Muslim society.

“I hope that the presence of the Church continues,” he adds. “At the same time I want the best for my brothers and sisters.

“The people who choose to go have our blessing and I also pray that in the place that they arrive in – the United States, Canada, Spain, Egypt, Jordan or wherever – they continue to preserve their Christian identity.

“Even if we are fleeing, if we lose Jesus – our faith – along the way, then we have lost the most important thing to us.”

He said he expected more Palestinian Christians to flee the territory in the weeks and months ahead.

Fr Romanelli said: “At the beginning of the war the majority of them desired to stay there to rebuild the society, but now many of them are depressed because they lost their houses and the houses of their relatives, their places of work and their jobs themselves, the schools of their children, their streets and their restaurants.

“Yet in spite of all that, still no-one knows where it will end.”

He added: “It is hard because we are a people of peace. We want peace for Israel. We want peace for Palestine. We love everyone. Our presence there is a good thing for all the region.”

The Pope, he said, is so troubled by the conflict and anxious for the safety of civilians that he “communicates every day” with the Christian community in Gaza, speaking by telephone either to Fr Romanelli or Fr Yusuf Assad, his Egyptian assistant priest.

Fr Romanelli said: “Usually, it’s a very small communication to show his closeness to the community, to pray, to manifest his work for peace between the Palestinians and Israel, to desire the ceasefire – many times he has prayed for that – to ask ‘please protect the children’, to be a strength.

“He speaks to me in dialect because he is from Buenos Aires and I am also. He gives blessings sometimes. If he calls the parish, sometimes people can say ‘hi’ and a few days ago someone presented a newborn baby to him .”

People in the West can help principally by prayer and charity and by also lowering the angry tone so that a climate of peace might supplant the atmosphere of war, the priest added.

“Pray and ask for prayers in the Holy Mass and to Our Lady,” he urges solemnly.

“Speak about this with wisdom and charity. We can make many good things with our tongues but we can also destroy a lot. This is the best step in making the situation calmer.

“Also, help through [giving to] the general appeal of the Latin Patriarch. [The aid] is effective. It arrives, and we try to help the largest number of people.”

He is most animated and at his warmest and jolliest when he reflects on the strong belief in the Resurrection that gives him the hope that the darkness of the conflict will soon pass, saying that in Gaza children are taught to adore Christ in the Eucharist as their Saviour.

The priests and the sisters, he says, “teach children to love Jesus… tell them that this is Jesus the Lord who said, ‘This is my Body’ and that if Gaza is not a hell it’s thanks to Jesus”, and that at Easter “we remembered with tears the death of Christ and the deaths of our beloved but we knew we must celebrate the Resurrection, the empty tomb”.

“We are the sons and daughters of Calvary and also we are the sons and daughters of the Resurrection,” he says with great enthusiasm as a smile breaks across his face, brightening his entire aspect.

“It’s the mystery of our faith. Not only do we fix our attention on the negative things – on the cross and the death – but also on the rising. We can bring his mystery to Gaza. Jesus is with us not as an image, but as a reality.”

New Hampshire teacher drove pregnant student to get an abortion

Education logo.png - Wikipedia

A private school teacher in New Hampshire faked an illness so she could drive a student to get an abortion without the knowledge of the student’s parents.

The student was at least 18 years old at the time and therefore under state law did not need the permission of her parents, the teacher says in a lawsuit filed this week seeking to get back her teaching license, which she says the state revoked earlier this month.

The pregnant student didn’t want to tell her parents and didn’t have a ride to the abortion facility, and the abortion could be performed only on a Friday, which was a school day, the teacher says in the complaint.

So the teacher faked food poisoning in order to leave school and drive the student to get the abortion, according to a redacted report by the New Hampshire Department of Education published by The Boston Globe.

The teacher, identified in court papers as Jane Doe, says that she did not try to persuade the student, identified in court papers as Student A, to have an abortion, which she says occurred during the fall of 2023.

“It was very important to Doe that she provided Student A with access to information and resources to make an informed decision but did not influence Student A’s decision. Doe wanted Student A to be empowered to make an informed decision about her own health care and expressed to Student A that she would do what she could to support her irrespective of her decision,” the teacher’s lawyers wrote in the complaint, filed Monday, June 24, in Merrimack County Superior Court in Concord, the state capital.

The school fired her the following week after school officials learned what happened.

The teacher says state education officials investigated and asked her to give up her teaching credentials but never held a hearing before she was informed on June 17 that her teaching credential had been revoked.

In addition, the teacher says the state’s education commissioner, Frank Edelblut, a Republican, published an article in April referring to her that she describes as misleading.

“How should the department respond,” Edelblut wrote in the article, before describing several instances of what he considered poor behavior by educators, including:  “… when, allegedly, an educator lies by calling in sick so they can take a student — without parental knowledge — to get an abortion.”

The teacher’s complaint argues that Edelblut’s article implies that she “helped a minor circumvent New Hampshire’s parental notification law,” even though, she says, Edelblut “knew that Student A was an adult months before Edelblut made the statement.”

A spokesman for the state Department of Education contacted by CNA on Friday referred questions to a spokesman for the New Hampshire attorney general’s office.

“We will review the complaint and respond as appropriate in due course. We would not comment on an open agency matter or pending litigation,” a spokesman for the attorney general’s office told CNA on Friday.

The teacher is currently working as a teacher and plans to teach this summer, according to the complaint.

The state’s education agency has scheduled a pre-hearing conference concerning her teaching credential for July 16, according to the teacher’s complaint.

The Boston Globe reported Thursday that the teacher’s teaching credentials have been restored while the case is pending.

Sunday, June 30, 2024

CWI : Operation TRUTH (6)

It is now 3 weeks today since we issued our invitation to Eduardo and indeed Creaner to meet with us here in CW - whether North or South, and regrettably, they have not taken us up on it.

One has to wonder why.

Yesterday, Saturday 29th June, 2024, one of our CW colleagues met with the 2 gentlemen who flew from America to make their own sworn affidavits to our solicitor in the North during the week, and the meeting certainly was an insight into Patrick Buckley in itself.

Both have sent emails, letters and attempted to speak by telelphone with Patrick Buckley down through the years, and indeed even as recently as Easter this year - only for Patrick Buckley to ignore them on a continuous basis. Any and all evidence of such attempts were lodged with the solicitor, and we have had sight of such also.

They are part of the group of 55 men who have made sworn affidavits, and lodged accompanying evidence, with our solictors North and South, and in doing so, want to ensure that the attempts by Eduardo and Creaner alike to present Patrick Buckley in an almost saintly fashion are countered with the truth.

Indeed, next weekend, a visit is going to be made to the Midlands by myself, another CW colleague and a specialist, to meet with those who have invited us to do so, in relation to another allegation that they wish to discuss with us.

This allegation will be joined with 2 others in the North of Ireland, namely in Antrim and Tyrone, similar in nature and seriousness, and would be deemed historical but yet relevant.

We would like to state publicly that we are of course, taking every legal step advised to us, to ensure that we do not jeopardise any potential legal action, and will continue to offer any support and outreach we can in such matters.

Also, we are also inviting those who have been in touch with us to consider whether they wish to speak with interested media outlets, which may then encourage others to come forward in relation to any possible maltreatment they may have experienced via Patrick Buckley.

We will continue to work with you all, remain available to you all, and support you all in any which way we can.

You are not alone in any of this.

Get in touch, and we will help.

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

AODHÁN DE FAOITE

Eagarthóir / Editor