A total of 1,314 ministers and pastoral workers put their names to a letter to Bridget Phillipson, the equalities minister, saying the draft Conversion Practices Bill would target “normal, responsible Christian parenting”.
Signatories included Anglican vicars and Catholic priests, as well as clergy from other denominations. They said the “grossly offensive” law would create a “speech crime” targeted at those who taught “mainstream Christian doctrine”.
The letter added: “We will not cease to fulfil our duty to God to teach his ways faithfully, even if an unjust law should make us criminals for doing so.”
Under the draft bill, which is being scrutinised by MPs and peers, people would face five years in jail for putting pressure on someone to change their sexuality or gender identity.
Although the legislation is meant to target abusive behaviour, opponents say it is poorly drafted and could mean parents being criminalised for having honest and loving conversations with their children about whether they really want to change gender.
The letter was organised by the Greater Love Declaration, a conservative Christian group that represents clergymen and other church staff from every major denomination, including the Church of England, Roman Catholics, Presbyterians, Baptists, Pentecostals and independent churches.
The group opposes same-sex marriage and blessings, and says Christians should “pursue chaste singleness outside of marriage”. It says its members are unanimously opposed to the abuse the ban is meant to outlaw, which it says is illegal under existing law.
As well as the ministers and pastoral workers, 1,539 other churchgoers and supporters have supported the letter.
The letter tells Ms Phillipson: “Responsible Christian parents and pastors will be criminalised by the draft bill, in direct violation of human rights law on family life, freedom of speech, and freedom of religion.
“We urgently request that you abandon this bill, and that you meet with us to gain a better understanding of historic Christian teaching, to avoid a disastrous legislative misstep.”
Calls for bill to be abandoned
Last week, the Anglican Church told The Telegraph the draft bill risked criminalising prayer.
A spokesman said the legislation must not “unintentionally criminalise” providing prayer and pastoral support, and that it must allow for discussion and disagreement.
The Catholic Church in England and Wales has also voiced concerns about the bill and called for it to be abandoned.
The letter signed by the church leaders said the legislation would “catch genuine, faithful, historic Christian ministry and Christian parenting in its scope”. It added: “We are dismayed and baffled by the draft bill on so-called ‘conversion practices’ currently undergoing pre-legislative scrutiny.
“None of our churches would ever condone abusive practices of the kind which advocates for this bill have implied take place in Christian churches, and which are thankfully already illegal. Nevertheless, as drafted this bill would criminalise normal, healthy Christian ministry, along with normal, responsible Christian parenting.”
Christian teachings ‘needed more than ever’
The signatories said Christianity had always taught that marriage was for a man and a woman, and had always been against sex before marriage.
The letter said: “Christianity has also understood, along with almost all people throughout history, that sex cannot be changed.
“These Christian teachings are very good and are more needed than ever in our day of vast family breakdown and ever-growing mental health problems among the young...
“For two millennia Christians have found these things to be gloriously true. Yet for Christian ministers to teach them to their congregations, and for Christian parents to teach them to their children, would inevitably be interpreted by some as attempts to ‘change’ their ‘orientation’ or ‘identity’.
“The bill creates a speech crime, and those who teach mainstream, historic Christian doctrine would inevitably be judged guilty of it. Needless to say, we will not cease to fulfil our duty to God to teach his ways faithfully, even if an unjust law should make us criminals for doing so.”
The letter said “conversion” was a core Christian concept “which describes turning, in obedience to Jesus Christ and by the power of the Holy Spirit, from self, sin and pride to humble trust in God”.
‘Grossly offensive to Christians’
It went on: “By appropriating this Christian language as a label for an ill-defined and wide-ranging criminal offence, the draft bill is not only grossly offensive to Christians but will inevitably catch genuine, faithful, historic Christian ministry and Christian parenting in its scope. Indeed, it seems designed to do so.
“The bill appears to be motivated by assumptions about Christian ministry which are unrecognisable to us. We are unaware that any attempt has been made in drafting this bill to speak to leaders of normal, orthodox Christian churches.”
One signatory, the Rev Dr Matthew Roberts, minister of Trinity Church York, writing for The Telegraph, below, said: “We say that we are ‘baffled and dismayed’ by it, for good reason. The bill is a Trojan horse.”
Another signatory, the Rev Tim Vasby-Burnie, Anglican vicar of St George’s Church in Shrewsbury, said: “Jesus’s teaching brings life and direction in this confused world, but it also challenges our inner desires and the assumptions of our society.
“The proposed bill would leave ministers and pastoral workers, who seek to pass on Jesus’ teaching, in danger of legal trouble or even cause their actions to be criminalised. I signed the letter to protect free speech and religious freedom.”
Julie Maxwell, deputy director of the Christian charity Lovewise and a member of the Church of England’s General Synod, said: “I signed this letter as someone who is involved in the pastoral support of young people and also of parents.
“I signed because of the danger the proposed bill poses to those who seek to teach and guide children and young adults in historic Christian biblical teaching on marriage, relationships, sexual intimacy and gender.
“The proposed bill claims to protect children but in fact turns the law on those who have primary responsibility for protecting children – those who care for and guide children as they navigate their development through puberty and adolescence.”
Graham Nicholls, a signatory and pastor of the independent evangelical Christ Church Haywards Heath, said the bill was harmful.
He said: “It will criminalise the everyday conversations parents and church workers have with children and adults where they explain the Bible’s teaching on sexuality and gender and encourage people to follow it.
“It would suppress freedom of speech and freedom of religion. It’s not plugging a gap in the law; it’s enforcing a particular ideology ... It’s the beginning of policing any moral conversation. Hundreds of thousands of Christians will likely fall foul of this law.”
A Government spokesman said freedom of belief, whether faith-based or wider, would be respected by the ban. He said: “Simple prayer, expressing religious freedom or holding different beliefs are not abusive conversion practices and therefore not in scope of our draft bill.
“We have consulted with a range of religious leaders who have shared support of our draft bill. We have brought forward a draft bill for pre-legislative scrutiny in order to get this right and end almost a decade of delay for LGBT+ people who should never have to suffer abuse in an effort to change who they are.”
.jpg)









.jpg)


