Sunday, June 30, 2024

Ukrainian Catholic priests freed by Moscow after 19 months

Arrested Priests ...

Two Ukrainian Catholic priests were released on Friday, more than 18 months after they were arrested by Russian forces in the occupied Ukrainian city of Berdiansk in the region of Zaporizhzhia, south-eastern Ukraine.

Fathers Ivan Levitsky and Bohdan Geleta, both of the Congregation of the Most Holy Redeemer, served the Greek Catholic and the Latin Catholic communities of Berdiansk and chose to remain in the city after it was occupied by Russian forces in 2022. 

In November 2022, the pair disappeared. It later emerged that they had been arrested by Russian authorities, and charged with sabotage and espionage. 

Russian military officials claimed to have found weapons and ammunition hidden in a church, and a map which allegedly served a military purpose. 

The Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church (UGCC) has denied that there were ever weapons or ammunition hidden on church grounds and that the map, though genuine, was marked with the 14 Stations of the Cross and had been used to plan religious processions.

Ukrainian Catholic leaders suggested instead that Fr. Levitsky had incurred the wrath of Russian occupiers by gathering the local Catholic community in the town’s main square every day at noon to pray for peace. 

Russia has long displayed animosity towards the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church. 

Greek Catholic activities have been made illegal in Crimea, for example, which was occupied by Russia in 2014. But the Church has a relatively small presence in Eastern Ukraine, with most of its adherents living in the west of the country. Though the few Greek Catholic communities in occupied Ukraine have been harassed and seen their services suspended, most priests of the Church have since left the regions and there are no other known cases of Catholic clergy in Russian custody. 

Very little is known about what transpired between the date of the arrest of Frs. Levitsky and Geleta and their release, including how they were treated, or where they were held. 

Shortly after their arrest, local Ukrainian Church authorities expressed concern that the priests might be subjected to torture, in order to force them to confess to the charges of holding weapons and conspiring against occupying Russian forces. 

But allegations of torture have not been confirmed, and the priests have not spoken publicly since their release. 

At the time of their detention, sources also alleged that the arrest of the two Catholic priests may have been Russia’s retaliation against mounting pressure by Ukrainian civilian authorities against the Ukrainian Orthodox Church which remained aligned with the Russian Orthodox Church after the invasion.

Ukraine currently has two major Orthodox churches, one of which is historically linked to Moscow, and another which was granted canonical status and autocephaly by the Patriarch of Constantinople. The feud between the two Churches, and alleged mistreatment of orthodox Christians loyal to the Moscow Patriarchate, contributed to the tension which eventually led to Russia’s attempted full-scale invasion of Ukraine. 

The news of the priests’ release was confirmed by the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church itself, on the Ukrainian language section of its official website. 

In the statement, the UGCC, which is the largest of the 23 Eastern Catholic Churches, attributed the clerics’ release to the intervention of key Vatican figures, mentioning Pope Francis, Cardinal Pietro Parolin, Cardinal Matteo Zuppi, and Archbishop Visvaldas Kulbokas by name. 

Parolin is the Secretary of State of the Vatican, and Kulbokas is the Lithuanian-born apostolic nuncio to Ukraine, one of the few diplomats who refused to leave Kyiv when Russia began its full-scale invasion. Zuppi is Pope Francis’ special envoy to Ukraine, tasked with trying to negotiate peace between the two countries. 

Though a full peace plan has yet to emerge, the Vatican has been credited in the past with successfully mediating prisoner exchanges. It is unclear, at the moment, if Ukraine released any prisoners of war in exchange for the release of the two priests, though reports in early June by Forum 18 – an organization dedicated to promoting religious freedom, with a special focus on Eastern Europe – stated that Russia may have proposed exchanging them for two Orthodox priests in custody in Ukraine.

Ukrainian civil authorities have accused the Orthodox Church loyal to the Moscow Patriarchate of collusion with the enemy, and at least two high-profile clerics, Metropolitans Pavlo and Ionafan, have been arrested in this context.

According to Russian Media, Metropolitan Ionafan was sent to Russia as part of a prisoner exchange in early June, so it is possible, though as yet unconfirmed, that he may have been released as part of the deal to secure the freedom of Levitsky and Geleta.

Massachusetts priest placed on leave for alleged sexual misconduct involving adult

A Massachusetts priest has been placed on administrative leave, following allegations of sexual misconduct involving an apparent adult victim — while an attorney for a separate alleged adult victim accused the diocese of having engaged in a "cover up" regarding the priest.

Bishop Edgar da Cunha of Fall River, Massachusetts, recently informed parishioners of St. Michael and St. Joseph parishes in Fall River that their joint pastor, Fr. Jay Mello, is under investigation due to "concerning information" the diocese had received about possible sexual misconduct.

The bishop's letter announcing the news was shared during the parishes' June 22-23 weekend Masses.

According to a June 23 statement by the diocese, "there are no allegations of inappropriate conduct with minors" in Mello's case.

The diocese said an initial inquiry "found that there is sufficient evidence to warrant further investigation to determine whether Father Mello has violated the standards of ministerial behavior and the Code of Conduct for Priests."

While on administrative leave, Mello "is no longer residing at the parish rectory and has been directed to refrain from exercising public priestly ministry."

The diocese noted Mello "has denied the allegations of priestly misconduct and is entitled to the presumption of innocence until the investigation is complete and a final determination is made."

The statement encouraged "anyone with concerns regarding the conduct of any priest, staff, or volunteer affiliated with the diocese" to contact law enforcement and/or the diocese's safe environment and victim assistance director.

OSV News has reached out to \Mello by email for comment, but did not receive an immediate response.

OSV News has also contacted the Diocese of Fall River to clarify the specific restrictions placed upon the priest.

As of June 27, Mello was listed on both the St. Michael and St. Joseph parishes' websites as their pastor.

But Boston-based attorney Mitchell Garabedian told reporters that allegations against Mello are far from unprecedented.

On June 26, Garabedian participated remotely in a press conference held outside the Diocese of Fall River's offices, claiming Mello "took advantage ... sexually" of his unnamed male client in 2013. Garabedian's client — who is not involved in the recent allegations against the priest — was 28 years old at the time.

Garebedian said his client had met Mello in the early 2010s at the former Sacred Hearts Retreat Center in Wareham, Massachusetts, and had shared with the priest — who is a 1998 graduate of a high school culinary arts program — a "common interest" in cooking.

The attorney said that in 2013, Mello had allegedly invited the man to discuss the topic of cooking at the rectory at St. Francis Xavier in Acushnet, Massachusetts, where the priest was filling in while still assigned to St. Patrick Church in Falmouth, Massachusetts (now part of St. Joseph, Guardian of the Holy Family Parish in Falmouth).

The alleged abuse took place at the rectory, said Garabedian, adding, "There was no consent in this sexual relationship. It was a violent incident ... and my client fled."

Garabedian told OSV News the alleged incident qualified as a "criminal sexual offense," and that his client had reported it to the Acushnet Police Department.

OSV News has requested confirmation from the police department of the complaint and is awaiting a response.

Garabedian also told OSV News that shortly after the alleged sexual assault, his client had met with now-deceased Bishop George Coleman, then bishop of the Fall River Diocese.

"And my client was ignored after that," Garabedian said. "The bishop was very quiet, and he just listened and he did not say anything."

Garabedian said Coleman "did nothing" after that.

"Common sense would dictate that an investigation should have been conducted back then, in 2013," he said.

Ten years later, said Garabedian, his client — who had since become "aware of other victims" — approached the diocese again, this time under da Cunha, about Mello.

The attorney added that his client has been "on an emotional rollercoaster" as a result of the alleged abuse, and is seeking "validation" of his experience as well as compensation from the diocese.

In response to the press conference, the Diocese of Fall River issued a June 26 statement saying that it was not able to provide additional information on the case during the ongoing investigation into Mello.

Once the inquiry has been completed, "all information including any allegations will be presented to the Ministerial Review Board for evaluation," said the diocese, referencing the independent, consultative body mandated by the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops' Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People.

"Upon its review and discussion of the information, the Review Board will offer recommendations to Bishop Edgar M. da Cunha … for a response to the allegations," said the diocese.

Cardinal Burke condemns Biden’s reception of Holy Communion as ‘sacrilege’

Featured Image 

Cardinal Raymond Burke condemned President Joe Biden’s reception of Holy Communion as a “sacrilege” during an interview with Pints with Aquinas host Matt Fradd.

Discussing how American Catholics can “better revere” Jesus Christ in the Holy Eucharist, Cardinal Burke stressed the importance of a “deepening of faith” in the Blessed Sacrament. He pointed out that one sign that this is “lost” is that someone like Biden, who unrepentantly supports legal abortion – the killing of innocent babies – is permitted to receive Communion by American clergy.

Cardinal Burke noted that Biden “claims to be a devout Catholic and yet is in favor of aborting babies even in the birth canal” and is also “in favor of… [the] transgender agenda, which is a complete rebellion against God’s plan for us.” 

“And then that he approaches to receive Holy Communion – this is not possible, because he denies Christ in these very blatant public ways,” said Cardinal Burke. 

“This is a sacrilege,” he continued, adding that it should not be permitted both “for his own sake and for the sake of the whole Church.” He added that, contrary to the claims of some, insisting that a politician who supports grave sin should not receive Communion – which he pointed out is Christ Himself – is “not making the Communion rail a battleground” but is “simply respect for our Lord Jesus Christ.”Cardinal Burke suggested that clergy use a “pastoral approach” by which they simply tell Biden that as long as he supports “policies and programs and laws that are in violation of the Divine Law,” he “may not approach to receive Holy Communion,” and then simply refuse him Holy Communion if he does approach. 

He pointed to the fact that the Apostle Saint Paul himself considered the worthy reception of Holy Communion an extremely important issue, so much so that he taught Christians that if they eat and drink the Body and Blood of Christ “unworthily,” they eat and drink their own damnation. 

Fradd made more explicit the significance of allowing a public sinner to receive Holy Communion: He noted that it sends a message to Catholics and “teaches” them something about the Eucharist. Fradd then asked Cardinal Burke what it would take for American bishops to come to a consensus on the importance of refusing Communion to politicians like Biden.

“It’s a question of a misunderstanding of the nature of the Church itself,” said Cardinal Burke, explaining that the Church is the “Body” of Christ and that “we are living members grafted onto the vine, Who is Christ.” In forgetfulness of this truth, the idea developed that “it was being kind to people not to deny them anything,” and Catholics began to neglect to examine their consciences or go to Confession regularly in order to prepare themselves to receive the Eucharist.

Cardinal Burke called for more teaching on the issue, adding that in his book Respecting the Body and Blood of the Lord: When Holy Communion Should Be Denied, he showed how the Church was “consistent” “from the time of St. Paul throughout all the centuries” in insisting upon “proper preparation to receive Holy Communion.”

The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (CDF)’s 2004 memo states that a politician “consistently campaigning and voting for permissive abortion and euthanasia laws” manifests “formal cooperation” with grave sin and must be “denied” the Eucharist.

Canon 915 of the Catholic Code of Canon Law also explicitly forbids those in mortal sin from receiving Communion: “Those who have been excommunicated or interdicted after the imposition or declaration of the penalty and others obstinately persevering in manifest grave sin are not to be admitted to Holy Communion.”

Cardinal Burke recently stated that the practice of giving Holy Communion to people like Biden leads to a de facto position of assuming that Catholic teaching has changed: “It gives the impression that the Church has changed its teaching with regard to these crimes, these previous sins, and it leads people to be very lax in their own conscience.”

You can imagine if somebody who is a pro-abortionist is receiving Holy Communion freely, are people going to be inclined to examine their consciences as they should, before they approach to receive the Sacrament? It dulls consciences.

Today we can’t take anything for granted because we’re dealing with six or seven decades of poor catechesis. Many Catholics today, not through their own fault, don’t know their own faith.

Woelki warns Church in Germany: Take Pope Francis more seriously

The Archbishop of Cologne, Rainer Maria Woelki, is urging Catholics in Germany to take the Pope more seriously. 

In a video published on the archdiocese's website on Saturday, he recalls a letter on the church reform debate that Pope Francis sent to Catholics in Germany exactly five years ago. 

"Let's be honest: who has actually read this letter?" asks Woelki. 

The Pope has repeatedly emphasised how important this letter is to him.

On 29 June 2019, Pope Francis wrote a letter "to the pilgrim people of God in Germany". 

In it, he referred to the Synodal Way reform process, which was still being planned at the time and has since been completed. 

On the one hand, Francis praised the commitment and reform efforts of German Catholics. At the same time, he urged unity with the universal Church. The letter caused quite a stir within the Church. 

Both supporters and opponents of the "synodal path", including Woelki, felt vindicated by the letter.

Woelki: No other nation has received such a letter from the Pope

The reform proposals of the Synodal Path continue to cause controversy between German Catholics and Pope Francis to this day. 

Only on Friday, several German bishops were in the Vatican for talks. 

Woelki said that with the letter, the Pope was inviting people to evangelise, which in his eyes constitutes the actual and essential mission of the Church. 

"I think so: We should fulfil his so urgently expressed wish - for our own sake, but also for the sake of the Church in Germany. Because only then will it have a future."

According to Woelki, the Pope spent a month writing the letter. 

"In his own hand in free hours. It was so important to him to stand by the Church in Germany in one of its darkest hours, to interpret the signs of the times for us, to give us orientation in this turning point. He wanted to reach out to us and guide us through this valley - as befits the successor of Peter. No other nation has received such a historic letter from him," said the Cardinal.

Pope issues new rules for priests at St Peter's Basilica

Blessing for Same-Sex Couples ...

On the feast day of St Peter, Pope Francis issued new statutes for the Vatican basilica dedicated to the apostle. 

On Saturday, the Vatican press office published a 59-page document with rules on the management and organisation of St Peter's Basilica. 

In particular, the document is dedicated to the tasks and regulations for the college of priests working there. 

The Pope had already issued transitional norms for this in 2021.

According to the new statutes, 24 priests from all over the world are to dedicate themselves to four areas of activity in St Peter's Basilica. These include the organisation and arrangement of mass celebrations as well as pastoral care for pilgrims, local faithful and employees. There are also charitable, cultural and theological tasks. 

The guidelines also regulate the term of office and remuneration. 

The head, the so-called archpriest, is appointed by the Pope. Cardinal Mauro Gambetti currently holds this office. The 58-year-old religious priest is also President of the Cathedral of St Peter.

This is also affected by the reorganisation. 

Pope Francis has taken them into account with new regulations and personnel rules. 

According to the paper, the task of the Cathedral Building Lodge is to preserve and enhance the religious, artistic, historical, architectural and cultural heritage of St Peter's Basilica. 

Francis had previously reorganised the legal status of the papal basilica of Santa Maria Maggiore. 

In 2005, Pope Benedict XVI did the same with the Papal Basilica of St Paul Outside the Walls.

German Synodal Way: Vatican demands changes to controversial new Church body

As part of an ongoing tug of war with the German bishops over the country’s controversial reform path, the Vatican has asked that several changes be made to a new national ecclesial body which curial officials have said has no foundation in Church law.

In a June 28 statement after a day-long workday with representatives of the German Episcopal Conference (DBK), the Vatican said the discussion lasted the entire day and “was again characterised by a positive, open and constructive atmosphere.”

It followed a similar meeting held March 22, which was part of a broader dialogue that began in 2022 amid a national consultation of German Catholics known as the “Synodal Way,” and after officials in the DBK ignored Vatican warnings to cease and desist with certain projects.

During the March meeting, the Vatican drew a hard line in the sand, demanding the German bishops pledge to respect canon law and to give the Holy See a final say over any proposed reforms.

The Vatican said this promise was the basis of the day’s meeting.

Namely, it said, they discussed “concrete forms of the exercise of synodality in the Church in Germany, in conformity with the ecclesiology of the Second Vatican Council, the provisions of canon law, and the fruits of the synod of the universal Church, to be presented to the Holy See for approval.”

During Friday’s discussion, the bishops gave Vatican officials an update on the most recent meeting of the Synodal Committee, a controversial body tasked with establishing a disputed Synodal Council, pitched as a new governing body for the Church in Germany composed of both laypeople and bishops.

On this point, “the theological foundations and the possibility of the legal realisation of a national body were discussed,” the statement said.

Friday’s meeting, it said, “focused on the relationship between the exercise of episcopal ministry and the promotion of the co-responsibility of all faithful, and, in particular, on the aspects of canon law for the establishment of a concrete form of synodality in the Church in Germany.”

“The desire and the commitment to strengthen synodality in the life of the Church, with a view to a more effective evangelisation, is shared,” it said.

As part of the ongoing dialogue between the German bishops and the Vatican, according to the statement, a new commission will be established by the Synodal Committee that deals specifically with “questions related to synodality and the structure of a synodal body.”

This commission, the statement said, will work in close collaboration with a similar commission on the Vatican’s side composed of representatives from the competent curial offices, to propose a draft on the topic.

According to the statement, curial officials Friday asked the German bishops for “a change in the name and in several aspects of the previously formulated proposal for a possible national synodal body.”

“As regards the position of this body, there is agreement that on the fact that it is neither above nor at the same level as the national episcopal conference,” the statement said, clarifying that whatever nature this body holds, it would not be able to overrule the bishops’ conference.

On Friday, the future composition of the delegation of the DBK participating in the ongoing dialogue with the Vatican was also discussed.

Representatives from the Roman Curia included Cardinals Victor Manuel Fernandéz, Prefect of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith; Kurt Koch, prefect of the Dicastery for Christian Unity; Pietro Parolin, Vatican Secretary of State; Robert Prevost, prefect of the Dicastery for Bishops; Arthur Roche, prefect of the Dicastery for Liturgy; and Archbishop Filippo Iannone, prefect of the Dicastery for Legislative Texts.

On the German side, participants included Bishops Georg Bätzing of Limburg; Stephan Ackermann of Trier; Bertram Meier of Augsburg; and Franz-Josef Overbeck of Essen, who respectively hold the positions as president of the German bishops’ conference, and presidents of the episcopal commissions for Liturgy, for the Universal Church, and for the Faith.

The secretary general of the DBK, Beate Gilles, and its spokesman, Matthias Kopp, were also present.

Friday’s meeting came after the Vatican earlier this year ordered the German bishops to halt a vote on the statutes of the Synodal Committee, and threatened canonical action if they did not comply.

As part of their Feb. 19-22 general assembly in Augsburg, the roughly 60 members of the DBK who attended were scheduled to review the results of their recently concluded “Synodal Path” reform process and vote on the statutes of a “Synodal Committee” that has the task of establishing a new national “Synodal Council.”

However, the bishops refrained from holding the vote after receiving a letter from the Vatican threatening punitive measures if they moved forward.

The idea for the Synodal Council, a governing body composed of both bishops and laypeople that would permanently oversee the Church in Germany, was approved during the fourth plenary assembly of Germany’s “Synodal Path” in September 2022, with the purpose of making “fundamental decisions of supra-diocesan importance.”

That assembly also approved of a “Synodal Committee,” to be co-chaired by Bishop Georg Bätzing of Limburg, president of the German Bishops’ Conference, and a layperson, which had the specific task of establishing the Synodal Council so as to be active by 2026.

In January of last year, the heads of several Vatican major departments wrote a letter to the German bishops vetoing the Synodal Council on grounds that it constituted a new form of ecclesial authority not canonically recognised, and which would essentially usurp the authority of the national bishops’ conference.

At the time, the German bishops ignored the Vatican’s warnings, announcing during their March 2023 spring assembly that plans for establishing the Synodal Committee were still moving forward.

Pope Francis and several dicastery heads within the Roman Curia have repeatedly intervened in the German bishops’ synodal process, which was launched with the aim of reforming Church structures to better respond to the national clerical abuse scandals.

The process quickly became a lightning rod over proposals to end priestly celibacy, allow women’s priestly ordination, broadly approve blessings for same-sex couples, and to give women the authority to administer baptisms.

In 2019, Pope Francis wrote a letter to the German bishops warning that their reform process risked fracturing church unity, and he later criticised proposals for both the Synodal Committee and the Synodal Council in a November 2023 letter to German theologians critical of the national reform process, saying these bodies “cannot be reconciled with the sacramental structure of the Church.”

Among the primary concerns with the Synodal Council is that it would constitute a new governing Church body not recognised by canon law and would essentially usurp the power of the national bishops’ conference.

Part of the Synodal Committee’s powers enable it to pass resolutions with a simple two-thirds majority. With just 23 bishop-members on the committee, after four refused to participate, over half of the body’s 70 members are laypeople, meaning resolutions could theoretically be passed without the approval of any of the country’s bishops.

When the German bishops visited the Vatican for their regular ad limina visit in November 2022, members of the Roman Curia proposed a moratorium on the process, however it was instead agreed that an ongoing dialogue be established with regular meetings.

An initial meeting took place at the Vatican on July 26, 2023, and further discussion of major reform topics took place during the October 2023 first session of the Synod of Bishops on Synodality, with the second and final session set to take place this year.

During their last meeting in March, Vatican officials drew a hard line in the sand, having the German bishops pledge that any national Church reforms would not breach canon law as is, and that no new measure would be adopted without prior approval from the Holy See.

The next meeting between representatives of the Roman Curia and the German bishops will take place after the conclusion of the second and final Rome-based session of the Synod of Bishops on Synodality, set to last the entire month of October.

Pope: Let us open the doors of the Church like Peter and Paul

History of the pallium given to Metropolitan Archbishops - Vatican News

God "opened the doors of his heart" to the apostles Peter and Paul, so they in turn could open tehir hearts to their brothers. Referring expressly to the Holy Door of the Vatican basilica that will be opened in the upcoming Jubilee of 2025, Pope Francis invited people to look to this image on Saturday's Solemnity of Saints Peter and Paul.

He did so in his homily at the solemn Eucharistic celebration in the Vatican basilica, during which - as is tradition - he presented the 42 archbishops appointed during the past year with the pallium, the strip of white woollen cloth that is a symbol of their communion with the Holy See in their jurisdiction.

"To Peter Jesus had entrusted the keys of the Kingdom," Francis recalled, "but he experiences that it is the Lord who opens the doors first, He always goes before us. And there is a curious fact: the doors of the prison were opened by the power of the Lord, but Peter then finds it difficult to enter the house of the Christian community: she who goes to the door, thinks he is a ghost and does not open it for him (cf. Acts 12:12-17). How often communities do not learn this wisdom of opening doors'. Paul, too," he added, "in recounting how the Lord has given him so many opportunities to proclaim the Gospel, uses the image of open doors. "Addressing the community of Corinth he says: 'A great and favourable door has been opened to me' (1 Cor 16:9); and writing to the Colossians he exhorts them thus: 'Pray also for us, that God may open to us the door of the Word to proclaim the mystery of Christ' (Col 4:3)".

"The two apostles Peter and Paul," the pontiff commented, "had this experience of grace. They touched the work of God, who opened the doors of their inner prison and also of the real prisons where they were imprisoned because of the Gospel. And, moreover, he opened before them the doors of evangelisation, so that they could experience the joy of meeting their brothers and sisters in the fledgling communities and be able to bring the hope of the Gospel to all".

An idea to which he also returned later on this feast day, from the window of the Apostolic Palace above St Peter's Square for the recitation of the Angelus. Pointing to the keys with which Peter is portrayed, he explained that 'authority if it is not service is dictatorship. The mission that Jesus entrusts to Peter is not to bar the doors of the house, allowing access only to a few select guests, but to help everyone find the way in, in fidelity to the Gospel of Jesus. Everyone'.

And it is precisely this style that Francis also indicated to the archbishops appointed during the past year. They are called - he said - "to be zealous pastors, who open the doors of the Gospel and who, with their ministry, contribute to building a Church and a society with open doors".

Among the bishops who received the pallium, the presence of Msgr. Linus Neli, archbishop of Imphal, the capital of the Indian state of Manipur, whose Christian community has experienced severe suffering this past year due to ethnic violence, was particularly significant.

For Asia, the list also includes Archbishops Vincent Aind of Ranchi (India), Andrew C. Alarcon of Caceres (Philippines), Hironimus Pakaenoni of Kupang (Indonesia) and Paulus Budi Kleden, Archbishop-elect of Ende (Indonesia). From the Churches of Oceania, Mgr Mosese Vitolio Tui, who was appointed Archbishop of Samoa-Apia just a few days ago, received the pallium.

Finally, on Saturday's feast of Saints Peter and Paul, the Vatican also released the annual report on St Peter's Obolus, which is collected in dioceses around the world on the Pope's Day of Charity, celebrated on the Sunday closest to this feast day.

During 2023, 48.4 million euro in donations were collected, while 103 million euro were contributed from this fund. Among the countries of origin of the donors, the Catholic community of South Korea confirms its top position with 1.3 million euro donated (it is the fourth largest donor together with Germany and behind the USA, Italy and Brazil).

The Churches in Asia are also among the recipients of direct assistance projects: on the continent with the funds of the Obolo di San Pietro a total of 33 projects have been realised for a total economic commitment of 2.8 million euro. 

In addition to the collections of these days in the parishes and dioceses each individual faithful can personally contribute to the Pope's charity at any time through the offerings collected online through the website www.obolodisanpietro.va.

Diocesan Changes 2024 - Kerry

I will sing forever of your love O Lord,

Through all ages my mouth will proclaim your truth.

Of this I am sure, that your love lasts forever,

That your truth is firmly established as the heavens. (Ps 88)

The past year has been a year of much discussion and planning in our diocese. The discussion is ongoing.  

I thank all who joined in and were part of the very large group involved in organizing these discussions.  

Every parish held a meeting that reviewed their strengths and their needs and focused on the question: What next steps do we all need to take?  

The discussion revolved around our Pastoral Letter: “Moving Forward in Hope”.

(Quotes in this statement are from the Pastoral Letter)

In reflecting on our next steps we look at parish life under the four headings in the Pastoral Letter:

“Think of your local church community in four ways:

  • A social/friendship community

  • A caring compassionate community

  • A praying, worshiping and sacramental community and

  • A community whose mission is to nourish and develop its faith, and hand it on to the next generation.”

All four headings are essential in a healthy parish.

This year we have one priest retiring, Fr Brendan Carmody.  We thank him for his years of ministry in Moyvane parish.  I thank all the priests who have agreed to take up new appointments in the weeks ahead.  Following on the joyful ordination of Fr Mark Moriarty last year, in August we will have the ordination to the priesthood of deacon Sean Murphy.  We are blessed to have been offered three priests on loan from Eldoret diocese in Kenya.  All going well they will join us in the months ahead.  We continue to pray for vocations to the diocesan priesthood in the years ahead.

As in the past decade, so in the decade ahead, the number of priests reaching retirement age will present a great challenge.  We can say looking at recent years, “Greater involvement of parishioners in all aspects of church life has enabled us to adjust well.”  In this regard “There are so many people in all our parishes to whom we owe a debt of gratitude for devoted voluntary service.”

Looking to the future, “Our hope is that parishioners and deacons will take a structured leadership role in their pastoral areas working in a co-responsible way with the priests of the pastoral area including priests from abroad.”

Sincere thanks to our team at the Pastoral Centre and to Mary Immaculate College, Limerick for delivering the course in Pastoral Leadership, and to the twenty-five lay people who will be commissioned as lay pastoral leaders in our diocese early next year.  In 2025 we hope to gather another group to prepare for the ministry of pastoral leadership.  Alongside this we have five in formation to be permanent deacons.  With everyone playing their part as baptized Christians we can rise to the challenge of continuing to have the fullness of Christian life in all our parishes and church areas.

For three years now Pope Francis has been courageously encouraging ongoing worldwide conversations, carried out in a spirit of faith and prayer, which will culminate in a second month-long gathering of the Synod of Bishops in Rome this October.  Central to his plan is that all the People of God, all who are baptized, will realize they have a contribution to make to the life of their Church, be it at parish, diocesan or national level.  They have a right to be heard.  Many gatherings have taken place in our diocese in connection with this synod.  Reports from similar gatherings worldwide have given us a context in which to understand our own challenges as a diocese.

We face the future with confidence, trusting in God’s help and guidance.  In the words of the vision statement of our Pastoral Letter: “Our faith is the Good News that Jesus Christ is the God of love.  Through the Holy Spirit Jesus Christ accompanies us both in this life and in the life to come.  To live and to share that Good News is our mission”.

Bishop Ray Browne

Diocese of Kerry

28 June 2024


Diocese of Kerry Appointments July 2024

Bishop Ray Browne wishes to announce the following changes to the appointments of clergy in the Diocese of Kerry:

Retirements:

Fr. Brendan Carmody, PP Moyvane.

Appointments:

Fr. Brendan Walsh, Causeway to be PP Moyvane.

Fr. Gerard Finucane, Waterville to be PP Causeway.

Fr Sean Jones, Killarney to be PP Waterville.

Fr Vitalis Barasa, St John’s Tralee to minister in Killarney Parish.

Fr Gerard Finucane to also be Moderator of Ballyheigue.

Fr Sean Jones to also be Moderator of Caherdaniel.

Priests of all Pastoral Areas of the Diocese take up different responsibilities outside their own parishes and within the Pastoral Area.  

This will be decided and communicated locally.

These appointments will become effective on Wednesday, July 17th 2024

Fr Nicholas Flynn

____________________

Fr. Nicholas Flynn

Diocesan Secretary

Church needs to rid itself of old sartorial habits (Opinion)

One of my favourite columnists is Liz Dodd who writes for The Tablet, an English Catholic paper, and sometimes in The Sunday Times. 

Liz is a young 30-something, has an unnatural shade of purple hair, a trendy haircut, five ear piercings and six tattoos and she is given, as part of her work, to cycling around Nottingham in a t-shirt and jump suit. At first sight not the kind of person I would normally want to read.

Oh! and by the way, she’s also a nun, a Sister of St Joseph of Peace, an ‘active’ congregation (as distinct from a contemplative ‘monastic order) and has made her first vows – of poverty, celibacy and obedience – at the end of a two-year novitiate. She is one of the few now entering religious life – just 11 in England and Wales in 2021, and of those only two made first vows this year. Liz was one of the two.

She lives in a convent with other sisters, refugees and young homeless people and sometimes she wonders, as do some family members and friends, why she gave up what she describes as ‘a dream gig as a travel, food and drink writer and her boisterous London houseshare’. She is, in short, the kind of nun that prompts the question: ‘She’s not a nun, is she?’ 

But she is. 

Her congregation’s charism (or mission) is peace through justice. They listen for God’s promptings in particular in the voices of the marginalised and their focus is on those society often excludes – in her case, asylum seekers and young homeless – including those marginalised by the Church: gay and transgender people and women. 

The God she encounters (usually when out running) is in soup kitchens and foodbanks and raves. It is a love, she believes, that will outlast the questions, the trendy haircut, even the tattoos.

For those of us who remember the staid, permanent world of religious life in the past with uniforms, habits and various forms of nonsense and incarceration, the image of the new nun courtesy of Liz Dodd seems a once-off curiosity. 

But, apparently, she seems to be exactly the kind of person God is calling into religious life at the moment – as she describes them – ‘risk-takers, in-between people, who thrive on uncertainty’. 

It’s obvious now that religious life as a stable, fixed entity with huge numbers of young women dedicated to teaching or nursing or parish work is well past its sell-by date.

I sometimes wonder whether the Liz Dodds of a different Church and their refusal to bend the knee to the traditions of the past by their ease with ‘modern’ dress have a message for the rest of us.

I remember once in Croke Park, on one of those recent painful All-Ireland days when Mayo conspired not to ‘bring Sam home’, seeing four priests dressed from head to toe in jackdaw black. 

It was a startling image, incongruous and almost defiant against the background of a sea of colour and life and energy. It seemed as if the black suit was an extension of their personalities, as if their role had consumed the person, as if they dressed any differently it would have meant leaving something of themselves at home.

Or maybe it was just that their wardrobes didn’t extend to dressing casually. Yet the rest of the human race can sometimes leave their uniforms at home. In Croke Park on that day soldiers weren’t wearing their uniforms. Nurses weren’t wearing their whites. Chefs weren’t in their high hats. Vets weren’t in their wellies. Barristers weren’t in their silly wigs. Yet for the men in black, it can mean black every day of the year, even on All-Ireland day. It’s like having a second skin we’ve grown into over the years.

In the 1940s and 1950s, students for the priesthood seemed to be everywhere. Like blackbirds. Black suits, black ties, sometimes even a black hat. (I remember at 18 years of age being turned back by a Dean of Discipline at the gates of Maynooth College as I was going home for Christmas because I wasn’t wearing my hat!) 

Strangely, younger priests seem to have a natural preference for black, favouring the old stock and wide collar, even (it is whispered) wearing black socks. They love wearing the long soutane (or cassock), walking confidently up the Church as it swishes around them, throwing back the lapels to reveal a touch of black silk. Capturing the good, old days when priests were everywhere and where they really were ‘the men in black’.

I notice now that the long black soutane seems to have disappeared in Maynooth, apart from formal liturgical occasions. In my time we wore it all day, even going to football matches. It had a symbolic significance as if representing the limited, enclosed clerical world we inhabited. It was the opposite of what Liz Dodd’s modern dress represents, a freedom to say what you think and to be the person you are.

In a recent column in The Tablet, Liz takes issue with some of comments made by the Vatican’s Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith on gender ideology and registers her disappointment with its head, Archbishop Fernandez, a celebrated liberation theologian. 

In another column, she criticises some decisions of the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of England and Wales in relation to the publication of the New Lectionary – the book used for scripture readings at Mass. 

She is unhappy that the translation used; unhappy too that the new version retains masculine pronouns – or sexist language; and unhappy that the New Lectionary with ‘gold-blocking, gilded edges and multiple ribbon markers’ costs £695.

Liz describes the bishops’ decisions in relation to the Lectionary as ‘wasteful and scandalously unjustifiable for a Church that ought to be prioritising the needs of the poorest in our communities’. 

Would that our Church, like the Sisters of St Joseph of Peace, would give us all the freedom and the courage to say what we think. 

As Liz Dodd does.

‘I’ve become a nun’, she says, ‘but the tattoos are non-negotiable.'

Priest: Pope Francis causing ‘many schisms’ and ‘deeper wounds’ in the Church than any other Pope

Anyone who has been following Church news recently will increasingly come across the term “schism,” which is causing an unusually strong stir.

In Spain, a convent of Poor Clares has broken away from the Church and considers all Popes after Pius XII (1939-1958) to be illegitimate. 

In their view, the Apostolic See has been vacated. 

This is commonly referred to as “sedevacantism.”

Similar to the Poor Clares in Spain, Archbishop Carlo Maria Viganò has caused a stir in Italy: like the Poor Clares, the former nuncio to the U.S.A. does not want to recognize the authority of the current Pope.

While the Spanish Poor Clares have already been excommunicated by the responsible bishop, this is probably only a formality in the archbishop’s case. However, this will not calm the situation. Both the Poor Clares and Archbishop Viganò have the secret sympathies of quite a few Catholics. At most, however, they are perceived as actual schismatics by those modernists who themselves have long since crossed the Rubicon of schism, albeit without being excommunicated.

Schisms are something that tears the church apart. Above all, however, they say something about the state of the Church. They often arise when the Church falls into disarray, and this is just as much the case in our time as it was in the time of Martin Luther, for example.

Of course, this does not justify a schism. And yet there are always two sides to a schism: The schismatic and the Church, that is: the Pope.

In the past, the Popes stood for the purity of Church doctrine, while the schismatics rejected this doctrine. Today, however, things look different, and that is precisely the problem: today, “schismatics” insist on the traditional teachings of the Church, while Pope Francis finds himself in an ambivalent role.

Increasingly, one gets the impression that Francis condones schisms or even provokes them. Let me put it this way: this Pope has fundamentally failed in the service of unity, and that is precisely what makes the schisms of the Poor Clares or Viganòs significant: they are an exclamation mark behind the aberrations of this pontificate.

Anyone who reads the statements of Viganò or the Poor Clares does not necessarily have to adopt their position of sedevacantism. Nevertheless, every orthodox Catholic will find many positions there with which he can identify with a clear conscience and with which – strictly speaking – he even has to identify with. After all, the only thing that is Catholic is what has always been Catholic, and it is precisely from this that Francis has now moved quite far away.

The obvious promotion of the “homosexual heresy” on the one hand and the fanatical persecution of the Latin Mass on the other are just two of the main criticisms of this pontificate; the intended transformation of the Catholic Church into a “synodal” one would be just another on a list that can be continued at will: it ranges from the (justified) accusation of watering down the sacrament of marriage in the post-synodal letter Amoris laetitia to the denial of the Catholic faith in God in the Abu Dhabi document.

Ever since Francis appointed Victor Fernández, an author of pornographic texts who has little theological knowledge, as prefect of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, this pontificate has become a parody. Francis and Fernández cannot accuse either the Poor Clares or Viganò of heresy without calling their own positions into question. Outgrowths of this pontificate, such as the “blessing of homosexual couples,” are not covered by the constant magisterium of the Church, and Francis’ ideological hatred of the Latin Mass hardly places him in continuity with the Catholic Church.

What’s more, the Pope has now managed to create a multitude of schisms in the Church. The schism of the German bishops should undoubtedly be mentioned here first, which Francis only tolerates so conspicuously because it anticipates his ideas of a “synodal” church reform.

Above all, however, there is the silent schism of rejection of this Pope, which is now quietly drawing ever wider circles, as one hears, right up to the top echelons of the Curia.

At the latest, since Cardinal George Pell described this pontificate as a “disaster,” it has become clear how deep the rift Francis has torn open in the Church is. This Pope has failed to meet his own stated expectations. He has not led the Church into a time of new evangelization but has deeply divided it.

Francis will no longer be able to heal the torn body of the Church. Yet it was he, of all people, who wanted to see the Church as a “hospital” and who only brought her to the hospital himself. No Pope has inflicted deeper wounds on the Church than he did.

The schisms of the Poor Clares and the Viganos are merely symptoms of this papal wound, and therefore, one can hardly help but look upon them with sympathy.

All the more so when one thinks of Germany. Unlike the schismatic bishops there, the Poor Clares and Viganò have remained faithful to the Catholic faith. This is quite strange for “schismatics,” but we live in strange times – and in a very strange pontificate.

Archbishop Viganò: I accuse Bergoglio of heresy and schism

Editor’s note: The following essay is the full English translation of a statement from Archbishop Carlo Maria Viganò in response to the charge of schism from the Vatican’s Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, published in Italian on June 28, 2024.

‘But even if we or an angel from heaven

Should preach to you a gospel other than the one that we preached to you,

let that one be accursed.

As we have said before, and now I say again,

if anyone preaches to you a gospel other than the one that you received,

let him be anathema.’ — Gal 1:8-9

“When I think that we are in the palace of the Holy Office, which is the exceptional witness of the Tradition and of the defense of the Catholic Faith, I cannot stop myself from thinking that I am at home, and that it is me, whom you call ‘the traditionalist,’ who should judge you.” So spoke Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre in 1979, when he was summoned to the former Holy Office, in the presence of the prefect, Cardinal Franjo Å eper, and two other prelates.

As I stated in my communiqué of June 20, I do not recognize the authority of the tribunal that claims to judge me, nor of its prefect, nor of the one who appointed him. This decision of mine, which is certainly painful, is not the result of haste or a spirit of rebellion; but rather is dictated by the moral necessity which, as bishop and successor of the apostles, obliges me in conscience to bear witness to the truth, that is, to God Himself, to Our Lord Jesus Christ.

I face this trial with the determination that comes from knowing that I have no reason to consider myself separate from communion with the Holy Church and with the papacy, which I have always served with filial devotion and fidelity. I could not conceive of a single moment of my life outside this one Ark of Salvation, which providence has constituted as the Mystical Body of Christ, in submission to its Divine Head and to His vicar on earth.

The enemies of the Catholic Church fear the power of grace which works through the sacraments, and above all the power of the Holy Mass, a terrible katechon which frustrates many of their efforts and wins to God so many souls who would otherwise be damned. And it is precisely this awareness of the power of the supernatural action of the Catholic priesthood in society that lies at the origin of their fierce hostility to tradition.

Satan and his minions know full well what a threat the one true Church poses to their antichristic plan. These subversives – whom the Roman pontiffs have courageously denounced as enemies of God, the Church, and humanity – are identifiable in the inimica vis, Freemasonry. It has infiltrated the hierarchy and succeeded in making it lay down the spiritual weapons at its disposal, opening the doors of the citadel to the enemy in the name of dialogue and universal brotherhood, concepts that are intrinsically Masonic. But the Church, following the example of her Divine Founder, does not dialogue with Satan: She fights him.

The causes of the present crisis

As Romano Amerio pointed out in his seminal essay Iota Unum, this cowardly and culpable surrender began with the convocation of the Second Vatican Ecumenical Council and with the underground and highly organized action of clergymen and laity linked to the Masonic sects, aimed at slowly but surely subverting the structure of government and magisterium of the Church in order to demolish Her from within. It is useless to look for other reasons: the documents of the secret sects demonstrate the existence of an infiltration plan conceived in the 19th century and carried out a century later, exactly in the terms in which it was conceived. Similar processes of dissolution had previously taken place in the civil sphere, and it is no coincidence that the popes were able to grasp in the uprisings and wars that bloodied the European nations the disintegrating work of international Freemasonry.

Since the council, the Church has thus become the bearer of the revolutionary principles of 1789, as some of the proponents of Vatican II have admitted, and as is confirmed by the appreciation on the part of the Lodges for all the popes of the council and of the post-conciliar period, precisely because of the implementation of changes that the Freemasons had long called for.

Change – or better still, aggiornamento – has been so much at the center of the conciliar narrative that it has been the hallmark of Vatican II and has posited this assembly as the terminus post quem that sanctions the end of the ancien régime – the regime of the “old religion,” of the “old Mass,” of the “pre-council” – and the beginning of the “conciliar church,” with its “new mass” and the substantial relativization of all dogma.

Among the proponents of this revolution appear the names of those who, until the pontificate of John XXIII, had been condemned and removed from teaching because of their heterodoxy. The list is long and also includes Ernesto Buonaiuti, the excommunicated vitandus, a friend of Roncalli, who died unrepentant in heresy, and whom just a few days ago the president of the Italian Bishops’ Conference, Cardinal Matteo Zuppi, commemorated with a Mass in the cathedral of Bologna, as reported with ill-concealed emphasis by Il Faro di Roma:

Almost eighty years later, a cardinal who is completely in line with the Pope is starting again with a liturgical gesture that has in all respects the flavor of rehabilitation. Or at least a first step in that direction.

The Church and the antichurch

I am therefore summoned before the tribunal that has taken the place of the Holy Office to be tried for schism, while the head of the Italian bishops – identified as being among the papabili and “completely in line with the Pope” – is illicitly celebrating a Mass of suffrage for one of the worst and most obstinate exponents of Modernism, against whom the Church – the one from which according to them I am separated – had pronounced the most severe sentence of condemnation. In 2022, in the Italian Bishops’ Conference newspaper Avvenire, Professor Luigino Bruni praised Modernism in these terms:

[…] a process of necessary renewal for the Catholic Church of its time, which was still impervious to the critical studies on the Bible that had been established for many decades in the Protestant world. For Buonaiuti, accepting scientific and historical studies on the Bible was the main way for the Church’s encounter with modernity. A meeting that did not take place, because the Catholic Church was still dominated by the theorems of neo-scholastic theology and blocked by the Counter-Reformation fear that the Protestant winds might finally invade the Catholic body.

These words would suffice to make us understand the abyss that separates the Catholic Church from the one that replaced Her, beginning with the Second Vatican Council, when the “Protestant winds” finally invaded the Catholic body.

This very recent episode is only the latest in an endless series of small steps, of silent acquiescence, of complicit winks with which the very leaders of the conciliar hierarchy made possible the transition “from the theorems of neo-scholastic theology” – that is, from the clear and unequivocal formulation of Dogmas – to the present apostasy.

We find ourselves in the surreal situation in which a hierarchy calls itself Catholic and therefore demands obedience from the ecclesial body, while at the same time professing doctrines that before the council the Church had condemned; and at the same time condemning doctrines as heretical that up until then had been taught by all the popes.

This happens when the absolute is removed from the truth and relativized by adapting it to the spirit of the world. How would the pontiffs of recent centuries have acted today? Would they judge me guilty of schism, or would they rather condemn the one who claims to be their successor? Together with me, the modernist Sanhedrin judges and condemns all Catholic popes, because the faith that they defended is mine; and the errors that Bergoglio defends are those that they, without exception, condemned. The words of the Jesuit martyr Edmund Campion in response to the verdict finding him guilty of treason in 1581 apply to the present Vatican no less than they did then to the fefender of the Faith: “In condemning us, you condemn all your own ancestors.”

Hermeneutic of rupture

I ask myself, then: what continuity can be given between two realities that oppose and contradict each other? Between Bergoglio’s conciliar and synodal church and the one “blocked by counter-reformation fear” from which he ostentatiously distances himself? And from what “church” would I be in a state of schism, if the one that claims to be Catholic differs from the true Church precisely in its preaching of what She condemned and in its condemnation of what She preached?

The adepts of the “conciliar church” will reply that this is due to the evolution of the ecclesial body in a “necessary renewal;” while the Catholic Magisterium teaches us that the truth is immutable and that the doctrine of the evolution of dogmas is heretical. Two churches, certainly: each with its own doctrines and liturgies and saints; but whereas for the Catholic believer the Church is One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic, for Bergoglio the Church is conciliar, ecumenical, synodal, inclusive, immigrationist, eco-sustainable, and gay-friendly.

The self-removal of the conciliar hierarchy

Is it possible, then, that the Church has begun to teach error? Can we believe that the one Ark of Salvation is at the same time also an instrument of perdition for souls? That the Mystical Body separates itself from its Divine Head, Jesus Christ, making the Savior’s promise fail? This cannot, of course, be admissible, and those who support such an idea fall into heresy and schism.

The Church cannot teach error, nor can her Head, the Roman pontiff, be at the same time heretical and orthodox, Peter and Judas, in communion with all his predecessors and at the same time in schism with them. The only theologically possible answer is that the conciliar hierarchy, which proclaims itself Catholic but embraces a faith different from that constantly taught for 2,000 years by the Catholic Church, belongs to another entity and therefore does not represent the true Church of Christ.

To those who remind me that Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre never went so far as to question the legitimacy of the Roman pontiff, while acknowledging the heresy and even the apostasy of the conciliar popes – as when he exclaimed: “Rome has lost the Faith! Rome is in apostasy!” – I remind them that in the last 50 years the situation has dramatically worsened and that in all probability this great pastor today would act with equal firmness, publicly repeating what he said then only to his clerics:

In this pastoral council, the spirit of error and lies has been able to work at ease, planting time-bombs everywhere that will blow up institutions in due course. (Principes et directives, 1977).

And again:

He who is seated on the Throne of Peter participates in the worship of false gods. What conclusion should we draw, perhaps in a few months’ time, in the face of these repeated acts of communication with false cults? I don’t know. I wonder. But it is possible that we will find ourselves forced to believe that the Pope is not Pope. Because at first sight it seems to me – I do not yet want to say it in a solemn and public way – that it is impossible for someone who is a heretic to be publicly and formally Pope (March 30, 1986).

What makes us understand that the “synodal church” and its head Bergoglio do not profess the Catholic faith? It is the total and unconditional adherence of all its members to a multiplicity of errors and heresies already condemned by the infallible Magisterium of the Catholic Church and from the ostentatious rejection of any doctrine, moral precept, act of worship, and religious practice that is not sanctioned by “their” council. Neither of them can in conscience subscribe to the Tridentine Profession of Faith and the Anti-Modernist Oath, because what they both express is the exact opposite of what Vatican II and the so-called “conciliar magisterium” insinuate and teach.

Since it is not theologically tenable that the Church and the papacy are instruments of perdition rather than of salvation, we must necessarily conclude that the heterodox teachings conveyed by the so-called “conciliar church” and the “popes of the council” from Paul VI onwards constitute an anomaly that seriously calls into question the legitimacy of their magisterial and governing authority.

The subversive use of authority

But this was precisely the “masterstroke of Satan” – as Archbishop Lefebvre called it – who knew how to make use of the natural respect and filial love of Catholics for the sacred authority of the pastors to induce them to put obedience before the truth, perhaps hoping that a future pope could in some way heal the disaster that had been accomplished and whose explosive results could already be guessed. This did not happen, despite the fact that some had courageously sounded the alarm. And I also count myself among those who, in that troubled phase, did not dare to oppose errors and deviations that had not yet fully shown themselves in their destructive value. I do not mean to say that I did not have an inkling of what was happening, but that I did not find – because of the intense work and the all-encompassing tasks of a bureaucratic and administrative nature at the service of the Holy See – the right conditions that would have allowed me to grasp the unprecedented gravity of what was taking place before our eyes.

The clash

The occasion that led me to clash with my ecclesiastical superiors began when I was delegate for the Pontifical Representations, then as Secretary General of the Governorate, and finally as Apostolic Nuncio to the United States. My war against moral and financial corruption unleashed the fury of then-Secretary of State Cardinal Tarcisio Bertone when – in accordance with my responsibilities as delegate for the Papal Representations – I denounced the corruption of Cardinal McCarrick and opposed his promoting corrupt and unworthy candidates for the episcopate presented by the Secretary of State, who had me transferred to the Governorate because “I prevented him from making the bishops he wanted.”

It was always Bertone, with the complicity of Cardinal Giovanni Lajolo, who hindered my work aimed at combating widespread corruption in the Governorate, where I had already obtained important results beyond all expectations. It was also Bertone and Lajolo who convinced Pope Benedict XVI to expel me from the Vatican and send me to the United States. There I found myself having to confront the vile events of Cardinal McCarrick, including his dangerous relationships with political representatives of the Obama-Biden administration and also on an international level, which I did not hesitate to report to Secretary of State Pietro Parolin, who took no account of it.

This led me to consider many events I had witnessed during my diplomatic and pastoral career in a different light, and to grasp their coherence with a single project that by its nature could be neither exclusively political nor exclusively religious, since it included a global attack on traditional society based on the doctrinal, moral, and liturgical teaching aspects of the Church.

Corruption as an instrument of blackmail

This is why from once having been an esteemed apostolic nuncio – for which few days ago Cardinal Parolin himself recognized me for my exemplary loyalty, honesty, correctness, and efficiency – I have now become an inconvenient archbishop, not only because I have asked for justice in the canonical processes undertaken against corrupt prelates, but also and above all for having provided an interpretive key that shows how corruption within the hierarchy was a necessary premise to control, manipulate, and coerce it with blackmail to act against God, against the Church, and against souls.

This modus operandi – which Freemasonry had described in detail before infiltrating the ecclesial body – mirrors that adopted in civil institutions, where the representatives of the people, especially at the highest levels, are largely blackmailable because they are corrupt and perverted. Their obedience to the delusions of the globalist elite leads peoples to ruin, destruction, disease, and death – death not only of the body, but also of the soul. Because the true project of the New World Order – to which Bergoglio is enslaved and from which he draws his own legitimacy from the powerful of the world – is an essentially satanic project, in which the work of the creation of the Father, the redemption of the Son, and the sanctification of the Holy Spirit is hated, erased, and counterfeited by the simia Dei and his servants.

If you do not speak, the very stones will cry out

Witnessing the total subversion of the divine order and the propagation of infernal chaos with the zealous collaboration of the leaders of the Vatican and the episcopate makes us understand how terrible are the words of the Virgin Mary at La Salette – “Rome will lose the faith and become the seat of the Antichrist” – and what a hateful betrayal is constituted by the apostasy of the pastors, and by the even more unheard-of betrayal of the one who sits on the throne of the Most Blessed Peter.

If I were to remain silent in the face of this betrayal – which is consummated with the fearful complicity of many, too many prelates who are reluctant to recognize in the Second Vatican Council the principal cause of the present revolution and the adulteration of the Catholic Mass as the origin of the spiritual and moral dissolution of the faithful – I would break the oath taken on the day of my ordination and renewed on the occasion of my episcopal consecration. As a successor of the apostles, I cannot and will not accept to witness the systematic demolition of Holy Church and the damnation of so many souls without trying by every means to oppose all this. Nor can I consider a cowardly silence for the sake of a quiet life preferable to giving witness to the Gospel and defending Catholic truth.

A schismatic sect accuses me of schism: this should be enough to demonstrate the subversion taking place. Imagine what impartiality of judgment a judge will be able to exercise when he depends on the one whom I accuse of being a usurper. But precisely because this event is emblematic, I want the faithful – who are not required to be familiar with the functioning of the ecclesiastical tribunals – to understand that the crime of schism is not committed when there are well-founded reasons to consider the election of the Pope dubious, due both to the vitium consensus as well as to the irregularities or violations of the norms which govern the conclave (cf. Wernz-Vidal, Ius Canonicum, Rome, Pont. Univ. Greg., 1937, vol. VII, p. 439).

The Bull Cum ex apostolatus officio of Paul IV established in perpetuity the nullity of the nomination or election of any prelate – including the Pope – who had fallen into heresy before his promotion to cardinal or elevation to Roman pontiff. It defines the promotion or elevation as nulla, irrita, et inanis – void, invalid, and without any value – “even if it took place with the agreement and unanimous consent of all the cardinals; nor can it be said that it is validated by the receipt of the office, consecration, or possession […], or by the putative enthronement […] of the Roman pontiff himself or by the obedience given to him by all and by the course of any duration of time in the said exercise of his office.”

Paul IV adds that all the acts performed by this person are to be considered equally null, and that his subjects, both clerics and lay people, are freed from obedience with regard to him, “without prejudice, however, on the part of these same subjected people, to the obligation of fidelity and obedience to be given to future bishops, archbishops, patriarchs, primates, cardinals, and Roman pontiffs who are canonically installed.” Paul IV concludes:

And to the greater confusion of those thus promoted and elevated, where they claim to continue their administration, it is permissible to request the help of the secular arm; nor for this reason are those who withdraw from loyalty and obedience towards those who have been promoted and elevated in the way already mentioned, to be subject to any of those censures and punishments imposed on those who would like to tear the tunic of the Lord.

For this reason, with serenity of conscience, I maintain that the errors and heresies to which Bergoglio adhered before, during, and after his election, along with the intention he held in his apparent acceptance of the papacy, render his elevation to the throne null and void.

If all the acts of governance and teaching of Jorge Mario Bergoglio, in content and form, prove to be extraneous and even in conflict with what constitutes the action of any of the popes; if even a simple believers and non-Catholics understand the anomaly of the role that Bergoglio is playing in the globalist and anti-Christian project carried out by the World Economic Forum, the U.N. Agencies, the Trilateral Commission, the Bilderberg Group, the World Bank, and by all the other sprawling branches of the globalist elite, this does not demonstrate even slightly that I desire schism by highlighting and denouncing this anomaly.

Yet I am attacked and prosecuted because there are those who delude themselves that by condemning and excommunicating me my denunciation of the coup d’état will somehow lose its coherence and consistency. This attempt to silence everyone solves nothing; indeed it makes those who try to conceal or minimize the metastasis that is destroying the ecclesial body all the more culpable and complicit.

The ‘deminutio’ of the synodal papacy

To all this we may add the study document The Bishop of Rome which the Dicastery for Promoting Christian Unity recently published and the downgrading of the papacy which is theorized in it, in application of John Paul II’s encyclical Ut Unum Sint, which in turn refers to the constitution Lumen Gentium of Vatican II.

It appears entirely legitimate – and dutiful, in the name of the primacy of Catholic truth sanctioned in the infallible documents of the papal Magisterium – to ask whether Bergoglio’s deliberate choice to abolish the apostolic title of Vicar of Christ and choose to define himself simpliciter as Bishop of Rome does not constitute in some way a deminutio of the papacy itself, an attack against the divine constitution of the Church, and a betrayal of the Munus petrinum. And upon closer inspection, the previous step was taken by Benedict XVI, who invented – along with the “hermeneutic” of an impossible “continuity” between two totally foreign entities – the monstrum of a “collegial papacy” exercised by the Jesuit and the emeritus simultaneously.

It is no coincidence that the study document cites a phrase from Paul VI: “The Pope […] is undoubtedly the most serious obstacle on the path of ecumenism” (Speech to the Secretary for the Promotion of Christian Unity, 28 April 1967).

Montini had began to prepare the ground four years earlier when he dramatically laid aside the Tiara. If this is the premise of a text that is intended to serve to make the Roman papacy “compatible” with the denial of the primacy of Peter that the heretics and schismatics reject; and if Bergoglio himself presents himself as merely primus inter pares amidst the assembly of Christian sects and denominations not in communion with the Apostolic See, failing to proclaim the Catholic doctrine on the papacy defined solemnly and infallibly by the First Vatican Council, how can one fail to think that the exercise of the papacy, and indeed the very intention to accept it, has been affected by a defect of consent (here and here), such as to render the legitimacy of “Pope Francis” null or at least highly doubtful?

Which “church” could I separate myself from, which “pope” would I refuse to recognize, if the former defines itself as the “conciliar and synodal church” in antithesis to the “pre-conciliar church” – i.e., the Church of Christ – and the latter demonstrates that he considers the papacy as his own personal prerogative to be disposed of by modifying and altering it at will, always in coherence with the doctrinal errors implied by Vatican II and the post-conciliar “magisterium”?

If the Roman papacy – the papacy, to be clear, of Pius IX, Leo XIII, Pius X, Pius XI, Pius XII – is considered to be an obstacle to ecumenical dialogue, and ecumenical dialogue is pursued as the absolute priority of the “synodal church,” represented by Bergoglio, what better way could this dialogue be implemented than by removing those elements that make the papacy incompatible with it, and therefore tampering with it in a completely illegitimate and invalid way?

The conflict of so many brother bishops and faithful

I am convinced that among the bishops and priests there are many who have experienced and still experience today the excruciating internal conflict of finding themselves divided between what Christ the pontiff asks of them – and they know it well – and what the one who presents himself as Bishop of Rome imposes with force, with blackmail, and with threats.

Today it is more necessary than ever for us pastors to wake up from our torpor: Hora est iam nos de somno surgere (Rom 13:11). Our responsibility before God, the Church, and souls requires us to unequivocally denounce all the errors and deviations that we have tolerated for too long, because we will not be judged either by Bergoglio or by the world, but by Our Lord Jesus Christ. We will give an account to Him of every soul lost through our negligence, of every sin committed by each soul because of us, of every scandal before which we have remained silent out of false prudence, through a desire for quiet living, through complicity.

On the day on which I was supposed to present myself to defend myself before the Dicastery for the Doctrine of Faith, I have decided to make public this declaration of mine, to which I add a denunciation of my accusers, their “council,” and their “pope.” I ask the holy apostles Peter and Paul, who consecrated the soil of the Alma Urbe with their own blood, to intercede before the throne of the Divine Majesty, so that they may obtain for the Holy Church that She may finally be freed from the siege that eclipses Her and from the usurpers who humiliate Her, making the Domina gentium the servant of the antichristic plan of the New World Order.

In defense of the Church

My defense is therefore not a personal one, but rather a defense of the Holy Church of Christ, in which I have been constituted a bishop and successor of the apostles, with the precise mandate of safeguarding the Deposit of Faith and preaching the Word, insisting opportune importune – in season and out of season – rebuking, reproving , exhorting with all patience and doctrine (2 Tim 4:2).

I strongly reject the accusation of having torn the seamless garment of the Savior and of having departed from being under the supreme authority of the Vicar of Christ: in order to separate myself from ecclesial communion with Jorge Mario Bergoglio, I would have to have first been in communion with him, which is not possible since Bergoglio himself cannot be considered a member of the Church, due to his multiple heresies and his manifest alienness and incompatibility with the role he invalidly and illicitly holds.

My accusations against Jorge Maria Bergoglio

Before my brothers in the episcopate and the entire ecclesial body, I accuse Jorge Mario Bergoglio of heresy and schism, and I ask that he be judged as a heretic and schismatic and removed from the throne which he has unworthily occupied for over 11 years. This in no way contradicts the adage Prima Sedes a nemine judicatur, because it is evident that, since a heretic is unable to assume the Papacy, he is not above the Prelates who judge him.

I also accuse Jorge Mario Bergoglio of having caused – due to the prestige and authority of the Apostolic See which he usurps – serious adverse effects, sterility, and death in the millions of faithful who followed his insistent invitation to undergo the inoculation of an experimental gene serum produced with aborted fetuses, even to the point of issuing a formal “Note” declaring that using the vaccine is morally permissible (here and here) He will have to answer before the tribunal of God for this crime against humanity.

Finally, I denounce the secret agreement between the Holy See and the Chinese communist dictatorship, by which the Church has been humiliated and forced to accept the government appointment of bishops, the control of liturgical celebrations, and limitations on its freedom of preaching, while Catholics loyal to the Apostolic See are persecuted with impunity by the Beijing government with the complicit silence of the Roman Sanhedrin.

The rejection of the errors of Vatican II

I consider it an honor to be “accused” of rejecting the errors and deviations implied by the so-called Second Vatican Ecumenical Council, which I consider to be completely devoid of magisterial authority due to its heterogeneity compared to all the true councils of the Church, which I fully recognize and accept, just as I fully recognize and accept all the magisterial acts of the Roman pontiffs.

With conviction I reject the heterodox doctrines contained in the documents of Vatican II and which have been condemned by the popes up to Pius XII, or which contradict the Catholic Magisterium in any way. I find it disconcerting to say the least that those who are trying me for schism are those who embrace the heterodox doctrine according to which there exists a bond of union “with those who, being baptized, are honored with the name of Christian, though they do not profess the faith in its entirety or do not preserve unity of communion with the successor of Peter” (LG 15).

I wonder how readily one can challenge a bishop for the lack of communion which is also claimed to exist with heretics and schismatics.

I equally condemn, reject, and refuse the heterodox doctrines expressed in the so-called “post-conciliar magisterium” that originated with Vatican II, as well as the recent heresies relating to the “synodal church,” the reformulation of the papacy in an ecumenical key, the admission of concubinaries to the sacraments, and the promotion of sodomy and “gender” ideology.

I also condemn Bergoglio’s adherence to climate fraud, a mad neo-Malthusian superstition engendered by those who, hating the Creator, cannot help but also detest creation, and man along with it, who is made in the image and likeness of God.

Conclusion

To the Catholic faithful, who today are scandalized and disoriented by the winds of novelty and the false doctrines that are promoted and imposed by a hierarchy rebellious against the Divine Master, I ask you to pray and offer your sacrifices and fasts pro libertate et exaltatione Sanctæ Matris Ecclesiæ, so that Holy Mother Church may find Her freedom and triumph with Christ, after this time of passion.

May those who have had the grace of being incorporated into Her in baptism not abandon their Mother who is today lying prostrate and suffering: tempora bona veniant, pax Christi veniat, regnum Christi veniat.

Given in Viterbo, on the 28th day of the month of June, in the Year of Our Lord 2024, the Vigil of the Holy Apostles Peter and Paul.

+ Carlo Maria Viganò, Archbishop