Thursday, July 04, 2024

Friars Film Falls Foul of The Force of OPW

Irish Dominican friars had a request for permission to film at Skellig Michael refused by the Office of Public Works (OPW). 

The Order is currently filming  a series of videos for their YouTube channel to tell the story of Irish religious/historical places from the religious viewpoint.

Fr Conor McDonough OP wrote on X  on June 27, “No permission from OPW to film on Skellig Michael. Such a shame. I’d been really looking forward to it from the start of our series.”  

Fr Conor said that these videos are “a case of the Church telling her own story”.

The island has been a religious place for centuries and many martyrs have died there; in the year 823 Norse pirates raided the Skelligs and wiped out the whole community.

Controversially, the American production company Lucasfilm received permission to film scenes for both Star Wars films The Force Awakens and The Last Jedi which involve bringing large film crews to the island.

Martina Purdy, a journalist and pilgrim guide for St Patrick’s Way in Co. Down said that “Skellig Michael was opened up for Star Wars which has really nothing to do with its authentic original meaning. These sites are sacred and they are actually famous for a reason – they were made famous by the religious.

“We should be able to reclaim the high places our Faith. To turn the Dominicans away is just really ridiculous and I find it hard to believe that in an entire summer schedule they can’t find some time for the Dominicans to go there, but of course it doesn’t suit the new religion of the State.”

Hugh MacMahon wrote is his book Voices from the Desert that “Skellig Michael itself was occupied by individual hermits during the medieval period and the Canons encouraged pilgrims to go there”.

The Diocese of Kerry’s website say that “even today with mass tourism bringing many visitors to the Skellig, there is always an element of pilgrimage about going to Skellig.” 

And the OPW’s Heritage Services said “the monks left the island in the thirteenth century. It became a place of pilgrimage and, during the time of the Penal Laws, a haven for Catholics.”

“I wonder if there was an application from Hollywood how it would be considered?”, Ms Purdy asked.  

However, writing on X, Fr Conor has vowed not to give into hate which leads to the Dark Side and hopes that the OPW will have a cancellation on their schedule this summer.

Ireland’s Former President Delivers Hopeful, Pro-LGBTQ+ Sermon for Pride

The former president of Ireland, who is a prominent pro-LGBTQ+ Catholic, delivered a sermon last weekend advocating inclusion, part of the nation’s wider celebrations of Pride.

Mary McAleese, who has a gay son and is also a canon lawyer, preached at Christ Church Cathedral, Dublin, an Anglican worship place, for the community’s Choral Evensong marking Pride. 

McAleese told the congregations that the Christians who have worshipped at the church for nearly a millennium often have heard Scriptures’ exhortation to “Love your neighbor as yourself,” and yet they also witness “time and again what happens when hatred rules human hearts.”

Many at Evensong were harmed by others’ failure to love, McAleese said, and the stories of that harm are carried into families, communities, and churches. She singled out Ireland’s past history of criminalizing homosexuality, a reality today in other parts of the world, commenting, “in this overwhelmingly Christian country there can be no doubt that the racists, homophobes and misogynists will all have heard the words of the great commandment to love one another. They have ignored them, or worse still edited them cynically.” 

Ireland is still marked by incidents of anti-LGBTQ+ violence, she noted. So, too, the Catholic Church has many shortcomings regarding LGBTQ+ people.

Though McAleese was cognizant of the challenges LGBTQ+ people face, she was largely hopeful, about the ways Ireland has changed and the ways the church can do so, too. She offered a personal anecdote to illustrate this idea:

“That Ireland has changed and changed profoundly came home to me in a very special way just a few weeks ago. I was coming back from Rome where the Vatican was reeling from the hostile global reaction to Pope Francis’ repeated homophobic locker room language. The shock and pain of my gay friends and family,  both lay and clerical, was just plain awful. I had texts and emails from many saying how tested they were in their faith. I knew how they felt. . .

“It was in precisely that mood of dejection and frustration that my husband and I disembarked the plane and entered Dublin Airport Terminal 2. The place was decked out in rainbows, wall to wall rainbows, proclaiming this month of Pride in Dublin, saying loud and clear that Dublin, that Ireland, is a place that has Pride’s back, that is proud of Pride and all it stands for. My husband and I looked at each other and laughed with joy. Here was love in action. Here was proof positive of the power of love and the power of Pride in pushing the LGBTIQA+ community from hiding in the wings of life to centre stage.  Everyone exiting that airport, heading East or West, North or South could be left in no doubt that God’s people will do whatever it takes for however long it takes to fulfil the law of love.”

McAleese celebrated the gains already made, too, calling today’s Irish citizens “a fortunate generation to have had that miraculous day of grace in 2015 when the voters of Ireland overwhelmingly endorsed same sex marriage.” She continued:

“Of all the decades we could have lived in, this one, though it could be better, is better than most. That is thanks to the courage and sacrifice of those who first lifted the Pride banner fifty years ago in very hostile times. Small in number then, they refused to settle for laws, attitudes, biases and language that rendered them second class citizens, made them vulnerable to violence, prejudice and untold and unnecessary  heartache. They brought out into the open the damage visited upon them by the prejudice and hate-filled language that had been festering, unchallenged in  private, safe spaces and had made toxic the public space whether streets or laws or encounters.

“Pride helped to change attitudes, change Ireland. Pride has grown  so exponentially that this is by far the best decade for LGBTIQA+ men and women in our country but in no way can anyone who proclaims the commandment to love one another settle for the way things are for there is a long road yet to travel to that place where love triumphs and proves its worth. If the best is yet to come it will take more courage, more work, more Pride gatherings, more solidarity until all that miserable hatred is squeezed out by Pride, by lived love of neighbour.”

Earlier last week, members of We Are Church Ireland lived out that commitment to love their neighbors by participating in Dublin’s 50th Pride parade. 

The members also gathered outside of St. Andrew’s Catholic Church in the city, which recently expelled a gay men’s chorus from performing there. 

Though the church’s doors were closed and gates were locked, the faithful gathered sang welcoming hymns amid rainbow decor.

Celebrating Pride with prayer at Christ Church was, for McAleese,  “a statement of intent about the next one thousand years. To the extent that we can, we will insist on the right of all of us to [receive] love, . . . respect, . . . equality, to be free from wrongs inflicted by ignorance, bigotry and abuse of the gospel and to call it out wherever it appears.”

So, likewise, are Catholics’ celebrations of Pride, wherever and whenever they occur.

Franciscan Friars of California ask to extend abuse claim deadline

Seven Native American tribes in Arizona and New Mexico should soon receive official notice explaining how tribal members who are clergy sex abuse survivors can file claims against the Franciscan Province of St. Barbara in its Chapter 11 case now wending its way through U.S. Bankruptcy Court.

The province, through its civil entity the Franciscan Friars of California, Inc., filed for bankruptcy protection Dec. 31, 2023, exactly one year after California's most recent "lookback window" for filing sex abuse claims closed. 

The province, which covers the western U.S., was facing 94 new abuse claims, most filed in California, Franciscan Fr. David Gaa, the provincial minister, stated in a court filing Jan. 8.

"To date, 59 current or former friars associated with the Debtor have been accused of childhood sexual abuse in the states of Arizona, California, Idaho, Missouri, New Mexico, Nevada, Oregon, Utah and Washington," attorneys for the Creditors Committee, which represents abuse claimants, said in court documents filed in May. 

Find information about the Franciscan Friars of California's bankruptcy case, including instructions on proofs of claim, on the website maintained by the religious order's claim agent, Donlin, Recano & Company, Inc. 

The Franciscans' list of friars it has determined have been "credibly accused" of sexual abuse documents at least 25 friars with at least one ministry assignment in Arizona or New Mexico. 

Thirteen of those friars served at least one assignment on a Native American reservation or within a tribal community — the Colorado River Indian Tribes, Gila River Indian Community, Pascua Yaqui Tribe, San Carlos Apache Tribe, Tohono O'odham Nation and White Mountain Apache Tribe in Arizona, and the Mescalero Apache Tribe in New Mexico.

In addition, the Catholic Truth & Healing website, published by "a group of archivists, historians, and concerned Catholics," states friars from the St. Barbara Province worked at the now closed St. John's Indian School in Arizona from 1915 to 1981. 

Three St. Barbara friars who have been credibly accused were assigned to St. John's, according to the province's list, The school enrolled students from several tribes and included a nearby church.

U.S. Bankruptcy Judge William Lafferty approved a two-month public notice period for abuse proofs of claim to be filed by July 19. "Sexual Abuse Claim Notice Packages" were mailed to the attorneys general of eight western states, as well as to sheriff's offices and a few other offices or agencies in 25 selected counties. Twenty-seven newspapers were selected to publish the "Sex Abuse Claim Notice" twice. 

However, more than half the counties and half the newspapers that received the packets and notices were in California.

None of the seven tribal governments in Arizona and New Mexico were sent the information, nor did nearby counties or local tribal or reservation border town newspapers.

The lack of public notice to the tribes was raised by NCR after a list of Native American ministry assignments on the Franciscans' Credibly Accused List was compared to Lafferty's order that authorized where the sexual abuse claim packages and notices were to be sent, posted and published. 

NCR raised questions about the public notice with officials with the St. Barbara Province, attorneys for both the Franciscans and abuse claimants, tribal officials, and the four dioceses where those seven tribes are located — the Dioceses of Gallup, Las Cruces, Phoenix and Tucson.

The incomplete public notice disparity seemed particularly jarring amid the commitments U.S. Catholic bishops made in "Keeping Christ's Sacred Promise: A Pastoral Framework for Indigenous Ministry," released on June 14.

"The Church recognizes that it has played a part in traumas experienced by Native children," the bishops said in the document, which did not mention clergy sex abuse.

Citing the need for "healing and reconciliation" between Native communities and the church, the bishops offered four recommendations to achieve that goal: transparency, relationship building, listening and accountability.

Just days after the bishops' document was released and NCR posed those questions, an attorney for the Franciscans advised the court they would be requesting additional public notice for the seven tribes, along with an extended bar date deadline of Aug. 30. 

In an email sent June 25, a spokesman for the Franciscans cited the desire "to ensure maximum notice and outreach to abuse survivors in Native American communities currently and formerly served" by the Franciscan Friars of California.

"While the original bar date was set by the Bankruptcy Court for July 19, 2024 – providing adequate time for survivors to file abuse claims – the Aug. 30th extension will afford more time to all abuse survivors desiring to file a claim, and not just those in Native American communities being notified for the first time," the spokesman said. 

The following day, attorneys for the Franciscans filed a document with the court, requesting the claims bar date be extended, and asking for additional public notice to the seven tribes, additional federal and county offices in Arizona and New Mexico, and advertising the notice in four tribal news publications: the Gila River Indian News, San Carlos Apache newsletter, the Runner News and the Fort Apache Scout.

However, until the court approves the extended bar date, the deadline for survivors to file sex abuse proofs of claim remains July 19.

One tribe, however, is not waiting for Judge Lafferty to approve an extension. After being contacted for comment by NCR, the Pascua Yaqui Tribe, which includes several communities in Southern Arizona, emailed its own notice to tribal members June 27. 

Alfred Lopez Urbina, the tribe's attorney general, and the Pascua Yaqui Tribal Council, sent out a five-page notice that included information about the bankruptcy case and the proofs of claim filing process. The notice included information about six friars named on the St. Barbara Province's Credibly Accused List who had assignments at two churches within or near Pascua Yaqui tribal communities.  

One credibly accused friar cited by the Pascau Yaqui Tribe was Franciscan Fr. Camillus Cavagnaro, who was at neighboring San Xavier del Bac — the renowned historic mission church outside of Tucson that draws thousands of tourists each year. 

Cavagnaro's ministry, according to the Franciscan list, included 60 years of assignments, mostly in Indigenous communities, with posts on three reservations in Arizona, one reservation in New Mexico, and a three-year stint in Pine Ridge, South Dakota, the tribal headquarters of the Oglala Sioux Tribe. 

Tribal officials said Cavagnaro was at San Xavier as recently as 2002-2005 and 2006-2007. He died in 2011.

"Our primary concern is to ensure that all Pascua Yaqui victims are given notice and the opportunity to receive the compensation and support they rightfully deserve," the statement said. "We understand that this process can be emotionally challenging, and we are committed to providing the necessary information and assistance. Taking the step to report a claim of sexual abuse is not easy. The strength and courage to make such a report often comes after many years of suffering."

 The tribe's statement, which included the current claims bar date of July 19, also included contact information for tribal victim advocate and legal support services.

Vatican to Publish ‘Instrumentum Laboris’ for October’s Synod on Synodality Meeting

The Vatican will publish next week the guiding document for discussions at the final assembly of the Catholic Church’s years-long Synod on Synodality.

The Instrumentum Laboris, or “working tool” for the upcoming 16th Ordinary General Assembly of the Synod of Bishops, will be presented at a July 9 press conference by Cardinals Mario Grech and Jean-Claude Hollerich, together with the special secretaries of the synodal assembly. 

Dubbed the “Instrumentum Laboris 2,” the document has been in preparation since early June, when approximately 20 experts in theology, ecclesiology, and canon law held a closed-door meeting to analyze synod reports from dioceses and religious communities.

The Instrumentum Laboris will guide the discussions at an assembly at the Vatican in October. The monthlong gathering is the second session of a two-part assembly of the Synod on Synodality. The first session was held in October 2023.

The second October assembly is a continuation of the multiyear Synod on Synodality, which began in October 2021 and has included stages of discernment and discussion at various levels of the Church. 

The fall meeting will bring together Catholic bishops, priests, religious, and laypeople from around the world to discuss topics included in the Instrumentum Laboris and to prepare the synod’s final document.

This is the second Instrumentum Laboris of the Synod on Synodality. A similar working document of 50 pages was published last year ahead of the synod’s October 2023 assembly.

The 2023 Vatican assembly produced a 41-page synthesis report, while the 2024 assembly is expected to vote on a “final report,” which will then be sent to Pope Francis for consideration.

The third phase of the Synod on Synodality — after “the consultation of the people of God” and “the discernment of the pastors” — will be “implementation,” according to organizers.

Arrested for Reading the Bible: Armenian Christian Sentenced to 10 Years in Iranian Prison

An Armenian citizen will serve 10 years in an Iranian prison after being prosecuted for alleged Christian evangelism.

An Iranian judge sentenced Hakop Gochumyan to prison in February 2024 for committing “illegal Christian activities.” 

The judge invoked Article 160 of Iran’s Islamic Penal Code, which allows for decisions based on “personal intuition.” 

Gochumyan appealed in early June as the conviction lacked evidence, but he was unsuccessful.

Gochumyan and his wife, Elisa Shahvardian, who is Iranian-Armenian, were arrested in August 2023 while they and their two children were staying at their friends’ house near Tehran. 

Agents from the Iranian Ministry of Intelligence searched the house and found several copies of the New Testament and Christian literature among their belongings.

Gochumyan and Shahvardian reportedly endured solitary confinement and psychological torture at Evin Prison in Tehran, according to Christian international aid agency Barnabas Aid. 

Shahvardian was released in October 2023, but Gochumyan remained imprisoned.

“Iran represses Christians; they are disproportionately arrested and detained and put under surveillance,” Nina Shea told the Register, a senior fellow and director of the Center for Religious Freedom at the Hudson Institute.

The U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom (USCIRF)’s 2024 “Annual Report” describes religious freedom in Iran as “extremely poor.” 

The U.S. government has redesignated Iran as a “country of particular concern” since 1999.

While the theocratic, authoritarian nation’s law permits Christians, Jews and Zoroastrians to practice their religion, they may not commit “any deviant educational or proselytizing activity that contradicts or interferes with the sacred law of Islam.”

Christians make up less than 1% of the nation’s total population, along with Jews, Yarsanis, Zoroastrians, Sabean-Mandaeans and Baha’is, according to the U.S. Department of State’s 2023 “Report on International Religious Freedom for Iran.”

Iran arrested 166 Christians in 2023, a third of whom were arrested for owning multiple copies of the Holy Bible, according to the 2024 annual report from Article18, a London-based nonprofit organization that advocates for persecuted Iranian Christians.

“There’s a great shift away from Islam by the populace; they’re becoming atheists, but there’s also the surge in evangelical Christianity, and this is a direct response to the oppressiveness of coerced religion in Iran, an arbitrary cruel regime that rules in the name of Shia Islam,” Shea said.

Despite the risk of persecution, evangelical Christianity is growing in Iran, with Open Doors having estimated nearly 800,000 Christian converts from Islam living in Iran in 2021.

According to Father Benedict Kiely, founder of Nasarean, a charity that advocates for persecuted Christians, the number of conversions to Christianity in Iran is “startling and encouraging,” and “many reports are emerging of Jesus or the Blessed Virgin Mary appearing in people’s dreams, causing them to convert.”

Shea said the religious shift is a “hopeful sign” that may signal a discrediting of the Iranian political system, as Islamic religious sites in many cities are increasingly empty.

While Christian converts from Islam make up most of the Christian population, they often worship in secret, evangelical house-churches for fear of being discovered for committing apostasy, according to Article18’s report.

Shea said many Christians receive training outside of Iran to evangelize, often through the illegal distribution of the New Testament.

Armenian-Iranian house-church pastor Joseph Shahzbanian was originally sentenced to 10 years in Evin in 2022 for “acting against national security by promoting Zionist Christianity.” 

He and five other Christians were arrested at a gathering and searched for Bibles and Christian literature. 

Iran shortened Shahzbanian’s sentence to two years after a retrial, and ultimately pardoned and released him in September 2023.

“As with all persecution, prayer is the priority, but also aid and advocacy,” Father Kiely said. “Christians are being persecuted more heavily than any other religious group in the world — thus, must be a higher priority for the Church.”

Article18 reports that, as of 2023, 21 Christians remain imprisoned in Iran.

Ex-Vatican auditor: Cardinal Pell's death "shrouded in mystery"

former Vatican auditor Libero Milone ...

The former Vatican auditor, Libero Milone, has described the death of Cardinal George Pell as "shrouded in mystery". 

"At his funeral, at his coffin, I promised him that we would bring the truth to light," said Milone according to a report in the newspaper "The Australian" on Wednesday (local time). 

The economic expert thus hinted at a connection between Pell's death and the property scandal in the Vatican. 

According to research by the Australian media outlet, there had been rumours in the Vatican for months about the last hours of Pell's life due to the unusual handling of his body. 

After the autopsy, his body was said to have been left "in disarray" rather than being prepared as is usually the case. 

After a routine hip joint operation on 10 January 2023 in Rome's Salvator Mundi Hospital, the Australian former curial cardinal died as a result of complications.

According to the newspaper, unnamed sources close to the Vatican claimed that the hospital's video surveillance was switched off at the time of Pell's death. 

A corresponding enquiry to the hospital had not been answered. There are also rumours that no doctor was available at the time of Pell's death. 

After the operation, 81-year-old Pell initially woke up in a stable condition and died somewhat unexpectedly a short time later from cardiac arrest.

In addition, Pell had been urged by close friends in the Vatican to have the medical procedure on his hip performed in Rome rather than in Australia. 

According to the newspaper, it is unusual that he was operated on in the private Salvator Mundi Hospital and not in the Gemelli Clinic, which is close to the Vatican. 

The Gemelli Hospital is the university hospital of a Catholic university in Rome. 

High-ranking Vatican employees are usually treated there.  

Pope Francis has also often stayed at the Gemelli Clinic for treatment.

After serving as Archbishop of Melbourne and Archbishop of Sydney, Pell was Prefect of the newly created Secretariat for Economic Affairs of the Curia from 2014 to 2019. 

In 2003, he was elevated to Cardinal by Pope John Paul II. From 2013 to 2018, Pell was a member of the Council of Cardinals, a close advisory body to Pope Francis. 

After the first allegations of cover-up abuse against Pell emerged in 2008, the Australian police launched an investigation into the sexual abuse of children by the cardinal during his time as a priest and archbishop in Australia in 2017. 

In 2018, Pell was found guilty, which was confirmed by an appeals court a year later. 

In 2020, however, this judgement against the cardinal was overturned by Australia's highest court due to a lack of evidence. 

Pell was imprisoned for over a year as an innocent man.

As an auditor for the Vatican, Milone was a close collaborator of Pell in the reorganisation of the church state's finances in the Vatican Secretariat for Economic Affairs. 

In 2017, Milone and another Vatican employee were dismissed by Archbishop Giovanni Angelo Becciu, then deputy of the Secretariat of State. 

The move was made in connection with the property scandal that has since been brought before Vatican courts. 

Becciu was sentenced to five and a half years in prison and a fine for fraud and embezzlement in 2023. 

Milone had sued the Secretariat of State for more than nine million euros in damages due to his dismissal, but the lawsuit was dismissed by a Vatican court in January 2024. 

Milone announced that he would appeal. 

The former auditor sees himself as a victim of corruption and conflicts of interest in the Vatican.

Report: No further restriction of the Traditional Latin Mass by the Vatican

Contrary to many rumours, no new document from the Dicastery for Divine Worship on the greater restriction of the Traditional Latin Mass is to be published for the time being. 

According to a report in the French newspaper "La Croix" on Monday, the Vatican has decided not to officially deny the rumours that have been circulating in traditionalist blogs for weeks. 

It is customary to leave rumours of this kind uncommented so as not to give them any weight, it added. 

A high-ranking Vatican representative described the rumours about a tightening of restrictions as "gossip" and "completely unfounded".

Several sources told the newspaper that the rumours were possibly due to a misinterpretation of Roman decisions on certain communities or institutes. 

One of these concerns the Missionaries of Divine Mercy in southern France.  

Rome has currently suspended the ordination of five seminarians indefinitely. It is being examined whether it would make sense to allow the prospective priests of the traditionalist community to celebrate Mass in the pre-conciliar form, as provided for in the community's statutes. 

Following the Moto Proprio "Traditionis custodes" of 2021, Pope Francis imposed a restriction on the Traditional Latin Mass. 

Priests who are ordained after its publication and wish to celebrate according to the Missale Romanum of 1962 must submit an application to the diocesan bishop. 

The latter must consult the Vatican before granting permission.

Reproach to Vatican representatives

According to a media report, German Cardinal Gerhard Ludwig Müller emphasised at a priestly ordination near Chartres at the weekend that the pre-conciliar liturgy does not meet with the approval of all Vatican representatives. 

The former Prefect of the Faith accused high-ranking representatives of the Dicastery for Divine Worship of persecuting old traditions such as the pre-conciliar liturgy because they saw "a greater danger to the unity of the Church" in this than in the "reinterpretation of the Creed". 

Among other things, Müller reported on a conversation with a representative of the Dicastery for Divine Worship, to whom he had reported on the faithfulness of young Catholics to the faith at the recent traditionalist pilgrimage in Chartres. 

The Vatican representative replied to Müller that this was "no reason at all to rejoice, as this Holy Mass was celebrated in the old Extraordinary Latin Rite".

Rumours have been circulating in traditionalist circles for several days that the Vatican wants to further restrict the celebration of the Traditional Latin Mass. 

The rumours were intensified after Pope Francis received the prior of the "Christ the King Institute", Gilles Wach, in audience last week. 

The institute celebrates the liturgy in the pre-conciliar form. Nothing was initially revealed about the content of the conversation. 

The institute later reported that the Pope had asked them to stick to their charism.

Probably no charges against Belgian bishops for cover-up

According to media reports, the Belgian federal public prosecutor's office will not press charges against the Bishop Roger Vangheluwe, who has been dismissed from the clergy and others responsible.  

In an interview with the newspaper "De Standaard" (Monday), the public prosecutor's office confirmed that the investigation into "Operation Chalice" had been completed and that the final application had been submitted to the competent investigating judge. 

The authority did not comment on the content, but with reference to sources, "De Standaard" reports that no alleged person responsible is to be charged, partly due to a lack of evidence and partly due to the statute of limitations.

As part of "Operation Chalice", the public prosecutor's office has been investigating the cover-up of abuse in the church since 2010. 

Dozens of victims have been questioned, church facilities have been searched and files and data storage media have been confiscated. 

A total of 68 suspects were identified. Pornography was found on Vangheluwe's devices, but no child pornography. 

Alongside Vangheluwe, the main suspect was the Brussels Archbishop and Cardinal Godfried Danneels, who died in 2019 and his successor André-Joseph Léonard were the focus of the investigation. 

Léonard was already sentenced to a fine of 10,000 euros in 2015 for negligence in a case of sexual abuse in the diocese of Namur.

The public prosecutor's office has already tried twice to end the investigation and bring the case to court. In 2015 and 2020, several of those affected called for further investigations. 

In April, a parliamentary committee of enquiry, which was set up in 2023 after the broadcast of a TV documentary about abuse in the church, found that the judiciary had failed in "Operation Chalice". 

The final report therefore called for a further committee of enquiry to investigate "Operation Chalice".

Sculpture of the "birthing Mary" in Linz Cathedral destroyed

The sculpture of the Virgin Mary giving birth in St Mary's Cathedral in Linz has been destroyed. 

As reported by the online portal ooe.orf.at and confirmed by the Diocese of Linz, the head of the sculpture was sawn off on Monday morning. 

The police have been called in. 

"Whoever removed the head of the sculpture acted very brutally," said the artist of the statue, Esther Strauß. This shows "that there are still people who question women's right to their own bodies. We must take a firm stand against this," said the artist.

The sculpture called "crowning" shows a woman giving birth sitting on a rock on a plinth in a chapel in St Mary's Cathedral in Linz. "Most portraits of the Virgin Mary were made by men and have therefore often served patriarchal interests," said the artist herself, explaining the background to the sculpture, which can no longer be viewed.

Episcopal vicar dismayed

Johann Hintermaier, Episcopal Vicar for Education, Art and Culture, also expressed his dismay in a statement: "We were aware that we were also provoking discussion with this installation. If we have hurt people's religious feelings, we are sorry, but I strongly condemn this violent act of destruction, the refusal to engage in dialogue and the attack on the freedom of art."

The modern statue of the Virgin Mary is part of the "DonnaStage" project, which, to mark the 100th anniversary of the consecration of St Mary's Cathedral, is exploring issues relating to women's roles, family images and gender equality in art installations, workshops and discussions. 

The sculpture "crowning" was part of a series entitled "Artistic positions on the Holy Family" and should have been on display until 16 July.

According to Martina Resch, theologian and co-initiator of "DonnaStage", the aim of the project is to create a space for critical discourse and to promote the ability of religion and the church to embrace plurality. 

Art opens up the opportunity to develop new perspectives in order to critically reflect on the foundations of faith. 

"The sculpture by Esther Strauß is a very poetic work that shows the natural birth of Jesus. Mary is shown in her vulnerability but also in her strength," says Resch.

Opus Dei in Central Europe reforms itself

The reform of the Catholic organisation Opus Dei is progressing. 

According to a statement published by the "Katholische Nachrichten-Agentur" (KNA) on Monday, Opus Dei in Central Europe will focus more on regionalisation and greater involvement of all members in future - a first for the personal prelature, which has so far been run rather centrally and by the celibate "numeraries".

The adjustments had become necessary after Pope Francis issued a reorganisation for Opus Dei in 2022. 

The Pope justified his move with the desire to "protect the original charism of the movement".  

A year later, Francis withdrew some of their other rights due to their special status as the only personal prelature of the Catholic Church.

At the end of 2022, some European regions merged to form a streamlined "Central Europe" administrative unit. Its members are now to be allowed to play a greater role in decision-making processes. 

Following a synodal process among the members, two regional assemblies in Austria and Germany have now developed further reform steps. 

According to the Central European region of Opus Dei, married members (supernumeraries) should also be more involved in educational tasks in future, i.e. in "personal spiritual guidance, leading retreats or participating in organisational aspects such as the economic management of educational institutions".

Renewing the founding spirit

The regional vicar of Opus Dei in Central Europe, Christoph Bockamp, sees the changes initiated by the Pope as an opportunity to "renew the founding spirit" and to be able to build on "the dynamism of the early days with its minimum of structure" in the future.

Opus Dei ("Work of God") was founded in 1928 by the Spanish priest Josemaria Escriva de Balaguer (1902-1975) , who was later canonised, as a Catholic lay movement. 

The female branch was founded in 1930. 

The organisation also has a good 2,000 priests of its own. Members of Opus Dei are required to help shape society by living a consistently Christian life. 

Opus Dei runs several universities, including the Pontifical University of Santa Croce in Rome. 

In Germany, there is a branch of its IESE Business School, a management school at the University of Navarra. 

It is recognised worldwide as one of the leading institutions in its field.

"Digital detox": Seminary restricts internet time

The seminary of the Archdiocese of Saint Louis in the USA has drastically restricted the online time of seminarians in the preparatory propaedeutic year. 

According to a recent decision by the seminary management, seminarians will not have their own computers during their first year of preparation for the priesthood and are only allowed to use their smartphones for four hours on Saturdays, writes the US magazine "America" in an article on the current state of priestly training in the USA. 

There are several reasons for this period of "digital detox", i.e. abstaining from the internet and social media, according to "America", citing the head of the seminary, Paul Hoesing. If the young men spent less time on the internet, they would have more time to learn how to interact with people, for example in the neighbourhood of the seminary, and have conversations. 

"These men develop a social acumen that we haven't seen in previous groups because this 'digital detox' makes them humanly and personally available in a special way," explains the priest trainer.

In addition, abstinence from the internet is intended to prevent the seminarians from being influenced by traditionalist websites and influencers. 

According to Joshua Rodrigue, who heads the Notre Dame Seminary in New Orleans, this is about the danger of a "parallel" or "shadow education" of the young men, which the seminary management must constantly keep an eye on. 

The seminarians used to read relevant blogs, but currently YouTube videos by sedevacantists such as Taylor Marshall or the controversial psychologist Jordan Peterson are more popular, the magazine quotes Rodrigue as saying. 

The aim of the seminary is to sensitise candidates for the priesthood to different approaches to ecclesiastical and theological issues. Many, however, have a desire for clarity and a firm hold on church doctrine.

Dealing responsibly with pornography

The "digital detox" is also intended to enable a more responsible approach to pornography. 

Many US seminarians have problems with their porn consumption and there are addictions, "America" quotes psychologist Maribel Rodriguez Laguna, an expert in the psychological support and therapy of theology students. 

Rodriguez also sees a problem in the fact that many seminarians in the USA come from upper middle class families. Through their "snowplough education", their parents have tried to pave a path to success for the young men that is as problem-free as possible and have removed many obstacles from their path in life. 

"We have young men here who sometimes don't know a lot of practical things, like how to budget responsibly, save money, do laundry, make the bed."

The US bishops published revised rules for priestly training in 2022, which came into force in 2023. 

The "digital detox" in many seminaries during the newly introduced propaedeutic year is one of the innovations. 

The adapted statutes were made necessary by the implementation of the "Ratio fundamentalis", the general rules for priestly training published by the Vatican in 2016. 

They must be implemented in the local churches.

Viganò accuses Pope Francis of schism and heresy


Archbishop Carlo Maria Viganò, accused of schism by the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, is going on the counter-offensive and is now accusing the Pope himself of schism and heresy. 

At the weekend the former nuncio published a manifesto on the website of his foundation, in which he reaffirms that he does not recognise the authority of Pope Francis and his Curia. 

The manifesto is dated 28 June, the last day of the defence period set for him by the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith a fortnight ago. 

Viganò does not want his statement to be understood as a personal defence, but as a "defence of the Holy Church of Christ": "Before my brothers in the episcopate and the entire body of the Church, I accuse Jorge Mario Bergoglio of heresy and schism, and as a heretic and schismatic I demand that he be condemned and removed from the throne he has unworthily occupied for over eleven years."

The new declaration is headed with the words "J'accuse" ("I accuse"). 

Viganò is referring to the open letter by French writer Émile Zola, with which he brought about a turning point in the Dreyfus affair in 1898 and which is synonymous with courageous public statements against the abuse of power. 

The French officer Alfred Dreyfus had been wrongly accused of treason.

Honouring the schismatic Archbishop Lefebvre

According to canon law, the Pope cannot actually be brought before a judge. For Viganò, however, this is not an obstacle: his accusation does not contradict the principle, "because it is clear that a heretic, if he is not able to assume the papal office, is not above the prelates who judge him". 

Specifically, Viganò, who has previously attracted attention for supporting a number of conspiracy myths, accuses Pope Francis of, among other things, his call for vaccination against the coronavirus and the secret agreement between China and the Holy See.

Once again, Viganò refers to Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre and quotes the opponent of the liturgical reform, who was later excommunicated due to his schism and unauthorised episcopal ordinations, with his testimony before the Holy Office, the predecessor authority of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith. 

Lefebvre had said in 1979 that he could not help thinking that he was the one who should pass judgement on the Office. 

Furthermore, Viganò does not recognise the authority of the Dicastery of the Faith, its prefect and the Pope.

Maximum penalty of dismissal from the clergy looms

Now that the defence period has expired, the proceedings against Viganò can continue. The dicastery had announced that it would provide him with a public defence lawyer if he did not appoint his own legal representation. It is not yet known who has been entrusted with this task. 

The offence of schism is punishable by excommunication, and other penalties such as bans on residence, fines and a ban on wearing clerical clothing can also be imposed. Further penalties, including dismissal from the clergy, can be imposed for "persistent rebelliousness" or particularly serious offences. 

An offence is automatically punished as soon as it is committed, but it only takes full effect once it has been formally established by a criminal trial or a penal decree. 

Schism is one of the serious offences against the faith for which the dicastery of faith is responsible for as a judicial is responsible for.

Viganò was in the diplomatic service of the Holy See from 1973, most recently as nuncio in the USA from 2011 to 2016. 

After the end of his term of office, he became one of the harshest critics of Pope Francis, whom he accused of personal Francis, whom he accused of serious personal failings in his dealings with Theodore McCarrick, who has since been dismissed from the cardinalate and clergy, who has since been dismissed from the cardinalate and clergy. 

In recent years, Viganò has become increasingly radicalised and has spread conspiracy myths, particularly in connection with the coronavirus pandemic; politically, he has spoken out in favour of former US President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin.

Last December, he announced that he would open a to found a traditionalist seminary in central Italy.

No consecration because of Traditional Latin Mass: Bishop emphasises further dialogue with Rome

Despite Rome's current blockade regarding the ordination of seminarians from a traditionalist community, the dialogue with the Roman dicasteries is to be continued. 

This was stated by the coadjutor bishop of the French diocese of Fréjus-Toulon, François Touvet, at a priestly ordination, according to a statement on the diocese's website on Saturday. 

"The dialogue will continue with their superiors, the competent Roman dicasteries (Divine Worship and Consecrated Life), in liaison with Cardinal Aveline, our Metropolitan Archbishop". 

Touvet also emphasised his attachment to the seminarians and reaffirmed his trust in the Superior General Jean-Raphaël Dubrule and his community. "They also know that I accompany them in their concern for obedience and communion with the Apostolic See. I am counting on everyone's trust in the Church," said the bishop.

The background to this is that Rome is currently blocking the ordination of seminarians from the traditionalist community of the Missionaries of Divine Charity. 

Five seminarians have been waiting for their ordination as deacons for over a year, one even two. 

One problem seems to be the celebration of the Traditional Latin Mass, which is provided for in the community's statutes. 

However, after many discussions with the relevant authorities in the Vatican, it emerged, according to the community, that the problem lies not only in the ordination rite, but also in the future priests' ability to celebrate the pre-conciliar liturgy. Alongside mercy and mission among Muslims, this is one of the charisms of the community. 

However, after the Motu Proprio "Traditionis custodes" (2021), the Vatican severely restricted the pre-conciliar liturgy. 

Priests who are ordained after its publication and wish to celebrate according to the Missale Romanum of 1962 must submit an application to the diocesan bishop. He must consult the Vatican before granting permission.

The traditionalist community "Société des missionnaires de la miséricorde divine" was founded in Toulon in 2005. 

According to the diocese, it has 22 members, including seven priests, one deacon, two brothers and 12 seminarians. 

The community has diocesan rights and is therefore subordinate to the diocesan bishop.