A MAN who experienced what he considered to be an
exorcism that sought to “rid him of his
homosexual inclinations” has had every aspect of his complaint against a church in Sheffield upheld, four years after it was lodged.
An independent investigation of St Thomas’s, Philadelphia, in respect of a complaint by Matthew Drapper, was published by the diocese of Sheffield on Monday evening, after it was leaked to the BBC. It is dated 30 November 2023.
Mr Drapper, who was a volunteer at the church from 2013 to 2016, first complained both to the church and the diocese of Sheffield
in 2019. He said that he had been forced to step down from volunteering
for the student leadership team at the church, after stating that he
was considering dating as a gay
man, and that he had been subject to prayer ministry — which he
considered to be an exorcism — that attempted to change his sexual
orientation from gay to straight.
He was told in a letter from a
trustee of the church that his complaint had not been upheld, and that
there was “no evidence to substantiate” his claims. But the independent
investigation, commissioned by the diocese of Sheffield (News, 11 February 2022) and conducted by Linda Richardson and Jane Sarre, safeguarding consultants at Barnardo’s, has upheld every aspect of his complaint.
The
report, from which names have been redacted, reveals the extent to
which the church resisted participating in the investigation. In
February 2022, a spokesperson for the church told BBC Yorkshire: “St
Thomas’s, Philadelphia, is a caring and generous church community which
does not engage in conversion therapy. We welcome the independent
investigation initiated by the diocese into these allegations of eight
years ago, and will participate in it.”
But the report records
that, three months later, the church referred to legal advice “that the
issue was not a safeguarding matter, and they were therefore not obliged
to comply with Core Group decisions or provide us with any documents or
reports linked to MD’s complaint as there were data sharing
implications”.
Some
individuals named in the complaint declined to be involved, talking of
“concerns about mental health and personal implications if they were to
contribute to the investigation”.
In a second report
about existing safeguarding arrangements at the church, the
investigators raise a number of concerns. Four years after Mr Drapper’s
complaint, there was “still no formalised recording system which
captured what safeguarding concerns or complaints had been made, how
these had been addressed and by whom”.
ST THOMAS’s, Philadelphia, was planted out of St Thomas’s, Crookes, an Anglican-Baptist
local ecumenical partnership, in 1998. Since 2009, when it was joined
by the King’s Centre, a Sheffield house-church, it has been known as
Network Church Sheffield.
Officially registered with the Charity
Commission as the Philadelphia Network Limited, it is part of the
Yorkshire Baptist Association and the diocese of Sheffield, although
there is no Local Ecumenical Partnership currently in place. Until 2019,
the church offered young adults an intern opportunity, called FORM.
Mr
Drapper joined FORM in 2013, and, having completed the first year, was
expecting to return for the second year. The investigators were
satisfied that there was “a clear expectation by both parties” that this
would occur, and said that it was “common knowledge” that he described
himself as a gay man during this first year.
In 2014, an
invitation to attend the second year of FORM was not extended to Mr
Drapper. He was informed, he told the investigation, that “having a
leader who believed in gay relationships would be a bad influence on
first-year interns”. During this period, he wrote blogs “about his
emerging views about gay theology”, the report says.
While he was
not invited to take part in this second year, Mr Drapper was invited to
join the student team as a volunteer, liaising with and meeting
university students. He was later informed, he told the investigation,
that if he chose to continue “promoting” gay relationships online and in
person, he would not be allowed to continue as a volunteer.
The
report upholds Mr Drapper’s complaint that, besides not being invited to
complete FORM part two, in 2015, he was forced to step down from
volunteering with the student leadership team at the church, after he
stated that he was considering dating as a gay man.
A
SIGNIFICANT aspect of the review concerns the church’s transparency
about its views on sexuality and leadership. The consultants write that
they “do not disagree” with the argument that it was “considered
appropriate that individuals were asked to uphold and abide by the
Church’s teachings”. In their response to Mr Drapper’s complaint, the
church argued that he was “aware of the Church’s theological position”.
Mr
Drapper’s said that he was “never given any indication that his
sexuality or views would be a barrier to him holding any leadership
positions in the Church”, the report says. The church has acknowledged
that there was no document in place at the time that clearly stated
this. It was, the investigation was told, “unspoken but understood, that
a gay person who could or would not commit to celibacy would not be
offered a leadership role in the Church”.
While the investigators
were told by one redacted contributor that “people who describe
themselves as gay were and are welcome and accepted in the church”, it
includes recollections that challenge this account. One person recalled
“celebrations in the congregation because a parent stood up and spoke of
an adult in their family, who had been ‘delivered from the sin of
homosexuality’”.
At the time of Mr Drapper’s complaint, the church
did not have a complaints policy, and the consultants write of “a sense
that the Church chose to quieten or discourage any open discussion
around the impact of their doctrine on individuals who wanted to openly
describe themselves as gay”.
They express disappointment that
“some key church leaders named in MD’s complaint refused or did not feel
able to meet with us to share their views and observations about MD’s
complaint, even though many continue to actively work in nearby churches
or projects.”
They uphold Mr Drapper’s complaint that he was not welcomed at the church after his removal from the student leadership team.
THE
investigation concludes: “It is clear from information provided to us
that deliverance ministries in relation to homosexuality was endorsed
and supported by the Church.”
It provides an account of a weekend
away for FORM interns (“Encounter with God”), during which interns were
asked to complete a questionnaire and provide “highly personal
information about their past life and childhood; they were asked to
detail any experience of abuse and describe their struggles and traumas
and any challenges they were trying to address in their adult lives”.
The
consultants observe that such disclosure “to individuals who have no
training in understanding or assessing the impact of vicarious traumas
and disclosures carries a significant risk of not only triggering and
retraumatising the individual but also rendering some individuals even
more vulnerable”.
The completion of this questionnaire was
followed by an individualised prayer-ministry session, documented in
notes taken by both Mr Drapper and an intern. It entailed “Sozo”
prayers: a model of deliverance prayer created by Bethel Church, a
megachurch in Redding, California.
Mr
Drapper recorded in his notes that he was told that he was “not taking
responsibility for his own choices, and this was due to the fact that he
had inherited from his family a ‘Hereditary Demon’.”
He was told
that “he needed to renounce his homosexual lifestyle and needed to speak
to the demons inside him as if they ‘were a dog’.”
The intern’s
notes refer to prayer calling out demons, and Mr Drapper recorded being
told that demons could be seen “leaving hand in hand, marching through
the window”. He was asked to repeat a prayer “which would indicate he
had broken off ‘his agreement with Satan’ and which would free him of
his homosexuality”.
The session had a “lasting impact on his
welfare and mental health”, the report concludes. It was “consistent
with what many individuals would describe as a form of exorcism which
could fall under the definition of spiritual abuse”.
While
focusing on Mr Drapper’s experience, the report raises concerns about
the wider fall-out of this ministry. It refers to a lack of support in
place in the aftermath of these “highly charged and emotionally intense”
sessions. Some contributors to the investigation described “having a
visceral/physical reaction to the experience, which was then regarded by
the prayer team as proof of spirit possession”.
The consultants
write of their contact with others involved in the church: “We were
struck by how many of those who spoke with us referred to their own
vulnerabilities at the time, either because they had family issues, were
lonely or just seeking ‘a home’ . . . it could be suggested they were
all vulnerable in some way.”
A desire “to be accepted and to fit
in” was a factor, they suggest, “which influenced why some individuals
looked to suppress their identity and ‘consent’ to practices or prayers
which sought to remove the sins they were told they carried.”
A
belief that demons cause homosexuality, and that rituals can allow gay
individuals to be “healed”, is “not unusual or confined to this church”,
the report observes.
“There are many other churches who believe
in demonic possession, but most have strict criteria that must be
followed when such spirits are discerned and/or when an ecclesiastical
exorcism is considered necessary.”
They say that, in the Church of
England, exorcisms may be carried out only by those authorised by the
Bishop. There is, their report says, “no evidence that the church has
ever sought permission from the Bishop in this respect or has ever
needed to do so”.
IT
WAS not until December 2020, a year after the initial complaint was
made, that the diocese of Sheffield, in line with C of E guidance,
decided to convene a core group to address the safeguarding concerns
raised by Mr Drapper’s complaint. Both staffing changes and the impact
of the pandemic are referred to as possible causes of the delay.
Besides
looking at Mr Drapper’s complaint, Barnardo’s was commissioned to
“review and assess current safeguarding arrangements in the Church to
ensure that all areas of student and prayer ministry are conducted
safely and without causing harm to any individual whatever their
sexuality or theological position”.
This second report is dated 26
February 2024. In contrast to the response to the first part of their
investigation, the consultants speak of a “constructive approach and a
willingness to work with us to examine safeguarding arrangements in the
Church and highlight where policies, procedures, and practice, going
forward needed to change or be strengthened.”
The report
identifies a number of changes that have taken place in recent years.
Prayer ministry at the church ceased during the pandemic in 2020, and
was only resumed in September 2023. It now takes place only at the front
of the church after services. A prayer ministry protocol has been
co-produced by church leaders and volunteers.
An executive summary
records that the church “now makes clear that it neither permits nor
endorses prayers which seek to change a person’s sexual orientation and
prayer ministry teams are not permitted to refer to or discuss a
person’s sexual identity”.
FORM no longer exists, Encounter with
God weekends no longer take place, and the review was told that “interns
are not required, and would not in future be required, to share deeply
personal information about their past experiences and vulnerabilities.”
The
consultants write of being told “on several occasions by different
people that what happened ten years ago [in relation to MD’s complaint]
was ‘then’, but the Church now has a different [and better] ‘feel’ under
the current church leader.” While they were “unable to observe how
prayer ministry is delivered”, they were “assured that practice has
changed significantly in recent years”.
In their report, however,
they raise several ongoing concerns. It remains unclear, for example,
“how the Church will, going forward, ensure that prayer sessions are
delivered in line with the prayer ministry protocol and that
individuals, whatever their personal beliefs, comply with the Church’s
policy and procedures on this issue”.
Among
the 22 recommendations is that those delivering prayer ministry “should
be able to demonstrate, through training, a trauma informed approach
which understands that, however carefully managed, prayer sessions can
re-trigger past traumas, and this can leave a person vulnerable”.
The
reviewers also uncovered “a lack of accountability and managerial
scrutiny at Board level in how safeguarding concerns are identified,
addressed, and managed”. It would appear, they write, that there are “no
records (other than some email trails) of discussions and decisions
taken. We found Board minutes to be so minimal that we were unable to
determine, from a safeguarding perspective, what information was shared
with the Board and what discussions took place.”
Four years after
Mr Drapper’s complaint, there was “still no formalised recording system
which captured what safeguarding concerns or complaints had been made,
how these had been addressed and by whom”.
The consultants write:
“We were unable to view any case records and were informed that there
had been relatively few safeguarding concerns or complaints reported in
recent years. This is most unusual in an organisation of this size and
especially one located in a relatively disadvantaged area.
“The
lack of reported safeguarding concerns or complaints could suggest any
of the following: the reporting process is not well known or staff and
volunteers fear using it, that there are complaints or concerns, but
they are not reported to leaders or managers or there are reported
concerns, but they are not recognised as being related to safeguarding.”
It
diagnoses “a somewhat restrictive approach to safeguarding, tightly
applying legal definitions of vulnerability and need and using
thresholds regarding those at risk as opposed to the more nuanced and
contextual application omen used in social care and not including the
all-encompassing safeguarding requirements of the Charity Commission”.
The
consultants warn: “The way in which the complaint made by Matthew
Drapper was handled, for example, over a four-year period has brought
into sharp focus that safeguarding procedures in the Church were not in
line with the Charity Commission regulation . . .
“We were unable
to identify any clear system or process by which the Board can
demonstrate robust managerial oversight or scrutiny of its safeguarding
arrangements.”
They were, however, “encouraged by the church’s readiness to support the development of a more robust approach to safeguarding”.
On
the church’s current position on sexuality, the consultants were told
that the congregation included people who were “openly gay and some who
lived in same-sex relationships”. But there was agreement that, “if
individuals did not believe and could not endorse the Church’s values
and beliefs, they should not hold or be invited to hold leadership
positions in the Church”.
It is, the report says, “still not clear how new members of the congregation would be made aware of this”.
ON
MONDAY, the BBC reported that Miriam Cates, the Conservative candidate
for Penistone and Stocksbridge and a former biology teacher in
Sheffield, was a member of St Thomas’s, Philadelphia, between 2003 and
2018, and a trustee from 2016 to 2018.
The BBC article referred to
social-media posts from Mrs Cates made in November 2012, “which suggest
she attended a conference hosted by a third party at the church which
Mr Drapper has described as an ‘exorcism training weekend’.”
Audio
from the conference, which the BBC has not verified, suggests that it
involved practising a prayer of repentance “for giving place to any
demons . . . including demons of . . . homosexuality . . . lesbianism”.
Mrs
Cates told the BBC that she “did attend a conference at the Church in
2012, although I have no diary records of the time, and, to the best of
my recollection, this was a standard church conference with a series of
seminars, Bible teachings and worship.
“I
have no recollection of the content or title of any of the seminars
that took place at the conference because it took place well over a
decade ago.”
She said: “I do not and have never advocated for what
is referred to as ‘gay conversion therapy’. I have never participated
in such activities, and I was not aware — nor was there any way that I
could have been aware — of Mr Drapper’s allegations.”
ON
MONDAY, a statement from the diocese of Sheffield said: “We have been
working urgently for the past month towards the publication of a lightly
redacted version of both stages of the report, and have been able to
publish it on our website today.
“The trustees of Network Church
Sheffield have accepted both parts of the report in full, and have
developed and put into effect a comprehensive action plan to implement
the report’s recommendations. . .
“We deeply regret that the
process has taken so long and understand the frustrations of those who
have been affected. We apologise unreservedly to the survivor for the
distress this has caused and to anyone else similarly affected by such
practices in the past. The Diocese of Sheffield believes, along with the
wider Church of England, that conversion therapy is unethical,
potentially harmful and has no place in the modern world.”
Network
Church Sheffield (NCS) told the BBC: “We have accepted the outcomes of
the first investigation and are saddened that eight years ago one of our
community was not cared for in the way we would have liked. We
sincerely apologised to them for this.
“Whilst the leadership of
the church has changed, we recognise there are significant lessons to be
learned and we are determined to learn them.”