Thursday, July 04, 2024

Cardinal Müller becomes a cardinal priest – promotion after ten years

The German Cardinal Gerhard Ludwig Müller was promoted from cardinal deacon to cardinal priest. 

On Monday, the consistory headed by Pope Francis decided to elevate Müller to the class of cardinal priests at his request, the Vatican announced. 

Müller's titular deaconry, Sant'Agnese in Agone, will be temporarily elevated to the status of titular church during his term of office ("pro hac vice"). 

After ten years in office, cardinal deacons have the right to ask the Pope for elevation to cardinal priest and for a titular church ("optatio"). 

Müller was appointed to the College of Cardinals on 22 February 2014 into the College of Cardinals. 

After his retirement as Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith Müller is now judge at the Apostolic Signaturethe highest court of the Church.

The College of Cardinals is divided into the three classes of cardinal bishops, cardinal priests and cardinal priests. are organised. 

However, the classes are independent of the actual degree of ordination. As a rule, all cardinals are bishops. Cardinal bishops are cardinals who are assigned the title of one of the suburbicarian bishoprics in the neighbourhood of Rome. 

However, the leadership of these dioceses is separate from the holders of the titles; they each have their own diocesan bishops. In addition, the patriarchs of the Eastern Catholic Churches who have been elevated to cardinals belong to the cardinal bishops. 

Pope Francis has also decreed that the episcopal class be expanded by five further members without a suburbicarian title. 

Cardinal priests are cardinals who are assigned a titular church in Rome; cardinal deacons are assigned a diaconate. Müller was the only one of the German cardinals in this class. The shift to the priestly class changes the order of honour, but does not entail any further privileges.

Müller's deaconry of Sant'Agnese in Agone was last the titular church of a cardinal priest from 1517 to 1654, until the title was relinquished. It is only since 1998 that the church has once again held the title of cardinal deacon. 

In addition to Müller, Cardinal James Michael Harveythe archpriest of the Patriarchal Basilica of St Paul Outside the Walls, and Lorenzo Baldisseri, the Secretary General Emeritus of the Synod of Bishops, were also admitted to the class of cardinal priests. 

Harvey was previously the longest-serving cardinal deacon under the age of 80 and thus had the task of announcing the election of the new pope after a conclave. 

This task now falls to the Prefect of the Apostolic Signature, Cardinal Dominique Mamberti.

Ex-Missionaries of Charity allege culture of abuse and neglect

Habit to Enter China, Superior General ...

Almost three decades after her death, Saint Teresa of Kolkata, commonly and affectionately referred to as “Mother Teresa,” remains an international icon of charity and among the most beloved figures in the world, probably the Catholic Church’s most celebrated 20th century personality who wasn’t a pope.

Named Time’s “Person of the Year” in 1975, Mother Teresa also founded a religious order, the Missionaries of Charity, which has become one of the Catholic Church’s most celebrated institutions, almost universally hailed for its service to the “poorest of the poor.”

Yet despite the society’s international fame, some former members have recounted a shadow side. They describe an internal culture at times marked by abuse and neglect, characterized by what they call a personalistic and pre-Vatican II style of leadership.

These former members, some of whom left decades ago and others who exited more recently, assert the order occasionally exhibits dynamics sadly familiar from other chapters of Catholicism’s abuse scandals. They claim they were routinely bullied, exploited and abused by authorities, while the only strategy when difficulties arose was to stay silent.

Membership in the Missionaries of Charity runs to roughly 5,750 sisters around the world, making it difficult to assess how systemic the abuses described in these reports actually are. One striking point, however, is that almost without exception, the ex-members who have come forward say they’ve done so not to damage the order, but rather to help it to realize the best version of itself.

A Vatican spokesman did not respond to a Crux request for comment on this article. A spokesman for the Missionaries of Charity, however, described the complaints as “old grievances” and characterized an earlier draft of this report as “badly biased” and “unfair.”

Allegations of abuse

The Missionaries of Charity were founded in October 1950 by Mother Teresa, then-Agnes Gonxha Bojaxhiu, an Albanian former Sister of Loreto who left when she felt moved by God to live a special vocation working among the poor on the streets of Calcutta, now known as Kolkata.

As of 2023, the Missionaries of Charity served in 139 countries, assisting the poor and homeless, orphans and abandoned infants, disabled adults and children, women in difficulty, the elderly, and AIDS patients, among many others.

Allegations of abuses of power and authority inside the order, as well as sexual abuse, have surfaced periodically over the last few decades.

The 2008 book Hope Endures by Colette Livermoore, a former Missionary of Charity from Australia who left in 1983 after 11 years, described a climate of excessive control and unthinking obedience during her time in the order.

Five years later, the 2013 memoir An Unquenchable Thirst by Mary Johnson, an American who spent 20 years in the Missionaries of Charity before leaving after having a relationship with a sister and then falling in love with a priest, recounted similar experiences.

That book helped inspire a 10-part podcast series in 2021 titled, “The Turning: The Sisters Who Left.” In the podcast, a handful of former sisters spoke of depression, sexual abuse, feelings of being trapped, and thoughts of suicide.

Both Livermoore and Johnson declined Crux requests to be interviewed for this article. A group of roughly a dozen ex-members who did speak to Crux, however, representing different age groups and periods of time within the order, largely confirmed many of the claims made in the earlier books and podcast.

These former members concede that many problems consisted of “micro-aggressions” from superiors and fellow sisters, meaning relatively trivial transgressions, but which they say added up over time and became normalized.

They described life inside the society as isolated, saying they had almost no contact with their families, they were barred from having close friendships, and they could do nothing without a superior’s permission, with their every action being closely monitored.

Sisters’ passports, they said, were held by superiors, and they were only able to travel for one month every 10 years to visit their families. Any letters sent were reviewed by superiors, and phone calls, even to family, had to be made in the presence of a superior.

In other instances, members said issues were more serious, describing a culture in which boundary violations in terms of physical contact were tolerated or explained away, and in which sexual abuse could unfold over considerable periods without being detected or punished. Alleged perpetrators were sometimes transferred rather than held accountable, they say, and alleged victims were encouraged to remain silent.

In another dimension to the story wearily familiar from other abuse scandals, ex-members describe attempting to bring these problems to the attention of authorities, both inside the order itself and also in the Vatican, generally without any response.

Experiences

Several former members shared their experiences with Crux on the record, while others chose to do so only on the condition of anonymity, fearing potential repercussions.

Anna Adamčikova, a Slovakian who now lives in Chile, left the Missionaries of Charity in 2018, receiving a final dispensation from her vows in 2022 after 27 years inside of the society, including serving as a superior and formator. She told Crux that she was anxious about whether to leave, but felt she could no longer stay because “my conscience would not allow it.”

Among other things, Adamčikova said she was routinely insulted and belittled by her superiors and was forced to eat rotten and expired food, even when it made her feel sick, so she could offer the physical suffering it caused to Jesus.

She said she knew of many sisters who worked while they were ill, and that after contracting tuberculosis, the Missionaries of Charity did not want to pay for her treatment or hospital stay, despite having more than enough resources to do so.

Adamčikova also charges that depression among sisters was common, and that some experienced thoughts of suicide.

Another former sister, Katie Langone, told Crux that minor physical boundary violations among the sisters were routine, and that “everyone knew someone” who had experienced them. She said that she herself received unwanted advances from a fellow sister in formation, but that the situation was resolved when she raised concerns.

Langone, who entered the Missionaries of Charity in 2007, said she also endured harsh bullying and psychological abuse from her superiors in various houses during her seven years in the order. When she requested spiritual direction, Langone said she was instead offered counselling, and had to beg for the money for each session from the sister in charge of the accounting.

She said she was pressured to take medication and to see a special psychiatrist, who prescribed even more medication, and that despite complying with all of her superiors’ requests, she was still “humiliated” by them, and was denied permission to renew her vows in 2014 with no explanation, resulting in her expulsion.

Another former member, identified as “Monica” in this article, said the sisters were regularly verbally abused by authorities. She also claimed to have been the target of unwanted sexual advances from a fellow sister, whom she said had made similar overtures to other members. When she brought the situation to the attention of superiors, Monica said they moved the sister to a different house whenever the problem arose.

Monica also decried what she said was an unhealthy attachment to suffering and harmful penances, including the controversial custom of daily self-flagellation for sisters who had completed an initial period of formation. While popular in previous centuries and still practiced in some Catholic groups, self-flagellation has fallen increasingly out of favor since the Second Vatican Council.

Another former member, referred to as “Isabel” in this article, says she was the victim of a violent physical assault by a priest outside of the order. When she confided the incident to Mother Teresa, she claims she was told to forget about it and to return to work as if nothing had happened, and that it was their duty to “protect the church, to protect priests.”

Isabel said her superiors acted as if the incident were her fault, as if she had led the priest on. She said the pressure took its toll, and after eventually leaving the community, she said she was diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder.

“Catrina,” who left the order years ago, said she chose to go due to the isolation of sisters and the lack of recourse when problems arise, telling Crux that she’s in contact with sisters today who still leave the community depressed and requiring psychological treatment.

Several former sisters complained they were given little help to start over with when they left. At times, they reported, they were provided as little as $500, even after decades of service.

According to Catrina, these experiences add up.

“It’s a system, a system of thought that launches obedience to the bitter end,” she said.

Perhaps the most prominent dissident voice about the Missionaries of Charity is a former Russian nun named Eli Anastasia Demidova, who left in 2014 and has publicly claimed she was sexually abused by a superior, and who now identifies as a man. Due to controversies surrounding her claims, however, Crux has relied on other sources.

Years of Complaints

Former members Crux spoke with have said they and others have attempted to bring concerns about problems inside of the Missionaries of Charity to church authorities, including the Vatican, for years, but with no concrete results.

Catrina said she accompanied another former sister who left to make a complaint at the Vatican in the late 1990s, around the time of Mother Teresa’s death in 1997. Later, she said, she was able to send a letter to Pope Francis in 2018, insisting that the issues she’d perceived two decades before were still present.

Shortly after the letter was delivered, she said she got a phone call from Spanish Archbishop José Rodríguez Carballo, who until last October served as secretary of the Vatican’s Dicastery for Institutes of Consecrated Life and Societies of Apostolic Life, also called the “Dicastery for Religious.”

After that call, Catrina said she had a sit-down meeting with Carballo in which he said he was “very concerned” about the issue, because she was not the only one who made had made a complaint and feared a potential public scandal involving the Missionaries of Charity, given the society’s global fame.

Carballo did not respond to a Crux request for comment prior to his departure as secretary.

Similarly, a Chilean former priest named Eugenio de la Fuente, who left the priesthood in 2021 over objections to what he saw as the church’s “indifference” to abuses of conscience and authority, told Crux he also brought concerns about the Missionaries of Charity to Pope Francis in 2018.

A victim of notorious Chilean abuser Fernando Karadima, de la Fuente was present in Rome when the Chilean bishops were summoned by Pope Francis in 2018 following a massive national clerical abuse scandal which prompted the entire bishops’ conference to present letters of resignation.

In his comments to Crux, de la Fuente claimed that when he presented Pope Francis a letter recounting various problems inside of the Missionaries of Charity in 2018, the pontiff’s response was, “another one!”

De la Fuente, who until leaving the priesthood celebrated Mass for the Missionaries of Charity at a community house charged with running a school for children with mental disorders in Santiago, described the problems he saw in the society as a system of blind obedience in which the vow was made into “an idol.”

“To think is almost a sin,” he said, saying he at times saw sisters being hit by superiors and enduring “humiliations for the sake of humiliations…(they) made humiliation a way of formation.”

Adamčikova told Crux she was able to meet privately with Rodríguez Carballo in February 2023, and that while acknowledging there were problems in terms of obedience and authority in the order, he said it was difficult to take action because many sisters don’t want to write things down, and that sisters had told him they prefer to confide any problems they face in confession.

Several former sisters told Crux they have already made contact with the new secretary of the Dicastery for Religious, Italian Sister Simona Brambilla, and that dialogue about problems within the Missionaries of Charity is ongoing, though some say they remain skeptical about the prospects for real change.

Brambilla likewise did not respond to a Crux request for comment.

Catrina told Crux that in May of this year, two more letters recounting problems inside of the society and among sisters who leave were delivered to Pope Francis, but so far there has been no contact or follow up.

“I believe that the pope should choose a person, or more people, to help the sisters to change and update their constitutions or ways of life according to the Second Vatican Council,” she said.

She, like the other former members, insisted that her desire is not to tarnish the Missionaries of Charity, but to see them reformed.

Reaction

In a statement to Crux, Towey, speaking as an official spokesman for the Missionaries of Charity, said the claim that there is an internal culture of abuse and neglect within the Missionaries of Charity “is patently false.”

“The Missionaries of Charity take allegations of the mistreatment of their members seriously and strive to improve if they fall short of their high standards,” he said, stating that this report “repeats old grievances from a determined, small group of ‘former members,’ nearly all of whom left the Missionaries of Charity a decade or decades ago.”

The report, he said, “undermines the 5,000 Missionaries of Charity sisters who today choose to joyfully and faithfully serve Jesus in the poorest of the poor in Gaza, Ukraine, Sudan, Haiti, Russia, and elsewhere in the world. They will not be distracted by this badly biased, unfair report.”

Gay man subjected to ‘exorcism’ at Sheffield church has complaint upheld

A MAN who experienced what he considered to be an exorcism that sought to “rid him of his homosexual inclinations” has had every aspect of his complaint against a church in Sheffield upheld, four years after it was lodged.

An independent investigation of St Thomas’s, Philadelphia, in respect of a complaint by Matthew Drapper, was published by the diocese of Sheffield on Monday evening, after it was leaked to the BBC. It is dated 30 November 2023.

Mr Drapper, who was a volunteer at the church from 2013 to 2016, first complained both to the church and the diocese of Sheffield in 2019. He said that he had been forced to step down from volunteering for the student leadership team at the church, after stating that he was considering dating as a gay man, and that he had been subject to prayer ministry — which he considered to be an exorcism — that attempted to change his sexual orientation from gay to straight.

He was told in a letter from a trustee of the church that his complaint had not been upheld, and that there was “no evidence to substantiate” his claims. But the independent investigation, commissioned by the diocese of Sheffield (News, 11 February 2022) and conducted by Linda Richardson and Jane Sarre, safeguarding consultants at Barnardo’s, has upheld every aspect of his complaint.

The report, from which names have been redacted, reveals the extent to which the church resisted participating in the investigation. In February 2022, a spokesperson for the church told BBC Yorkshire: “St Thomas’s, Philadelphia, is a caring and generous church community which does not engage in conversion therapy. We welcome the independent investigation initiated by the diocese into these allegations of eight years ago, and will participate in it.”

But the report records that, three months later, the church referred to legal advice “that the issue was not a safeguarding matter, and they were therefore not obliged to comply with Core Group decisions or provide us with any documents or reports linked to MD’s complaint as there were data sharing implications”.

Some individuals named in the complaint declined to be involved, talking of “concerns about mental health and personal implications if they were to contribute to the investigation”.

In a second report about existing safeguarding arrangements at the church, the investigators raise a number of concerns. Four years after Mr Drapper’s complaint, there was “still no formalised recording system which captured what safeguarding concerns or complaints had been made, how these had been addressed and by whom”.

ST THOMAS’s, Philadelphia, was planted out of St Thomas’s, Crookes, an Anglican-Baptist local ecumenical partnership, in 1998. Since 2009, when it was joined by the King’s Centre, a Sheffield house-church, it has been known as Network Church Sheffield.

Officially registered with the Charity Commission as the Philadelphia Network Limited, it is part of the Yorkshire Baptist Association and the diocese of Sheffield, although there is no Local Ecumenical Partnership currently in place. Until 2019, the church offered young adults an intern opportunity, called FORM.

Mr Drapper joined FORM in 2013, and, having completed the first year, was expecting to return for the second year. The investigators were satisfied that there was “a clear expectation by both parties” that this would occur, and said that it was “common knowledge” that he described himself as a gay man during this first year.

In 2014, an invitation to attend the second year of FORM was not extended to Mr Drapper. He was informed, he told the investigation, that “having a leader who believed in gay relationships would be a bad influence on first-year interns”. During this period, he wrote blogs “about his emerging views about gay theology”, the report says.

While he was not invited to take part in this second year, Mr Drapper was invited to join the student team as a volunteer, liaising with and meeting university students. He was later informed, he told the investigation, that if he chose to continue “promoting” gay relationships online and in person, he would not be allowed to continue as a volunteer.

The report upholds Mr Drapper’s complaint that, besides not being invited to complete FORM part two, in 2015, he was forced to step down from volunteering with the student leadership team at the church, after he stated that he was considering dating as a gay man.

A SIGNIFICANT aspect of the review concerns the church’s transparency about its views on sexuality and leadership. The consultants write that they “do not disagree” with the argument that it was “considered appropriate that individuals were asked to uphold and abide by the Church’s teachings”. In their response to Mr Drapper’s complaint, the church argued that he was “aware of the Church’s theological position”.

Mr Drapper’s said that he was “never given any indication that his sexuality or views would be a barrier to him holding any leadership positions in the Church”, the report says. The church has acknowledged that there was no document in place at the time that clearly stated this. It was, the investigation was told, “unspoken but understood, that a gay person who could or would not commit to celibacy would not be offered a leadership role in the Church”.

While the investigators were told by one redacted contributor that “people who describe themselves as gay were and are welcome and accepted in the church”, it includes recollections that challenge this account. One person recalled “celebrations in the congregation because a parent stood up and spoke of an adult in their family, who had been ‘delivered from the sin of homosexuality’”.

At the time of Mr Drapper’s complaint, the church did not have a complaints policy, and the consultants write of “a sense that the Church chose to quieten or discourage any open discussion around the impact of their doctrine on individuals who wanted to openly describe themselves as gay”.

They express disappointment that “some key church leaders named in MD’s complaint refused or did not feel able to meet with us to share their views and observations about MD’s complaint, even though many continue to actively work in nearby churches or projects.”

They uphold Mr Drapper’s complaint that he was not welcomed at the church after his removal from the student leadership team.

THE investigation concludes: “It is clear from information provided to us that deliverance ministries in relation to homosexuality was endorsed and supported by the Church.”

It provides an account of a weekend away for FORM interns (“Encounter with God”), during which interns were asked to complete a questionnaire and provide “highly personal information about their past life and childhood; they were asked to detail any experience of abuse and describe their struggles and traumas and any challenges they were trying to address in their adult lives”.

The consultants observe that such disclosure “to individuals who have no training in understanding or assessing the impact of vicarious traumas and disclosures carries a significant risk of not only triggering and retraumatising the individual but also rendering some individuals even more vulnerable”.

The completion of this questionnaire was followed by an individualised prayer-ministry session, documented in notes taken by both Mr Drapper and an intern. It entailed “Sozo” prayers: a model of deliverance prayer created by Bethel Church, a megachurch in Redding, California.

Mr Drapper recorded in his notes that he was told that he was “not taking responsibility for his own choices, and this was due to the fact that he had inherited from his family a ‘Hereditary Demon’.”

He was told that “he needed to renounce his homosexual lifestyle and needed to speak to the demons inside him as if they ‘were a dog’.”

The intern’s notes refer to prayer calling out demons, and Mr Drapper recorded being told that demons could be seen “leaving hand in hand, marching through the window”. He was asked to repeat a prayer “which would indicate he had broken off ‘his agreement with Satan’ and which would free him of his homosexuality”.

The session had a “lasting impact on his welfare and mental health”, the report concludes. It was “consistent with what many individuals would describe as a form of exorcism which could fall under the definition of spiritual abuse”.

While focusing on Mr Drapper’s experience, the report raises concerns about the wider fall-out of this ministry. It refers to a lack of support in place in the aftermath of these “highly charged and emotionally intense” sessions. Some contributors to the investigation described “having a visceral/physical reaction to the experience, which was then regarded by the prayer team as proof of spirit possession”.

The consultants write of their contact with others involved in the church: “We were struck by how many of those who spoke with us referred to their own vulnerabilities at the time, either because they had family issues, were lonely or just seeking ‘a home’ . . . it could be suggested they were all vulnerable in some way.”

A desire “to be accepted and to fit in” was a factor, they suggest, “which influenced why some individuals looked to suppress their identity and ‘consent’ to practices or prayers which sought to remove the sins they were told they carried.”

A belief that demons cause homosexuality, and that rituals can allow gay individuals to be “healed”, is “not unusual or confined to this church”, the report observes.

“There are many other churches who believe in demonic possession, but most have strict criteria that must be followed when such spirits are discerned and/or when an ecclesiastical exorcism is considered necessary.”

They say that, in the Church of England, exorcisms may be carried out only by those authorised by the Bishop. There is, their report says, “no evidence that the church has ever sought permission from the Bishop in this respect or has ever needed to do so”.

IT WAS not until December 2020, a year after the initial complaint was made, that the diocese of Sheffield, in line with C of E guidance, decided to convene a core group to address the safeguarding concerns raised by Mr Drapper’s complaint. Both staffing changes and the impact of the pandemic are referred to as possible causes of the delay.

Besides looking at Mr Drapper’s complaint, Barnardo’s was commissioned to “review and assess current safeguarding arrangements in the Church to ensure that all areas of student and prayer ministry are conducted safely and without causing harm to any individual whatever their sexuality or theological position”.

This second report is dated 26 February 2024. In contrast to the response to the first part of their investigation, the consultants speak of a “constructive approach and a willingness to work with us to examine safeguarding arrangements in the Church and highlight where policies, procedures, and practice, going forward needed to change or be strengthened.”

The report identifies a number of changes that have taken place in recent years. Prayer ministry at the church ceased during the pandemic in 2020, and was only resumed in September 2023. It now takes place only at the front of the church after services. A prayer ministry protocol has been co-produced by church leaders and volunteers.

An executive summary records that the church “now makes clear that it neither permits nor endorses prayers which seek to change a person’s sexual orientation and prayer ministry teams are not permitted to refer to or discuss a person’s sexual identity”.

FORM no longer exists, Encounter with God weekends no longer take place, and the review was told that “interns are not required, and would not in future be required, to share deeply personal information about their past experiences and vulnerabilities.”

The consultants write of being told “on several occasions by different people that what happened ten years ago [in relation to MD’s complaint] was ‘then’, but the Church now has a different [and better] ‘feel’ under the current church leader.” While they were “unable to observe how prayer ministry is delivered”, they were “assured that practice has changed significantly in recent years”.

In their report, however, they raise several ongoing concerns. It remains unclear, for example, “how the Church will, going forward, ensure that prayer sessions are delivered in line with the prayer ministry protocol and that individuals, whatever their personal beliefs, comply with the Church’s policy and procedures on this issue”.

Among the 22 recommendations is that those delivering prayer ministry “should be able to demonstrate, through training, a trauma informed approach which understands that, however carefully managed, prayer sessions can re-trigger past traumas, and this can leave a person vulnerable”.

The reviewers also uncovered “a lack of accountability and managerial scrutiny at Board level in how safeguarding concerns are identified, addressed, and managed”. It would appear, they write, that there are “no records (other than some email trails) of discussions and decisions taken. We found Board minutes to be so minimal that we were unable to determine, from a safeguarding perspective, what information was shared with the Board and what discussions took place.”

Four years after Mr Drapper’s complaint, there was “still no formalised recording system which captured what safeguarding concerns or complaints had been made, how these had been addressed and by whom”.

The consultants write: “We were unable to view any case records and were informed that there had been relatively few safeguarding concerns or complaints reported in recent years. This is most unusual in an organisation of this size and especially one located in a relatively disadvantaged area.

“The lack of reported safeguarding concerns or complaints could suggest any of the following: the reporting process is not well known or staff and volunteers fear using it, that there are complaints or concerns, but they are not reported to leaders or managers or there are reported concerns, but they are not recognised as being related to safeguarding.”

It diagnoses “a somewhat restrictive approach to safeguarding, tightly applying legal definitions of vulnerability and need and using thresholds regarding those at risk as opposed to the more nuanced and contextual application omen used in social care and not including the all-encompassing safeguarding requirements of the Charity Commission”.

The consultants warn: “The way in which the complaint made by Matthew Drapper was handled, for example, over a four-year period has brought into sharp focus that safeguarding procedures in the Church were not in line with the Charity Commission regulation . . .

“We were unable to identify any clear system or process by which the Board can demonstrate robust managerial oversight or scrutiny of its safeguarding arrangements.”

They were, however, “encouraged by the church’s readiness to support the development of a more robust approach to safeguarding”.

On the church’s current position on sexuality, the consultants were told that the congregation included people who were “openly gay and some who lived in same-sex relationships”. But there was agreement that, “if individuals did not believe and could not endorse the Church’s values and beliefs, they should not hold or be invited to hold leadership positions in the Church”.

It is, the report says, “still not clear how new members of the congregation would be made aware of this”.

ON MONDAY, the BBC reported that Miriam Cates, the Conservative candidate for Penistone and Stocksbridge and a former biology teacher in Sheffield, was a member of St Thomas’s, Philadelphia, between 2003 and 2018, and a trustee from 2016 to 2018.

The BBC article referred to social-media posts from Mrs Cates made in November 2012, “which suggest she attended a conference hosted by a third party at the church which Mr Drapper has described as an ‘exorcism training weekend’.”

Audio from the conference, which the BBC has not verified, suggests that it involved practising a prayer of repentance “for giving place to any demons . . . including demons of . . . homosexuality . . . lesbianism”.

Mrs Cates told the BBC that she “did attend a conference at the Church in 2012, although I have no diary records of the time, and, to the best of my recollection, this was a standard church conference with a series of seminars, Bible teachings and worship.

“I have no recollection of the content or title of any of the seminars that took place at the conference because it took place well over a decade ago.”

She said: “I do not and have never advocated for what is referred to as ‘gay conversion therapy’. I have never participated in such activities, and I was not aware — nor was there any way that I could have been aware — of Mr Drapper’s allegations.”

ON MONDAY, a statement from the diocese of Sheffield said: “We have been working urgently for the past month towards the publication of a lightly redacted version of both stages of the report, and have been able to publish it on our website today.

“The trustees of Network Church Sheffield have accepted both parts of the report in full, and have developed and put into effect a comprehensive action plan to implement the report’s recommendations. . .

“We deeply regret that the process has taken so long and understand the frustrations of those who have been affected. We apologise unreservedly to the survivor for the distress this has caused and to anyone else similarly affected by such practices in the past. The Diocese of Sheffield believes, along with the wider Church of England, that conversion therapy is unethical, potentially harmful and has no place in the modern world.”

Network Church Sheffield (NCS) told the BBC: “We have accepted the outcomes of the first investigation and are saddened that eight years ago one of our community was not cared for in the way we would have liked. We sincerely apologised to them for this.

“Whilst the leadership of the church has changed, we recognise there are significant lessons to be learned and we are determined to learn them.”

Defrocked Montreal priest denied parole

Former Montreal priest and convicted sex offender Brian Boucher remains unrepentant as he prepares to leave prison this month, says the bishop instrumental in bringing him to justice.

While he was denied parole at his June 25 parole board hearing — according to the board report, parole was denied because Boucher refuses to admit to the crimes for which he was sentenced — Boucher is eligible for statutory release in July as he has served two-thirds of his eight-year sentence.

Boucher, 62, was convicted in March 2019 of sexually abusing two teenage boys while a priest in Montreal.

Sault Ste. Marie Bishop Thomas Dowd told The Catholic Register that Boucher “categorically denied that his original crimes ever happened.” Dowd, who served as auxiliary bishop in Montreal from 2011 to 2020, attended the former priest’s parole board hearing.

Dowd recounted that when Boucher was asked why he had pled guilty, he replied, “I was advised to do it to avoid a harsher sentence.”

“As your sentence proceeded over time, you changed your position to an outright denial of all events,” the report said. “At the hearing, you stated that you had never acknowledged any involvement in the offences. You stated that you never said what is written in the official documentation.”

Despite being laicized by the Archdiocese of Montreal in 2020, Dowd said that Boucher repeatedly referred to himself as a priest during the hearing.

Statutory release is a “legislated release” and the role of the parole board at that juncture is to impose conditions that consider both the safety of the community and the reintegration of the prisoner.

In Boucher’s case, the board imposed the maximum number of conditions for the full extent of his remaining sentence. Boucher must live in a half-way house, have no contact with his victims or children, have no job or position that places him in authority over children and report all relationships with adults who have parental authority.

Boucher's release comes despite in July 2023 being charged with sexual assault, voyeurism and harassment of a fellow inmate while he was resident at the La Macaza Institution in Quebec. 

The charges bear a striking similarity to the pattern of behaviour documented in the Capriolo Report, the independent investigation commissioned in 2020 by the Archdiocese of Montreal into the Boucher affair.

The parole board report notes that in March 2023, “information started coming in from different staff members regarding a concerning and questionable relationship between you and a younger offender living in your unit. Correctional officers observed a strong attachment between the two of you. Your CMT learned the young offender was locking himself in his cell to avoid your harassment. In the same month, he expressed his discomfort to his program officer that you were rigid in your opinions and somewhat invasive, even going to talk to him when he was in the shower. He said you refused his request to give him distance.”

Combined with the denial of the original crimes, the new charges led the board to recommend “a strict and structured environment that can also offer you opportunities to address your high needs for intervention.”

Boucher, represented by Sylvie Bordelais, has his next hearing on the new charges scheduled this month.

While in prison, Boucher has undergone multiple programs, titled Integrated Correctional Program Model (ICPM), and psychological counseling. At the end of the last ICPM undertaken in May, it was noted that Boucher had “improved your self-talk to reimagine your values and beliefs so they are not so rigid but more fluid.”

Dowd recounted that Boucher told the parole board that his takeaway from prison counselling was that “he needed to love himself more.”

‘Apache Christ’ icon removed from New Mexico mission, shocking Indigenous parishioners


An Indigenous image of Jesus Christ by an acclaimed iconographer has been removed from a New Mexico church for unspecified reasons, days after the U.S. bishops approved a pastoral framework for Indigenous ministry.

Painted by Franciscan Friar Robert Lentz, “Apache Christ” is an 8-foot icon depicting Jesus as a Mescalero holy man, with the inscription in Apache “giver of life.” Since 1989 it had hung behind the altar of the church under a crucifix.

This image and a painting of Apache dancers by the late Apache artist Gervase Peso were taken down from the interior walls of St. Joseph Apache Mission in Mescalero, N.M., sometime during the evening of June 26 and the early morning hours of June 27.

The parish is located on the lands of the Mescalero Apache Tribe.

The discovery was made by parish staff and volunteers as they opened the church for use in catechetical activities on the morning of June 27, according to two parishioners with whom OSV News spoke. A St. Joseph Parish staffer who did not wish to be identified told OSV News the Peso painting had been mounted in the church’s reconciliation room.

In addition, the staffer said the icon’s detailed frame, which had been crafted by New Mexico-based wood sculptor Roberto Lavadie, had been disassembled and left in a locked storage area of the church to which only the pastor, Father Peter Chudy Sixtus Simeon-Aguinam, had access.

Father Simeon-Aguinam, who is also pastor of Our Lady of Guadalupe in Bent, N.M., told OSV News by telephone July 1 that he would comment next week — a statement he reiterated after OSV News asked if he could in the meantime provide any specific reason for the artworks’ removal. An email sent by OSV News to the priest earlier that day went unanswered.

A number of parishioners took to social media to report their astonishment and dismay over the sudden removal — among them, volunteer youth minister and catechist AnneMarie Brillante, who stated on a Google webpage she created for the mission parish that the icon “was taken in the middle of the night while community members recovered” from two major wildfires in mid-June that killed two and forced thousands to evacuate.

“It was a shock to our summer youth catechism teachers and attendees to enter the church and be greeted by an empty space where the ‘Apache Christ’ icon once stood,” wrote Brillante, who told OSV News she is Mescalero Apache and has been a lifelong member of the mission.

Brillante said in her post that “those responsible for the secret removal of the painting include the pastor, members of the Knights of Columbus and the Roman Catholic Diocese of Las Cruces.”

OSV News reached out to Deacon John Eric Munson, the chief operating officer and head of human resources for the Diocese of Las Cruces who also oversees communications, but has not yet received a response to several phone and email inquiries.

Anthony D. Salazar, state deputy of the New Mexico State Council of the Knights of Columbus, told OSV News by phone that regarding any Knights of Columbus who may have been involved in the icon’s removal, “these gentlemen were acting on their own behalf” and “not … in the capacity of a Knight of Columbus.” As an organization, the Knights of Columbus — the largest Catholic fraternal organization in the world — has a Native Solidarity Initiative and is involved in promoting awareness about Native Catholics and their traditions through their “Enduring Faith” documentary and their support for the canonization of Nicholas Black Elk, a Lakota holy man and Catholic catechist. The Knights’ Supreme Secretary Patrick Mason is a member of the Osage Nation.

Mescalero Tribal Police told OSV News that they had “taken a report” about the removal of the painting on June 27, and that the matter is under investigation.

On her Google webpage for the parish, Brillante posted an audio recording of a 12-plus minute June 27 phone call she had with Deacon Munson, in which Brillante said she had “just (been) made aware that the ‘Apache Christ’ has been stolen.”

“Not stolen, just removed,” replied Deacon Munson, who advised Brillante that the pastor, “the Knights of Columbus” and the diocesan property risk manager had been involved in the change.

When Brillante asked where the icon was, the deacon replied, “It’s not germane.”

Brillante countered that “if (the icon) was taken off the reservation, off of federal land, without permission then that’s called theft,” and that the icon had been “given to the parishioners of the Mescalero Apache Tribe.”

Deacon Munson said in reply, “There is no such thing as the parishioners owning anything. The parish is a corporation … and the parishioners are not stockholders in the corporation,” and that “anything that is in that church is the church’s … and the building is the church’s responsibility.”

According to the New Mexico secretary of state’s corporations division, the St. Joseph Mission is a domestic nonprofit corporation created in 1993. Its current officers are all officials of the Diocese of Las Cruces, with Bishop Peter Baldacchino as the chairman of the board.

The church was built in 1920 by Franciscan friars and a number of volunteers, replacing a previous, smaller adobe church that had deteriorated. Much of the artwork throughout the cruciform structure reflects elements of Apache culture, and throughout the years the church has undergone upgrades and a recent renovation.

OSV News has contacted Brother Lentz for comment on the icon’s removal but has not yet received a response.

However, the friar — who had previously posted a video to Facebook describing the creation of the icon, which included substantial consultation and collaboration with the Apache community — said in a statement posted on his behalf on X, formerly Twitter, that he “GAVE the icon to the Mescalero people, who then commissioned an elaborated hand-carved frame for it.

“What has happened in the past few days reminds me of something from the nineteenth century, when it was not uncommon in New Mexico or Arizona for a posse of white men to sneak up on an Indian village in the dark of night for an ambush,” wrote Brother Lentz in the statement. “The ‘posse’ in this case was made up of men from a conservative Catholic organization in a military town, on the other side of a mountain range, 30 miles from Mescalero. That they were led by the priest currently assigned to Mescalero only adds to the shame.”

Brother Lentz, who designed the “Saints of the Americas” altar reredos in Sante Fe’s Cathedral Basilica of St. Francis of Assisi, added that “from 1990 to 2019, bishops of Las Cruces visited the church in Mescalero and gave their tacit approval to the icon. Had it violated Roman Catholic doctrine, they would have asked for its removal. They did not.”

At the same time, some of Brother Lentz’s work has also generated controversy — for example, his painting of slain politician and gay rights activist Harvey Milk.

Yet any specific concerns regarding “Apache Christ” and Peso’s painting were not made clear to parishioners, said the unnamed St. Joseph staffer, Brillante and Brillante’s 23-year-old daughter, Gabrielle Brillante, currently a student at Yale Divinity School who assists her mother in parish catechetical ministry.

The unnamed parish staffer pointed to depictions of Christ by European artists, saying, “They painted (him) like themselves.”

Gabrielle Brillante told OSV News that when Father Simeon-Aguinam stated at a June 11 parish meeting the “Apache Christ” icon was problematic for not meeting a Catholic “rubric,” she asked him to provide details but he offered no further explanation.

However, one parishioner (who asked not to be named out of fear of retaliation by the priest) told OSV News some five tribal members had heard Father Simeon-Aguinam declare in a weekday Mass homily during Lent 2024 that “God comes first. You cannot be both an Apache and a Catholic. You have to choose. You cannot be both. … You have to leave those ways and that way of life behind … you have to choose.”

The parishioner and at least two of the tribal members present were “just quiet, and … just didn’t say anything,” with the parishioner telling OSV News, “I just didn’t feel comfortable … I already know that there will be repercussions.”

The parishioner added that “it was widely known and talked about that (Father Simeon-Aguinam) did not like anything to do with our Native culture.” The parishioner stated that with respect to the parish’s sacred vessels made from materials prized in Apache culture, the priest “immediately replaced our cups (chalices) and our basket that we bring up the host in,” which were of “a Pueblo pottery style, and … replaced those with brass … because he didn’t like (them).”

The recent incident involving “Apache Christ” follows in the wake of the U.S. Catholic bishops’ overwhelming vote June 14 to approve a new pastoral framework for Indigenous Catholic ministry called “Keeping Christ’s Sacred Promise” during their spring general assembly in Louisville, Kentucky.

“Many Indigenous Catholics have felt a sense of abandonment in their relationship with church leaders due to a lack of understanding of their unique cultural needs,” says the introduction of the pastoral framework. “We apologize for the failure to nurture, strengthen, honor, recognize, and appreciate those entrusted to our pastoral care.”

The five-part framework focuses on calls for healing, mission, reconciliation, holiness and transformation in ministry to the nation’s Indigenous Catholics, whose “journey … in the United States of America has been marked by moments of great joy but also of profound sorrow,” the document states.

Nearly two years earlier, in July 2022, Pope Francis made a penitential pilgrimage to Canada in which he affirmed the importance of the Catholic faith expressing itself through Indigenous cultures, and apologized for the ways in which “Catholics contributed to policies of assimilation and enfranchisement that inculcated a sense of inferiority, robbing communities and individuals of their cultural and spiritual identity, severing their roots and fostering prejudicial and discriminatory attitudes.” Pointing to the various Indigenous Catholic inculturated art and symbols at Sacred Heart Church in Edmonton, Alberta, he said, “This liturgical symbolism reminds me of the magnificent words spoken by St. John Paul II in this country: ‘Christ animates the very center of all culture. Thus, not only is Christianity relevant to the Indian people, but Christ, in the members of his Body, is himself Indian.'”

The unnamed St. Joseph’s Parish staffer told OSV News that “the whole tribal community is upset” by the removal of their artwork.

AnneMarie Brillante agreed with that view.

“I would say (the removal) opened up old, old wounds that our ancestors were victims of,” she said.

63-year-old German missionary bishop resigns

Pope Francis has accepted the resignation of Bishop Reinhold Nann, 63, who has led the Territorial Prelature of Caravelí, Peru, since 2017.

In a statement on his blog, Bishop Nann said he was suffering from stress and high blood pressure brought on by his multiple roles, including president of Caritas Peru and member of the Episcopal Commission for the Protection of Minors, as well as declining physical and mental health “since the time of Covid.”

Despite his membership in the Episcopal Commission for the Protection of Minors, Bishop Nann accepted a priest accused of sexual abuse elsewhere for ministry in his prelature, according to a 2020 report. The priest, according to the prelature, had been cleared by a Vatican investigation, but was still under civil investigation.

In 2020, Bishop Nann also offered strong public criticism of Archbishop Georg Gänswein, a seminary classmate. 

That same year, Bishop Nann permitted telephone confessions until a Vatican intervention led him to declare his permission null and void.

Bishop Nann said that he would return to Germany and spend time in prayer and reflection at his parents’ home and at a retreat house. 

He asked forgiveness for his “impatience and impetuosity,” which have “probably caused some damage.”

New cardinal ‘protodeacon’ would announce next Pontiff

French Cardinal Dominique Mamberti, the prefect of the Apostolic Signatura, has become the Protodeacon of the College of Cardinals, and would have the role of announcing the newly elected Pontiff at the next papal conclave.

That task is given to the senior prelate among the ranks of cardinal-deacons present at a conclave. 

Cardinal Mamberti gained that status on July 1, when Pope Francis promoted three cardinal-deacons— Cardinals James Harvey, Lorenzo Baldisseri, and Gerhard Müller— from cardinal-deacons to cardinal-priests.

Cardinal Renato Martino is actually the senior cardinal-deacon, having held that title since 2003. 

However, at the age of 91 he is ineligible to participate in a conclave.

Pope splits Brazilian diocese into two

Countering the trend of diocesan consolidations in Italy, Canada, Alaska, and elsewhere, Pope Francis has split a Brazilian diocese that is relatively small in area into two.

The Pontiff created the Diocese of Jaú from the territory of the Diocese of São Carlos. 

The Diocese of São Carlos formerly had 112 parishes and was smaller than 48 of the 50 US states.

The new Diocese of Jaú will have 47 parishes, 67 priests, and 9 seminarians; the diocese’s first bishop will be Bishop Francisco Carlos da Silva of Lins. 

The reduced Diocese of São Carlos will have 75 parishes, 144 priests, and 14 seminarians.

Last October, Pope Francis split an Argentine diocese into two. 

In 2024, he has also established new dioceses in Paraguay, Guinea, and Indonesia.

Vatican budget black hole swallows Peter’s Pence

Peter’s Pence, the annual collection to support the work of the Holy Father, reported an uptick in donations for 2023, but allocated nearly 90% of revenue to Vatican operating expenses.

And although voluntary donations climbed after 2022, total revenue to Peter’s Pence in 2023 nearly halved, after the fund disposed of millions of euros in real estate assets to help cover the operations of the Roman curia the previous year.

While climbing Peter’s Pence donations are getting headlines, the more important story told by the report is an ongoing budget black hole at the center of the Roman curia, with the Vatican’s need for cash absorbing not only donations to Peter’s Pence, but triggering a sale of the fund’s assets as well.

The annual Peter’s Pence collection is taken on the nearest Sunday to the feast of Saints Peter and Paul, June 29, falling this year on June 30. To coincide with the collection, the fund released its annual report for the previous year’s collection and disbursements.

According to the report, in 2023 Peter’s Pence collected 52 million euros in total revenue, 48 million of which came from donations from around the world. Donations rose over 2022, when receipts totalled 43.2 million. However, those headline figures sit over significantly higher expenses for the fund, which also recorded more than 109 million euros in costs and disbursements. 

The nearly 55 million euro gap between donation income and grant allocations was bridged, the report said, by just over 3 million in income generated by assets belonging to the fund and by spending millions in cash generated from the 2022 sale of real estate assets, when the fund recorded more than double its 2023 revenue.

The 2022 annual report recorded 63.5 million euros in “financial and other revenue,” in addition to donations totalling 43.5 million, compared to only 3 million of such income in 2023. 

The 2022 report noted the extra-donation income was boosted by “a significant capital gain” which came “thanks to the sale of real estate assets assigned to the fund.” The report did not include a final figure for the sale income. However, the 2023 report did identify it subsidized that year’s allocations with 51 million from “the Peter’s Pence Fund patrimony.”

In 2022, Peter’s Pence assigned more than 95 million in grant allocations and disbursements, compared to more than 109 million in 2023. 

Allocations for “direct assistance to those most in need,” charitable projects picked by the pope, totaled 13 million euros in 2023, spread across 236 projects in 76 countries. Of the 103 million given out by Peter’s Pence last year, the report says, 90 million (87%) went to funding the operations of the Roman curia. 

In 2022, 16.2 million went to charitable projects, versus 77.6 million euros which went to funding Vatican departments.

The figures suggest that, rather than building up and relying on stable assets to generate regular returns, or limiting its grant allocations in line with donations, Peter’s Pence is selling its stable patrimony to plug the Vatican’s budgetary black hole. 

It is unclear what percentage of the annual Vatican operational budget was made up by the 90 million euros it received from Peter’s Pence last year. The Vatican’s Secretariat for the Economy formerly published an annual mission budget presentation, but has not done so since 2022.

According to the last published budget report, curial operations in 2022 were set to cost 796 million euros per year, with a forecast operating loss of 33.4 million after expected donations from sources including Peter’s Pence.

In October 2023, the secretariat’s prefect, Maximino Caballero Ledo gave an indication of the scale of the Vatican’s financial “crisis” when he said that the Holy See had a structural budget deficit of “between 50 and 60 million euros a year,” despite years of cost-cutting measures implemented by the Holy See and a curia wide hiring freeze.

Caballero Ledo was promoted to prefect in 2022, following the resignation of Juan Antonio Guerrero Alves, SJ, for health reasons. 

As part of Pope Francis’ efforts to bring financial reforms to the Vatican, a curia-wide pay and hiring freeze has been in place for nearly a decade — though 2021 budget reports show salaries remain the curia’s biggest single expense line at 139.5 million euros, so Francis instituted senior level pay cuts for clerical employees.

Pope Francis has continued to authorize a slew of financial reforms aimed at tightening central oversight of major expenditures and encouraging curial departments to work together to share the costs of external purchasing and contractors.

Early in 2023, Pope Francis announced that he would end the practice of offering subsidized Vatican accommodation to senior curial officials, citing “a context economic crisis such as the current one, which is particularly serious,” which the pope said highlighted “the need for everyone to make an extraordinary sacrifice.” 

The pope has also ordered the centralization of all curial assets and accounts under the management of the Institute for Works of Religion, Vatican City’s for-profit bank, including the “on-shoring” to Vatican City of all Holy See funds held in foreign bank accounts — a move portrayed by Vatican financial officials as a bid to stave off a liquidity crisis for the Holy See.

The sale of stable assets by Peter’s Pence to fund daily running costs raises serious questions about the medium-term financial viability of Vatican operations.

In February, a senior official close to the Secretariat for the Economy told The Pillar that “Our Lord guaranteed the Church will never fail, but that guarantee didn’t come with an annuity.”

“There’s no magic money tree in the Vatican gardens,” he said.

“There are still a lot of underperforming assets that need to be identified and maximized,” said the official, “but even that goes only so far. We are talking about very large operating losses every year bleeding away reserves.”

“Everyone likes to cheer the small victories, chipping away here and there at an unsustainable situation, but there’s no big picture thinking. Past a certain point, you’re just trimming the catering budget on the Titanic — sure you’re making savings, but what you need is a total change of course.”

Another senior Vatican financial expert predicted to The Pillar that a curial cash crunch looked increasingly unavoidable in the medium term: “I would say in five years, maybe.”

“People like to imagine the Vatican is ‘too big to fail,’ especially people in the Vatican,” he said. “But if the deficit is totally unsustainable, and shuttering whole departments is unthinkable, what is the plan, exactly? I don’t think there is one.”

Sources close to the Secretariat for the Economy also previously told The Pillar that in the early years of Francis’ reforming efforts, under the leadership of Cardinal George Pell, the department drew up plans for generating new and more reliable long term income streams for the Holy See by identifying land and buildings otherwise not being used.

Plans included the large-scale development of sites for industrial, residential, or mixed use but would be contingent on securing external partnerships to develop sites and land while signing long-term leasehold agreements stretching out for decades. Such projects would also take years to come online and likely entail significant upfront expenses.

The same sources said that while the potential for new, significant, long term revenue generation was there, curial will outside the Secretariat for the Economy was not.

“The pushback from APSA [the Holy See’s real estate manager], from the Secretariat of State, from people around Number 1 [Pope Francis] was total — it was absolute,” one source recalled to The Pillar. “We were called alarmists, radicals, and so nothing got approved and everything went in a drawer.”

Now, the window for bringing such projects to fruition is closing fast, if it is not already closed. 

All sources agreed that a medium-term Vatican liquidity crisis is now at least as likely as not. “When that happens,” the Secretariat for the Economy official said, “options are limited and very bad things can start happening.”

In October last year, secretariat prefect Maximino Caballero Ledo noted that “If we were to cover this deficit [in curial operating expenses] only by cutting expenses, we would close 43 of the 53 entities that belong to the Roman Curia, and this is not possible.”

That comment shed partial light on the relative costs of Vatican departmental operations. According to 2022 budget figures — the last year such numbers were published — 56 smaller Vatican departments split a total operating budget of 28 million euros. 

Other key dicasteries of the Holy See, including the Dicasteries for the Doctrine of the Faith, and for Laity, Family and Life, operated on budgets of 2 million euros each. 

The Holy See’s global diplomatic network of papal embassies was the most expensive department, costing some 41 million euros per year, followed closely by the Dicastery for Communications, with an annual budget of 38 million euros. 

By comparison, the Dicastery for the Evangelization of Peoples, the Vatican’s missionary and evangelizing department, was budgeted only 21 million.

Rather than slashing departmental budgets, which Caballero Ledo called “not possible,” the prefect said instead that “we have to work hard to increase revenues,” though it is not clear where that new income would come from.

Global donations from the faithful and from dioceses around the world, including via the annual Peter’s Pence collection, make up about 30% of Holy See income annually — though with significant amounts of that money ring-fenced for charitable work.

According to the 2023 Peter’s Pence report, donations did track up modestly over 2022, rising by nearly 5 million euros, with the United States continuing to supply the largest block of donations at more than 28%, up from 25% the previous year.

Germany was previously a consistently high source of income for the Holy See, and a top contributing source of donations, fueled in large part by the Church in Germany’s extraordinary wealth generated by Church allocations from government income taxes. 

However, Vatican relations with Germany’s bishops have been strained by years of disagreement over the controversial “synodal way” in that country, resolutions from which curial cardinals have repeatedly intervened to block.

At the same time, years of institutional disaffiliation among German Catholics have begun to impact revenue for the local Churches, leading to even the largest dioceses now forecasting budget deficits. 

Germany accounted for only 2.7% of donations to Peter’s Pence last year, down from 3% the year before.

While some financial reforms have led to an increase in profitability for some Church assets, most notably the IOR, those results do not appear to be enough to cover the ongoing Vatican overspending — leading to short-term funding decisions, like the Peter’s Pence real estate sale in 2022.

Officials close to the Secretariat for the Economy have warned for months about a potential liquidity crisis, at which point, one official said, “options are limited and very bad things can start happening.”

While the IOR could act as a lender to the Holy See to meet immediate needs, several sources agreed this was not a sustainable prospect as it would destabilize the bank — whose customers include curial employees and religious communities and dioceses in developing parts of the world — and could even trigger regulatory issues with European financial inspectors if the bank’s owner (the Holy See) became its major lendee.

“After that stops working choices become very dark,” one source close to Vatican financial planning told The Pillar earlier this year, “either people stop getting paid, or assets start getting sold off, then you come dangerously close to a slow burning fire sale which can become a financial death-spiral.”

“People need to start thinking and talking about this now,” he warned, “because the alternative is everything is handled in a reactionary panic, and that only makes things worse.”

Vatican official to testify in London property trial at UK High Court

Over 8 months after the conclusion of the trial in the Vatican Tribunal regarding the purchase and sale of the London property, which saw the conviction of ten defendants for various crimes including fraud and corruption, the issue of the Sloane Avenue property has returned to the forefront in another judicial proceeding, this time at His Majesty's High Court of Justice in England.

The trial began on June 24 following a civil complaint filed in 2020 in England by Raffaele Mincione, the financier among the ten defendants in the Vatican trial. 

The Vatican Tribunal sentenced him to 5 years and 6 months imprisonment, plus an 8,000-euro fine and permanent disqualification from public office, for money laundering, embezzlement, and corruption.

The Federal Court of Appeals in Switzerland had also expressed its opinion on the matter, confirming in 2021-22 the seizure of almost 100 million euros from some defendants, including Mincione.

Mincione initiated this civil proceeding, aiming to obtain around thirty declarations from the High Court affirming that he "acted in good faith" in the transactions with the Holy See for the purchase and sale of the London property.

The Secretariat of State, however, has always contested the inflated price of the property and the special powers Mincione acquired in the various transactions beyond the contracts.

Mincione was introduced to the Vatican through Enrico Crasso, a longtime financial consultant for the Secretariat of State (also convicted in the Vatican trial), to conduct due diligence on an investment initially proposed by Cardinal Angelo Becciu, then Substitute of the Secretariat of State, for oil wells in Angola. The investment quickly fell through, partly due to a negative opinion presented by Mincione.

After more than a year, Mincione had warned the investment would be a risky operation, instead proposing the purchase of a building, formerly Harrods warehouses, in a prestigious street in the British capital.

The property was "overvalued" between 56 and 101 million pounds, something that caused "damage" to the Holy See, which owned 45% of it, as stated in the argument by the civil lawyer of the Secretariat of State, Paola Severino.

All subsequent operations, such as the expensive Credit Lombard and the purchase of a share through the Athena Capital Fund headed by Mincione himself, were aimed "to satisfy the interests of the managers rather than the subscriber, burdened with significant losses," Severino highlighted.

The Holy See, summoned to the High Court, will be represented by Archbishop Edgar Peña Parra, the Substitute of the Secretariat of State, who will appear as a witness.

The Venezuelan-born Archbishop arrived in Rome in 2018 and was immediately called to deal, between late 2018 and early 2019, with a financial operation that he himself, in a June 2, 2020, memorial filed with the Vatican Tribunal, described as a true "fraud" against the Holy See.

In his double interrogation in the Vatican Tribunal courtroom in March 2023, he spoke of a "via crucis." He will now report to the British magistrates in three interrogations scheduled for July 4, 5, and 8.

The Substitute will therefore intervene in the ongoing trial, being the only representative of the Holy See since all other Secretariat of State actors involved in the matter (Cardinal Angelo Becciu, the aforementioned Crasso, and former Administrative Office official Fabrizio Tirabassi) were convicted in the Vatican Tribunal in the first instance. This fact makes it impossible for them to be heard as witnesses.

Meanwhile, the attorneys for the Secretariat of State—Charles Hollander, Samar Abbas Kazmi, James Bradford, and Jagoda Klimowicz—have prepared an 84-page defense memorandum.

The document notes the timing of Mincione's complaint, filed on June 16, 2020, when the financier "was under investigation by the judicial authority of the Vatican City State, the Office of the Promoter of Justice, for a series of serious financial crimes of which the Secretariat of State was the victim."

The Promoter's investigations, it reads, "led, among other things, to the freezing of some of Mincione's assets in Switzerland and the indictment of Mincione and others for fraud, self-laundering, and embezzlement of funds. His co-accused included employees and agents of the Secretariat of State, some directly involved in operations related to the property" (the Sloane Avenue building).

The lawyers also note that the complaint came a couple of days after the arrest in the Vatican of Torzi (June 13-14, 2020), who, according to the Secretariat of State's thesis, "while claiming to act as an agent of the Secretariat of State in operations related to the property at the center of this proceeding, was part of a criminal association with illegal means (together with Mr. Mincione and others) to defraud the Secretariat of State."

The memorandum also emphasizes that the trial in the Vatican Tribunal had the "advantage" of being based on a broad adversarial process with an "enormous number" of people heard from "all interested parties (55 witnesses in addition to the accused)," reaching "conclusions that spanned a long period."

From this trial, which began in July 2022 and ended in October 2023, "a sad story of corruption and abuse of office by unfaithful officials and speculation by external actors" emerged, during "the entire period from Mincione's entry into the Secretariat of State in 2012 until after the acquisition of the property by Gutt."

"The events addressed by the Vatican court concern deeply rooted corruption, fraud, and embezzlement over the years," the document reads. It is acknowledged that "many of the issues subject" to the criminal proceedings in the Vatican "are not admissible" in the civil trial in London, but it is still urged to consider them.

Regarding the formulation of the requested declarations, the memorandum emphasises that “the key issue raised (market price of the property and whether the Secretariat of State paid too much) does not appear in the requested declarations" from Mincione, "which seem deliberately to avoid this topic."

"The closest they come is a series of statements about the applicants acting in good faith," it notes.

Finally, the defense memorandum points out that Archbishop Peña Parra was involved in the entire matter when it was already nearing its conclusion and therefore has "very limited" knowledge of the previous events,

"Therefore, the Secretariat of State's case in this trial is based on a combination of documentary evidence and issues that will need to be addressed to Mincione and others in cross-examination."