Tuesday, May 01, 2012

Shatter row over priest libel drags on

JUSTICE Minister Alan Shatter remained under pressure to apologise for supporting the RTE programme that defamed Fr Kevin Reynolds.

Mr Shatter made a public statement the morning after the RTE 'Prime Time Investigates' programme last year, which falsely accused the Galway priest of rape and of fathering a daughter with a Kenyan woman.

The minister said at the time he had watched the programme with a "sense of revulsion" at the unspeakable catalogue of abuse against children it had revealed.

Mr Shatter also contacted Garda Commissioner Martin Callinan about the programme -- saying that people were entitled to be reassured that everything was being done to counteract this "evil".

But Association of Catholic Priests spokesman Fr Sean McDonagh said Mr Shatter had yet to apologise for the statement: "It was totally inappropriate for a Minister for Justice and for a solicitor on the morning after the programme to be calling them 'revelations' rather than 'allegations'. It's judge and jury; it's not a small matter. You have a right to your good name," he said.

Fr McDonagh has had no response from the minister or from the Department of Justice to his criticism.

Mr Shatter's spokesperson said the minister had already explained his remarks following the programme were based on "an assumption that the matters detailed on the programme had been fully researched".

"The fact remains that the Murphy Report into the Archdiocese of Dublin and Cloyne set out in stark detail the unacceptable behaviour of church authorities in handling cases of sexual abuse of children and it would be cynical, and clearly not in the interests of children, to seek to distract from that by reference to one particular extremely flawed television programme or the reaction to it," the spokesperson said.

Shatter: Everyone is obliged to report sex abuse

Justice Minister Alan Shatter reiterated that everyone, including priests, were obliged to report child sex abuse and other offences, including white collar crime, to the gardaí, even if they hear about it in the confessional.

The minister described the issue as a media obsession and said priests had been obliged to provide gardaí with information about a whole series of crimes since the 1998 Offences Against the State Amendment Act.

Nobody had raised any question about this or the 2011 Criminal Justice Act that placed the same obligation on the whole community, including priests, to assist gardaí with information.

The confessional was a diversion from the real issue, which had nothing to do with the confessional but with the fact that sexual abuse of children by clergy had been known about by religious orders and leaders as a result of parents, victims and others telling them, outside of the confessional.

"It was reported but covered up. And in the future it will be illegal for anyone across the community to do so," he said.

The legislation was about more than clerical abuse but was also designed to deal with the more prevalent cases of child abuse within families.

"This is a mammoth piece of legislation of great importance," he said, adding that the obligation to report information about it to gardaí should not have been excluded from the original 1998 law.

Meanwhile, an organisation has said it’s a ‘red herring’ to focus on the seal of the confessional when discussing the statutory reporting of child abuse, as such an obligation would be impossible to monitor, according to the Irish Association of Catholic Priests (ACP).

The ACP yesterday reiterated that priests would never pass on information shared in the confessional as, during ordination, they take an oath ensuring total confidentiality.

Anyhow, any such mandatory reporting by priests would be "unenforceable", said Fr Brendan Hoban.

"There are only the two people in confessional, the priest and the confessor. So who could enforce this rule? Secondly, the dynamic of confession is that you don’t know the identity of the person. You only hear the voice. Are you supposed to run out and take down their car registration?

"The second thing is that these type of confessions don’t happen. There has never been any indication that such confessions have been made to a priest. So I don’t think this is an issue at all," he said.

The row over the seal of confession erupted again when Mr Shatter published legislation on Wednesday that will make it a criminal offence for a person to fail to disclose information to gardaí that would assist in prosecuting a person who commits a serious offence against a child or vulnerable adult.

Under the legislation, anyone failing to pass on information could face up to 10 years in jail.

Mr Shatter warned that any defences published in the new laws would not protect priests from prosecution for failing to pass on information obtained during confession.

His draft legislation, which is due to be introduced later this year, also provoked a response from one of the Dublin Archdiocese’s auxiliary bishops, Raymond Field, who said: "The seal of the confessional is inviolable as far as I am concerned, and that’s the end of the matter."

Meanwhile, the Irish Association of Social Workers (IASW) has said that it "doesn’t have enough staff to cope with its current workload, never mind with the increased demand once mandatory reporting is introduced".

IASW president Ineke Durville said: "People are not coping at all at the moment. Yes, on paper we got 260 new posts as part of the Ryan Report implementation plan, but at the same time, people retiring, on maternity leave and sick leave are not being replaced.

"We also fear that because there will be this renewed emphasis on child protection because of mandatory reporting, resources will be taken from early intervention and it is this early intervention that stops a welfare care becoming a crisis case. We are operating as a fire brigade service as it is and that, we would imagine, will increase even further."

Vatican’s (positive) approach to the Church in China

The statement from the Pope’s commission does not mention the Beijing government, but emphasizes the role of the laity and says: “Illegitimate bishops have disturbed the faithful.”

A long and complex statement was issued today, upon conclusion of the work of the Commission on the Church in China, created by Benedict XVI in 2007 after publication of the papal letter addressed to Catholics. 

It expresses concern for current difficulties (bishops and priests detained or restricted in their freedom, the role of the Chinese Patriotic Catholic Association in illegitimate episcopal appointments), but the overall outlook is positive, and emphasizes aspects of “normality.” 

And above all, there is no reference to the Government of Beijing and the interference of government authorities in the Church.
 
The commission, which met in the Vatican for the fifth time, is composed of the heads of related curial dicasteries, some representatives from the Chinese Episcopate, and members of religious congregations in China. 

"With deep spiritual closeness to all brothers and sisters in the faith living in China, the Commission recognised the gifts of fidelity and dedication which the Lord has given to His Church throughout the past year.”
 
This is in keeping with the theme of the annual meeting, “Formation of Lay Faithful,” and also in view of the Year of Faith organized by the Pope. The committee stresses how Chinese laypeople “must enter ever more deeply into the life of the Church, nourished by doctrine, conscious of their being part of the Catholic Church, and consistent with the requirements of life in Christ,” calling especially for close study of the Catechism of the Catholic Church. 

But it also urges them “to take part in civic life and in the world of work, offering their own contribution with full responsibility: by loving life and respecting it from conception until natural death; by loving the family, promoting values which are also proper to traditional Chinese culture; by loving their country as honest citizens concerned for the common good.” 

As an ancient Chinese sage put it, “the way of great learning consists in illustrating noble virtues, in renewing and staying close to people, and in reaching the supreme good”. 

Finally, Chinese laypeople - considered the hope of the Church in China – “must grow in grace before God and men, by nourishing and perfecting their own spiritual life as active members of the parish community and by involving themselves in the apostolate, also with the help of associations and Church movements which foster their ongoing formation.”
 
In this regard, the commission “noted with joy that the proclamation of the Gospel by Catholic communities, which are sometimes poor and without material resources, encourages many adults to request baptism every year.” 

It therefore asks dioceses to promote “a serious catechumenate.” 

Moreover, bishops must “make every effort to consolidate the lay faithful in their knowledge of the teachings of Vatican Council II, and in particular of ecclesiology and the social doctrine of the Church.” 

It is “useful” to dedicate “special solicitude to the preparation of pastoral workers dedicated to evangelisation, catechesis and works of charity,” with special attention given to “the phenomenon of internal migration and urbanization.”
 
As for the sufferings of bishops and priests, the committee expressed “admiration for the strength of their faith and for their union with the Holy Father. They need the Church’s prayer in a special way so as to face their difficulties with serenity and in fidelity to Christ.” 

The implied reference here is to the members of the underground community of faithful.
 
The statement then mentions the “particular situation of the Church in China,” noting that “the claim of the entities, called “One Association and One Conference”, to place themselves above the bishops and to guide the life of the ecclesial community, persists.” 

These are, as is well-known, pro-government organizations whose role had already been criticized in the letter from Benedict XVI in 2007.
 
With regard to illegitimate episcopal ordinations, the statement mentions them, also mentioning “acts of jurisdiction or the Sacraments” carried out by these illegitimate bishops which “usurp” a power not granted to them by the Church. 

This refers to one of the issues taken under consideration during the meeting, namely the problem of ordinations celebrated by illegitimate bishops. 

Nothing seems to have been decided on the issue, since the text announces no decisions or proposed sanctions.
 
The statement then recalls that in recent days, some of these illegitimate bishops “took part in these illegitimate episcopal ordinations,” adding that “The behaviour of these bishops, in addition to aggravating their canonical status, has disturbed the faithful and often has violated the consciences of the priests and lay faithful who were involved.” 

The statement notes that the consequences of this participation by illegitimate bishops in consecrations authorized by Rome affect only themselves, that is, it worsens their position, but does not in any way affect the ceremonies presided over by them.
 
But regarding bishops in communion with Rome who participated in illegitimate episcopal ordinations, the statement reads: Many of these bishops have since clarified their position and have requested pardon; the Holy Father has benevolently forgiven them. 

Others, however, who also took part in these illegitimate ordinations, have not yet made this clarification, and thus are encouraged to do so as soon as possible. 

“Many of these bishops have since clarified their position and have requested pardon; the Holy Father has benevolently forgiven them. Others, however, who also took part in these illegitimate ordinations, have not yet made this clarification, and thus are encouraged to do so as soon as possible.” 

Again, there is no reference to canonical sanctions, but only an urging to repent and to clarify their position with the Holy See, as some have already done.

The members of the commission on China follow these “painful events with attention and in a spirit of charity. Though they are aware of the particular difficulties of the present situation, they recall that evangelisation cannot be achieved by sacrificing essential elements of the Catholic faith and discipline” - and obedience to the Pope is one of these elements. 

Finally, "With regard to priests, consecrated persons and seminarians” the commission reiterated the importance “of their formation,” but found that “the number of vocations to the priestly and religious life has noticeably declined in recent years.”
 
With regard to the two, often markedly differentiated approaches which have been invoked in recent years - patient dialogue and recognition of the special situation of China on the one hand, the firm invocation of canonical sanctions for participating in illegitimate consecrations on the other - today’s statement seems to express a middle position, embodied today by the Prefect of Propaganda Fide, Fernando Filoni, and the new Cardinal of Hong Kong, John Tong. 

They do not hide the problems, nor ignore principles, but their approach is pastoral, emphasizing the positive things taking place in the Chinese Church, viewed in its essential unity, without reducing to and focusing exclusively on the serious problems of illegitimate ordinations and unlawful interference by pro-government associations.

Crisis between U.S. nuns and Vatican has been a long time coming

The doctrinal rebuff which the LCWR received from the Holy See, has its roots back in 1971, when the U.S.’s women religious rewrote their statute.

The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, led by U.S. Cardinal William Levada, has asked for a deep reform of the Leadership Conference of Women Religious (LCWR), the organisation which represents the majority of religious women’s orders in the United States. 

The request for the reform came after the conclusions of an inquiry showed that ““the current doctrinal and pastoral situation of the LCWR is grave and a matter of serious concern.” 

The Congregation concluded that an intervention from the Vatican was necessary to reform the group. 

The Archbishop of Seattle, Peter Sartain, was chosen as the Vatican delegate to supervise the reform process. 

The leader of the LCWR will have to assist in reviewing the group’s statutes, plan programmes, review liturgical texts and reconsider the group’s affiliations to other organisations.
 
The Congregation’s declaration based on the results of an apostolic visit by the Bishop of Toledo, Ohio, Leonard Blaire, revealed "serious doctrinal problems which affect many in consecrated life." 

According to the Congregation of the Doctrine for the Faith, many American nuns have drifted away from “the fundamental Christological centre and focus of religious consecration.” 

One of the more serious accusations was that nuns had challenged the teachings of the Catholic Church on subjects such as homosexuality and the priesthood and that they had promoted “radical feminist themes incompatible with the Catholic faith.” 

The organisation was also criticised for making public statements that “disagree with or challenge positions taken by the bishops, who are the church's authentic teachers of faith and morals.” 

American bishops are critical of some aspects of Obama’s health care reform and yet dozens of nuns signed a document in support of it, detaching themselves from the stance taken by the Holy See on the issue. 

On its website, the LCWR says it has 1500 members and represents 80% of women religious in the U.S.

But this crisis goes back a long way.

“After having studied this for many years, I think it was 40 years in the making,” Ann Carey, author of Sisters in crisis: the tragic Uraveling of Women religious communities said. 

Relations between the LCWR and the Vatican have been stormy since 1971, when the LCWR rewrote its statutes. 

“The Vatican was patient, trying to give the sisters some guidelines to modify the direction they were taking, and they resisted that.” 

The changes made were so drastic that some nuns actually left the LCWR and formed a separate group, known as the Council of Major Superiors of Women Religious (CMSWR). 

But - and this is probably one of the many reasons that have driven the Holy See and particularly the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, while the Congregation for religious life has taken a much softer line – it is this minority that has the largest number of vocations. Indeed, numbers of women religious in the U.S. have dropped from 179.954 in 1965 to 55.000 today.

After their initial reaction to the inquiry’s conclusions, the leaders of the LCWR are now saying they are cautiously open to dialogue with the commission of American Bishops set up by Rome and led by the Archbishop of Seattle, J. Peter Sartain. 

“We will engage in dialogue where possible and be open to the movement of the Holy Spirit: We ask your prayers for us and for the Church at this critical time," the Archbishop said in a statement. Mgr. Sartain said he was committed to “help[ing] the sisters and the LCWR recognize that we are all in this together.” 

He went on to speak about his “personal appreciation for the role of religious women in the United States” and all the “all the extraordinary things they have done.” Sartain is aiming for a soft approach. Others, however, are less diplomatic. For example, Cardinal Raymond Leo Burke, head of the Vatican Supreme Tribunal, who some time ago denounced the "public and obstinate betrayal of religious life by certain religious."

Of course, the secular press immediately sided with the nuns against the Vatican. But there are others who are asking themselves whether certain kinds of behaviour and attitudes should be tolerated in the Church. George Weigel, a Church historian, writes that in most cases, as far as the LCWR is concerned, “their spiritual life is more likely to be influenced by the Enneagram and Deepak Chopra than by Teresa of Avila and Edith Stein; their notions of orthodoxy are, to put it gently, innovative; and their relationship to Church authority is best described as one of barely concealed contempt.”

In some communities of nuns belonging to the LCWR, many do not attend the Eucharist regularly because - Weigel says - they cannot abide the “patriarchy” of a male priest presiding at mass. Some churches allegedly celebrate fake Eucharistic services. In others, liturgical rules are said to bend the liturgical norms to the breaking point in order to radically minimize the role of the male priest. 

And as Weigel mercilessly adds, “The other fact to be noted about the LCWR congregations — largely unremarked in the Gadarene rush to pit plucky nuns against Neanderthal prelates — is that they're dying.” 

Faced with the theological, spiritual and behavioural meltdown of many congregations, “young Catholic women have quite sensibly decided that, if they wish to do good works or be political activists while dressing like middle-class professionals and living in apartments, there is little reason to bind themselves, even in an attenuated way, to the classic vows of poverty, chastity, and obedience.” According to Weigel, without a radical overhaul, it is a matter of a decade or so before these orders, which are becoming “greyer and greyer”, disappear.

According to Marjorie Murphy Campbell, the LCWR’s main slipup was on the abortion question: “Sadly, in my opinion, many Catholic feminists, including the religious leadership of the LCWR, opted to ignore the fundamental conflict between the Church’s teaching on abortion and the foundational nature of abortion to the radical feminist agenda.”

Vatican embassy issue 'may be revisited in year or two'

The issue of reopening the Vatican embassy may be revisited in a year or two.

The Secretary General at the Department of Foreign Affairs, David Cooney, told the Public Accounts Committee that talks were on-going on working out a more flexible arrangement with the Holy See.

He said the Vatican was unlikely to cooperate if the negotiations were made public and said people who wanted to see the embassy re-opened would be better served by keeping quiet.

"They have their rules. They may make exceptions, but they don't want to broadcast their exceptions," he said.

"I think people who really want to see progress on this, the best thing they could do is just let things happen quietly. If the issue is to be revisited, I would say it's more likely to happen in a year or two."

Pope plans day-long trip to centers of Italian monastic tradition

The Vatican has announced plans for a visit by Pope Benedict XVI to three Italian towns closely connected with the history of monasticism. 

The Holy Father will travel to Arezzo, La Verna and Sansepolcro on May 13. 

Traveling by helicopter first to Arezzo, the Pope will celebrate Mass there and lunch with the bishops of the Tuscany region before continuing his trip with a short flight to La Verna. 

There he will visit the Chapel of the Wounds, favored by St. Francis of Assisi, and meet with Franciscan friars and Poor Clare nuns. 

A final leg of the trip will take him to Sansepolcro, and the cathedral that is home to the famous crucifix known as the Santo Volto (Holy Face). 

He will return to the Vatican later that Sunday evening.

Pope calls in Opus Dei troubleshooter to uncover source of Vatican leaks

Vatican staffers who have been leaking embarrassing letters about corruption and nepotism inside the tiny city state are to be hunted down by a crack squad of cardinals led by a senior member of the religious group Opus Dei.

Irritated by the anonymous release of documents to the press this year, Pope Benedict has named Cardinal Julian Herranz, 82, to lead a three-man team which will haul in staffers for questioning and rifle through files until they catch the perpetrators of what has been dubbed "Vatileaks".

A short statement printed on Thursday on the front page of the Vatican's daily newspaper warned the team had a full "pontifical mandate" to "shed complete light" on the whistle blowers, who have lifted the lid on alleged theft and false accounting.

Herranz was a long-time personal secretary to Josemaría Escrivá , the now canonised founder of Opus Dei, which has been accused of excessive secrecy, strict control over members and undue influence within the Vatican – a reputation pushed by Dan Brown's thriller The Da Vinci Code.

One of two cardinals who are members of the group, Herranz has insisted that Opus Dei has "no hidden agenda" and is only interested in the "the message of Christ", but he does appear to be cut out to be a Vatican troubleshooter, once stating that "men need to act decisively, like Jesus Christ – who was a real man".

Herranz's squad, which met for the first time this week, is just one of three inquiries now under way at the Holy See into the leak of letters in January and February that discuss the mysterious kidnapping of Emanuela Orlandi – the daughter of a Vatican employee in 1983 – the likely date of Benedict's death and an internal row over just how transparent the Vatican bank should be as it tries to shrug off allegations of money laundering.

The most shocking revelations are in a letter addressed to the Vatican's secretary of state by Archbishop Carlo Maria Viganò, the deputy governor of Vatican City, denouncing the signing by employees of inflated contracts with friendly companies. As proof, Viganò said he had discovered the price of the Christmas nativity scene in St Peter's Square was €250,000 (£204,000) more than it should have been.

One priest, who Viganò describes as "vulgar" and "arrogant" had been responsible for nepotism, fake invoicing and €70,000 going missing, he claimed.

After telling all, Viganò was reassigned to the US as papal nunzio, an appointment he describes as punishment for his honesty in a plaintive letter to Benedict in which he begs for a commission to look into his claims.

Since then, the Vatican has instead focused on finding out who leaked the letters, which it describes as "biased and trivial".

"I hope the Vatican employs the same tenacity in improving transparency at its bank and in reopening the Orlandi kidnapping case as it has with this inquiry," said Gianluigi Nuzzi, the Italian journalist who first broadcast the contents of the Viganò letters.

Herranz has been called in by the pope before to snuff out trouble at the Vatican. 

In 2007, he oversaw the suspension of a senior Vatican cleric who was secretly filmed telling a young man he was "hot" and that homosexual sex was not sinful.

Any employees now nabbed by Herranz and his team in the Vatileaks probe could be fired or face canonical punishment if they are clerics. 

But to track them down, the three "detectives" – as they were dubbed by Italian newspapers on Thursday – must penetrate the secretive world of the Vatican's bureaucracy, a task that Il Messaggero warned could turn out to be a "Mission Impossible".

Dublin churches unite for “Camino” Pilgrim Walk

Dubliners and visitors to the capital will be able to take part in a city centre “Camino” or Pilgrim Walk during the International Eucharistic Congress in June.

Details of the Pilgrim Walk, which involves visiting and praying in seven city centre churches, were announced following an ecumenical prayer service in St Ann’s Church in Dawson Street, Dublin Wednesday, April 25th. 

Church of Ireland Archbishop Michael Jackson presided at the prayer service joined by Auxiliary Bishop of Dublin, Ray Field and members of the Dublin Diocesan Eucharistic Congress Preparatory committee.

A Pilgrim Walk is a sacred journey during which pilgrims seek to strengthen and renew their faith. Pilgrims walk with a clear intention, to draw closer to God.

The Walk is being held from Saturday 2nd -16th June. During this time Pilgrims will be able to walk and visit seven designated churches in Dublin City and spend time in quiet prayer and reflection in each. 

All pilgrims will be issued with a “Pilgrim Passport” that will be stamped in each of the seven churches visited. 

The walk concludes with a visit to St. Mary’s Pro-Cathedral, Marlborough Street where pilgrims will receive a Pilgrimage Certificate of completion.  

People can participate in groups, on their own; they can complete the Pilgrim walk or “Camino” in a day or throughout the days of the Congress.

Speaking at the launch, Archbishop Michael Jackson said, “I am delighted that St Ann’s, Dawson Street, is associated with this most recent initiative in the exciting developments towards the International Eucharistic Congress. St Ann’s location allows a prime opportunity to welcome Congress pilgrims, something I know the parish feels privileged to be able to do.”

Bishop Ray Field said, “The essential nature of pilgrim walks remains a powerful experience for the spiritual life of Christians. I invite and encourage as many people as possible to walk with us in the days leading up to and during the Congress.”

The seven churches participating in the Pilgrim Walk are St Ann’s, Dawson Street, St. James, James Street, Our Lady of Mount Carmel, Whitefriar Street, John’s Lane, Thomas Street, St. Mary of the Angels, Church Street, St. Michans, Halston Street, and St. Mary’s Pro Cathedral, Marlborough Street. 

These churches will open from 8am to 8pm in order to facilitate pilgrims. 

A Pilgrim Mass will also be held at 5.45 pm each day in St. Mary’s Pro-Cathedral.

Ends

Further information:
 
Carol Faulkner, 
Communications Office, 
Archdiocese of Dublin 

01 -8360723/0876172947
 

Vatican commission says illicit ordinations in China cause scandal

Lay Catholics in China have been scandalized by priests who are ordained bishops without papal approval and by the participation of Vatican-recognized bishops in those ordinations, said the Vatican Commission for the Catholic Church in China.

The very identity of the Catholic Church as "apostolic" -- guided by the faith handed down from the apostles through bishops in communion with the pope -- "has been obfuscated by those clerics" who have been ordained bishops without papal recognition, said the statement released April 26 after a three-day meeting at the Vatican.

The commission said that in administering the sacraments and exercising jurisdiction over dioceses, bishops who are not recognized by the pope "usurp a power which the church has not conferred on them."

Bishops approved by the Vatican and recognized by the Chinese government were ordained April 19 and April 25, but the commission said illegitimately ordained bishops also participated in the ceremonies, "aggravating their canonical status" and disturbing the faithful laity and priests who attended.

Even worse, however, was that last year, some Vatican-approved bishops participated in the ordination of bishops who were not approved or recognized by the pope, the commission said.

At the time, the Vatican said that if the bishops were forced by the communist government to participate, they would not face canonical penalties and it asked the bishops to get in touch with the Vatican.

"Many of these bishops have since clarified their position and have requested pardon; the Holy Father has benevolently forgiven them," the commission said. The bishops who have not explained themselves were urged to do so.

The commission, which was focusing on the education of lay Catholics in China and the celebration of the upcoming Year of Faith, said "evangelization cannot be achieved by sacrificing essential elements of the Catholic faith and discipline."

"Obedience to Christ and to the successor of Peter is the presupposition of every true renewal and this applies to every category within the people of God. Lay people themselves are sensitive to the clear ecclesial fidelity of their own pastors," the commission said.

The commission also said the true identity of the Catholic Church cannot shine in China as long as the Chinese Catholic Patriotic Association and the Bishops' Conference of the Catholic Church in China -- both of which are government-controlled bodies -- continue "to place themselves above the bishops and to guide the life of the ecclesial community."

Looking specifically at ways to strengthen laypeople's knowledge of their faith, the commission recommended greater use of the Catechism of the Catholic Church.

It also encouraged them to bring their faith to bear on every aspect of their lives, particularly in their families, at work and by "loving their country as honest citizens concerned for the common good."

Catholics live their faith "by loving life and respecting it from conception to natural death," it said.

Despite a serious lack of material resources, the Catholic Church in China welcomes a large number of adults into the church each year, the commission said. In fact, just days before the commission began meeting at the Vatican, the Study Center of Faith in He Bei, China, published a report saying more than 22,100 Chinese were received into the church at Easter.

The Vatican commission encouraged Chinese Catholic dioceses to develop a thorough catechumen program to prepare candidates for baptism and asked them to adopt the formal Rite of Christian Initiation of Adults.

The commission also discussed the declining number of vocations to the priesthood and religious life in the country and asked Chinese Catholics to begin praying for vocations.

Timeline of Vatican relations with US women religious since 1950s

Here is a timeline of major events related to the Leadership Conference of Women Religious and the Vatican:

-- 1956: The Conference of Major Superiors of Women was founded as the sole canonical conference for U.S. superiors of women religious.

-- 1970-71: The Conference of Major Superiors of Women is restructured and changes its name to the Leadership Conference of Women Religious.

-- 1971: Some nuns who disapprove of LCWR's new directions create a new organization, the Consortium Perfectae Caritatis. They are concerned that what they consider necessary, distinctive elements of religious life -- such as a common identifying garb, community life and religious obedience to a superior as traditionally understood -- are disappearing among American sisters. In the early 1970s the consortium seeks recognition from Rome as an alternative conference to the LCWR.

-- 1974: The Vatican Congregation for Religious calls representatives of the two groups to Rome for a three-day meeting to try to sort out differences and improve dialogue. The Vatican rules that LCWR will remain the sole canonical conference for U.S. superiors of women religious.

-- 1974: The Institute on Religious Life is established to promote vocations and religious life in the United States. The Chicago-based organization is open to laity, priests and men religious as well, but women religious -- most of them linked with the consortium -- make up the bulk of its membership.

-- 1979: Welcoming Pope John Paul II to a meeting with 7,000 U.S. women religious in Washington, Mercy Sister Theresa Kane, then LCWR president, raises the issue of the church's prohibition of women priests by asking that women be allowed to participate in "all ministries of the church." Several days before, the pope had reaffirmed that an all-male priesthood is part of God's plan.

-- 1983: Archbishop John R. Quinn of San Francisco is named by Pope John Paul to conduct a Vatican-mandated study of U.S. religious life. He transforms the study into a nationwide dialogue over the next three years. The study is completed in 1986 with a 152-page report to Rome.

-- 1987: As a follow-up to the Quinn study, the National Conference of Catholic Bishops, the Conference of Major Superiors of Men and the LCWR decide to reinforce strengthened bishop-religious relations on an ongoing basis with a new Tri-Conference Commission of Religious and NCCB.

-- 1988: The Forum of Major Superiors, a new organization of women superiors formed in 1987 by the Institute on Religious Life, unsuccessfully petitions the bishops for a place on the commission.

-- February 1989: In a letter to the U.S. bishops responding to the Quinn study, the pope expresses concern about the "polarization" among U.S. women religious and calls for dialogue to resolve their divisions.

-- March 1989: At a Rome summit of U.S. archbishops with the pope and top Vatican officials, Cardinal James A. Hickey of Washington gives a talk on the "crisis" in U.S. religious life. He says women who do not belong to LCWR "desire some representation with the Holy See."

-- May 1989: The former Vatican Congregation for Religious, now called the Congregation for Institutes of Consecrated Life and Societies of Apostolic Life, appoints Cardinal Hickey to a three-year term as official liaison between non-LCWR women religious in the United States and the Holy See.

-- Fall 1991: A group of women's superiors, led by Discalced Carmelite Mother Vincent Marie Finnegan of Los Angeles, decides to try to form a new council that will receive canonical recognition from the Vatican.

-- Early 1992: Mother Vincent Marie, on behalf of herself and 43 other superiors, petitions the pope for recognition of the Council of Major Superiors of Women Religious and approval of its proposed statutes as a new canonical conference in the United States. According to sources, Cardinal Hickey personally intervenes with the pope and the religious congregation on behalf of the new group.

-- April 1992: Reacting to rumors about the new council, representatives of the LCWR, CMSM and the U.S. bishops meet with top officials of the religious congregation. They report back to LCWR members that congregation officials "affirmed that there will continue to be one canonically recognized, national conference of women religious leaders in the U.S., namely LCWR (and that)... the proposed entity is not a parallel conference nor is it an alternative to LCWR."

-- June 1992: Cardinal Hickey and Mother Vincent Marie jointly announce that the new council has been approved by the Vatican and that the superiors of 84 religious congregations, with a combined membership of 10,113 sisters, have applied for membership. LCWR and CMSM say they are "profoundly disappointed" with the Vatican decision. LCWR says its members represent 94 percent of the 99,894 sisters in the United States.

-- October 1994: The world Synod of Bishops addresses the topic of consecrated life. A past president of LCWR who attended the sessions says the synod "did not suggest that the direction taken by religious life since Vatican (Council) II can or should be reversed" and "wisely chose not to attempt specific solutions to local problems."

-- June 2004: Archbishop (later Cardinal) Franc Rode, newly appointed to head the Vatican religious congregation, says in a talk in Canada that the "secularization of society and religious communities," and Catholic families having fewer children, have contributed to the declining membership of Canadian religious communities.

-- April 2008: Bishop Leonard P. Blair of Toledo, Ohio, is named by the Vatican doctrinal congregation, to carry out a "doctrinal assessment" of the "activities and initiatives" of LCWR.

-- January 2009: Cardinal Rode initiates an apostolic visitation to determine why the number of members in religious communities of women in the U.S. had declined since the late 1960s and to examine the quality of life in U.S. communities.

-- July 2010: Bishop Blair completes an eight-page report on LCWR and submits it to the Vatican.

-- January 2012: The apostolic visitation team completes its work and submits its report to the Vatican.

-- April 2012: Vatican announces major reform of LCWR, citing "serious doctrinal problems which affect many in consecrated life." Archbishop J. Peter Sartain of Seattle is named to provide "guidance and approval, where necessary," of the organization's work. LCWR now says it represents 80 percent of the 57,000 women religious in the United States.

Bishops join call for US to ban landmine use

Representatives of more than 75 nongovernmental organizations have called on the United States to join a treaty banning the use of antipersonnel landmines.

Such a ban would illustrate the U.S.'s commitment to protect “civilians from the ravages of war,” and would align with the nation's “generous support for mine clearance programs around the world,” the leaders said.

Bishop Richard E. Pates of Des Moines, chairman of the U.S. bishops’ Committee on International Justice and Peace, joined with leaders of both religious and secular groups to encourage the United States to sign the 1997 Mine Ban Treaty.

Other signatories included representatives from groups including Catholic Relief Services, Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International USA.

In an April 4 letter to President Barack Obama and several members of his administration, the organization heads noted that the U.S. has already banned certain types of mines and called for a ban on the remainder as well.

The Obama administration recently concluded a multi-year interagency review of its landmine policy and is working to make a decision on future U.S. policy.

The signatories noted that the administration has received letters supporting the treaty from many Americans, including more than half of the U.S. Senators, 16 Nobel Peace Prize Laureates and several key NATO allies.

They observed that 159 countries have already agreed to the treaty, including every other member of NATO, every country in the European Union and nations such as Afghanistan and Iraq.

In addition, they said, the participation of the United States is important for “the universalization of the treaty” because some remaining countries have argued that they will not join if the U.S. does not.

The organization leaders also pointed out that the United States has not used antipersonnel landmines since 1991.

“Surely if the U.S. military has been able to defend the country for the last 21 years without using antipersonnel landmines, it can do so in the future as well,” they argued.

Calling the issue “a crucial humanitarian decision that should not be put off any longer,” the signatories urged the president to submit the treaty to the Senate without delay. 

“The last steps to acceding to the treaty are now achievable,” they said, adding that the landmine ban is “vitally important” to efforts aimed at protecting civilians, bolstering international norms and isolating irresponsible regimes.  

Rabbi knocks atheist's misuse of evolutionary theory

An Orthodox rabbi criticized atheism masked as science, citing a prominent biologist who said scientists should undermine religion to advance popular acceptance of evolutionary theory.

Rabbi Moshe Averick, a columnist for the Jewish magazine The Algemeiner Journal, chided a recent article by University of Chicago professor Dr. Jerry Coyne which depicted religion as an opponent of evolutionary theory and as something associated with social dysfunction.

“It is clear that Dr. Coyne is not promoting Science, he is promoting Atheism and all that it entails,” Rabbi Averick said in his April 24 column. 

“Coyne sees his role as being much greater than that of just a professor teaching a scientific discipline; he has donned the mantle of Atheologist and is spreading the good word wherever he can. It is for this reason that many Americans are justifiably antagonistic towards the worldview of Jerry Coyne.”

The rabbi focused on Coyne’s article “Science, Religion and Society: The Problem of Evolution in America,” published online by the journal “Evolution” on April 17.

“Ultimately, the best strategy to make Americans more receptive to Evolution might require loosening the grip of religion on our country,” Coyne said. 

“We could best promote evolution…by concentrating on bringing Catholics and mainline Protestants into the ‘no religion’ category!”

Religion, Coyne said, is the reason why Americans “hate evolution.” 

He added that resistance to evolution is “truly a byproduct of America’s extreme religiosity” because evolution “contravenes many common religious beliefs.” 

The contradicted beliefs, in his view, include both biblical literalism and beliefs involving “morality, meaning and human significance.”

Rabbi Averick countered that much of this “resistance to evolution” is against an atheistic version of evolutionary theory. Almost 40 percent of Americans accept a theistic form of evolution, a position also criticized by Coyne.

Rabbi Averick charged that the biologist is effectively engaged in “his own form of jihad on believers who refuse to display proper fealty to Coyne’s grand atheistic/scientific, and of course, Darwinian view of reality.”

In his article, the Chicago-based rabbi – author of the book “Nonsense of a High Order: The Confused and Illusory World of the Atheist” – zeroed in what what he called the philosophical consequences of Coyne’s stance.

He prefaced that American democracy is founded upon and bound to “fundamental religious principles.”

The Declaration of Independence, he noted, says that “all men are created equal” and “endowed by their Creator” with inalienable rights. The declaration also appeals to God’s judgment and states “a firm reliance on the protection of divine providence.”

Rabbi Averick underscored that human equality rests upon religious assumptions.

“Men are created equal as they stand in front of their infinite, transcendent Creator; they do not evolve equally at all! In fact, as pointed out by G.K. Chesterton, they evolve astonishingly unequal,” he said.

The rabbi contended that Darwinian evolution is not based on accountability to a higher power but is “the pitiless, indifferent, and unrelenting pressure of survival of the fittest.” 

An atheistic, humanistic philosophy like that of Coyne “ascribes dignity to human beings based on a religious principle, and when no one is looking, they simply subtract God from the equation.”

Coyne, he noted, has said that there are no objective moral truths in a materialistic universe and has contended that free will is an illusion.

“It seems patently absurd for Coyne to argue so vehemently for his position if his audience’s beliefs – and his own for that matter – are determined, not by decisions based on arguments, but by causes and effects beyond human control,” Rabbi Averick said.

Coyne’s article said that American social dysfunction is “associated with high degrees of religious belief,” citing a study that shows the United States ranking poorly on a measure of successful societies. 

In response, the rabbi credited religious belief with generating American “moral fortitude” in opposition to the totalitarian ideologies of the 20th century.

Rabbi Averick ultimately suggested that the “most important realms of human thought” are areas in which science has “little or nothing to say.”

Author warns of anti-humanism's global effects

The author of a new book outlined the global dangers of “anti-humanism,” a theory which holds that people are fundamentally bad because they destroy things and waste resources.   

“Human existence is not a struggle of all against all,” said Dr. Robert Zubrin. Rather, humans actually “benefit from the existence of other peoples and nations.”

Zubrin, an aerospace engineer and author, as well as the founder of the Mars Society, spoke at an April 24 event in Washington, D.C. sponsored by science and technology journal, “The New Atlantis.”

He discussed the arguments made in his new book, titled, “Merchants of Despair: Radical Environmentalists, Criminal Pseudo-Scientists, and the Fatal Cult of Antihumanism.”

Zubrin noted that anti-humanism has surfaced in different manifestations over past centuries, masked by both left and right wing movements.

One such manifestation was the work of 19th century economist Thomas Malthus, who claimed that because population increases at a much greater rate than food supply, rising population levels will lead to a decrease in humanity’s well-being. 

However, Zubrin explained, Malthus was an employee of the British East India Company, and his theory “was largely a rationalization” for the British to continue practices that fostered starvation in other countries.

Historical data shows that Malthus’ theory is “totally wrong,” he said, pointing to statistics indicating that as human populations increase, the standard of living also rises.

This makes sense because “the more people there are, the more technological advances there are,” he explained, noting that such advances are cumulative and therefore benefit the human population greatly.

He added that a similar strain of anti-humanism has also surfaced in the famous 1968 book, “The Population Bomb,” and other campaigns calling for urgent action to limit population growth to avoid running out of resources.

This argument is flawed, Zubrin said, because it fails to recognize that “resources are a human creation.”

He explained that human technology is able to create new resources that were not previously available. For example, oil was not a resource before we had drilling technology, he said. 

Thus, the human gift of ingenuity prevents man from running out of resources as some have feared.

Zubrin said that the anti-humanist ideology went on to influence the eugenics movements that led to atrocities such as the Holocaust.

He highlighted the anti-humanist belief that the individual is insignificant and the race alone has value, as well as the idea that war is needed to eliminate weak races and nations.

The Holocaust was seen as “applied biology,” he said, observing that the Nazi party openly said that it wanted to eliminate those who were unfit and succeeded in committing terrible crimes  “because this ideology was so pervasive.”

In America, the eugenics movement consisted largely of anti-immigration efforts, Zubrin said. 

Such efforts targeted those deemed inferior, who were considered to be “threatening the complete mental degeneration of the United States.”

More recently, the anti-humanist ideology has appeared in China’s brutal one-child policy, which utilizes forced abortions and sterilizations to prevent couples from having more than one child, he added. 

Today, anti-humanism can also be seen in the radical environmental movement, Zubrin said.

He offered multiple examples of efforts to suppress the human population for the sake of the environment, while ignoring the fact that “humans have improved the fertility of the biosphere.”

Opposition to chemicals and procedures that could save millions of human lives because of their effects on the environment shows a deeply anti-humanist viewpoint, he said.

“This isn’t about the environment at all,” he explained. “This is about making the case that humanity needs to be prosecuted.”

In the end, Zubrin said, this is a debate “about the nature of humanity.”

The anti-human point of view sees human beings as fundamentally destroyers whose activity must be limited and controlled, while the pro-human point of view sees human beings as essentially creators, for whom liberty is “a necessity,” he said.

Arguing that an anti-human ideology can quickly become “an incitement to genocide,” Zubrin explained that the choice is ultimately one between “war and peace, death and life, hate and love.”

Europe pushes back against the pope

Irish Catholics may embrace the idea of a more progressive church, but Pope Benedict isn’t willing to budge.

Almost nine in 10 believers, 87 per cent, think priests should be allowed to marry, according to a new survey by Ireland’s Association of Catholic Priests, and 77 per cent say women should be ordained. 

The survey results came on the heels of a rare rebuke by the pontiff of priests who question the church’s hard-line stance.

Earlier this month, Benedict denounced the “call to disobedience” by a dissident group of Austrian priests known as the Pfarrer Initiative. 

The group, led by the Reverend Helmut Schüller, advocates for the abolition of priestly celibacy and the ordination of women. 

Speaking from the altar at St. Peter’s Basilica in Rome, the Pope asked rhetorically, “Is disobedience a path of renewal for the church?” 

Apparently it depends on whom you ask. 

The Catholic Church “has changed time and again over the centuries,” says Rev. Schüller. 

“It is our hope that that can happen again.”

Eucharistic Congress 2012 - Prayer

 
 
Lord Jesus,
You were sent by the Father
to gather together those who are scattered.

You came among us, doing good and bringing healing,
announcing the Word of salvation
and giving the Bread which lasts forever.

Be our companion on life’s pilgrim way.

May your Holy Spirit inflame our hearts,
enliven our hope and open our minds,
so that together with our sisters and brothers in faith
we may recognise you in the Scriptures
and in the breaking of bread.

May your Holy Spirit transform us into one body
and lead us to walk humbly on the earth,
in justice and love,
as witnesses of your resurrection.

In communion with Mary,
whom you gave to us as our Mother
at the foot of the cross,
through you
may all praise, honour and blessing be to the Father
in the Holy Spirit and in the Church,
Now and forever.

Amen