Thursday, November 12, 2026

Nuncio halts parish reform process in the diocese of Speyer

The diocese of Speyer must suspend its ongoing parish structural reform at the behest of Nuncio Hubertus van Megen during the sedisvacance. 

The Apostolic Nunciature has communicated this to the diocese with reference to the provisions of the Church, as the diocese announced on Wednesday. 

Diocesan Administrator Markus Magin, the General Spiritual Assembly and the steering group of the reform process were disappointed and now expect significant consequences for the future of the diocese. 

"We will respect and implement the decision. However, I am disappointed with the content of the letter," Magin said.

In mid-August, Bishop Karl-Heinz Wiesemann resigned from his office. With the acceptance of the resignation, the bishop's chair is vacant. Until the seizure by the new bishop, diocesan administrator Magin leads the diocese. Church law stipulates that nothing may be changed during the sedisvacance ("Sede vacante, nihil innovetur", c. 428 § 1 CIC). 

As a statement, the Apostolic Nuncio cited "canonically justified concerns," according to the diocese. Continued work could "arouse expectations, initiate changes and establish personal obligations" that could significantly restrict the decision-making freedom of the future bishop.

The nuncio had reminded that according to church law, "the establishment, annulment and substantial change of parishes is reserved exclusively for the diocesan bishop"; likewise, that during the vacancy priests' council and diocesan pastoral councils stop passing and thus cannot take binding decisions. 

It is exclusively a matter of "protecting the freedom and full responsibility of the future bishop, so that he can make decisions of such great significance according to his own distinction and in full exercise of the leadership to which he is entitled," Magin quotes from the letter from van Megens.

Disappointment over lack of synodality

According to the diocese, Magin had envisaged, as a diocesan administrator, after consulting with other responsible persons at the diocese level and after church law advice, to prepare the reform further even during the sedisvacance. 

Essential or even legally binding decisions should be reserved for the new bishop. Magin was still convinced that this project was compatible with church law. The complete interruption did not adequately take into account the decisions taken so far and breached the continuity of diocesan life. 

From the point of view of the diocesan administrator, it thus opposes the true meaning of the prohibition of change under church law.

Magin sees the stop as an interruption of synodal participation processes. This threatened to discourage stakeholders. He also criticized how the decision came about. Those responsible in the diocese were not involved and their description of the diocesan situation was not sufficiently taken into account. This is contrary to the understanding of synodality that the Synod of World Bishops has formulated. "We have set out together with many believers on the way to a more synodal church. This includes involving people in consultations and decisions and shared responsibility. It is difficult for me to understand that this path is now interrupted without such participation," says Magin.

Large parishes planned

The diocesan administrator fears that the suspension will weigh on the entry of the new bishop. 

"We would have liked to have handed over to the new bishop well-prepared and with great unanimity concept designs for structural reform, on the basis of which he can make his decisions in full freedom," Magin explained. "Now there is a risk that he will have to regain lost trust first. We very much regret that.”

In the fall of 2024, the diocese of Speyer had published a first draft of a structural reform under the title "A blessing you should be". 

In a broad-based consultation process, more than 3,500 feedbacks from councils and groups, individuals and associations as well as honorary and full-time employees were obtained, according to the diocese. 

On the basis of this and the results of a consultation at the Diocesan Meeting, the draft was revised by five working groups. 

At the end of October 2025, the diocese presented the first results. 

Accordingly, only nine large parish units are planned, which are to replace the 70 previous parishes.