Monday, November 16, 2026

Beloved All Saints priest will remain through June, bishop reconsiders decision

The Rev. Fred Daley will stay on as a co-pastor at All Saints Church through June, according to a statement from the Roman Catholic Diocese of Syracuse.

Earlier this month, Bishop Douglas Lucia forced Daley, 79, to retire after 18 years at the church in Syracuse’s Westcott neighborhood. 

The diocese announced abruptly that it would hand the church leadership over in January to the Rev. John Manno, the priest at Holy Family in Syracuse and St. Marianne Cope church in Solvay.

The news stunned All Saints parishioners, who have insisted the bishop explain and reverse his decision. 

Parishioners suspected the church pushed Daley out because conservative leaders do not agree with his progressive practices.

More than 100 parishioners gathered in silent prayer Monday night while Lucia met privately with Daley and parish leaders from All Saints and St. Lucy’s churches.

Daley, who is openly gay, has long challenged conservative Catholic norms. The church has an LGBTQ+ Task Force, a Transgender Family Support Group and a group for gay, nonbinary and transgender Catholics who have felt ostracized at other churches.

In recent months, Daley has fiercely advocated for immigrants who have been swept up in President Donald Trump’s aggressive enforcement campaign.

Lucia made the announcement on the diocese website Friday.

After prayerful reflection, the statement said, the bishop has named Daley and Manno to serve together as pastors of All Saints Church from Jan. 2 to June 30. Manno will also serve as pastor of St. Lucy’s Church, where the Rev. Jim Mathews is retiring.

Manno is the only other active diocesan priest with experience in inner-city Syracuse churches and has ministered to the homeless and to marginalized populations on the South Side.

Daley has not commented on the announcement. The statement was expected to appear in church bulletins this weekend.