While civil authorities found no evidence of a crime, an independent investigation found credible evidence to support complaints of “frequent boundary violations with both minors and adults.”
In December 2024, 6 News reported that Father Joseph Reed was placed on administrative leave after the complaint was initially received and an independent investigation was conducted.
The Knox County Sheriff’s Office at the time shared that it had an open investigation into Reed, but the sheriff’s office said in January that it had closed the investigation after finding the allegations against Reed unsubstantiated.
On Tuesday, the Diocese released a statement explaining that the investigation began when two individuals brought concerns to the bishop regarding behavior that made them uncomfortable.
Although the independent investigator did not find evidence of a crime, but, the Diocesan Review Board determined that there was credible evidence to support the complaints.
The board is composed of trained professionals in law enforcement, the legal field, and medical and health-care professionals.
According to the Diocese’s release, there was evidence of “frequent boundary violations with both minors and adults” and that the violations were “frequent and consistent, grave and unbecoming of the Holy Priesthood.”
Because of this, the board recommended strong oversight for Reed in the future and an assignment with a seasoned pastor to “provide vigilance and mentoring.”
Bishop Mark Beckman is consulting with the Priest Personnel Board to recommend a future assignment for Reed, following the results of the investigation and recommendation of the Diocesan Review Board.
The Diocese of Knoxville Safe Environment Policies and Procedures Code of Pastoral Conduct provides specific guidance on setting strong boundaries for pastoral ministers to safeguard the well-being of everyone.
According to the release from the Diocese, this code of conduct holds priests to a standard that exceeds civil law.
Additionally, all clergy, staff, employees and volunteers are required to complete Safe Environment training before being allowed to participate in ministries, groups, and diocesan organizations.