Egypt’s Coptic Church, one of the oldest Christian denominations, is being threatened with a major schism within its ranks over demands by congregants to be allowed to divorce.
Dozens of Christian protesters demonstrated across from St. Mark’s Church in Cairo Monday, clashing with police, as they petitioned their church’s clerical council to grant them second marriage permits.
Dozens of Christian protesters demonstrated across from St. Mark’s Church in Cairo Monday, clashing with police, as they petitioned their church’s clerical council to grant them second marriage permits.
The Coptic Church, an orthodox denomination led by Pope
Shenouda III, restricts divorce to cases of adultery or the religious
conversion of one of the spouses.
On Saturday, the Right of Life Movement, a Coptic group, threatened that a large number of its members would collectively leave the ranks of the church if they were not granted the right to divorce.
On Saturday, the Right of Life Movement, a Coptic group, threatened that a large number of its members would collectively leave the ranks of the church if they were not granted the right to divorce.
The Egyptian daily Al-Wafd
reported that some 150,000 members could potentially break away from
the church, joining the evangelical or protestant denominations instead,
which comprise just some 5% of Egypt’s Christians.
"It is my civil right to get a divorce, how dare they prevent that from me?" Rafik Farouk, an Egyptian Copt who wants to divorce his wife, told The Media Line. "The church and the court make it almost impossible to prove adultery. They leave us hanging."
"It is my civil right to get a divorce, how dare they prevent that from me?" Rafik Farouk, an Egyptian Copt who wants to divorce his wife, told The Media Line. "The church and the court make it almost impossible to prove adultery. They leave us hanging."
Farouk said the Coptic Church was attempting to maintain the integrity
of the family at all costs, fiercely guarding the monopoly given to it
by the state in matters of marriage and divorce.
Family law is exclusively governed in Egypt by the religious
denominations. A Christian may, however, leave his denomination and be
judged by default under Islamic law, which is more lenient in allowing
divorce.
"We are portrayed as fornicators who only follow our lust. Pope Shenouda
keeps saying that we are acting against the New Testament," Farouk
said.
Up until 2008, Egyptian Christians divorced according to a 1938 bylaw
which allowed them to separate under nine conditions including
impotence, abandonment, abuse and mental disability. But local
Christians accuse Pope Shenouda of recently limiting the permissible
reasons to infidelity and conversion only.
"We could have left the church and accepted Islam, but we want to remain
in the church," Farouk said, adding that the clerical council must
become more cooperative and transparent. "We will continue to engage the
Church until the last moment."
He added, however, that many of his friends would consider converting in
order to attain a divorce and then rejoin the Church in order to
remarry. "It's a trick," he said.
Ishaq Ibrahim, an expert on religious freedom at the Egyptian Initiative
for Personal Rights, a Cairo-based human rights watchdog, said that the
exact number of Copts prevented from obtaining a divorce is unknown,
but estimated it at a few thousand cases. It was pointless trying to
convince the Church to change its policy, he believed, saying the only
viable solution being the creation of a parallel track for civil
marriage.
"We have no civil marriage in Egypt," he told The Media Line. "But
marriage is the responsibility of the State, not the church. The state
cannot force the church to change its doctrine, but it can create an
alternative which will allow Christians to divorce without converting
their religion."
Prior to Egypt's revolution in February, legislation of a unified
personal status law for Egypt's Christian minority was underway.
Christians comprise some 10% of the country's population of 80 million.
Ibrahim said that the Anglican Church was the only Christian
denomination which agreed to civil marriage in Egypt.
Inter-sectarian marriage is currently restricted in Egypt. Muslim men
are allowed to marry Christian women, but Christian men are banned from
marrying Muslim women unless they convert to Islam. Religions not
legally defined as "heavenly" (Judaism, Christianity and Islam) are not
recognized by Egypt's family law.
Right to Life, the Coptic pro-divorce movement, is planning to stage a
large protest at Egypt's Justice Ministry on September 15, demanding the
state immediately enact a civil marriage law.