Michael Moore has been
accused of a “dereliction of duty” for not continuing his predecessors’
bid to change the Act of Settlement, which discriminates against
Catholics and women, as renewed calls by the Catholic Church in Scotland
are made to scrap the antiquated legislation.
Last
year, Gordon Brown as Prime Minister began talks to reform the Act with
Bucking-ham Palace and leaders of 15 Commonwealth countries, whose
approval would be needed to bring about any change.
Previously,
Jim Murphy as Scottish Secretary and John Reid, the former Home
Secretary, had pushed for change, with the former branding the Act
“unfair and discriminatory” and the latter “offensive” and “divisive”.
The
legislation bans a member of the Royal Family from marrying a Catholic
and also maintains discrimination against women in the line of
succession.
In 2008, Autumn Kelly
relinquished her Catholic faith and converted to the Church of England
to ensure her husband, Peter Phillips, son of the Princess Royal, did
not lose his place in the line of succession.
During
the last parliament, Evan Harris, the former Liberal Democrat MP,
sought, unsuccessfully, to end the inbuilt discrimination of the Act of
Settlement.
Labour’s Keith Vaz, the
Leicester MP, is launching a fresh attempt to scrap the 309-year-old
Act with his Succession to the Crown Bill, which will be debated in
January.
He has also tabled a
parliamentary motion that “recalls the all-party agreement in the last
Parliament to amend the law and calls on the Government to legislate to
end these outdated, sexist and anti-Catholic aspects of the
constitution”.
Last night, Tom
Greatrex, the Shadow Scotland Office Minister, took Scottish Secretary
Michael Moore to task for failing to follow up his predecessors’
campaign to end “blatant discrimination against Catholics”.
The
Labour MP for Rutherglen and Hamilton West told The Herald: “Michael
Moore’s two immediate predecessors were both active in getting the
Government to address this issue.
While it is largely symbolic, it does
go to the heart of the kind of society we are.
“Michael
Moore appears to have done absolutely nothing to keep this on the
agenda and, given the role that he has, it is a dereliction of duty.”
Meantime, the Catholic Church in Scotland intervened, branding the Act of Settlement “iniquitous and incongruous”.
A
spokesman for Cardinal Keith O’Brien said: “Neither the present
Government nor its predecessors showed any sign of repealing it.
Frankly, we still think the Act, apart from being unjust, is ultimately a
serious barrier to tackling problems like sectarianism and
anti-Catholic bigotry in Scotland. It’s
difficult for a government at any level, Westminster or Holyrood, to
assert that sectarianism is wrong when the Act perpetuates it.”
In
response, the Scotland Office made clear abolition of the Act could
happen but gave no indication that moves were actively afoot to bring it
about.
A spokesman said: “The
Government recognises that this is an important issue and have not ruled
out a change to the Act of Settlement but, if we are to undertake
change, we need to do it in a careful and thoughtful way.”
He
added: “It is correct for Mr Greatrex to highlight the fact that,
while previous Scottish Secretaries did regularly talk about the
changing the Act of Settlement, they didn’t actually do anything about
it.”
SIC: HS/UK