The pope won praise among some Brazilians for focusing on poverty and
the need for political activism instead of potentially more divisive
issues such as abortion and gay marriage, issues where many young
Catholics diverge from their pastors' conservative teachings.
Francis seemed to endorse the mostly young demonstrators
who have been taking to the streets here since last month to demand an
end to corruption, excessive government spending and lack of basic
services such as education and healthcare.
"The pope's telling us to listen to the voice of the streets, that
was good," said Pedro Abramovay, a human rights activist and professor
at the Getulio Vargas Foundation law school in Rio.
"It reinforces this
important political moment in Brazil … when there is a great opportunity
to reshape Brazilian democracy."
Of all his comments, Francis
was perhaps most critical of the church's failure to stop the
hemorrhaging of members to rival denominations, which he blamed on
numerous factors, including an adherence to rigid rules and
intellectualism over the "grammar of simplicity."
Brazil is the world's largest Catholic country. But, according to
census data and a recent poll, the percentage of Brazilians who identify
as Catholics has declined by 6 percentage points in just the last three
years, to 57%.
And among 16- to 24-year-olds, the number of Catholics
has fallen to 44%, while 38% say they are Protestants, which here almost
always means membership in an evangelical church.
Andrew Chesnut, an author and professor of religious studies at Virginia Commonwealth University, said inclusion of the charismatic elements in Sunday's Mass was a positive step.
But the gesture is also overdue, in part because discussion of social
justice, a favored Francis theme, remains esoteric for many of Latin
America's poorest, while the evangelicals offer more concrete and
immediate benefits, Chesnut said.
"This has the potential for sparking a revitalization of the church,"
Chesnut said of the pope's week in Brazil. "But nobody can stop the
trend of pluralization of religions."
By nearly every account, the trip has been a roaring success for
Francis, who has displayed his ease with pilgrims and his accessible
messages, despite considerable logistical troubles such as failing
public transportation that stranded worshipers and overly strained
electrical and water systems.
"It's been like Teflon for the pope where the [organizational]
problems are concerned," said Francis X. Rocca, Rome bureau chief for
the Catholic News Service. "He goes back to Rome with his prestige
definitely enhanced."
A mean task awaits him there.
He is forgoing the usual papal summer in the Castel Gandolfo outside
Rome and is instead expected to shake up the Vatican's equivalent of a
Cabinet with new appointments. Already, though, he seems to be meeting
resistance, or at least controversy.
Two key appointments to a team
meant to launch much-needed oversight of Vatican administration are
being attacked in some Italian media circles as, on one hand, an
indiscreet gay priest and, on the other, an indiscreet Twitter-user.
In comments to reporters on the flight to Rome, the pope said that
he opposed any type of lobby that might try to influence his decisions.
He was responding to a question about the so-called gay lobby inside the
Vatican that some officials have alleged exists as a cabal of gay
priests who run the Holy See.
He said it was important to
distinguish between a lobby, which he did not approve of, and priests or
other Catholics who might be gay.
“If a person is gay, seeks God and has good will, who am I to judge?” Francis said. “They should not be marginalized.”
The church has traditionally labeled homosexuality a “disorder,” and under Pope Benedict XVI,
who resigned in February, men with “deep-seated tendencies” toward
homosexuality were to be barred from the priesthood. Francis’ comments
seemed to back away from an absolute ban.
On women, he repeated
the church position that they cannot be priests. But he added women
should not be “limited to being altar girls” and should be given
expanded administrative roles in the church.
On the
scandal-plagued Vatican bank, suspected of being used to launder
millions of dollars, Francis said he would heed the advice of a
five-member special oversight committee. But he said he did not know
whether the bank could be saved or must be closed.
“Whatever the solution, it must have transparency and honesty,” Francis said.
Even on his lone day of rest here, after a flight of more than 15
hours, Francis was reported to be working on problems back in Rome.
Maybe that is what he had in mind as he bade farewell to his native
continent Sunday night.
"Already I am beginning to miss Brazil," he said. "I shall miss the warm and natural smiles."