Parents protested at St. Agatha Catholic School Tuesday night.
One side wants Father Rolando Garcia removed from the Catholic School while the other side supports Garcia.
"Simply put, I don't feel comfortable with him at the school, and I think it is appropriate for him to be moved," said parent Erica Garcia.
The two sides are at odds because Father Garcia was named in another lawsuit alleging he abused a young boy at another church in the 1980s. "My position is we are judging a priest without having anything from a court," said a supporter.
The Archdiocese of Miami previously settled a lawsuit against Father Garcia in 2007. Garcia, a pastor of the school's Catholic church, regularly interacts with children, and parents are concerned.
According to the Archdiocese of Miami, they have given Garcia a polygraph, which he passed and have allowed to him to remain as pastor.
Parents are so worried, though, they have organized an on-line petition and want him to be removed until the second lawsuit is settled in court.
"As parents, we are a little bit concerned there is a new allegation against Father Garcia," said parent Sebastian Rejon.
Father Garcia denies all allegations.