Lambour, however, didn't live to see it.
He died in September 2025 at 67, after years of pressing the church to acknowledge his allegations.
DeWater, who denied another accuser's allegations in an exclusive interview with WWL, died in 2023 at 88.
New Archbishop James Checchio added deWater and 26 other priests to the list Friday, bringing the total clergy on the list to 106. DeWater's entry on the updated list notes that nine proofs of claim were filed against him in the archdiocese's bankruptcy case, which concluded with a $305 million settlement early this year.
Checchio did not respond to specific questions about why deWater was added now, years after allegations against him became public and his predecessor launched a formal investigation.
For Lambour's younger brother, David, the announcement brought both relief and renewed frustration.
"I'm sad that it has taken six years almost since your original reporting," David Lambour said, referring to WWL's detailed report on deWater in January 2021.
"But it's a pattern of lies, obfuscation, deflection. And it's been the same way for however many years it has been since the first victim."
Years of unanswered calls
WWL first interviewed Mark Lambour in August 2018.
He demonstrated how calls to the archdiocese's clergy abuse hotline went straight to voicemail.
"This is why it's frustrating," he said. "This is why you can't get help."
Lambour said he first reported his abuse to the archdiocese in 2011. He accused deWater of molesting him in 1972, when he was an altar boy and deWater was pastor at St. Francis Cabrini Church.
In a December 2020 interview, Lambour described being in the church sacristy when the priest put his arms around him and kissed the back of his neck, then fondled him.
He recalled panicking, hoping someone in the church would hear him.
"I just kind of broke away crying, just said 'I'm going to tell my dad,'" Lambour said. He added that he never told his father, a burly widower, for fear he would have gone into a rage and killed deWater.
Two months after WWL first started looking into Lambour's allegations in 2018, then-Archbishop Gregory Aymond released a list of 57 clergy credibly accused of sexual abuse. DeWater was not on it.
The omission devastated Lambour. As Aymond added names over the following years, deWater remained absent.
In late 2020, a second accuser came forward, and Aymond launched a formal investigation.
Earlier this year, another man who said deWater abused him as a boy, Andre Fourroux, told WWL that the priest belonged on the list.
"He needs to be added!" Fourroux said in February.
Aymond retired earlier this year without adding deWater.
DeWater said Aymond believed him
In December 2020, WWL sent a crew to interview deWater at his home in the Netherlands.
DeWater welcomed the crew inside his apartment in Voorhout, southwest of Amsterdam, and said he had spoken with Aymond just two few days earlier. DeWater said Aymond informed him of the formal investigation in a letter and spoke with him about it on the phone.
DeWater still had his paperwork related to the allegations out on his living room table, and he described the archbishop as understanding.
Asked whether he felt Aymond believed him, deWater replied: "I have the feeling that he believes me. Yeah."
The second accuser alleged that deWater took him swimming naked. DeWater acknowledged going swimming with him but denied undressing in front of him or seeing the boy unclothed.
"The changing was done separately," deWater said.
Asked whether anything happened in the swimming pool, he responded: "No, no, absolutely nothing."
The nine bankruptcy proofs of claim now noted in deWater's entry are allegations submitted through the bankruptcy process, not criminal charges.
Unless forcible rape is alleged or a victim was taken across state lines, deadlines for filing criminal charges for sexual assaults that allegedly happened before the 1990s have almost all run out.
But that's not the case for civil lawsuits. The Louisiana Legislature enacted a "lookback window" for filing for damages from decades-old sexual assault claims, paving the way for the archdiocese to settle around 600 claims in its bankruptcy.
Checchio pledges to face the truth
In a recorded video announcing the list update Friday, Checchio called the release "a heavy day and a sad day" and connected the disclosures to the church's obligations under its bankruptcy settlement.
"The road forward has to be connected with the telling of the truth," he said, also emphasizing assistance for survivors.
"We have to be willing to face the truth, whatever it was," he said.
Checchio said no clergy with allegations found credible remain in ministry in the archdiocese. He also pledged to do everything possible to prevent further abuse.
When Checchio took over from the retiring Aymond in February, the new archbishop asked a church board that reviews allegations of abuse to take a fresh look at all claims made through the archdiocese's 2020 bankruptcy case, archdiocesan spokeswoman Sarah McDonald said.
That review led to the additions announced Friday, she said.
Those assurances did not answer why deWater's name remained off the list for years after Lambour and others came forward.
For David Lambour, the consequences of that wait are inseparable from his brother's struggles.
He remembers Mark as the older brother who looked after him when they were children. Later, their roles reversed as Mark struggled with the effects of childhood trauma.
David believes the abuse set his brother on a downward spiral involving drinking and other mental and physical health problems.
"I believe that the incident perpetrated by Joseph deWater killed my brother," he said. "Not immediately, but (it) set him on a path of a downward spiral that ended up costing him his life."
Now, David is relieved that the church has finally named the priest his brother accused, even as he says the ordeal cost him his own faith.
And he had a message for other survivors, hoping they'll be inspired by his brother's courage.
"You're not forgotten," he said, "and that there hopefully will be better days for you."
