Kevin Kijewski, a Michigan attorney and former superintendent of Catholic schools in Detroit and Denver, said the directive was delivered to his home on 26 October, the day before a meeting organised by the Parish Preservation Alliance, an organisation seeking to defend parishes threatened by the Archdiocese’s restructuring plans.
The document, dated 22 October, specifically identified the meeting, which brought together more than 600 Catholics from over 120 parishes in suburban Detroit.
According to Kijewski, the directive prohibited him from offering “canonical advice or guidance” to Catholics within the Archdiocese, raising money for any canonical cause or working with a canon lawyer who had not received the Archbishop’s approval.
Later that evening, the Archbishop’s vicar for the Archdiocese warned him that by attending the gathering he “will knowingly be in violation” of the directive. Kijewski attended the meeting regardless, saying that he was challenging the directive through the Church’s own procedures.
He subsequently set out these circumstances in a feature for Catholic World Report, arguing that the restrictions raised questions about the rights of Catholics to organise independently and discuss the future of their parishes.
According to Kijewski’s account, the Archdiocese projects that the number of active priests will fall from 224 to approximately 130 by 2034. Its director of parish renewal has said that the Archdiocese “simply can’t continue to serve the 209 parishes” with the number of priests expected to be available. Kijewski argues that the shortage does not, in itself, justify closing churches or merging parishes out of existence.
He points to a 2020 Vatican instruction on parish restructuring, which provides for neighbouring parishes to be entrusted to a single pastor where there are insufficient priests. This is the arrangement being pursued through Detroit’s new pastorates.
The instruction, he argues, distinguishes between sharing a priest and suppressing a parish. A shortage of clergy may justify placing several communities under one pastor, but it is not automatically sufficient grounds for eliminating a parish.
He also questions the practical implications of the Archdiocese’s assurance that churches will not necessarily be closed. Without Sunday Mass, he argues, a church can effectively cease functioning as a parish community even without a formal decree of closure.
The restructuring also involves the reassignment of almost every parish priest in the Archdiocese during the summer of 2027, with only nine priests exempted.
Kijewski acknowledges the Archbishop’s authority to reassign clergy but argues that the same Vatican instruction calls for pastoral stability and consideration of the relationship between a priest and the community he has served.
The 27 October meeting was organised independently of the Archdiocese, with the Parish Preservation Alliance bringing parishioners together to hear a canon lawyer explain their rights under Church law. Under the current timetable, Catholics are expected to learn the final decisions on the weekend of 17–18 April 2027.
Kijewski also challenged a 28 October statement from the Archdiocese warning Catholics about “outside organizations and individuals” seeking donations while claiming that canon law could prevent or control the restructuring.
Following discussions with the Vatican’s Dicastery for the Clergy, the prohibition was withdrawn as “too restrictive of the rights of the faithful”. Rome subsequently reversed several of the proposed closures. Kijewski argues that the Detroit directive goes further because it concerns not simply the use of parish property but the ability of a layman to participate in an independently organised gathering in a rented hall.
Kijewski concluded by calling on the Archdiocese to honour its original commitment to an open restructuring process, including allowing Catholics to meet independently, seek canonical advice and determine who will assist them in making their concerns heard.
