Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Bishop replaces progressive priest after 18 years at Syracuse parish

The Bishop of Syracuse has announced the retirement of a controversial parish priest who has become a prominent advocate for LGBTQ+ Catholics and progressive political causes. 

Bishop Douglas Lucia has accepted the retirement of Father Fred Daley, 79, pastor of All Saints Catholic Church in Syracuse, New York, effective January 2. 

Father John Manno, 51, currently pastor of Holy Family Church in Fairmount, will succeed him as pastor of All Saints and St Lucy’s Parish.

The announcement came on Thursday, November 5, when Bishop Lucia summoned Father Daley and Father James Mathews, the 89-year-old pastor of St Lucy’s, to his office. The decision was subsequently included in a letter outlining the diocese’s wider pastoral restructuring.

The news has provoked considerable opposition among members of All Saints, according to local press reports. Parishioners had celebrated the 18th anniversary of the parish only a week earlier. Around 200 people attended a Mass on Saturday at which Father Daley addressed his impending departure, with some parishioners openly weeping when he explained the bishop’s decision.

“It certainly is a shock to me and to us all,” Father Daley told the congregation, according to Central Current.

The priest had previously been expected to assume a leading position in the Costello Project, an initiative intended to preserve the Church’s ministry among disadvantaged communities in Syracuse despite declining numbers of priests and Catholics moving towards suburban parishes.

The project, named after the late Bishop Thomas Costello, was developed by teams from All Saints and St Lucy’s over approximately two years. Its original arrangements envisaged Father Daley leading both parishes until July before overseeing the sharing of resources with the Brady Faith Center, the Spiritual Renewal Center and the Ignatian Volunteer Corps.

Bishop Lucia has now decided to expand the initiative, incorporating St Anthony’s Parish on Colvin Street and eventually the Cathedral of the Immaculate Conception downtown, following the retirement of its current pastor, Monsignor Neal Quartier.

Father Daley told parishioners that the bishop considered it beneficial for a younger priest to lead the expanded project. He also acknowledged that the decision to appoint Father Manno had come as a surprise.

“The bishop feels that it would be beneficial for a new pastor, one younger than 79, to take that position,” he said, prompting objections from the congregation.

Diocesan spokeswoman Danielle Cummings has maintained that the decision was motivated by the need for a long-term transition amid a shortage of priests, rather than political disagreements, according to Syracuse.com. She pointed out that priests are required under canon law to submit their resignation to their bishop upon reaching 75, although the bishop determines when to accept it.

“If it was motivated by that, it would have happened 18 years ago,” she said, rejecting suggestions that political considerations had prompted the decision.

Some parishioners believe Father Daley’s departure is connected to disagreements over the parish’s activities and his relationship with the bishop. Dale Avers, a member of the parish council, said Father Daley had previously been summoned to the bishop’s office on several occasions over matters including the celebration of Mass, LGBTQ+ activities and the decision to host Democratic Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez at the church on September 28.

“Father Fred has been called into the bishop’s office several times in the last few years – because he didn’t say Mass according to what they think, or because of our LGBTQ pride activities, or for opening the church to an event with AOC,” she told Central Current.

Avers questioned why the bishop had previously approved Father Daley’s involvement in the Costello Project before deciding to replace him.

“I think it has to do with politics,” she said. “If it isn’t politics, what is it?”

The bishop had also written to priests in 2024 stating that secular or politically charged banners and flags had no place inside churches or on church property, with American and Vatican flags excepted.

The controversy has also revived attention to the bishop’s previous recognition of Father Daley’s charitable work. In 2023, Bishop Lucia presented him with a Bishop’s Award, praising him as a “leading light” for his service to vulnerable communities, diversity, inclusivity and justice.

Father Daley told parishioners that he had never intended to retire but accepted that his future ministry would take a different direction.

“I deeply appreciate the love and care for me as I figure out my future,” he said. “I clearly had no intention to retire … but I’m sure that whatever lies ahead, I will continue to have fun with all of you working for justice and peace.”

He also urged the congregation not to make the parish dependent upon its individual priests, saying: “If All Saints and St. Lucy’s were all about Fred Daley and Jim Mathews, then we haven’t done a good job of teaching that we are ALL the church.”

Bishop Lucia has scheduled a meeting with the worship teams of both parishes, while parishioners have planned a vigil at All Saints to pray and demonstrate their support for Father Daley.

Father Manno, who has led Holy Family for 12 years and also oversees St Marianne Cope in Solvay and Our Lady of Peace in Lakeland, previously served at St James Parish on Syracuse’s South Side. He founded the Emmaus Ministry, which provides meals and healthcare to disadvantaged people, and serves the diocese as vicar for clergy.

Father Fred Daley is known for championing progressive causes. He is one of the few openly gay priests in the United States, having made the disclosure in 2004.

On 15 June 2025, Fr Daley celebrated Mass at All Saints with a rainbow flag reportedly projected above the altar and tabernacle. According to the Lepanto Institute, he opened the service by telling parishioners that they were celebrating Pride Weekend. In June 2013, All Saints hosted an LGBTQ+ Pride interfaith prayer service.

At the most recent service celebrated at All Saints, the priest opened by referencing the US midterms, which led to a spontaneous round of applause from the congregation. He told the congregation: “Although we are not supposed to talk about politics in church, what really struck me over and above so many other things was just the beautiful inclusivity and diversity of people elected from Christians, Jews, Muslims, no religion, every colour, every sexual orientation and identity … it sort of gave us a shot in the arm, didn’t it, of what we are really all about.”