Historical figures listed as secret police ‘network contacts’ include the late Cardinal László Paskai of Esztergom-Budapest and Archbishop István Seregély of Eger, as well as two living bishops.
Hungary’s bishops have warned Catholics against leaping to judgement after the release of Communist-era archives revealed the names of clergy and bishops who co-operated with the secret police before 1989.
In a statement on 4 November, the day the State Security archives became available to the public, the Hungarian Catholic Bishop’s Conference recalled the words of John Paul II about the importance of “purifying memory, coming to terms with the wounds of the past and healing them”.
Releasing the files, the bishops said, could facilitate this “provided it does not lead to oversimplified conclusions and is not intended to destroy specific individuals”.
They urged caution in interpreting sources which, due to the uneven survival of records, is often fragmentary or inconclusive.
“Behind the names of church members … lie a wide variety of stories,” they said, recalling that some persons listed, “were tortured or blackmailed”.
Some informants, they continued, nominally co-operated but wrote “meaningless reports”, thereby subverting the system.
Even so, the bishops acknowledged that among clergy there were “those who did indeed collaborate with the party-state and passed on confidential information about community members and others”.
The statement continued: “On their behalf, we ask for forgiveness from the victims and their families.”
Records made available in the first wave of releases (which are searchable online) provide minimal information. They show basic data including the date of recruitment, an agent’s code name, the assigned area of activity and whether recruitment relied on coercion, incentive or “patriotism”.
The latter designation is treated sceptically by experts who argue that a fiction that co-operation by agents was mostly voluntary was an important part of the security services’ institutional psychology.
The newly released records contain about 60,000 names. That figure, however, includes several thousand people who were invited to become agents but refused, or who were simply identified as “of interest” to security services.
More detailed agent personnel records (“B Files”) will be released in February, but these will clarify only 9,000 cases.
The disparity arises from strategic destruction of records by security services before and after the fall of the Communist government. It is thought that traces of only about one third of the agent body survive.
Overall, between seven and 10 per cent of clergy across the Christian denominations are understood to have co-operated, with the proportion higher among senior clergy.
Significant historical figures listed as ’network contacts’ include Cardinal László Paskai OFM, who served as Archbishop of Esztergom-Budapest and Primate of Hungary from 1993 to 2002, Archbishop István Seregély of Eger, who led his diocese for 20 years until 2007 and was president of the bishops’ conference from 1990 to 2005.
Among living clergy, the former Bishop of Vác Miklós Beer and the current Bishop of Szeged-Csanad László Kiss-Rigó are also listed. Both, however, firmly deny any involvement, arguing that their identification as agents was an administrative error.
Bishop Kiss-Rig’s office also cited a 2009 court judgement which ruled allegations of his involvement with the security services were unproven.
.jpg)