New laws that would force anti-abortion campaign group Youth Defence
to disclose the source of its funding are being considered by
Environment Minister Phil Hogan.
Mr Hogan has made the commitment to
examine the possibility of imposing sanctions on groups other than
political parties that refused to disclose their funding in legislation
due before the Dáil in the autumn.
He made the promise in
response to a letter from the chairman of the Standards in Public Office
Commission (Sipo) asking for its powers to be strengthened.
Sipo’s chairman, Justice Matthew Smith, told Mr Hogan it has been
“impossible for the commission to operate effectively” in the area of
abortion campaigning.
He said the recent debate on abortion “has once again highlighted the ineffectiveness of the existing provisions”.
Under current law, any third party that receives a donation of more
than €100 and is involved in political campaigning must register with
Sipo and declare the source of its funding.
However, failure
to comply with this provision does not carry any offence or penalty, and
therefore is often ignored by campaign groups.
Sipo has
regularly raised this issue in its annual reports and highlighted
concerns following the debate on the Lisbon Treaty referendum about its
inability to monitor third parties involved in that particular campaign.
In response to Justice Smith’s letter, Mr Hogan said he could
confirm that consideration will be given to the commission’s
recommendations during the preparation of updated laws on referendum and
election campaign funding.
Yesterday, the Irish Examiner
reported correspondence between Sipo and a member of the public,
informing them that Youth Defence — which is known for its graphic
anti-abortion ad campaigns — had repeatedly refused requests to declare
its funding.
“In essence, without legislative support, the
standards commission is not in a position to act on your complaint,” the
commission wrote.
Questions have been raised over how Youth Defence funds its sophisticated media campaign and nationwide advertising drive.
Joseph Scheidler of the US-based Pro-Life Action League recently
claimed that hundreds of thousands of US dollars have poured into the
anti-abortion campaign in Ireland, with Youth Defence among the big
recipients.
The organisation did not answer a number of
queries from the Irish Examiner on where it got its funding, or why this
information is not available.
Last summer, the advertising
watchdog said it had received more than 100 complaints about Youth
Defence’s billboard ads which were described as “offensive and
inaccurate”.
However, the Advertising Standards Authority of
Ireland said it was powerless to do anything about the concerns because
banning the advertisements would amount to a breach of freedom of
speech.
The ads showed images of foetuses and young,
distraught women, and carried slogans such as “abortion tears her
life apart”, and “there’s always a better answer”, with the word
“always” underlined.