Doubts have emerged on whether Magdalene women who have previously
received compensation because they resided in industrial schools or
other institutions will qualify for further payment under the new
scheme.
The president of the Law Reform Commission, Mr Justice
John Quirke is to recommend criteria to be applied when assessing
provision in terms of “payments” and supports such as medical cards and
counselling services to the Magdalene women.
A Department of
Justice spokeswoman said the issue of further compensation for women who
were sent to the laundries from industrial schools – and were thus
compensated by the State Redress Board – “will be considered by Judge
Quirke”.
However, Minister of State for Trade Joe Costello said:
“I think they should be dealt with in the context of the Magdalenes.
They shouldn’t be excluded.”
Bethany Home
Separately,
Church of Ireland Archbishop of Dublin, Michael Jackson said he had
written to the Minister for Justice Alan Shatter asking him to establish
an inquiry into the Bethany Home, a Protestant-run home for unmarried
mothers and their children.
However, the Government has ruled out
the Magdalene redress scheme being extended to former residents of the
home. Taoiseach Enda Kenny stressed it was not a laundry, “but dealt
with the health and welfare of young women and their children”.
Mr
Shatter and Minister of State for Equality Kathleen Lynch were aware of
the issues involved and were “looking at this matter”, according to a
Department of Justice spokeswoman.
Support groups for the
Magdalene women said it would be difficult to quantify the number of
women who received compensation through the Redress Board – but Claire
McGettrick of Justice for Magdalenes said it would be “at least dozens”.
She
said “without exception” every woman she had spoken to who had dealt
with the Redress Board had been told “not to speak” about being
compensated for time spent in laundries.
“One woman told me that her
solicitor just drew a red line through her time in the laundry.”
‘Separate issue’
Steven
O’Riordan of Magdalene Survivors Together also said women who went
through the Redress Board were “consistently told” it was a “completely
separate issue” – and that the laundries were “of no consequence in
terms of what they would be paid by the Redress Board”.
He said it
would be “bizarre” if women who went through the Redress Board were to
be treated differently. All members of his organisation were to be
represented by Frank Buttimer Solicitors – with whom they were to meet,
together with Mr Shatter, today.
“We will be sitting down to go
through the terms of reference and what’s being laid out. None of those
in our group will be signing up to anything if the terms of reference
don’t suit what we have laid out,” he said. “Our proposal is that the
women get paid for loss of wages as well as a lump sum to cover the
aggravation and emotional and physical neglect people suffered.”
President
Michael D Higgins yesterday welcomed Mr Kenny’s apology to those who
had spent time in the laundries, and his announcement of a fund to
assist the women.
Mr Higgins described as “very generous” Mr
Kenny’s address. “I know the emotional strength with which it was
delivered and I’m even more pleased that those who were affected, the
women, were very pleased with it,” he said.