CLLR Tom Shortt has stood over his criticism of a remembrance mass
held in the council chamber this week - and organised by his Labour
colleague Mayor Gerry McLoughlin.
“I am not against the concept of a mass. By all means
have it but have it in a Catholic church. I was surprised by how
quickly the mayor’s desk could be transformed into an altar. That’s more
like the Ireland of the 1950s. We need to be careful about what message
we are sending out to people of all denominations and none,” said Cllr
Shortt.
Monday’s meeting of Limerick City Council was adjourned as
a mark of respect for former Fianna Fail councillor, the late John
O’Connor.
But before the meeting was adjourned, a number of councillors
took the opportunity to thank Mayor McLoughlin for having organised a
service, presided over by Canon Donough O’Malley earlier in the day, for
councillors and members of staff at City Hall who had been bereaved
during the year.
These included Cllr Kieran O’Hanlon, who recently
lost his brother Jack; Cllr Maria Byrne and Cllr Kathleen Leddin, who
described it as “a unifying and memorable occasion”.
But Cllr Shortt, who found it less inclusive, said he had “an alternative view”.
“I
appreciate that November is the month of remembrance in the Catholic
faith but Limerick City Council must move in a more multi-denominational
direction and it is, I feel, not appropriate to have mass in the council
chamber. And if we are to have a service, it must be
multidenominational in nature,” he declared.
Cllr Maurice Quinlivan, while he did not wish to get into a lengthy debate, expressed sympathy with Cllr Shortt’s view.
But
Cllr Diarmuid Scully said the service was “entirely appropriate” and
suggested Cllr Shortt was confusing the secularist tradition of a
country like France with the multi-denominational tradition in Ireland
which he said respected all faiths. It was not for Limerick City Council
to “deny people the comfort they do find it their faith. That is
something to be protected and not to be shunned,” Cllr Scully said.
Mayor McLoughlin said he would take Cllr Shortt’s views on board. He added that times were changing.
“I
went to 12 o’clock mass in John’s for the feast of Christ the
King and I met a man who said he could remember a time when all
councillors would come to the cathedral robed for the feast of Christ
the King,” said the mayor.
But Cllr Shortt this Wednesday appealed for “a little bit more sensitivity for the times we live in.
“It’s
only a couple of weeks ago since we were grappling with the issue of
Muslim burials in Limerick City Council cemeteries and that shows we
have to respect all denominations. Some of the Muslim community tell me
that because they can’t get the type of burial they would like in
Limerick, they are buried in Dublin and that is not fair on people who
are living in Limerick.”
“We are an arm of government. There has to be a bit more sensitivity around use of the council chamber,” said Cllr Shortt.