“One
of the options could have been and should have been another referendum
on the issue [of abortion legislation], that was never even mentioned”,
says Bishop Kieran O’Reilly, SMA, of Killaloe diocese Ireland,
commenting to Vatican Radio’s Emer McCarthy on the Irish Bishops
strongly worded initial response to a government commissioned report on
abortion legislation.
“We
believe that the terms of reference of the Expert Groups report were
far too restricted”, he continues, “the focus was towards legislation
for limited abortion and that we do not accept”.
The government
appointed expert group were called to report on the European Court for
Human Rights judgement in A,B and C versus Ireland, which states that
legislation to regulate access to lawful termination of pregnancy in
Ireland is “constitutionally, legally and procedurally sound”.
The government is now studying the reports recommendations.
The
Bishops state that “of the four options presented by the Report, three
involve abortion – the direct and intentional killing of an unborn
child. This can never be morally justified. The judgement of the
European Court of Human Rights does not oblige the Irish Government to
legislate for abortion”.
Earlier this week an estimated 8
thousand people held a candle light vigil outside Parliament buildings
calling on the government to uphold the right to life of the mother and
unborn as enshrined in the nations’ constitution.
“What was so
special about the Vigil for life this week”, notes Bishop O’Reilly, “was
that people from across Ireland, Catholic and non Catholic, people of
no particular religious affiliation travelled to Dublin to express their
concern about the reality of the change in this country. We want to
uphold and we want to maintain our very strong pro-life ethos. The
ethical basis for the positive approach to pro-life goes beyond the
Christian understanding of morality. Its an issue that affects all of
society”.