There is progress being made in resolving a key issue between the Holy See and China regarding the authority to appoint bishops, though Cardinal John Tong of Hong Kong said it will be a "gradual" process and other challenges remain.
Elaborating on an extensive article published Feb. 9 in the English language Sunday Examiner, Tong in an NCR
interview in his office in Hong Kong said he was focusing "only about
the dialogue [between the Holy See and China] and things that are
important elements to the dialogue and that an important element has
been achieved — at least almost — about the appointment [of bishops] by
the Holy Father."
Tong declined to give any timetable for an agreement. In the article,
he noted that over the past year, a working group has been set up
through which both sides have tried to resolve several issues, and that a
preliminary agreement had "reportedly been reached and that will lead
to the appointment of bishops."
Vital to the agreement, Tong said in the NCR interview, is
the authority of the pope to have final approval on bishops. "That is
necessary — otherwise we cannot accept whoever is presented," Tong said.
China has maintained it can appoint bishops, contrary to Catholic
doctrine, in which that authority rests with the pope. What has evolved
in China is a complicated structure in which about 70
government-appointed bishops operate in the registered, sometimes called
the "open" church, run through the Chinese Catholic Patriotic
Association established in 1957 under government authority.
of those bishops have been tacitly recognized by the Vatican. Seven
bishops are not recognized by Rome and are excommunicated.
Close to 40 bishops have been appointed by the Holy See but not
recognized by the Chinese government. These bishops operate the
unofficial church, often called the "underground" church, and are often
restricted in their activities and sometimes persecuted.
Cardinal Joseph Zen, former bishop of Hong Kong and Tong's predecessor, has been critical
of efforts by the Vatican to reach an agreement with Beijing, warning
it would betray the underground church and that Pope Francis is being
"naive" to pursue relations with China.
of Tong's essay have voiced their disagreement or said his message was
largely ignored by Chinese Catholics who believe little will really
change, given the repressive nature of the Chinese government.
Tong said in the interview that some critics may not have read his
essay carefully or they went beyond the scope of his writing. "Besides
telling the people my optimistic viewpoint, I also asked the people to
pray for the progress of the dialogue between the Holy See and China,"
His essay focused on the process of dialogue and the central issue of
the appointment of bishops, not on re-establishing diplomatic relations
with China. The Vatican and China ceased
diplomatic relations after the communist government victory in 1949
threw out foreign missionaries and later established the Chinese
Catholic Patriotic Association.
To have diplomatic relations "would be good, but without them also
the church can function," Tong said. The Catholic church functions in
many countries without formal diplomatic relations, he noted.
"I'm not a politician — as a priest, as a church people, we care
about the church method, which is more important — about the appointment
[of bishops] and about the unity between the church in China and the
Regarding the pope's appointment of bishops, "that's very important,"
he said. "I would like to move a step forward but still there are many,
many issues. That is one reason why even if this problem could be
solved, there are more issues to be solved."
Establishing diplomatic relations "would be good but that's not the
most important. That's not the first step — it may be the last step."
As for Zen's comments, "we just talked to each other. He said, 'We
are brothers.' He plays his own role, I play my own role," Tong said.
"He just says he wants to help the people [negotiating the agreement] to
be careful — of course, we should always be careful."
Whether there will be a formal announcement of an agreement is up to
the Holy See, he said, "provided we have some concrete results."
Tong said he doesn't think China is growing more repressive about
religious activities and freedoms. As one example, he said about 20 to
30 priests and women religious come to the Holy Spirit Center in Hong
Kong every other month for weeklong seminars on topics such as running a
parish, starting youth activities, and helping couples with marriage
"Comparing with the past, I think there isn't [more
repression]," he said. "In some places, maybe, but not the whole
When China first began opening up in the 1980s, there was a lot of
fear among Catholics and religious. When he asked questions, few dared
to answer. Now, he said, there is much more openness of expression.
"China cannot go back to the old ways because ordinary people can
come out [of China]," he said. "They've already seen situation outside
so they have a better appetite regarding the freedom which they enjoy
outside. The common people have a big appetite for freedom, so the
government is not stupid — they know common people want some more so
they will loosen their control a little bit from time to time. They
still want to control the people but they have to compromise. In the
long run, you can see China is wider open if you look back from 1980
In the interview, Tong drew on stories from his book Challenges and Hope: Stories From the Catholic Church in China
and on a favorite three-word structure that he often uses to describe
the Catholic church in China: wonderful, difficult and possible.
It is wonderful because "beforehand the door was closed and you could
not see anything — after the opening, there are many, many good
things," he said, including lessons about perseverance. In the 30 years
from the beginnings of the communist regime until the opening in the
1980s, many Catholics "suffered a lot but they kept their faith."
It is difficult because of continued restrictions by the Chinese
government, and "even while it is more open than compared with the past,
yet still they are not the same" as more open, free societies.
"So it's difficult — so you have to be smart on how far you can go,"
he said. "And it's 'possible,' meaning if you learn how far you can go,
then you can still do something."
He cited the example of one "underground" bishop not recognized by
the government and not able to practice in an open church. Praying about
what he could do, the bishop saw that under China's former one-child
policy, many families preferring boy babies would abandon girl babies.
He opened a house to care for the babies and mobilized Catholic laity
and some women religious to help. The effort grew to more than 100
babies and drew praise from a government agency for its work.
"So that's the 'possible,' " Tong said. "You don't have to make
confrontations — there are some other chances. If you try to search for
chances, you can still do some good pastoral work to help the people and
also even for evangelization."