A senior official of the Order of Malta has admitted that its recent conflict with the Pope threatened to upset relations with many of its donors.
Dominique de La Rochefoucauld-Montbel, grand hospitaller of the
order, said the crisis had been “troublesome for our donors,” many of
whom “decided maybe not to help us any more because they thought we were
fighting against the Pope, which is not true.”
“So now we have to restore this trust,” he said.
He was speaking at a press conference alongside the Order’s newly reinstated grand chancellor, Albrecht von Boeselager.
Boeselager said the crisis would remain a footnote in history that
paled in comparison to the suffering of refugees and the poor.
While recent events had shown that “we are not immune to crisis in
our government,” he said, the Knights of Malta will continue placing
their priority on helping migrants, the poor and the marginalised.
“This crisis will be a marginal event in history. What is more at
stake is the crisis we are facing in the world and the misery and the
plea of the millions of people [who are] homeless, migrating and
fleeing,” he said.
The German nobleman’s removal by former Grand Master Fra’ Matthew
Festing was at the heart of a public dispute between the order and the
In a statement in December, the order said Boeselager was removed
“due to severe problems which occurred during Boeselager’s tenure as
grand hospitaller of the Order of Malta and his subsequent concealment
of these problems from the Grand Magistry.”
Numerous media reports have said the problems specifically regarded
the distribution of condoms by aid agencies working with Malteser
International, the order’s humanitarian relief agency.
After weeks of very public tensions with the Vatican, Festing offered
his resignation last week at the behest of Pope Francis, who had
established a commission to investigate his removal of von Boeselager.
Von Boeselager was subsequently reinstated as grand chancellor of the
order and the Pope said he would appoint a special delegate who will
“specifically take care of the spiritual and moral renewal of the
order,” especially the 50 or so members who have taken religious vows of
poverty, chastity and obedience.
The grand chancellor said he was grateful for the Pope’s help in resolving the crisis.
“Without this trustful relationship between the order and the Pope,
the order cannot function. So, the concern of the Holy Father was to
reestablish the trustful relationship between order and the Holy See,”
Von Boeselager also emphasised the order’s priorities of providing
humanitarian relief, encouraging dialogue and assisting migrants and
“We firmly condemn discriminatory policies” against migrants and
refugees, he said, “and call for a strong reaffirmation of humanitarian
laws. We are alarmed and concerned by the proliferation of
discriminatory positions toward immigrants based on their national
When asked if he was referring to the recent executive order on
refugees by US President Donald Trump, von Boeselager said that he “made
a statement of principle” and that there are “many countries, many
institutions that are violating humanitarian principles.”
“I am not singling out anyone. It’s a principle of the Order of Malta,” he said.
“People are drowning in the Mediterranean, tortured on their way.
Please don’t forget to report about these cases and fight the arrogant
ignorance regarding this crisis,” von Boeselager said.