In the latest development in the remarkable showdown between the ancient Catholic lay order and the Holy See, Fra’ Matthew Festing explained and defended his actions in a January 14 letter to the order’s membership.
“Suffice it to say, whilst I was trying to enjoy a peaceful Advent and Christmastide, I have barely been able to concentrate on anything else,” he wrote. “It has been extremely tiring and I am sure many of you have had your Christmases disturbed by similar preoccupations.”
Fra’ Matthew said he was only protecting the order’s sovereignty in refusing to cooperate with a commission appointed by Pope Francis to investigate the ousting of Albrecht von Boeselager.
Church teaching forbids artificial contraception; Boeselager has said he stopped the programmes when he learned of the condom distribution.
Fra’ Matthew also sought to discredit Francis’s commission, saying there were “serious accusations of a conflict of interest” involving three of its five members. The three, he said, were linked to a Geneva-based fund in which the order had a financial interest and therefore couldn’t be trusted to address the spat objectively.
He didn’t elaborate but the National Catholic Register has reported that three of the commission members were involved, along with Boeselager, in a $118 million bequest to the order that was brought to the Vatican’s attention in 2014. Fra’ Matthew said he had decided to launch an internal inquiry into the bequest.
Boeselager has appealed his dismissal to the order’s internal tribunal, arguing that Fra’ Matthew made a series of procedural errors that invalidate the decree he issued.
In his letter, Fra’ Matthew acknowledged there was “originally some debate about the legality of the process.” But he insisted that “numerous sources,” particularly the order’s in-house counsel, have said the correct procedures were followed.
Independent of the legal manoeuvering, Francis appointed the commission after Boeselager said he had been told that the Holy See wanted him to resign.
The Vatican secretary of state has since said the Pope wanted nothing of the sort and wanted the dispute resolved through dialogue.