The Society of Saint Vincent DePaul has claimed that the Troika was interested primarily in deficit reduction and structural reform and not in the hardship that budget measures would to cause to Ireland’s poorest people.
The SVP made the claim in its submission to the ECON (Economic and Monetary Affairs) committee last week.
Several MEPs were in Ireland to review the Troika’s engagement with NGOs.
John-Mark McCafferty, SVP, stated that his members met with Troika members several times.
“The representatives listened, but concluded at each meeting that
they were interested primarily in deficit reduction and structural
reform,” he said.
“Budget measures pursued by the Irish Government, which may cause
hardship to people we assist, were exactly that –a domestic matter and
not something that the Troika had strong opinions on nor intervened in,”
the SVP spokesman added.
The visiting MEPs from across the European Union, included Irish
representatives, Gay Mitchell, Paul Murphy and Emer Costelloe. They
wanted to know how SVP was consulted by European Central Bank (ECB), the
European Commission (EC) and the International Monetary Fund (IMF).
John-Mark McCafferty reported how on a hot July Monday, the SVP’s
Mid-West Region met with two delegates from the European Central Bank
(ECB) and the International Monetary Fund (IMF).
SVP members and staff conveyed the impact of the recession and
austerity on the people being visited and assisted by them in the
“They spoke with clarity, passion and conviction and ECB and IMF
representatives at the Limerick meeting got a very good sense of the
issues facing people,” said John-Mark McCafferty.
They visited a drop in centre, and a homeless hostel.
Yet one week
later at a meeting with the wider Troika in the Department of Finance he
recalled, “We received a muted response from them to our take on the
human cost of austerity in Ireland.”
The SVP concluded that the Summer visit of the young economists “is
nothing more than a balmy memory”.
The charity continues to pick up the
pieces of peoples’ lives following austerity and cuts.
In its submission to ECON, the charity highlighted the failure of the
Irish Government to implement certain structural reforms resulting in
medicines and medical and dental fees that are still too high; expensive
legal services; and 60% of unemployed people out of work for more than
“On the basis of our experience, those who were least well off and
with least assets before the economic crisis remain so, and their
struggles have been worsened due to cutbacks to the supports and
services on which they rely,” John-Mark McCafferty said.
For example, the SVP’s spend on direct assistance to households
increased by 50% comparing 2012 with 2008.
In monetary terms,
€42,817,000 was provided directly to households in need in 2012 compared
to €28,494,000 in 2008.
In 2012, the SVP spent over €22 million on food and cash assistance
and over €11 million was spent on helping households with their energy
Help with fuel and energy costs are up by almost 200% since 2008
and assistance with education costs are up by 22% since 2008.
help to larger regional offices have increased by over 100% since 2009.