The Archbishop of Dublin Diarmuid Martin has said he told Pope John Paul II that he was wrong about the rapid secularisation of Irish society.
Archbishop Martin said late in his life Pope John Paul II had asked him why secularisation had moved so fast in Ireland.
"For one of the rare times in my life I said to
him 'Holy Father, you are wrong'. In fact the roots go back back. They
are basically cultural roots," Archbishop Martin told The Marian Finucane Show on RTÉ Radio One.
The Archbishop said he believed the
secularisation of Irish society pre-dated the release of Humanae Vitae
in 1968, the doctrine disapproving of contraception which caused many
liberal-minded Catholics to drift away from the Church's teaching.
He maintained that the secularisation of Irish society was a result of the fact that Ireland was an open economy.
“Humanae Vitae was a moment when you could mark
as a significant event, but things had changed well before that I
believe,” he said.
He also acknowledged that the role of women in
Irish society had changed radically.
“The Church has never really
grappled with that in the way that it should and it must,” he said.
He also said that the previous Pope Benedict XVI had taken a keen interest in the future of Irish culture and its relationship with the Church.
“I'd gone out with all my statistics but they
are not much use. He asked me about media, he asked me about theatre, he
asked me about literature and we don't do clearly enough thinking about
these questions. Irish literature always had a healthy
anti-clerical streak in it, but the church has found it difficult to
find a place in that area.”
He revealed that he could not say mass in the Pro-Cathedral on Holy Thursday without mentioning the case
of Father Patrick McCabe who was sentenced last week for abusing
children in the crypt of the cathederal.
“I just could not simply
ignore that. It would have been dishonest of me,” he said.