Rite & Reason: The unjust ruling Protestant
ascendancy established following the defeats at the Boyne in 1690 and
Aughrim in 1691 took the best part of a century to unravel.
This was
accomplished through Catholic emancipation in 1829, the abolition of
tithes, disestablishment of the Church of Ireland in 1871, a series of
land Acts and finally the establishment of the Free State in 1922.
The
“special position” of the Roman Catholic Church enshrined in the 1937
Constitution, and the at times overweening influence of the Roman
Catholic hierarchy in the affairs of State, also constituted a
privileging that has now been largely dismantled.
Through the
constitutional campaigns associated with Garret FitzGerald and former
dean of St Patrick’s Cathedral in Dublin Rev Victor Griffin, a
successful divorce referendum, and the social enrichment resulting from
immigration, Ireland has become a more pluralist and secular society.
The
churches should welcome this, and while still wishing to imbue society
with their deeper values, should not seek to do this on the basis of
advantaged status.
From John Locke onwards the default mode of
political liberalism has been to separate church and state, religion and
society, by seeking to confine religion to the private sphere.
The US has adhered closely to this model, while European democracies have had more variegated arrangements.
The
question for Ireland now is what would be the best way forward given
our distinctive history and present cultural composition?
While no religious tradition should be favoured, religion should not be progressively excised from public life.
Modern
industrial societies exist in the context of powerful administrative
bureaucracies and a globalised free market, and lack the resources to
provide the necessary checks and balances to withstand these corroding
influences.
A valueless secular autonomy cannot provide the kind
of civic culture that can resist the evident pathologies of contemporary
market economies.
We need a public sphere infused with the moral
energies of not only a reinvigorated secular humanism, but also the
ethical vitality that religion at its best can bring to society.
At
the heart of Ireland’s recent economic collapse was the lamentable
moral failure of a blind faith in the market, and if the present
Government is to put any distance between itself and its predecessor it
must act in step with the constructive moral energies in civil society.
Irish
society is at a tipping point where it could very easily flip from a
theocratic past to an ideologically driven secularism that offers no
resistance to valueless economic liberalism.
It would be ironic if this
were to happen at the very point where much secular political theory has
now come to acknowledge the critical role of religion.
Germany’s
leading political philosopher, Jürgen Habermas, has described religion
as offering an early warning system against some of the worst excesses
of modern market-orientated societies.
Habermas argues that
religious language has “inspiring, indeed, unrelinquishable semantic
contents which elude . . . the expressive power of a philosophical
language and still await translation”.
Social egalitarianism, human rights and democracy, he writes, “is the direct legacy of the Judaic ethic of justice”.
With
political roots in the fertile soil of Irish 18th-century
republicanism, we need to be reminded of two significant features of
that tradition.
First, democracy requires a love of the civic virtues, which was central to the republicanism of the United Irish Society.
Second, the reception of the Enlightenment in Ireland worked in harness with and not in opposition to religious convictions.
In
his A Letter to the People of Ireland (1796), Thomas Russell, without
embarrassment, made religion the basis of his political credo.
The 1916 leaders bore witness to this heritage when they began their proclamation: “In the name of God . . .”
* Very Rev John Marsden is Dean of St Brigid’s Church of Ireland Cathedral, Kildare