Thursday, December 20, 2012

Pope's credit crunch Christmas: Vatican spends £15,000 on nativity compared to £445,000 in 2009, fuelling corruption claims

Thousands flock to St. Peter's Square in Rome every December to see the life-size nativity scene and hear the Pope's annual blessing (file picture) The Vatican's decision to use a donated nativity scene in Rome's St. Peter's Square this Christmas has fuelled rumours of corruption following the publication of leaked documents that suggest it had paid companies over-inflated prices to produce similar displays in the past.

This year's larger-than-life Christmas tableau depicting the biblical scene of Jesus's birth, said to have cost about £73,000 was donated by the southern region of Basilicata, one of Italy's poorest. 

Much of the money was reportedly provided by local businesses including oil giants Shell and Total which operate in the petroleum-rich region. 

It means that the Vatican will pay just £15,000 this year, mostly towards the cost of assembling the structure, compared to the massive £445,000 it spent in 2009. 

Yesterday a Vatican spokesman denied a link between its decision to accept this year's display as a gift and allegations that it had previously paid inflated prices to have them built. 

Some of the documents that sparked this year's 'Vatileaks' scandal indicated that in 2009 the Vatican paid an Italian company six times that amount, about 550,000 euros ($720,000), to build its nativity scene in the square. 

The letters, leaked to the media, mentioned the payment as an example of corruption in the city state's business dealings. 

Monsignor Giuseppe Sciacca, deputy governor of the Vatican City, was asked by reporters whether accepting a donated crib was a response to the scandal.  'This is exclusively the result of the offer by the Basilicata region to give us this gift, which, with a minimum of good sense, has been accepted,' he said. 

In the leaked documents, Sciacca's predecessor, Archbishop Carlo Maria Vigano, said the exorbitant cost of the 2009 crib was an example of how the Vatican was losing money through corruption. 

Vigano said he had managed almost to halve the cost of the 2010 crib. He was subsequently transferred to the United States, despite an appeal to his superiors to be allowed stay in his job, in what he saw as punishment for doing his work too well.  

Two people were convicted by a Vatican court over the leaks of documents. 

 Paolo Gabriele, the Pope's former butler, is now serving an 18-month jail sentence in a Vatican jail cell for stealing sensitive papal documents and leaking them to the media. 

 A computer expert was given a suspended sentence for obstructing justice in the case.