New rules issued by Pope Benedict
XVI for the governance of Catholic charities will not prevent such
charities from accepting government funding, so long as the funding does
not entail conditions that conflict with church teaching, said the
second-highest official of the Vatican office in charge of applying the
new legislation.
Msgr. Giovanni Pietro Dal Toso, secretary of the Pontifical Council Cor Unum, said
about the pope's apostolic letter on the "service of charity," issued
"motu proprio" (on the pope's "own initiative") Nov. 11, and released by
the Vatican Dec. 1.
The document, which has the status of canon law, emphasizes that
Catholic charitable activity must not become "just another form of
organized social assistance," and directs bishops to ensure that
charitable agencies under their authority conform to church teaching.
One section of the letter forbids Catholic charities to "receive
financial support from groups or institutions that pursue ends contrary
to the church's teaching."
Commenting on this, Msgr. Dal Toso said that the rule would not
necessarily prevent such agencies from taking money from national or
local governments that fund, promote or permit practices condemned by
the church, such as abortion or contraception.
Nevertheless, he added, "if there is a program that goes against the
church's teaching, for example, programs promoting abortion, then we
cannot accept funds for such a program or even accept funds with certain
conditions that are contrary to the church's doctrine."
The secretary said that the new papal document instructs bishops to
ensure that Catholic charities "exercise proper discernment in their
relationship with financial entities," such as private foundations,
whose "institutional ends" -- their primary goals or core mission as
defined in their statutes -- "do not conform to the church's teaching."
In those cases, he said, "such financing is not acceptable."
The document also states that staff members of Catholic charities must
"share, or at least respect, the Catholic identity of their agencies,"
and that they should exemplify "Christian life" and "witness to a
formation of heart which testifies to a faith working through charity."
That requirement, Msgr. Dal Toso said, does not mean that non-Catholics
may not work for Catholic charities, but it means that such employees
"should be aware of the fact that (they) are working in a Catholic
organization."
He said that the "theological and pastoral formation" that the motu
proprio mandates for the staff of Catholic charities should ensure
knowledge not only of relevant church teachings, but also of the
distinctive approach and "anthropology" that the church brings to its
charitable mission.
The secretary named two U.S. agencies, Catholic Relief Services and
Catholic Charities USA, that he said offer such instruction to their
non-Catholic staff members.
The pope's apostolic letter is primarily concerned with laying out the
responsibility of each bishop to oversee charitable agencies in his
diocese, in order to reinforce such agencies' Catholic identity, Msgr.
Dal Toso said.
"Catholic charity is an ecclesial activity, not merely a social
activity, and that means the role of the bishop is important," he said,
noting that Pope Benedict expressed this idea in his 2005 encyclical
"Deus Caritas Est," and finally gave it legal force in the motu proprio.
The responsibility for agencies that do not fall under the jurisdiction
of a single bishop is determined by canon law cited in the papal
document, he said. National bishops' conferences oversee charitable
agencies established under their authority, and the Vatican oversees
international agencies established with its approval.