Jüergen Mettepenningen resigned Tuesday as the top spokesman for the
Catholic Church in Belgium to protest recent comments about
homosexuality and abuse scandals made by his boss, Archbishop
Andre-Joseph Leonard.
A senior Vatican official said support for Archbishop Leonard
remained strong in Rome, adding that his comments had been widely
"misinterpreted."
The Vatican typically ousts bishops only for acts such
as committing abuse themselves or publicly defying the pope's authority
by consecrating priests as new bishops.
Still, Mr. Mettepenningen's departure is a rare act of rebellion for a
Catholic theologian, and exposes divisions within the church as it
tries to face up to decades of widespread unpunished sexual abuse by its
priests.
Mgr. Leonard, Belgium's top Catholic leader, recently answered a
reporter's question about whether AIDS is God's punishment for
homosexuality by comparing sexual promiscuity to mistreating the
environment, and the disease to pollution.
He also said that pedophile
priests should be forgiven and that punishing them long after the facts
was akin to "revenge."
His comment caused a stir in a country hit hard by the abuse scandal.
Bishop Roger Vangheluwe of Bruges, a once-respected leader, admitted
this spring to raping his nephew for years.
He resigned and currently is
in hiding, but because the crime occurred two decades ago, he has
escaped punishment from the law or the Vatican.
A recent study commissioned by the church highlighted 497 cases of
previously undocumented abuse.
The church has refused to compensate
those victims, agreeing only to pay some therapy costs.
In June, Belgian federal investigators raided church headquarters,
seeking documents showing cover-ups of abuse.
A judge ruled the raid
illegal and the documents had to be returned.
The special commission
appointed by the church to investigate abuse resigned in protest.
Mgr. Leonard has been called insensitive, and even criminal, by
politicians, liberal Catholics and victims' rights groups.
On Tuesday,
Jean-Marie de Meester, a socialist member of the Belgian parliament,
filed a charge alleging that Mgr. Leonard had broken the law with his
antigay remarks.
The archbishop's comments ultimately pushed his spokesman to quit.
"He thinks everybody else is wrong," said Mr. Mettepenningen during a
news conference in Grimbergen, a suburb north of Brussels.
"I was his
GPS for three months. But it is the driver who has his hands on the
wheel and sets the course."
Mr. Mettepenningen said his boss had promised to abstain from
excessively controversial statements. He called the archbishop a "loose
cannon."
Lieve Halsberghe, a spokesman for the Belgian chapter of the
Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests, said that Mr.
Mettepenningen had resigned for "the wrong reasons."
The issue, he said,
"is not Archbishop's Leonard's remarks. It's the actions, and inaction,
of Leonard and his brother bishops in the face of a horrific, ongoing
scandal that leaves children at risk and victims in pain even now."
Mr. Mettepenningen is a 35-year-old father of two and a theologian
from Belgium's Dutch-speaking north. He is the author of "New Theology:
Inheritor of Modernism, Precursor of Vatican II."
In Belgium, church
officials say he is respected for his work on the church's relationship
with the media.
At a Mass he celebrated Monday, Mgr. Leonard acknowledged his
rhetoric was controversial to some. "I understand your concerns," he
said, according to wire reports. "It is what it is. Think of it as you
will, with the help of God."
SIC: WSJ/INT'L